<akomaNtoso xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13" xsi:schemaLocation="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13 ./akomantoso30.xsd">
  <debate name="Official Report">
    <meta>
      <identification source="#debates">
        <FRBRWork>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-19" name="#generation"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#author" href="/ie/oireachtas/house/seanad/27"/>
          <FRBRcountry value="ie"/>
          <FRBRname value="debate"/>
        </FRBRWork>
        <FRBRExpression>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate/mul@/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate/mul@"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-19" name="#reported"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
          <FRBRlanguage language="eng"/>
        </FRBRExpression>
        <FRBRManifestation>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate/mul@/main.xml"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/seanad/2026-11-19/debate/mul@.akn"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-21" name="#publication"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
        </FRBRManifestation>
      </identification>
      <analysis source="#source">
        <parliamentary>
          <voting eId="vote_1" href="#sum_14" refersTo="#sum_13" outcome="#carried">
            <count eId="vote_1-count_1" href="#qty_1" value="27" refersTo="#ta"/>
            <count eId="vote_1-count_2" href="#qty_2" value="5" refersTo="#nil"/>
          </voting>
          <voting eId="vote_2" href="#sum_20" refersTo="#sum_19" outcome="#carried">
            <count eId="vote_2-count_1" href="#qty_3" value="23" refersTo="#ta"/>
            <count eId="vote_2-count_2" href="#qty_4" value="12" refersTo="#nil"/>
          </voting>
        </parliamentary>
      </analysis>
      <references source="#debates">
        <TLCConcept eId="#lost" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#DeclaredLost" showAs="Declared Lost"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#carried" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#DeclaredCarried" showAs="Declared Carried"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#staon" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#StaonVote" showAs="Staon Vote"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#nil" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#NílVote" showAs="Níl Vote"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#ta" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#TáVote" showAs="Tá Vote"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AidanDavitt" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aidan-Davitt.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Aidan Davitt"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AliceMaryHiggins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Alice-Mary-Higgins.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Alice-Mary Higgins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AnneRabbitte" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Anne-Rabbitte.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Anne Rabbitte"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AubreyMcCarthy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aubrey-McCarthy.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Aubrey McCarthy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CathalByrne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cathal-Byrne.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Cathal Byrne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CatherineArdagh" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Catherine-Ardagh.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Catherine Ardagh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ChrisAndrews" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Chris-Andrews.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Chris Andrews"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DeeRyan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Dee-Ryan.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Dee Ryan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DiarmuidWilson" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Diarmuid-Wilson.S.2002-09-12" showAs="Diarmuid Wilson"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EileenLynch" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eileen-Lynch.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Eileen Lynch"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EvanneNiChuilinn" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Evanne-Ní-Chuilinn.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Evanne Ní Chuilinn"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GarretAhearn" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Garret-Ahearn.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Garret Ahearn"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GerardPCraughwell" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Gerard-P-Craughwell.S.2014-10-10" showAs="Gerard P. Craughwell"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ImeldaGoldsboro" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Imelda-Goldsboro.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Imelda Goldsboro"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoanneCollins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joanne-Collins.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Joanne Collins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeFlaherty" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-Flaherty.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Joe Flaherty"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeOReilly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-O'Reilly.S.1989-10-01" showAs="Joe O'Reilly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="LindaNelsonMurray" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Linda-Nelson-Murray.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Linda Nelson Murray"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MalcolmNoonan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Malcolm-Noonan.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Malcolm Noonan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ManusBoyle" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Manus-Boyle.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Manus Boyle"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MargaretMurphyOMahony" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Margaret-Murphy-O'Mahony.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Margaret Murphy O'Mahony"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarianHarkinIND" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Marian-Harkin.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Marian Harkin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkDaly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Daly.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Mark Daly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkDuffy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Duffy.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Mark Duffy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinConway" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Conway.S.2011-05-25" showAs="Martin Conway"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinHeydon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Heydon.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Martin Heydon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaryFitzpatrick" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mary-Fitzpatrick.S.2020-06-29" showAs="Mary Fitzpatrick"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMcDowellPD" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-McDowell.D.1987-03-10" showAs="Michael McDowell"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MikeKennelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mike-Kennelly.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Mike Kennelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NessaCosgrove" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Nessa-Cosgrove.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Nessa Cosgrove"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NiallBlaneyIND" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Niall-Blaney.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Niall Blaney"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NoelODonovan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Noel-O'Donovan.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Noel O'Donovan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="OllieCrowe" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ollie-Crowe.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Ollie Crowe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ParaicBrady" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paraic-Brady.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Paraic Brady"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PatCasey" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pat-Casey.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Pat Casey"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PatriciaStephenson" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Patricia-Stephenson.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Patricia Stephenson"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulineTully" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pauline-Tully.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Pauline Tully"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RayMcAdam" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ray-McAdam.S.2026-11-06" showAs="Ray McAdam"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobbieGallagher" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robbie-Gallagher.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Robbie Gallagher"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobertTroy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robert-Troy.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Robert Troy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RonanMullen" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Rónán-Mullen.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Rónán Mullen"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SarahOReilly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Sarah-O'Reilly.S.2025-01-29" showAs="Sarah O'Reilly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="TomClonan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Tom-Clonan.S.2022-04-04" showAs="Tom Clonan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="VictorBoyhan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Victor-Boyhan.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Victor Boyhan"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Acting_Chairperson" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/office/acting_chairperson" showAs="Acting Chairperson"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister/agriculture__food__marine" showAs="Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/finance" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Finance"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Further_and_Higher_Education,_Research,_Innovation_and_Science" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/further__higher_education__research__innovation__science" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Justice,_Home_Affairs_and_Migration" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/justice__home_affairs__migration" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration"/>
      </references>
    </meta>
    <preface>
      <block name="title_ga">
        <docTitle>DÍOSPÓIREACHTAÍ PARLAIMINTE</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="title_en">
        <docTitle>PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_ga">
        <docProponent>SEANAD ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_en">
        <docProponent>SEANAD ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="status_ga">
        <docStatus>TUAIRISC OIFIGIÚIL</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="status_en">
        <docStatus>(OFFICIAL REPORT)</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="date_ga">
        <docDate date="2026-11-19">Déardaoin, 19 Samhain 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block name="date_en">
        <docDate date="2026-11-19">Thursday, 19 November 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_en">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_ga">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
    </preface>
    <debateBody>
      <debateSection name="prelude" eId="dbsect_1">
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_1">Chuaigh an Cathaoirleach i gceannas ar 09:30 a.m.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_2">Machnamh agus Paidir.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_3">Reflection and Prayer.</summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_2">
        <heading>Teachtaireacht ón Dáil - Message from Dáil<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_1">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_1">Dáil Éireann has agreed, on 18 November 2026, to the amendments made by Seanad Éireann to the Media Regulation Bill 2026.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_3">
        <heading>Gnó an tSeanaid - Business of Seanad<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_2">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_2">I have received notice from the following Senators that they propose to raise the following matters:</p>
          <p eId="para_3"> Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony - The need for the Minister for Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science to make a statement on the measures being taken to address the significant commuting challenges facing college students.</p>
          <p eId="para_4"> Senator Victor Boyhan - The need for the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine to make a statement on the implications for the agricultural sector if commercial rates are applied to agricultural buildings.</p>
          <p eId="para_5"> Senator Cathal Byrne - The need for the Minister for Transport to make a statement on the procedure for notifying the National Driver Licence Service of driving bans and endorsements on licences.</p>
          <p eId="para_6"> Senator Dee Ryan - The need for the Minister for Health to make a statement on the access to pre-exposure prophylaxis medicine for people in the mid-west.</p>
          <p eId="para_7"> Senator Joe O'Reilly - The need for the Minister for Transport to make a statement on the provision of increased funding for the discretionary grant scheme for roads.</p>
          <p eId="para_8"> Senator Sarah O'Reilly - The need for the Minister for Education and Youth to provide an update on additional accommodation for schools in Cavan.</p>
          <p eId="para_9"> Senator Martin Conway - The need for the Minister for Health to provide an update on the timeline for a dialysis service to be operational in Ennis, County Clare.</p>
          <p eId="para_10"> Senator Nessa Cosgrove -The need for the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality to make a statement on the composition of the early years service joint labour committee.</p>
          <p eId="para_11"> Senator Patricia Stephenson - The need for the Minister for Transport to make a statement on enhancements to rail services on the Dublin-Waterford line as part of the rail project prioritisation strategy.</p>
          <p eId="para_12"> Senator Malcolm Noonan - The need for the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport to make a statement on the system for announcing recipients of the basic income for artists scheme.</p>
          <p eId="para_13"> The matters raised by the Senators are suitable for discussion and I have selected Senators Margaret Murphy O'Mahony, Victor Boyhan, Cathal Byrne and Dee Ryan and they will be taken now. The other Senators may give notice on another day of the matters they wish to raise.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_4">
        <heading>Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_5">
          <heading>Third Level Costs<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#MargaretMurphyOMahony" eId="spk_3">
            <from>Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_14">I thank the Cathaoirleach for choosing my Commencement matter. Táim an-bhuíoch den Aire Stáit as a bheith anseo ar maidin. I welcome the opportunity to raise this important matter regarding the significant commuting challenges facing third-level students. Much attention has rightly been focused on the student accommodation crisis in recent years. However, an equally pressing issue is the growing number of students who are forced to commute long distances each day because they cannot access affordable accommodation, or sometimes any accommodation, near their college or university. For many students, attending college now means spending hours travelling every day before they even enter a lecture hall. These journeys are not only time-consuming; they also place considerable financial, academic and personal pressure on students and their families.</p>
            <p eId="para_15"> The findings of the finalised Munster Technological University, MTU, students' union commuter survey report provide stark insight into the scale of the problem. More than 1,500 students participated in the survey, with many reporting commute times of over 90 minutes each way, each day. Some students reported travelling up to four hours each way to attend lectures. The financial burden is equally significant. More than a quarter of respondents spend between €50 and €100 every week getting to and from college, while some reported weekly commuting costs in excess of €200. At a time students are already facing significant costs associated with higher education, these additional expenses are placing considerable strain on household budgets. The long journeys are having a direct impact on education outcomes. Almost 80% of respondents said they had missed lectures due to traffic congestion, public transport delays or difficulties in finding parking. Almost 75% felt that commuting was negatively affecting their academic performance.</p>
            <p eId="para_16"> The impact extends beyond the lecture hall. College is not only about attending lectures and examinations. It is about personal development, building friendships and participating in clubs, societies and campus life. More than 82% of students surveyed said commuting had affected their ability to engage in these activities. There is also a clear well-being dimension. Almost 60% of the respondents reported that commuting was having a negative impact on their mental health. Long travel times, early departures, late returns home and uncertainty around transport services all contribute to increased stress and fatigue. Students have a lot going on without having to worry about how long it will take to get to college and how to get there. One of the most striking findings relates to parking provision. Across MTU campuses, parking received an average satisfaction rating of just 2.54 out of ten. While public transport must remain a key focus, many students, particularly those from rural areas, simply do not have a viable alternative to driving. For these students, inadequate parking provision becomes another barrier to accessing education.</p>
            <p eId="para_17"> These students are not asking for anything special. They are asking for a fair opportunity to access higher education without facing unreasonable obstacles. No student should have to leave home before dawn, spend hours commuting every day or miss lectures because transport services are unreliable or parking is unavailable. While increasing the supply of affordable student accommodation must remain a priority, immediate action is needed to support commuter students. This includes improved public transport links to higher education institutions, more reliable and frequent services, better co-ordination between colleges and transport providers, and investment in transport and parking infrastructure where required. I ask the Minister of State to outline the measures being taken to support commuter students. What engagement is taking place with the National Transport Authority, NTA, and higher education institutions to improve transport services? Is consideration being given to addressing the significant parking pressures that exist in many colleges at the moment? Education should be accessible regardless of where a student lives. No students should be disadvantaged because they cannot afford accommodation closer to their college.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarianHarkinIND" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Further_and_Higher_Education,_Research,_Innovation_and_Science" eId="spk_4">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science (Deputy Marian Harkin)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_18">I thank Senator Murphy O'Mahony for raising this matter.</p>
            <p eId="para_19"> The Minister, Deputy Lawless, the Department and I are acutely aware of the challenges facing students, including the affordability and availability of student accommodation and the long commuting journeys many students undertake to access higher education, which the Senator has outlined. The Government's response is set out in the new National Student Accommodation Strategy 2026-2035, published in March of this year. This sets out the Government’s long-term approach to addressing student accommodation affordability, supply and viability. The strategy aims to make higher education more accessible by addressing two critical challenges: first, increasing the supply of student accommodation; and, second, improving affordability for students.</p>
            <p eId="para_20"> The Government has already committed up to €100 million through the short-term activation programme, STAP, to unlock student accommodation projects affected by construction cost and viability challenges. STAP will support approximately 967 student beds, with 116 of those beds already completed and occupied in Maynooth, 493 under construction at University College Dublin, UCD, and a further 358 beds in the programme progressing at Trinity College Dublin. The programme has already provided valuable lessons for future accommodation delivery and will inform the development of the national student accommodation strategy.</p>
            <p eId="para_21"> STAP identified that the cost per bed would require an untenable funding level for the State, given that we have a demand for 42,000 beds by 2035, and private sector collaboration would be required. Informed by those learnings from STAP, the Department is developing a higher education institution student accommodation programme, HSAP. The purpose of this programme to increase purpose-built student accommodation through partnerships with higher education institutions and private sector providers. A non-binding expression of interest process was issued to the development and construction sector on 30 October 2026 for on-campus accommodation at TU Dublin Grangegorman, Munster Technological University Cork, Atlantic Technological University, ATU, Galway and the Institute of Art, Design and Technology, IADT, in Dún Laoghaire, as well as off-campus opportunities in Dublin, Cork and Galway. While I have a lot of figures here, I will just quote those from Cork for the Senator, as I know that is what she is most interested in. This phase of the programme has the potential to develop and deliver a total of approximately 3,300 new on-campus beds for four universities, one being MTU Cork, where the estimated range of bed places is between 940 and 1,184. There is work progressing on a phased basis in other regional locations.</p>
            <p eId="para_22"> The Senator also mentioned commuting challenges. As part of the development of that strategy, commuting patterns were examined and daily return journeys exceeding three hours were identified as unsustainable. A pilot initiative is under way that will involve higher education institutes, the National Transport Authority, NTA, local authorities and transport operators strengthening their co-ordination around student transport needs and supporting improved transport planning.</p>
            <p eId="para_23"> Decisions regarding on-campus parking are matters for individual higher education institutions as part of their on-campus development and transport planning.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MargaretMurphyOMahony" eId="spk_5">
            <from>Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_24">I thank the Minister of State for laying out those plans. While they are very welcome, much of them are long term and many of the boys and girls going to college now will be finished their degree courses by the time the plans come in. I would like more urgent action on the transportation side of things. Obviously, accommodation takes much longer, but a lot of short-term measures could be put in place to help students with transportation problems. These are the best years of a student's life and they should be working and playing hard. Unfortunately, due to lack of transport and accommodation, many students are losing out on these fantastic years of their lives.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarianHarkinIND" eId="spk_6" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Further_and_Higher_Education,_Research,_Innovation_and_Science">
            <from>Deputy Marian Harkin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_25">The Government recognises the challenges, both in the long-term and the short-term. The short-term activation programme and the higher education institution student programme follow on from that. Work has already been completed on the former. With the learnings from the short-term activation programme, the Government understood that it needed to put in place another programme where there would be collaboration with the higher education institutions and private providers.</p>
            <p eId="para_26"> In the context of supply information where Cork is concerned, UCC campus accommodation provides 1,536 beds. In addition to the public beds in UCC, there are over 8,000 private beds in Cork. As of 28 October, there were 130 digs beds being advertised through the higher education institutions, HEIs, in Cork. Nonetheless, we recognise that this is a challenge and the Government is working in the short and long terms to address it. It is working with the HEIs and other relevant stakeholders to look at the patterns of travel to ensure that local transport is available to students in the most feasible and economic way.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_6">
          <heading>Commercial Rates<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#VictorBoyhan" eId="spk_7">
            <from>Senator Victor Boyhan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_27">I thank the Cathaoirleach for selecting this Commencement matter, and I welcome the Minister to the House. I thank him for making himself available, because I know that there was some confusion relating to this Commencement matter. Initially, the Department contacted me to say that it would not be taking it because it thought that this was more of a local government matter, what with the rates and all of that, yet we see that there is extensive conversation with the Minister, Deputy Burke, on this. That prompted me to follow through with what the Minister, Deputy Burke, was saying regarding the issues raised in this topic, which I will now discuss with the Minister, Deputy Heydon. I thank him for coming.</p>
            <p eId="para_28"> My matter requested that the Minister for agriculture make a general statement; I do not want to get into the specifics, nor will the Minister. It would not be right or appropriate to get into the specifics of any site or enterprise at this point, but I want him to make a statement on the recent ruling of the court that could potentially expose agricultural buildings to commercial rates. I was hoping to achieve a general response from the Minister.</p>
            <p eId="para_29"> The Minister knows - no better man - the challenges for farmers, growers, producers and agriculture more widely as well as the concerns emanating from a recent High Court ruling on commercial rates. The court judgment may affect the temperature-controlled potato, onion and vegetable stores and facilities used by dairy farmers as well as agricultural, horticultural and related food producers. The enterprise Minister, Deputy Burke, has said that a High Court ruling that could expose agricultural buildings to commercial rates was "hugely concerning" for the Government. The court case involved a potato company - I do not want to get into the specifics - and Tailte Éireann, whose property evaluations underpin rates collected by all local authorities.</p>
            <p eId="para_30">As a member of the Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food, I understand the challenges of farmers and food producers and the circumstances they are facing at this time, as does the Minister. There may be unforeseen additional costs in the sector which will have huge implications for sustainability and profitability.Margins are tight at best. Any resemblance of a fair return and profitability are critical. I understand the Minister is having informal discussions across government. I hope he might be in a position to provide a memo on the challenges around that or we might discuss it at the agriculture committee.</p>
            <p eId="para_31"> Farmers, growers and producers whose facilities are currently outside the commercial rates scheme are seeking assurances that the <i>status quo</i> would remain for them and that any unintended consequences would be addressed. We are talking about sustainable food production, farm enterprise viability and food security. These all areas I know the Minister is fully supportive of. I am giving him the opportunity to share his general concerns and what might be done across government to address them.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinHeydon" as="#Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine" eId="spk_8">
            <from>Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine (Deputy Martin Heydon)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_32">I thank the Senator for raising this important issue. The issue of commercial rates falls under the responsibility of the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage pursuant to the Valuation Office and valuation tribunal order 2017 or SI 575/2017. As Minister, I have clear roles and responsibilities under my remit in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine but there are times when as a senior Minister have to watch things that come under the remit of other Ministers may have a direct impact on my sector. Rates is one such issue and I am happy to be hear to talk about the general impact on agricultural buildings.</p>
            <p eId="para_33"> The rateability of farm buildings and the application of certain exemptions is provided for in the Valuation Act 2001. The Act provides an exemption for farm buildings. “Farm buildings” as defined includes buildings occupied together with agricultural land, buildings used solely for the production of livestock and horticultural farm buildings as provided for in the Act. The recent High Court decision the Senator referenced has resulted in certain farm buildings being found to be rateable. The key issue was the finding that the use of farm buildings for the storage of horticulture produce in a temperature-controlled environment amounted to “processing” of horticultural goods, which is an exception to the exempted properties from commercial rates under the 2001 Act. Buildings used for “processing” have previously and continue to be rateable under the Act. As this is a recent court adjudication, the implications of this decision including any appeal outcome need to be considered carefully to fully understand the implications. Consumers demand a year-round supply of staple goods such as potatoes and onions. The storage of these goods in a manner that prevents spoilage over extended periods has become an integral part of that horticultural activity before they are processed and placed on the market. </p>
            <p eId="para_34"> I am aware that this High Court decision has potential significant implications for the horticulture sector, which is already operating on very tight margins. The Minister of State, Deputy Collins, who has responsibility for horticulture as a delegated function, and I have written to the Minister for housing, Deputy Browne, and have requested engagement on the potential significant implications of this court ruling on the horticulture sector and any wider implications, including any opportunities to address a decision that goes beyond what I believe was the original policy intention. </p>
            <p eId="para_35"> The Government provided €15.7 million in payments to the horticulture sector in 2025 through a range of schemes. My Department provides significant support to the sector and €9 million has been made available in the budget for 2027. This builds on the substantial supports provided this year through the horticulture capital, innovation and diversification schemes, the fuel support schemes for specialist horticulture scheme, with a second tranche covering the period August to December 2026, and the fertiliser exceptional aid scheme recently announced by me and the Minister of State. These supports are in addition to the significant support available to fruit and vegetable growers through the CAP strategic plan including the producer organisation scheme for fruit and vegetables. </p>
            <p eId="para_36"> In addition to this financial support progress continues to be made on the eight cross-cutting key strategic actions contained in the National Strategy for Horticulture 2023-2027. The aim of this strategy is to drive change and growth across all the horticulture industry’s sub sectors leading to environmental, economic and social sustainability for the industry. Substantial progress has been made in the implementation of this strategy, helping drive this industry forward.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#VictorBoyhan" eId="spk_9">
            <from>Senator Victor Boyhan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_37">I thank the Minister for that comprehensive report. I do not doubt his ongoing enormous commitment to the horticultural sector. We had a discussion last night about aspects of potato production, which I will not go into now. </p>
            <p eId="para_38"> It is great to hear there will be a cross-government examination of it and greater clarity on the implications of the court judgment but farmers, growers and food producers who are currently outside the commercial rates system are seeking assurances. The focus must be on them initially. They have enjoyed this space outside rates, although many other producers are subject to rates and have particularly big storage capacity and commercial buildings associated with their enterprises. This is coming at a time when the sector is under enormous pressure. If it is not profitable, people will not stay in business. We know that is the case in any business but particularly in food and horticulture, which is tied up with food security.</p>
            <p eId="para_39"> I thank the Minister for his comprehensive response. It is something we should keep under review. In the short term, I ask the Minister to consider the case of those that are outside any rates at this time and whether there is anything to support them or make a case for them. If not, we need to prepare them for what is coming down the track.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinHeydon" eId="spk_10" as="#Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine">
            <from>Deputy Martin Heydon<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_40">We have a change of interpretation here. Court cases have the potential to do that. We have to see how this plays out. If there is any appeal, we want to see how it goes. I will work really closely with the Minister, Deputy Browne, on this. The Government’s policy rationale is that we recognise food production is a tight-margin operation and the storage of agricultural produce – food in large storage units would have a significant rate liability if they were rateable so they have been exempted for storage. That changes if processing is involved. With potatoes, for example, a farmer should be able to take a potato into a shed and store it until it is sold to market and that would not be rateable. That is the exemption. If, say, the potato was peeled, chipped and put in a bag to go out, that is processing. That is ratable activity and that is different. That is food production in a processing capacity. The concern is about storage and activity that involves storing it correctly, because people need this food all year round, which creates challenges, becoming rateable in certain instances. That is something we want to watch. I will work very closely with the Minister, Deputy Browne, on the interpretation of this case and any implications it may have.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MalcolmNoonan" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_11">
            <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Malcolm Noonan)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_41">We will have to suspend the House until the Minister of State's arrival.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#CathalByrne" eId="spk_12">
            <from>Senator Cathal Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_42">I propose that the sitting be suspended until the Minister of State's arrival.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MalcolmNoonan" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_13">
            <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Malcolm Noonan)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_43">Is that agreed? Agreed.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_4">
            <i>Cuireadh an Seanad ar fionraí ar 10.01 a.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 10.10 a.m.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_5">
            <i> Sitting suspended at 10.01 a.m. and resumed at 10.10 a.m.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_7">
          <heading>Driver Licences<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#CathalByrne" eId="spk_14">
            <from>Senator Cathal Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_44">The Minister of State is welcome to the Seanad Chamber. I tabled this Commencement matter because it is important to bring a little clarity to what is an important situation. I call on the Department of Transport to outline who is responsible for notifying the National Driver Licence Service, NDLS, of driving bans and licences that are held by people who are disqualified.</p>
            <p eId="para_45"> Nobody wants to see individuals who are disqualified from driving getting back behind the wheel. It is, therefore, important that we have a robust mechanism for clearly identifying to the men and women of An Garda Síochána the drivers who are disqualified. We also want those drivers to be able to look to see when that disqualification ends. I would be grateful for a response. I will come in thereafter with one or two queries.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance" eId="spk_15">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Deputy Robert Troy)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_46">I thank the Senator for raising this matter. I was delayed by traffic on my way in so I apologise for that.</p>
            <p eId="para_47"> The national vehicle and driver file, NVDF, is a State database, operated and maintained by the driver and vehicle computer service division of the Department of Transport. The NVDF contains details of all registered vehicles and their owners, as well as of all licensed drivers in the State. The record of licensed drivers on the NVDF includes details of any current penalty points or disqualifications on the driver’s record.</p>
            <p eId="para_48"> Penalty points are notified to the NVDF by An Garda Síochána on the payment of a fixed charge notice or by the Courts Service on conviction in a court. They are then applied to the driver record. Disqualifications may arise from a court conviction and are notified to the NVDF by the Courts Service. A driver may also be disqualified on reaching the penalty points threshold of seven or 12 points, depending on the driver's status on their driver record.</p>
            <p eId="para_49"> The NVDF is used by numerous Departments, agencies and other entities, including the NDLS, for a variety of purposes where a legal basis exists for the data to be shared and processed. In some cases, this will be the equivalent to read-only access, whereby a counterparty can access the NVDF to view or verify information on drivers or vehicles. In other situations the counterparty will send amendments or updates to the Department to be written onto records on the NVDF.</p>
            <p eId="para_50"> Every motorist has his or her own unique driver number. This is shown on section 4(d) on the driving licence. A driver number follows an individual, remaining the same even where a new licence is issued to the same person. The driver number is the key identifier used for the data matching to the NVDF.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#CathalByrne" eId="spk_16">
            <from>Senator Cathal Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_51">I thank the Minister of State for his response. I appreciate the clarification. In these situations, there is sometimes a little confusion if someone is disqualified because of reaching 12 penalty points or because of a court order. I appreciate the clarification that An Garda Síochána notifies once a driver has reached the 12-point threshold. I again thank the Minister of State.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_17" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_52">To clarify, when an individual has been disqualified from driving, it is notified to the Department of Transport by the courts or An Garda Síochána, as appropriate. The disqualification is recorded on the NVDF. The NDLS has access to the national vehicle and driver file and, therefore, can determine whether a driver is currently disqualified or has been awarded penalty points within the previous three years. The driver record also contains information on driver conditions, such as a requirement to wear spectacles while driving or a restriction limited to automatic transmissions. Information is provided by the Department to An Garda Síochána to indicate if a driver has been disqualified. The Garda uses the data to populate its PULSE system and the information is available to gardaí at the roadside under appropriate data-sharing procedures.</p>
            <p eId="para_53"> I hope that brings clarification for the Senator. I understand his rationale for wanting clarity brought to the situation. Anybody who is disqualified should not be driving. It is important that there is information sharing across the relevant authorities. As we can see from the information supplied by the Department, that is currently the case.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_8">
          <heading>Medicinal Products<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#DeeRyan" eId="spk_18">
            <from>Senator Dee Ryan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_54">I raise an important issue concerning equality of access to healthcare and specifically the availability of HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis, commonly known as PrEP, in Limerick and the wider mid-west. PrEP is a highly effective medication that prevents HIV infection. It is one of the most important tools that we have for reducing HIV transmission and protecting public health. Ireland established its national PrEP programme in 2019 and since then, more than 11,400 people have commenced PrEP through the programme. That is significant progress, which we should acknowledge.</p>
            <p eId="para_55"> However, information I have received from the Department of Health reveals a concerning geographical inequality in access to this essential preventative healthcare. In Limerick and the mid-west, there are currently 119 people on the waiting list for PrEP appointments across public clinics in Limerick and Ennis. It is more concerning that both clinics are closed to routine self-referrals and are accepting urgent referrals only. That means someone in Limerick who wants to take responsible and proactive steps to protect their sexual health cannot currently access a routine appointment through their local public PrEP service.</p>
            <p eId="para_56"> We can compare that with other parts of the country. In Letterkenny, a person can access a routine PrEP appointment within ten days. In Sligo, the waiting time is approximately four weeks. In Galway, it is approximately three months. In Limerick, however, routine self-referrals are closed altogether. It simply should not be the case that a person's ability to access HIV prevention depends so heavily on where they live.</p>
            <p eId="para_57"> There is another particularly concerning aspect to this. The Department has confirmed to me that there are 50 approved private or GP PrEP providers nationally. Of those, 45 are located in the three Dublin-based HSE regions. There is not a single approved GP PrEP provider in the entire mid-west region. Limerick previously had one approved GP provider but that practitioner relocated to Galway in June this year. That means people in Limerick face a double barrier. Routine appointments are unavailable, the waiting list is closed and there is no local GP provider to offer an alternative. That is a significant gap in preventative healthcare provision. We must ensure that areas such as Limerick, Clare and north Tipperary are not left without adequate access to essential services.</p>
            <p eId="para_58"> I have four questions. What immediate action can the HSE take to increase capacity at the Limerick and Ennis PrEP clinics, reduce the waiting list of 119 people and reopen routine self-referrals? Will the Minister for Health ensure that the particular difficulties facing the mid-west are addressed in the 2027 national service plan, including consideration of additional dedicated staffing for local PrEP services? What can be done to encourage and support GPs in Limerick and the wider mid-west to become approved PrEP providers? Surely, at a minimum, we should be working towards having a number of approved GPs providing the service locally. The HSE is currently evaluating a hybrid model of PrEP care combining online consultations with face-to-face services. Will the Minister consider the mid-west for the next phase of this initiative, which could make a difference to people who currently struggle to access appointments?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_19" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_59">I thank the Senator for the opportunity to address the House on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Health, on an issue of real significance to the people of the mid-west. Sexual health is a priority for the Department of Health. Our national sexual health strategy prioritises HIV prevention, early diagnosis and care. Furthermore, we are currently developing a HIV action plan that will focus on prevention, testing, early diagnosis, care, wider supports for people living with HIV and stigma reduction. A public consultation will launch in early 2027. Stakeholders and people living with HIV will be involved in the plan's subsequent development.</p>
            <p eId="para_60"> To reaffirm Ireland's commitment to tackling HIV, the Minister recently endorsed a refreshed Dublin Declaration focusing on ending onward transmission of HIV infections by 2030 in Europe, in line with international commitments.</p>
            <p eId="para_61">HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis, or PrEP, can reduce the risk of acquiring HIV sexually by approximately 99%. Our national PrEP programme was launched in 2019. Over 11,000 people have accessed PrEP at least once between 2019 and the end of 2025. Seven additional staff were recruited in late 2025 and the PrEP medication budget was increased in both 2025 and 2026. A PrEP clinic in Waterford, which was previously closed for some time, re-opened this August. The HSE has expanded PrEP training for GPs, with the number of approved providers increasing from 17 in late 2023 to 45.</p>
            <p eId="para_62"> A hybrid PrEP service is also in development and the home STI testing service is being used to help reduce in-person appointments. However, positive national developments can mask regional deficits, as Senator Ryan has highlighted this morning. HSE data from early 2026 indicated that the mid-west service, while closed to self-referrals, was meeting the core requirement of seeing people who had been urgently medically referred within three months. Previously reported waiting times in the mid-west were lower than in some other regions. However, longer waiting times have recently come to light, resulting from underlying consultant recruitment issues. The GP training service for PrEP is open to GPs across the country but to date no mid-west providers have been approved.</p>
            <p eId="para_63"> Community prevention and support services for people at risk of, or living with HIV, are provided through community partners, supported by the HSE sexual health programme. Additional funding of €400,000 was allocated in budget 2027 to support regional focus groups, including people living with HIV and community representatives. The HSE is supporting the HIV steering group in Limerick to increase the numbers of GP PrEP providers in the mid-west and advises that a GP provider in Nenagh is undergoing training. In the meantime, there is a wide range of GPs and other private providers in Dublin. In terms of public clinics, the Dublin-based gay men’s health service and GUIDE Clinic both provide online booking systems and can be accessed while we work with the HSE and community organisations to improve regional service provision.</p>
            <p eId="para_64"> In relation to the specific questions Senator Ryan has asked, clearly I cannot give confirmation today because it is not within my remit. The reply clearly outlines that work has already commenced on encouraging GPs. We all possibly have a role to play in this area and I have no doubt Senator Ryan is using her influence in Limerick and the broader area to encourage GPs to avail of the training which, as the reply states, is available. Additional funding has been secured in the 2027 national health plan. I will relay Senator Ryan's concerns and recommendation that some of this funding be diverted towards the region in question. In relation to the hybrid model being reviewed, I will take on board what the Senator has said and will relay it to the Minister for Health. There is one immediate action helping now, which is GP training and I encourage the Senator to encourage GPs to take advantage of this.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#DeeRyan" eId="spk_20">
            <from>Senator Dee Ryan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_65">I thank the Minister of State for his detailed response and I appreciate the information. It is great news that a GP in Nenagh is undergoing the training. We will continue to relay the message throughout the counties to encourage more GPs to do so. PrEP has been proven to be highly effective in preventing HIV infection. People seeking access to it are taking a responsible step to protect their health and our healthcare system must be in place to support this.</p>
            <p eId="para_66"> I acknowledge the contributions of prominent advocates such as Panti Bliss, Veda Lady and Robbie Lawlor, who have helped to challenge HIV stigma. The advances in HIV treatment and prevention have been transformative and it is no longer the death sentence it was in the 1980s. People living with HIV can lead full, healthy and fulfilling lives. However, they are required to take medication for the remainder of their lives. This is why, when we have tools such as PrEP to reduce new HIV transmissions significantly, we need to ensure they are accessible to everyone. I thank the Minister of State for the response.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_21" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_67">I agree fully with what Senator Ryan has said. The HSE is meeting quarterly targets to see 500 new PrEP patients but patients accessing PrEP regularly need repeat appointments and testing so new capacity is used up very quickly. Unmet need for PrEP is estimated at approximately 30% to 60%, and the number of those who may benefit from PrEP is also increasing by 500 to 600 annually. We can see that the service is growing and the demand for it is also growing. A review of PrEP services is ongoing and our challenge as a Government, and specifically for the Department of Health through the HSE, is to ensure an accessible service is delivered in every region in line with increasing demand. The aim is to support everyone who can benefit from PrEP to access it promptly, safely and without unnecessary barriers, in line with national and international policy. I confirm to Senator Ryan that I will relate back to the Minister for Health her specific requests for her region on foot of the representations she has made this morning.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_6">
            <i> Cuireadh an Seanad ar fionraí ar 10.26 a.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 10.34 a.m.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_7">
            <i> Sitting suspended at 10.26 a.m. and resumed at 10.34 a.m.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_9">
        <heading>Gnó an tSeanaid – Business of Seanad<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_22">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_68">Before I call the Acting Leader to outline the Order of Business, as Senators will be aware, Standing Order 87 allows Seanad Éireann to debate reports from Oireachtas committees and we have updated Standing Order 87 to allow for reports from the previous Dáil and Seanad to be debated as well. Currently, on the Order Paper we have scheduled, hopefully, in the new year for debate Perspectives on Constitutional Change: Women and Constitutional Change. We also have reports that will not only be debated in relation to their content but also their recommendations, including a report by the Joint Committee on Tourism, Culture, Arts, Sport and Media entitled A Safe and Respectful Working Environment in the Arts; a report by the Joint Committee on Agriculture, Food and the Marine entitled Issues Impacting Dog Welfare in Ireland; and a report on the school transport 2030 review and the school transport scheme. I ask Members to consider the opportunities that lie within Standing Order 87 whereby they can ask the Leader for a debate. The Cathaoirleach selects the reports that will be debated by the House to make sure the House goes through the recommendations contained in the reports. The Minister is invited in to address those issues and it is a great opportunity for the Seanad to scrutinise those reports that had been laid before the Houses, including in this Dáil term but also in the previous one, and to have the recommendations debated. It is a new procedure we brought in under Seanad reform. I ask Members to use it as an opportunity to make sure that when they have put all of the work into those committees, the recommendations are followed up, and it is the Seanad is able to do that. I ask them to look at Standing Order 87.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="orderofBusiness" eId="dbsect_10">
        <heading>An tOrd Gnó – Order of Business<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" eId="spk_23">
          <from>Senator Mary Fitzpatrick<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_69">The Order of Business is No.1, motion re a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation, Eurojust, and repealing Regulation (EU) 2018/1727, to be taken on the conclusion of the Order of Business without debate; No. 2, motion re the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund 2026, which is back from committee and is to be taken at 11.45 a.m. and to conclude at 12.45 p.m., if not previously concluded, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed five minutes, all Senators not to exceed five minutes each and the Minister to be given no less than five minutes to reply to the debate; and No. 68, motion 7, Private Members' business, motion re the protected disclosures system, to be taken at 1 p.m., with the time allocated to this debate not to exceed two hours.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AnneRabbitte" eId="spk_24">
          <from>Senator Anne Rabbitte<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_70">I am going to raise two items. The first and foremost is a positive one. Today, Dexcom is opening in Athenry, County Galway. Dexcom is a new pharmaceutical company and, believe it or not, it got its planning permission first time round. The facility was built on time and on budget. We cannot say that about all projects but we certainly can say that about Dexcom. It is a very welcome addition to Athenry and east Galway because in the past we have always provisioned all of our medtech in Galway city. With a growing and expanding city, in actual fact, everybody was travelling in from the east to be the employees of a factory in the city. It showed great foresight at the time, when IDA Ireland and Galway County Council worked with Teagasc and the Department of agriculture in ring-fencing the land in Moanbaun, Athenry. It now means Dexcom is opening the doors to approximately 1,000 people, including highly qualified engineers and technicians, which brings, in itself, huge positivity to east Galway and the surrounding counties, be it Mayo, Westmeath or Clare. It is not just all about Galway but it is putting us on the map. It also shows the foresight in relation to roads infrastructure because it is located on a major crossroad between Ennis, Clare, Limerick and Sligo. That was one of the few projects during the downturn. There were only three road projects kept on the books back in the early 2010s and that was one of the key pieces of infrastructure. Again, there was foresight by the local authority, the Department of Transport and the Minister with responsibility at the time to retain that project. It has opened up Athenry to its glory this morning. I am here as the only lone ranger from east Galway here today. I would say all of our colleagues in opposition are there as we speak to welcome its opening. I wish the community in Athenry the best. </p>
          <p eId="para_71"> It is great having that investment but we also need to look to the next generation.</p>
          <p eId="para_72">Far too often, we talk in this House about infrastructure for young people. When I look at that teenage population that will be coming through in Athenry, we need to ensure we have amenities to cater for them. While Athenry Camogie Club is looking after the ladies in sourcing fields and St. Mary's GAA Club is looking after the guys, there need to be other choices for young people in Athenry. We need to make sure there are skateparks, outdoor amenities and community centres they can access as well, so we ensure that for a student population of 2,100 young people attending Clarin College and Presentation College there are other choices available for young people. The last thing we want is any form of antisocial behaviour in a thriving, well-invested community.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ManusBoyle" eId="spk_25">
          <from>Senator Manus Boyle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_73">Today, I ask the Minister for housing to meet the DCB Silver Circle. It is a group of retired homeowners who have defective concrete blocks in Donegal. There was a meeting on Saturday in Dungloe. A large crowd attended. I was unable to attend for personal reasons. This is a group of people that has been set up. We all know there are major problems in Donegal with defective concrete blocks. I would really like the Minister to meet these people and listen to them. More could be done for them. They are really caught between a rock and a hard place here so the Leader might ask the Minister to meet them.</p>
          <p eId="para_74"> Before I finish, another thing that came up during the week was temporary modular homes being allowed to put on the site where people with defective blocks are trying to rebuild their houses and their lives. They are trying to keep their children beside the schools and in their communities. The Minister might have a meeting with us. We could have a chat and see how we could move this forward.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AubreyMcCarthy" eId="spk_26">
          <from>Senator Aubrey McCarthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_75">This morning I want to raise the cost of doing business in Ireland and the number of small businesses that are closing. Yesterday, we read about KC Peaches, just around the corner on Nassau Street. It is a restaurant I would have used. It is right opposite Trinity College and it has closed after 15 years. The owner, Katie Cantwell, said it was a big call to make. After employing staff since Covid, her supply costs have gone up by 40%. Her staff costs have shot up and statistics show that footfall in the city centre is down by 36%. In her own words, she is saying there is no way she can make this work. I acknowledge Ms Cantwell and all of the other SME owners out there who are struggling. Deloitte has published a report telling us that over 600 SMEs have gone insolvent in the past year.</p>
          <p eId="para_76"> I know it is not just Dublin. I know that my own home town of Naas used to be a thriving town. We had the Manor House at the top; all of the pubs would be full and there were brilliant shops. The main street was lined with business but today, Naas has the highest commercial vacancy of any town in Kildare. Even the businesses that open struggle. One unit on Fairgreen Street, which is close to where I live, has been a coffee shop three times in the past two years. It was then a waffle shop and now it is a vape shop. Imagine people like Ms Cantwell, who are showing courage, investing in their businesses and putting their savings on the line, and it just does not pay. I spoke about this in the House before with regard to my own business in County Kildare. We were there since 1969, when my father started it. You would sit down on a Sunday evening and realise that this does not actually make sense. Nobody begrudges people getting a decent wage but wages, sick pay, auto-enrolment, energy and rates have all shot up together. Often, it is the small business owner who is carrying the brunt.</p>
          <p eId="para_77"> The cost of business advisory forum reported in July. It issued a report with practical recommendations. I ask the Leader to arrange for the Minister for enterprise to come into the House and tell us which of those have been acted upon and when the rest will be. I know we have spoken in this house about foreign direct investment, FDI, and about how the multinationals employ thousands of people in Ireland. They need to be supported, and rightly so, but I would also say the same effort and focus needs to be given to the likes of Katie Cantwell, who is working just as hard to keep her businesses open. When the Intels and the Pfizers and all those have to leave eventually, it will be the SMEs who will be the backbone of our economy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ChrisAndrews" eId="spk_27">
          <from>Senator Chris Andrews<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_78">It has recently been reported that Portobello Institute graduates are being left unqualified for teaching jobs, despite these students completing a master's degree in education. The students were told that their degrees would not be recognised by the Teaching Council following a rule change, despite many being left unaware that this rule change was being made. One student was told directly by Portobello Institute that this degree would enable them to register with the Teaching Council. They were then advised, years into the course, that they were essentially wasting their time because they could not register with the Teaching Council.</p>
          <p eId="para_79"> Another case that was brought to my attention was a young woman who completed a Montessori teaching course in St. Nicholas Montessori College in Dún Laoghaire. In her third year, she was told that the qualification she had been working for would no longer be recognised by the Teaching Council. This situation has, understandably, been extremely frustrating for graduates. I think there were 30 in that cohort who were told that. It seems they are being punished for not noticing a bureaucratic technicality, one which appears to have been swept under the rug by the colleges or, at least, not advertised at the proper level by the colleges. Their degrees are being made worthless here in Ireland because of a purely bureaucratic decision which was clearly not communicated to those who have been affected.</p>
          <p eId="para_80"> There are a lot of people in this boat. One day, the qualifications were enough to teach in Ireland and the next day they were not. You would wonder how people are allowed to go through two or three years under the impression they would be able to qualify to be teachers and then three quarters of the way through that course, three or four years in, they are excluded.</p>
          <p eId="para_81"> Bizarrely, these qualifications are more than enough to work in other countries like Australia and Canada. We are technically forcing people to emigrate if they want to follow with a career in teaching and education. We should be enabling our young people to work more and contribute in Ireland and not push them abroad, which is what decisions like this are doing to many young people. It has been an ordeal for everyone and both the Ministers for education and higher education need to do everything that is possible to ensure these sorts of situations are not repeated, that students are not left high and dry and that they do not have to emigrate in order to follow their dreams.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MargaretMurphyOMahony" eId="spk_28">
          <from>Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_82">Today, I honour men and celebrate their impact. Today is International Men's Day.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_29">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_83">Yahoo, a Chathaoirligh.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ChrisAndrews" eId="spk_30">
          <from>Senator Chris Andrews<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_84">Every day.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MargaretMurphyOMahony" eId="spk_31">
          <from>Senator Margaret Murphy O'Mahony<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_85">Yes. I love men. I am going to say it officially on the record. I am blessed with a great husband, sons and brothers and great colleagues and friends, many of whom are male. Today, I celebrate them and thank them for what they bring to the table. Men and women are equal but we do bring different things to the table. It is important for us, in life, to work together. The world is definitely a much better place with men in it. Today, I celebrate them.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_32">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_86">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#LindaNelsonMurray" eId="spk_33">
          <from>Senator Linda Nelson Murray<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_87">In April 2025, I got an email from a lady called Caroline. She explained that on 20 October 2015, she gave birth to Stephen at 20 weeks and two days. He weighed 420 g but, unfortunately, passed away at the time of his birth. She was told she would not eligible for still-birth certificate because he did not meet the criteria. He was not 24 weeks nor was he 500 g. Stephen was perfect, though; he had ten fingers, ten toes, a cute button nose and he was the image of his daddy.</p>
          <p eId="para_88"> I sat there with Caroline and her husband on that day, listening. She listened to me about my story and the pain of miscarriage. Sometimes people - and maybe the young people in the Gallery - wonder what politicians do and what we work at. I can tell them, from talking to Caroline that day and then joining a new cross-party group on pregnancy and infant loss, we have driven the work on this.</p>
          <p eId="para_89">There is no "I" in team. We have worked with TDs and Senators, including Evanne Ní Chuilinn, Nicole Ryan and Tom Clonan. We met every month for the past year and half. Yesterday, the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Dara Calleary, informed the Select Committee on Social Protection, Rural and Community Development that he wants:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_90">... to give notice to the committee that I hope to table an amendment on Report Stage that would introduce, on a statutory basis, a scheme to allow the parent or parents of a child lost in early pregnancy to apply for a certificate from the State that would recognise the loss they have suffered.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_34">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_91">Hear, hear. Well said.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#LindaNelsonMurray" eId="spk_35">
          <from>Senator Linda Nelson Murray<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_92">Thank you. To Caroline Smith, thank you for contacting me. Thank you for working with me. To every mother out there who has longed for a pregnancy loss certificate to recognise that they had a much-wanted baby, I want to tell you that we are almost there on this work. To groups such as like Féileacáin, the Miscarriage Association of Ireland and the Pregnancy Loss Research Group that tirelessly fed information to our cross-party group, thank you. Finally, to the Minister, Deputy Dara Calleary, who has listened to us, I say thank you. Thank you to his adviser, Craig. I have a little word for the Minister. Let us keep driving this. Let us get this vital piece of paper for women and families out there.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_36">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_93">Well said.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#" eId="spk_37">
          <from> Senators<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_94">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MartinConway" eId="spk_38">
          <from>Senator Martin Conway<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_95">Well done.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_39">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_96">Thank you, Senator. I know you have raised that issue and have been working very hard on it over the past while. Part of what happens in Seanad Éireann is that people bring their own personal experience to bear and make sure that it benefits others in terms of getting change where change is needed. I thank you and all the others involved in that particular matter.</p>
          <p eId="para_97"> Before I call the next speaker, I welcome the guests of Deputy Grace Boland from the Balscadden school and thank them for being here today.</p>
          <p eId="para_98"> Anois, an Seanadóir Craughwell.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_40">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_99">I rise to offer my condolences to the family of Private Lee Reeves who died as a result of an injury received while boxing. Maybe his death might get the boxing associations to look at their safety procedures. Boxing is a tough sport. I fought three bouts in my life. Actually, I fought two. I jumped out of the ring for the third one because I was not going to take another beating.</p>
          <p eId="para_100"> There has been a lot of talk about the triple lock. I have tried to keep my counsel as much as I can. The triple lock is a Government issue. It is up to the Government to get what it is doing in this regard over the line . It is not my job to do the job of the Government. However, there has been a lot of talk about peace enforcement and people saying that if we lose the triple lock we will be involved in peace enforcement. Here is the news. We have been involved in peace enforcement since 1993. Sometimes there are warring factions that just will not come to the table to discuss peace and that have to be kept apart. From my point of view, peace enforcement is part and parcel of what we do. Our troops have worn the blue beret as UN peacekeepers in various parts of the world. They have also worn the black beret on Chapter VIII missions authorised by the United Nations Security Council. Those missions involved peace enforcement. Let us be honest about what we are talking about. Ultimately, our troops need to have freedom to serve this country. We spent 800 years seeking to get our sovereignty. What did we do when we go it? We handed it back and said that we were neutral and that we would do nothing unless the United Nations Security Council approved it. Then, the NICE treaty brought in the United Nations General Assembly.</p>
          <p eId="para_101"> The bottom line is that we are a proud sovereign nation. We stand on our own. I am sick to the back teeth of listening to people talking about our neutrality being threatened. Who has been protecting Ireland for the past six months? The French and the British. Two NATO countries, and we start talking about neutrality. There is no enshrinement of neutrality in the Irish Constitution or in law. It is a policy issue and nothing else. It is up to the Government to resolve the issues surrounding the Nice and Lisbon treaties when it comes to the triple lock, but the triple lock is the abdication of our sovereignty.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#OllieCrowe" eId="spk_41">
          <from>Senator Ollie Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_102">I want to raise the issue of road safety. As members will be aware, the Joint Committee on Transport will today be publishing a report on this matter. I have spoken about this topic already this year, but, unfortunately, the figures in recent weeks make it clear that the problem is continuing. Those figures show that there has been a significant increase in the number of young people being killed on the country's roads this year. According to the provisional figures for 2026, 45 people under the age of 25 have died in road collisions to date this year. That is almost a third of all road traffic fatalities. This compares with 33 people under the age of 25 being killed in the same period last year and represents an increase of over 40%.</p>
          <p eId="para_103"> Today, the Joint Committee on Transport will today recommend the establishment of an independent road safety commissioner to co-ordinate road safety activities across Departments and agencies. It has made a number of other recommendations, including increasing numbers in Garda roads policing units, the consolidation of the Road Traffic Acts, the deployment of safety cameras and the introduction of a new offence whereby persons who deliberately travel the wrong way down a motorway will be the subject of much stronger custodial sentences. These recommendations are all worthy of serious consideration. Unfortunately, it is clear from the rising number of road deaths that we must take action. I would be grateful if the Leader would invite the Minister for Transport to the House for a debate on this topic in the coming weeks.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CathalByrne" eId="spk_42">
          <from>Senator Cathal Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_104">I want to begin by fully supporting what Senator Andrews said. I have met students at my clinics in Wexford who, having attended the Portobello Institute, have experienced the same difficulties in having their qualifications recognised by the Teaching Council. This is a matter that will have to be looked at in greater detail.</p>
          <p eId="para_105"> On behalf of the Fine Gael group, I would like to offer my condolences to the family of Jim Corr, the former TD, two-time Lord Mayor of Cork and long-standing member of Cork City Council for 40 years. He was a passionate believer in public service. His funeral will take place in the coming days. It is important that we acknowledge in this Chamber people who have given 40 years of public service.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_43">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_106">On behalf of the House, I extend our deepest sympathies to the family and friends of Jim Corr. Forty years of public service is an amazing record, and not likely to be reached nowadays. Obviously, people now spend a certain a time in public service. Spending 40 years or four decades - that is nearly half a century and nearly half the lifetime of the State - in public service is quite an amazing contribution. Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam dílis.</p>
          <p eId="para_107"> Anois, an Seanadóir Tom Clonan.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_44">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_108">I rise today to again bring some clarity regarding the issue of the triple lock. I want to particularly address my good colleagues in Fianna Fáil. Senator Craughwell said that we have done peace enforcement before. We have. In Somalia, Kosovo, East Timor and elsewhere, but what we have never done is done it without a UN mandate. When it is without a UN mandate, as proposed by the Taoiseach and the Minister, it is warfighting. Let us be clear. I say that as somebody who has had the unique privilege of commanding Irish troops overseas in direct fire and indirect fire. I know what I am talking about.</p>
          <p eId="para_109"> I got a letter from a woman whose husband was killed in Lebanon on UN service. It reads:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_110">Dear Tom,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_111">I can no longer stay silent.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_112">My husband was killed in Lebanon.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_113">As I watch the ongoing debate about abolishing the Triple Lock, I find myself becoming increasingly angry. Not because of party politics, but because of what is being forgotten [or omitted from statements in this House].</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_114">My husband did not go to Lebanon as a "peace enforcer". He went as a peacekeeper. He believed in the mission. He loved the people of Lebanon and was immensely proud to wear the Blue Beret and of everything it represented: neutrality, service, humanity and peace.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_115">That Blue Beret meant something. It still does.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_116">The men who served in Lebanon under the United Nations flag accepted hardship and danger in the pursuit of peace. Some, including my husband, paid the ultimate price.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_117">When I hear people dismissing or undermining the principles that Irish peacekeeping has stood for, I cannot help but feel that their sacrifice is being diminished.</p>
          <p eId="para_118"> In some of the responses made by the Minister, there has been an attempt to disparage the service of people like me. It is disgraceful. The letter continues:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_119">Their service deserves respect. Their memory deserves respect.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_120">I am proud of my husband. I am proud of the Blue Beret. And I will continue to defend what it stands for.</p>
          <p eId="para_121"> So will I. In particular, I ask my colleagues in Fianna Fáil to join me in that defence. Do not take this step. This letter is from a woman who lost her husband.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_45">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_122">Senator, your time is up.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_46">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_123">This is not about lobbyists going on RTÉ or other platforms talking absolute tripe about something they know nothing of.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_47">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_124">Senator, your time is up. Anois, Senator Gallagher.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RobbieGallagher" eId="spk_48">
          <from>Senator Robbie Gallagher<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_125">The cyberattack on our credit unions is very worrying and concerning for many people. It is causing great stress and annoyance to many of our people. It is important to say at the outset we are advised that people's money and savings are safe. That is hugely important. It is expected that the people affected will be receiving texts and scams and it is important they do not act on them. If anybody wants assurance, I suggest they call into their local credit union where the excellent staff who operate there will help them.</p>
          <p eId="para_126"> As was mentioned earlier. today is International Men's Day. The message I would like to get out today is about men connecting with their health. In relation to their physical health, I encourage men to go at least once a year to their GP and get their MOT from a physical perspective. Equally, if not more important, is their mental health. Unfortunately, we men are not the best at talking about our mental health struggles, which we all have from time to time. It is worth noting that 80% of all suicides in this country are male.</p>
          <p eId="para_127"> In that regard, I would like to give a shout-out to the Minister of State, Deputy Mary Butler, on her initiative of some 12 months ago where she introduced a free counselling service for men. The response has been outstanding. Over 10,000 men have connected with that service in the past 12 months with more than 30,000 counselling sessions received. That is hugely positive. It is a free service. I encourage men who are feeling down or stressed, as we all do from time to time, to reach out and know that there is help available, but they have to reach out and ask for it. If people do not want to use the helpline, they can access it online or in person. They can also simply pick up the telephone and call 1800 577 577 between 5 p.m. and 9 p.m. each evening, and there will be a qualified therapist there to help. As the old adage goes, a problem shared is a problem halved.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RayMcAdam" eId="spk_49">
          <from>Senator Ray McAdam<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_128">I want to extend my condolences to the family of the late Jim Corr. As former Lord Mayor of Dublin, I want to extend my sympathies to Jim's family. He was a former TD and gave almost 40 years to public service. It is important that we acknowledge that.</p>
          <p eId="para_129"> The Acting Leader will be familiar with the lack of mobile BreastCheck facilities in the north inner city. I raise this issue this morning because we know in the likes of Sean MacDermott Street in the heart of Dublin 1, women are effectively keeping families together, looking after grandchildren and looking after the extended family. The problem is they are not getting the chance to look after themselves. Through the North East Inner City Initiative, the HSE was very good in locating a mobile BreastCheck facility in the grounds of the church on Sean MacDermott Street. Senator Fitzpatrick and I both know the dividends that paid in terms of helping a lot of our constituents with early diagnosis of breast cancer. I ask that, through Senator Fitzpatrick's office and the Leader of the Seanad, we liaise with the HSE and the Minister for Health to increase the availability of mobile BreastCheck facilities in the likes of the Dublin 1 area.</p>
          <p eId="para_130"> This is something we should look for in other parts of the city, as well, because these are women who are doing it tough. They are doing it hard and they are keeping families together but are not getting the chance to look after their own health. Every available opportunity the State can provide to make it easier on them should be examined and advanced. I request that we move this forward.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SarahOReilly" eId="spk_50">
          <from>Senator Sarah O'Reilly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_131">I want to raise the issue of CAP funding. The proposed CAP funding cuts will see a 24% reduction in payments for Irish farmers. That 24% is incredibly high, but what does that mean for each county or for the individual farmers involved? Over the seven-year CAP period, from 2028 to 2034, these proposed cuts would mean a €72 million loss for Cavan farmers and a €54 million loss for farmers in Monaghan. The multiplier effect for that financial loss will be devastating for the local economy and for farm families also.</p>
          <p eId="para_132"> In the 1980s, CAP accounted for 60% of the EU budget but if the cuts go ahead, it will only be 15% of the EU budget, which has not decreased but has increased. I want to be clear about what is happening here. Farmers are being put out to pasture so the EU can redirect the budget for military spending. Billions of euro will be taken from CAP, fisheries and the European Social Fund so it can be used for weapons and militarisation. That is the reality.</p>
          <p eId="para_133"> CAP was brought in after the Second World War to guarantee food security and ensure people had access to affordable produce. Every day we hear a Government Minister or representative talking about growing global instability. We are told we need to be prepared for cyberattacks and disruption to supply chains. Where is the focus on food security? The EU is talking about arming up for war, while destroying the ability for member states to produce food internally. How do you plan on feeding people if there are disruptions to supply chains? These are crazy cuts.</p>
          <p eId="para_134"> The EU is prioritising the wrong issues and I hope our Minister has enough gumption to point that out. We should not rush into a deal just to get it over the line. If there is not a new agreement, then the budget for this year will automatically be set for next year. That leaves our farmers in a better position than having to adopt a sudden cut to their budget. The Government has to hold the line and negotiate a deal for Irish farmers. The Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Deputy Martin Heydon, should know that no deal is better than a bad deal, and I call on the Minister to come here for a debate. I do not think he has been into the House to debate this issue.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#NessaCosgrove" eId="spk_51">
          <from>Senator Nessa Cosgrove<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_135">The UK-based docudrama "Dirty Business" shows what happens when essential public infrastructure is sold off to private equity firms, often located overseas and interested only in profit. As we know, private equity firms repeatedly strip out value, quality and services in a bid to maximise short-term returns and then sell the company a few years down the line to make a profit.</p>
          <p eId="para_136"> In this docudrama, which looked at the privatisation of water services, the government agency that was tasked with overseeing the regulation of the water companies was compromised by links to the industry, so, effectively, the multinational corporations were left to regulate themselves. This true story results in predictable disaster, as water quality plummets and raw sewage is repeatedly discharged straight into the rivers, leading to pollution, massive fish kills, and, tragically, the death of an eight-year-old girl.</p>
          <p eId="para_137"> The reason I bring this up is to ensure water services stay in public ownership. The programme looks at the detrimental effects of the corporatisation of state services. We have seen it in housing. We have recently seen an increase in the corporatisation of elderly care, healthcare, social care, and we now see it in early years and childcare. If we keep allowing it to go on and keep sleepwalking into this, it is not going to end well. Eighteen months ago, I raised the issue of elder care and some of the most vulnerable citizens in our State being served with eviction notices because a group invested in by private equity firms sold off its shares. It was an Irish-owned company. These elderly adults were served with eviction notices.</p>
          <p eId="para_138"> Earlier this year, the <i>Dublin Inquirer</i> reported that 11 large commercial organisations, some of which are backed by investment corporations, received two thirds of the €270 million spent by Tusla on providing residential care for children in this State. In childcare, we are increasingly seeing roles played by big national corporations with direct State-funded money, and the €1.6 billion that goes into the early years sector is being given into the hands of private equity firms.</p>
          <p eId="para_139">If this was not bad enough, we learned that some of the CEOs of these chains hold voluntary positions on some of these important boards. This came up last Thursday at a meeting of the children’s committee. One CEO of a corporate chain that was recently purchased by an equity firm has a majority stake in that equity firm, so she holds two important positions. First, she is chairperson of the Fingal County Childcare Committee and, second, she is a representative on a joint labour committee, JLC. Both of these positions are influential, not only in determining remuneration for low-paid workers in the sector but also in the context of influencing Government policy in a number of areas. Conflicts of interest need to be called out. I request that we have a debate with the Minister around the provision of State-led care within the early years sector. Who is going to call out these conflicts of interest? We have called them out now. What is the Minister going to do about them?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_52">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_140">Before I call the next speaker, I welcome Padraig Ronahan, Gaelcholáiste an Phiarsaigh and boxers with the Nutgrove Boxing Club. I also welcome the guests of Deputy Joe Neville from Scoil Uí Dálaigh.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VictorBoyhan" eId="spk_53">
          <from>Senator Victor Boyhan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_141">I will speak briefly on the report, Connecting Communities, Global Relationships. The Minister, Deputy Calleary, organised a briefing in the audiovisual room last week on the report and on the potential of our diaspora. That was timely. I am conscious that the Genealogical Society of Ireland is one of the bodies that nominated Senator McAdam. In a recent edition of its journal, the society commented very favourably on the Senator. I am sure that he will have a huge interest in this matter. The Senator might use his connections to push this along. The Minister organised the briefing on the Connected Communities, Global Relationships report and spoke about the importance of connecting with our diaspora and the significant economic return and leveraging this could bring. There has also been a new interest in genealogy since the publication of the 1926 census, which is important.</p>
          <p eId="para_142"> The report in question contains 12 recommendations. I will not read them into the record. The report builds on the ideas arising from the public consultation process. There was engagement and there were opportunities to identify the key areas we should look at, namely: strategic leadership and co-ordination; shared infrastructure and capacity; collaboration, networking and learning; targeting audiences and research; and, of course, moving from connection to impact and leveraging our diaspora. This is a positive area. There is a lot of potential to and interest in it. As I alluded to, the Genealogical Society of Ireland has nomination rights for the Seanad. Senator McAdam is its latest nominated candidate. I congratulate the society on its participation in that process. It would be timely to have a debate on the document to which I refer at an appropriate time, maybe early in the new year. We should have such a debate.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RonanMullen" eId="spk_54">
          <from>Senator Rónán Mullen<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_143">I take this opportunity to congratulate Senator McAdam on his win and fine campaign. I compliment him on his handwriting in particular.</p>
          <p eId="para_144"> The Congregation of Christian Brothers has been faulted for its legal strategy in dealing with civil actions relating to historical abuse. As it is not an incorporated company, it can only be sued as a body if it puts up a nominee to defend claims, which it has declined to do. I have not been in touch with the Congregation of Christian Brothers about this matter, nor has it asked me to make any comment on it. However, I want to offer a couple of observations about the ongoing debate. I note the comments of the Taoiseach, as well as the particularly harsh comments of the Tánaiste who, not for the first time, resorted to the use of the word "despicable". This is a discussion in which there is more than one legitimate point of view.</p>
          <p eId="para_145"> From listening to the media, I know that the Congregation of Christian Brothers is saying that its focus is on settling abuse claims quicker and without the stress and delays of litigation. It points out that as well as contributions to redress and statutory funds, it has also provided compensation of over €40 million, including legal fees to over 200 claimants. It also provides counselling for the survivors of abuse. Typically, it acknowledges claims with an offer of mediation and says that the majority of claims are settled within 12 months. Members can take that either way, but it is at least arguable that the Congregation of Christian Brothers is entitled to try to settle cases and use all legal means to stay out of court. When it points out that in one case the legal fees generated by the plaintiff’s representation amounted to almost 19 times the value of the financial compensation paid, its caution towards the legal system does not, on the basis of one reading, seem so strange.</p>
          <p eId="para_146"> I note the way Senator Boyhan spoke about this matter yesterday. I endorse that 100%. We can all have our views on what is right or wrong here. We know the courts have allowed the publication of current and former brothers in order to allow claims to proceed. There can be no issue with whatever order the court makes with regard to the procedure of things, but, in general, people are entitled to take their own legal approach to matters. Where it is necessary to limit that, such as in the case of the Strategic Lawsuits against Public Participation Bill 2026,<b>
						</b>we do the right thing and legislate in order to avoid abuses. Where courts and judges are saying-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_55">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_147">This might be an issue in respect of which a Commencement matter could be submitted.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RonanMullen" eId="spk_56">
          <from>Senator Rónán Mullen<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_148">I will finish on this. Where courts and judges are somehow making moral commentary on people’s legal approaches, that is not the role for them. Let them make their moral judgments when making findings of guilt or liability, but it is important that judges preserve their objectivity in these matters.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_57">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_149">As Members are aware, there are matters that are <i>sub judice </i>in this case. Obviously, Members are able to discuss matters under the Standing Orders, despite the issue around matters that are <i>sub judice</i>, but they need to remain within the parameters of the Standing Orders when they do so.</p>
          <p eId="para_150"> I welcome Emma Burke, who is a guest of Deputy Michael Cahill. She is an internship student from Boston. She is most welcome to Seanad Éireann. I thank her for being here. I call the Acting Leader to respond to the Order of Business.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" eId="spk_58">
          <from>Senator Mary Fitzpatrick<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_151">I welcome Deputy Cahill, all the way from the kingdom, and his visitor.</p>
          <p eId="para_152"> The Order of Business this morning commenced with a contribution from Senator Anne Rabbitte, all the way from east Galway. I know she was disappointed not to be in Galway this morning for the official opening of the Dexcom facility. She worked hard over a long period to support Dexcom and get Government support for that facility, at which over 1,000 highly skilled and talented workers will be employed. While I am disappointed for the Senator, I am thrilled and I share her celebration of such an achievement. I thank the people of Athenry for how they have welcomed and supported Dexcom and how they value its presence in its community.</p>
          <p eId="para_153"> The Senator spoke passionately about the need to support young people in Athenry in order that, hopefully, they will get to complete their education and further training and be able to continue to live and work in the area. Her call for funding for community spaces for young people is incredibly on the mark. In the first instance, this is a matter that should be raised with the local authority back in Galway and secondarily with the Department of Education and Youth.</p>
          <p eId="para_154"> Senator Boyle is a great champion of his community in Dungloe. He raised the issue of the DCB Silver Circle, a group of people who, unfortunately, have found themselves with homes affected by defective concrete blocks. Obviously, this is a huge priority. He has asked for the Minister for housing, Deputy Browne, to meet these people. The Minister, within his first week of holding the office, went up to Donegal to meet families and communities impacted by the defective concrete blocks scheme. The scheme is in place. I am disappointed to hear that families who qualify and whose homes have been affected are not getting the support they need, particularly as it is a very generous scheme. The amount on offer is close to €500,000 per household. I struggle to understand why it is not working and why the DCB Silver Circle does not feel it is working. I will certainly pass on the request for a meeting.</p>
          <p eId="para_155"> Senator McCarthy raised the issue of the cost of doing business. This is an issue that I have also raised. As Members will be aware, RGDATA nominated me to contest the Seanad election. It indicates – I have raised this issue previously - that only four out of ten of its members, independent SME retailers, expect to turn a profit this year. This is a huge issue. We need the Minister for enterprise, Deputy Burke, to come to the House and provide an update on his forum.</p>
          <p eId="para_156">He has made this a priority. We will arrange that as soon as possible.</p>
          <p eId="para_157"> Senator Andrews raised the issue of the qualifications of Portobello graduates, their master's degrees in education, not being recognised by the Teaching Council. I will take this issue up with the Minister for higher education.</p>
          <p eId="para_158"> Senator Murphy O'Mahony loves all men. Why would she not? Are they not great? They are our husbands, our sons, our brothers, our colleagues and our friends. It is important to celebrate them. We might give out about them an awful lot.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RonanMullen" eId="spk_59">
          <from>Senator Rónán Mullen<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_159">We never hear it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" eId="spk_60">
          <from>Senator Mary Fitzpatrick<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_160">We probably give out about them a bit too much of the time. However, the truth is that we love them and celebrate them. Senator Gallagher returned to that theme in his contribution. He emphasised the need for men to look after themselves. As their mammies, we look after them initially. Their wives and partners also look after them. However, do you know what? Lads need to look after themselves. We all do. I do not say that to scold them or to give out to them. I say it because we really do care about them. They need to look after their physical and mental health. Take care of it. Nobody else is going to do it for you.</p>
          <p eId="para_161"> I congratulate Senator Nelson Murray and everybody in the cross-party group that has taken up the issue of the loss of a child in pregnancy. It is a very personal and very lonely thing. The group has worked on a cross-party basis and is about to achieve something that was not achieved by others. Without meaning any disrespect, this group is not the first to have raised this issue. Others did so before them. They went to previous Ministers. I am not talking about one or two previous Ministers but about quite a few. I congratulate the Senator and everybody involved in the cross-party group. This is what real politics is. This is why we are in politics. It is so that we can make changes like this. I congratulate the Minister, Deputy Calleary, on engaging with the group, listening to it and amending the law so that women and families who experience the loss of a child in pregnancy can have a certificate. Well done. It is a really important achievement.</p>
          <p eId="para_162"> Senator Craughwell offered his condolences on the passing of Private Lee Reeves. He hoped that the boxing association would review its safety procedures. The Senator went on to talk about the triple lock and articulated how Ireland has been involved in peace enforcement since 1993. He asserted how proud we should be of our status as an independent and sovereign state and how we should not shirk that responsibility or abdicate our capacity and power to act independently.</p>
          <p eId="para_163"> Senator Crowe spoke about road safety and the increasing number of deaths on our roads. He made specific reference to the report from the Oireachtas committee. That was timely considering the Cathaoirleach's encouragement to Senators at the beginning of this debate on the Order of Business to put reports like this on the agenda. Perhaps Senator Crowe might take up that invitation to propose a debate in the House on the latest report.</p>
          <p eId="para_164"> Senator Cathal Byrne also raised the issue of those students and the Teaching Council. We will raise this issue with the Minister for higher education. The Senator offered his condolences and those of the Fine Gael group to the family, friends and colleagues of the former TD, Jim Corr, who served as a public representative for 40 years. He was clearly somebody who understood the value and importance of good public representation and public service. I offer my condolences to the Senator, to the Fine Gael Party and to Jim Corr's family and friends. Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam.</p>
          <p eId="para_165"> Senator Clonan shared his observations on the triple lock and his pride in the blue beret and the tradition of peacekeeping.</p>
          <p eId="para_166"> Senator Gallagher spoke about the cyberattacks on the credit unions. It is a serious issue. The Minister of State at the Department of Finance who has responsibility for this area, Deputy Troy, has been actively engaging with the credit unions on it. Senator Gallagher's advice to members of credit unions who have concerns is not to respond to any texts or potential scams and to go into their credit unions. Credit unions are incredibly valued in all of our communities. There are incredibly talented staff working in them. People should just go in and check with their credit unions if they have concerns.</p>
          <p eId="para_167"> Senator McAdam added his condolences to those of Senator Byrne's on the passing of the former TD and councillor, Jim Corr. He also raised a really important issue in relation to women's health, particularly in our own constituency and the north inner city. He is right. The NEIC ran an excellent initiative in having the mobile breast check unit come down to Sean MacDermott Street. The NEIC is to be commended on the work it is doing both generally and in the area of women's health. It recently had a whole series of events in relation to women's health and women's health issues. This is an issue we could raise with the Minister. We could ask her to ask the HSE to arrange for the BreastCheck van to return to Sean MacDermott Street.</p>
          <p eId="para_168"> Senator Sarah O'Reilly raised concerns about CAP funding. There is no doubt about it; this Government and the Minister have been very clear. Our spokesperson for agriculture, Senator Paul Daly, is hoarse in the throat from raising the issue of concerns about CAP funding. It is a real concern. The Government's position is that Europe cannot expect farmers to continue to do more for food security, climate action and rural communities while giving them less support. That is just not a sustainable proposition. The Government has highlighted that. I caution the Opposition against scaremongering on this issue. We have a very competent Minister and junior Minister. We have a Government that really understands the agricultural community and the value of agriculture to our country. What is being spoken about is part of the multi-annual financial framework for 2028 to 2034. I hear the concerns and echo them. The Government is certainly alert to this.</p>
          <p eId="para_169"> Senator Cosgrove raised the issue of conflicts of interest in State-provided early childcare. We will request that the Minister come in to address that issue.</p>
          <p eId="para_170"> Senator Boyhan raised the issue of the report launched last week by the Minister, Deputy Calleary, on the diaspora and requested a debate on the diaspora. He made his point well. We will arrange for that, probably early in the new year.</p>
          <p eId="para_171"> Senator Mullen raised the issue of claims being made against the Christian Brothers, which is an issue that has been going on for far too long. I am very conscious that these matters are before the courts so I will be temperate in what I say. However, it is important that, when people seek justice, they get it. Justice delayed is justice denied. I will not say anything more on the matter but I heard the Senator's comments.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_8"> Order of Business agreed to.</summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="motion" eId="dbsect_11">
        <heading>European Union Regulations: Motion<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" eId="spk_61">
          <from>Senator Mary Fitzpatrick<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_172">I move:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_173">That Seanad Éireann approves the exercise by the State of the option or discretion under Protocol No. 21 on the position of the United Kingdom and Ireland in respect of the area of freedom, security and justice annexed to the Treaty on European Union and to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, to take part in the adoption and application of the following proposed measure: </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_174">Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation (Eurojust) and repealing Regulation (EU) 2018/1727,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_175">a copy of which was laid before Seanad Éireann on 23rd July, 2026.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_9"> Question put and agreed to.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_10">
          <i> Cuireadh an Seanad ar fionraí ar 11.29 a.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 11.48 a.m.</i>
        </summary>
        <summary eId="sum_11">
          <i> Sitting suspended at 11.29 a.m. and resumed at 11.48 a.m.</i>
        </summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="motion" eId="dbsect_12">
        <heading>Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026: Motion<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#ParaicBrady" eId="spk_62">
          <from>Senator Paraic Brady<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_176">I move:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_177">That Seanad Éireann approves the following Regulations in draft:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_178">Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_179">copies of which were laid in draft form before Seanad Éireann on 9th October, 2026.”</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MartinHeydon" as="#Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine" eId="spk_63">
          <from>Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine (Deputy Martin Heydon)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_180">The horse and greyhound industries have deep historical links to Ireland’s economy and cultural heritage. Both sectors play an important role in balanced regional growth, offering substantial economic and social benefits to rural communities. By supporting jobs and local economies, they ensure balanced growth across the country. Successive Governments have recognized this importance through supportive legislation and policy. Exchequer funding via the horse and greyhound racing fundsustains these sectors and drives their development, ensuring this vital public investment continues to yield an excellent return and leads to a flow of income throughout the economy, thereby providing widespread benefits for our society. </p>
          <p eId="para_181"> The horse and greyhound racing industries receive financial support from the State through the horse and greyhound racing fundunder section 12 of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Act 2001. Payments are made from the fund to Horse Racing Ireland, HRI, and to Rásaíocht Con Éireann, RCE. Since 2001, a total of €1.9 billion has been paid from the fund to the horse and greyhound racing industries in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The cumulative upper limit on payments from the fund provided for under the relevant regulations has been reached. To give effect to the provisions of budget 2027, this cumulative upper limit must be increased by regulation. </p>
          <p eId="para_182"> The Estimates for my Department, passed by both Houses as part of budget 2027, include an allocation of €102 million for the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund. This will be distributed in accordance with section 12(6) of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Act 2001, with 80% or €81.6 million to HRI, and 20% equating to €20.4 million to RCE. The proposed increase in the fund this year is linked to the implementation of the recommendations contained in the Indecon review, in respect of both equine and greyhound welfare and integrity. This will form part of my Department’s overall animal welfare package and is in line with the programme for Government commitments on equine and greyhound welfare. It is also worth pointing out this approach is consistent with the strategic plans of both RCE and HRI. </p>
          <p eId="para_183"> To allow my Department to provide the monies allocated in budget 2027, it is necessary to comply with the technical requirement under section 12(13) of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Act, to increase the cumulative limit on the amount payable from the horse and greyhound racing fundby €102 million to just over €2 billion. This is achieved by way of the regulations submitted to the House today.</p>
          <p eId="para_184"> In the time I have remaining here, I will turn my attention to specific sectors and will begin with the Irish horse racing and breeding industry, a vital pillar of the country’s rural economy. A 2023 Deloitte report on the social and economic impact of Irish thoroughbred breeding and racing revealed the thoroughbred sector generated an annual economic impact of €2.46 billion, marking a substantial 34% growth since 2016. Furthermore, the horse racing sector sustains over 30,000 direct and indirect jobs, predominantly distributed across rural communities. Ireland has a globally recognised reputation in both breeding and racing excellence. We know of the six counties and ten stables that were on show at the Breeders' Cup in Keeneland, Kentucky at the end of October. These achievements also demonstrate the cumulative value of sustained investment in bloodstock, facilities, people and international relationships. Sustaining this premier position requires continuous effort and a continued focus on human and equine welfare in line with Horse Racing Ireland's own current strategic plan. HRI is committed to maintaining the highest standards in conjunction with the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, IHRB, and my Department will continue to back the HRI and IHRB in these efforts. </p>
          <p eId="para_185"> For the greyhound industry, greyhound racing across the country has a valued heritage and a deep sporting and cultural history in Ireland. This industry supports significant economic activity nationwide, and this funding underpins economic activity in what are, in many instances, highly rural areas. The greyhound industry continues to support considerable direct and indirect employment across the country. For owners and participants, it remains a central part of daily life, delivering vital economic support and building strong, lasting social connections. The industry’s future relies on a strong governance platform and upholding the highest standards of integrity and welfare, supported by a robust regulatory system. We do that with Rásaíocht Con Éireann through its financial support for the Irish Retired Greyhound Trust, IRGT, and contributing to rehoming greyhounds. We know there is a very high level of welfare inspections and transparency with the increased number of inspections. A total of 2,636 were carried out in 2025. </p>
          <p eId="para_186"> We will continue to support those two sectors, as affirmed in the programme for Government, with a clear focus on increasing support in the area of welfare. There is also an ongoing commitment of Government to support rural communities where these two industries continue to contribute significantly to economic activity and employment. The two industries are key to balancing regional economic growth and both continue to provide a range of benefits for many rural locations. These benefits cannot be overlooked. The horse and greyhound racing fundhas played a key role in providing this investment and has been instrumental in shaping these industries and the many livelihoods they support. </p>
          <p eId="para_187"> I commend this regulation to the House.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ParaicBrady" eId="spk_64">
          <from>Senator Paraic Brady<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_188">The Minister is very welcome, and I congratulate him and his Department for the funding they have put into the horse and greyhound industry.</p>
          <p eId="para_189"> We had a greyhound track in Longford town and we saw the economic benefits it had for the town but when it closed, we witnessed the subsequent downturn for our local pubs, shops and the general area. Horse racing is probably one of the biggest fundraisers Longford GAA has on an annual basis in Punchestown. It probably has one of the biggest sell-out events, with the Longford diaspora coming from Dublin and elsewhere to support the county GAA board at that fundraising event every year, which is well-supported. It is an event that brings people together and shows the economic value horse racing has for the country in general.</p>
          <p eId="para_190"> Irish horse racing is sought after all over the world. At the Kentucky Derby, we had ten different yards competing in one of the most prestigious events in the world. This shows the level our horse racing industry is at. We also compete in Cheltenham, the Galway races, France and America. This shows where the sport is in this country, and that we are at the top end of our game. We can even fly horses over to Australia to compete there. We are world leaders when it comes to the horse racing industry. </p>
          <p eId="para_191"> The Minister will hear from the Opposition about attendance numbers falling at all dog tracks for one reason or another. Numbers have fallen at GAA games in recent years, yet they still go on and they are part of our culture. The same should happen with our dog racing. It is part of our DNA and having a pup at home. My father had greyhounds years ago, and it was about walking them, rearing them and bringing them to a race. If you had £2 in your pocket, you would put it on your own dog and hopefully get him at 5-1. You then went home with money in your pocket and the thought that this was a great achievement for your dog to win on the day and for you to get a rosette or ribbon and whatever else.</p>
          <p eId="para_192"> The funding the Minister has in place is welcome. I spoke the other day regarding a licensed premises for horses that have reached the end of their lives and I hope we will see such a premises open in this country. I have been slated in the media for bringing that up, but if we are truly interested in our industry, we have to look at an end-of-life facility. On average, we ship 50 to 70 horses on a weekly basis to England, France and elsewhere. That is an economic benefit to some part of the country here, and I hope we would have such a facility here.</p>
          <p eId="para_193"> We support dog rescues and horse sanctuaries but the reality is these horse sanctuaries with a fodder crisis coming this year will not be able to cope with the number of horses, unless we provide such a facility. If something happens to that current facility in England or France, there will be an increase in the horse population and the number of horses going into those sanctuaries. I hope such a facility will be forthcoming because going into the winter months, farmers and others will give hay silage and haylage generously to these sanctuaries. The Department has more than funded sanctuaries for horses and retired greyhounds, but I would like to see an end-of-life facility. It is not the popular thing people want to see but unfortunately, this is part of the industry we are in, and these animals are worth money.</p>
          <p eId="para_194"> We have such an industry here because we have a traceability system.</p>
          <p eId="para_195">If a horse is fit for human consumption, it has a book that states that it is not stamped out. If a horse is not fit for human consumption, it will state that on the book. Unfortunately, if it states this, the horse is worthless and must go to the knackery.</p>
          <p eId="para_196"> This leads on to my next question. We have seen the price of offal in fallen animals increase by 100% this week. I would hope that the Minister might make a small comment on that and maybe alleviate some of the problems faced at this time by these abattoirs and centres that take in dead animals.</p>
          <p eId="para_197"> I thank the Minister once again for coming to the House. I welcome the supports that the Government has put into greyhound racing and horse racing for the last number of years.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AubreyMcCarthy" eId="spk_65">
          <from>Senator Aubrey McCarthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_198">I thank the Minister for being here today as we speak about horse racing, which has been a part of my life for as long as I can remember. The Minister will know that I grew up beside Punchestown Racecourse where I live on a farm. During festival week years ago, it closed down the whole town. The shops shut early, the banks shut, the schools shut and half of the county was walking out towards the track and the rest of them were thumbing a lift. It was not a day at the races. Rather, it was part of what we did in County Kildare. I am delighted to say that the top three racecourses are in Kildare. There is Punchestown, the home of national hunt racing, led by David Mongey and Conor O'Neill. Then we have Naas, which has recently been done up and is run by Aidan McGarry. It does a huge amount for the town. Of course, there is the Curragh, where all the classics are run and Evan Arkwright and the team do amazing work there. I do not know of anywhere else in the world that has been blessed with three racecourses. The crowds are still coming. In 2025, 136,000 attended the Punchestown festival over the five days. My colleague Senator Brady mentioned Longford GAA causing a ruckus as usual. It takes over the town and certainly adds a flavour.</p>
          <p eId="para_199"> The record shows that attendance is up 15% in the last year. I want to thank a lot of people who make that happen. Suzanne Eade from HRI has done amazing work as chief executive since 2021. I mentioned David Mongey, who last weekend won the overall award for the contribution to business in County Kildare. Then there is the National Stud, of which Mr. Mongey is chairperson, and which is run by Cathal Beale, who is moving on. Cathal Beale joined the National Stud on an apprenticeship breeding course in 2007. He then became CEO. Even that reflects exactly what happens in the horse racing industry. People come in, they get involved and then they actually start to run it. I wish Mr. Beale well.</p>
          <p eId="para_200"> I also want to thank the people who rarely get mentioned, such as the farriers, the vets and the stable staff. They keep the whole thing going, along with the caterers and the people on the gates who have become friends of mine over the years. What is very interesting about racing is that it is often seen as a prestigious sport that is only for really wealthy people. The people I know who have had point-to-pointers are all farmers. I was at the breeder awards last year and the lady who won it was from Tipperary. She is a farmer, she bred a horse and it went on to do marvellous things.</p>
          <p eId="para_201"> Regarding gambling, I am involved in addiction rehab and all of that. Gambling is a big issue. I do not bet, so I do not go to the racing to take part in the gambling industry.</p>
          <p eId="para_202"> Horse racing is a serious industry when it comes to business. It contributes €2.5 billion or thereabouts to the nation and it supports over 30,000 jobs, most of them in rural Ireland. I am on the enterprise committee. We often talk about regional development. This is regional development at source. Horse Racing Ireland estimates that for every euro the Minister gives, there is a return to the Exchequer of €35. I know and I have looked at the different lines in the budget. There are not many areas that can say that. Attendance at Irish racecourses over the last year was over 1.3 million. That was up 6%. Red C has done surveys that show that it is now on a par with hurling.</p>
          <p eId="para_203"> However, none of that counts if we do not look after the horse and if we do not look after the welfare of the horse. That is why I am delighted to say that, in the budget, Horse Racing Ireland has seen an increase of up to €17.8 million for testing and regulation. It is important that the public has confidence in the sport and that animals are cared for.</p>
          <p eId="para_204"> I also welcome the capital project that HRI is putting in place, including the racetrack in Tipperary, which is expected to be completed in 2027. I was recently at Leopardstown. HRI is bringing it in as a site for all sport, business and community use all year round. That is hugely important. I was with the Minister, Deputy Heydon, at the National Equine Campus in County Kildare, which is a standard for excellence. It will be something special. It makes sense and definitely needs support.</p>
          <p eId="para_205"> Horse racing cannot apply for the community sport facilities fund, which we used to call sports capital funding. Racing is a sport. It draws the same interest as hurling but is shut out of the main capital fund for sport in this country. Will the Minister look at that and explain why racing is treated differently in that regard? As the Minister mentioned, Ireland is one of the leading countries in the world for thoroughbred racing and breeding. We did not get here by accident. We got here by investment, and that needs to continue.</p>
          <p eId="para_206"> For me, racing was never just about sport. It was a day that the town closed and was part of our culture. It is a major employer. I will always support it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JoeFlaherty" eId="spk_66">
          <from>Senator Joe Flaherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_207">The Minister is welcome to the House and I commend him on his continued support for the horse racing and greyhound sector. Long may it continue in this country. We have heard a lot of the statistics but it is sometimes important to try to humanise the people in the sector. Some people in the House would vilify the sector and the people within it. We as a nation boast a very long and strong tradition in horse racing and greyhound racing going back several hundred years. It is something that we are very proud of.</p>
          <p eId="para_208"> I often lament the passing of the famous sports writer Hugh McIlvanney of <i>The Sunday Times</i>, arguably the greatest sports writer of all time. He had a particular fascination with and love for Irish horse racing and for the people who populated it, including the stables, and looked after the breeding and bringing through of horses. He famously said in one article when he had the back page on <i>The Sunday Times</i> that the Irish were the All Blacks of horse racing and that there was no other sport in the world that could be so dominated by a country so small. It has dominated because of the passion, the enthusiasm and the drive of the people. He identified the unique trait that was in Irish people, namely, we were horsey people. Everybody in Ireland, even if they were born in a city, when passing a horse sees an intrinsic connection with the horse, because we are intrinsically linked with the horse, be it through the Irish draught, the Connemara or the thoroughbred. Where Senator Brady and I grew up, every farm had a horse at one stage, either a working horse or, as we got more automated and tractors came along, draught or sport horses, and that evolved into hunting horses and point-to-point horses. That is what we grew up with and that is what we knew. I was very fortunate to grow up in rural Ireland and to see many of those people. I was very lucky to see Jimmy Ward as he passed by our national school every morning on a bike. He would have two greyhounds coming behind him and if it was a winter morning, he would have a fire lit in the basket of the bike to keep warm. When the dogs were finished, he would bring them into the house and feed them there. Those dogs got the same care as every greyhound right across this country because greyhounds are loved by the people who have them. They are loved for a reason. They have an innate connection with the people who have bred them, have owned them and have brought them to the racetracks.</p>
          <p eId="para_209"> I apologise that I do not know her name, but Senator Lynch had a young lady in the House yesterday who was very connected with the Irish Retired Greyhound Trust - a young girl of probably no more than 16 years of age. She had a passion for greyhounds and loved to see a greyhound race, but she also wanted to rehabilitate greyhounds. She wanted greyhounds to go on and have a future after the track. There is nobody in greyhound racing or horse racing who does not want to see those animals have a future afterwards. There is no reason in the wide earthly world we should be vilifying those sectors. If you want to meet some of the most decent, most caring, most loyal and hardest working people, you will meet them in the stable yards on the Curragh, you will meet them in the doggy houses and the doggy kennels right across the country. It is sad that we have seen the tide turn where greyhound racing in particular has been vilified and sectors of the House will also turn their sights on horse racing.</p>
          <p eId="para_210"> Senator Brady will be very familiar with a man in Longford town called Kevin "Bunty" Dempsey who worked with Longford County Council for many years. He was their hardest working member of staff. He was not the county manager. He was a porter and delivered the post.</p>
          <p eId="para_211">No one worked as hard as Bunty. He worked in local government for as long as he could. He was eventually told he would have to retire. I asked him what he was going to do without work and he said he would spend every single day at the greyhound track. Unfortunately, the greyhound track closed. Bunty retired and passed away within a number of months Obviously, there were medical reasons for that but it is hard not to see the connection. He loved dog racing and did not have that outlet when the track was gone.</p>
          <p eId="para_212"> I am immensely proud of horse racing and everybody involved in it. There is nothing as fine, pure or wholehearted as seeing a horse clear a ditch. I cannot see anything wrong with it. There is nothing as wholehearted or as invigorating as seeing three greyhounds coming around a turn and one getting its head in front and beating the other two. When they get to the line, their handlers go to them with affection and care and bring them back, whether they won or lost.</p>
          <p eId="para_213"> Are there issues with horse racing and greyhound racing? There are. There is overbreeding. The greyhound sector is probably not doing enough to address that. If we did not have greyhound racing, what would we do with greyhounds? They are bred to race. If you do not want greyhound racing, you are going to have to make extinct a breed of dog that has been with us for hundreds of years. I cannot see how that leads to dog welfare.</p>
          <p eId="para_214"> My greatest obsession as a child was a horse called Shergar. I had a little scrapbook. There was no social media at that time. I used to come home from St. Mel's College as early as I could every evening to read the <i>Evening Herald</i> and the latest news on Shergar. As we know, Shergar was shot dead by a group of men affiliated with a political party. Many of the members of that party take a particular view and would like to ban horse racing. The men in question shot Shergar, a garda and an Army private over a couple of days. When people are calling out those in horse racing and greyhound racing, perhaps they need to look at their own sins of the past.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_67">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_215">Before I call on the Sinn Féin Senators to contribute, I welcome to the Gallery the young boys and girls, and the adults accompanying them, from Tallaght and Firhouse, and Scoil Treasa. We are delighted they could visit us. There will be no homework through the weekend.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JoanneCollins" eId="spk_68">
          <from>Senator Joanne Collins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_216">I confirm that Sinn Féin will be supporting this motion. We recognise the importance of the horse racing and greyhound racing industries and the significant contribution they make to the Irish economy, particularly in rural areas, where they support employment, businesses and livelihoods. However, supporting an industry does not mean that we should not ask some serious questions about where public money is allocated and what it is used for. A substantial amount of taxpayer money is going into one particular sector of the industry. We would like to see a fairer spread of this funding across the equine sector, including other equestrian and horse sport activities, rather than retaining such a strong focus on the thoroughbred industry.</p>
          <p eId="para_217"> We also believe that there needs to be strong governance, transparency and accountability across both the horse and greyhound industries. Where a significant level of funding is being provided, there must be clear oversight on how the money is being used and the outcomes it delivers.</p>
          <p eId="para_218"> Most important is animal welfare, as has been said by those across the floor. I agree that it must be at the centre of this. Sinn Féin is committed to achieving the highest standards of animal welfare and ending animal cruelty. There are ongoing concerns about the animal welfare standards when it comes to the greyhound industry. We cannot ignore those. They need to be looked at. Our position is clear: future State funding for the horse and greyhound industries must be explicitly conditional on demonstrable compliance with the highest standards of animal welfare and must be, backed up by rigorous monitoring and effective enforcement. I heard the Minister speaking about that earlier, which is welcome. We must ensure that the organisations receiving State funding are living up to what they need to live up to. We want the funding used to improve animal standards and welfare standards, to strengthen regulation and to support the long-term sustainability of the wider industry.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ChrisAndrews" eId="spk_69">
          <from>Senator Chris Andrews<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_219">Every year, the Irish taxpayer hands over up to €20 million to greyhound racing. It is a blank cheque. The industry offers no transparency. There is no business plan for it. There is no independent cost-benefit analysis. I regularly hear Senators talking about how dog owners love their dogs. Perhaps they could explain to me how thousands of greyhounds are killed every year. That does not reflect an industry that cares about greyhounds.</p>
          <p eId="para_220"> Giving €20 million as a blank cheque to greyhound racing is absolutely ridiculous. It is beyond words. You could not make that up. This year, the payment is being increased to a record high despite accountability on the part of Greyhound Racing Ireland being at a record low. People talk about their love for animal welfare. The Minister would not answer a particular question at the committee. Will he explain why surgical artificial insemination has not been banned? This is still allowed in the case of greyhounds. It is banned for all other dogs but is allowed for greyhounds. There have been research, studies, reports and countless consultations, and it is still allowed. To be clear, surgical artificial insemination is where the dog is cut open, the uterus is removed, the semen is inserted, the uterus is restored and the dog is then expected to recover while carrying a litter of pups. How is that funded? Some €20 million is going in to fund the industry.</p>
          <p eId="para_221"> We hear about the greyhound rescues run by RCÉ. The cost to rehome greyhounds is can be up to €7,000 or €8,000 per animal. Rescues across the island of Ireland are doing work that the Government should be doing. The Government is facilitating the creation of their work. Rescues are stretched beyond their limits and do not have the capacity to deal with the number of dogs being presented to them.</p>
          <p eId="para_222"> We also hear how rural communities love greyhound racing. If that is the case, why have attendances for race meetings dropped by 45% in the past ten years? The Minister might point to the Covid-19 pandemic but, even adjusting for that, the decline is fairly dramatic. Yet, there is an increase in greyhound funding year after year. There is no consideration of welfare. There is no transparency or accountability. If there was, there would not be €20 million going to greyhound racing.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_70">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_223">I welcome to the Visitors' Gallery Paul and Joanne Kelly, who are guests of our good colleague, Senator Boyle. I hope they enjoy their visit. They are in good company.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PatriciaStephenson" eId="spk_71">
          <from>Senator Patricia Stephenson<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_224">My contribution is going to focus on greyhound racing. We are back here again, another year on, to vote on funding for what is effectively animal cruelty. Some 8,414 greyhounds born between 2021 and 2024 are recorded as dead. In 2024 alone, 389 dogs suffered racing injuries and 202 died as a result of those injuries. Greyhounds are bred and forced to race in order for people to bet on which is the fastest. The consequences are the dogs who suffer injuries, the dogs who never made the grade and the dogs whose lives ended far too soon. Meanwhile animal welfare groups are left dealing with the consequences, trying to find homes and provide care for animals that deserve so much better. Go to their social media pages and you will see image after image of battered, malnourished and injured dogs that have been discarded by the industry. You will see endless images of greyhounds that have had their legs amputated.</p>
          <p eId="para_225"> At the same time, we know that attendances are declining rapidly. They have declined by 75% since 2005, according to Greyhound Racing Ireland's figures.</p>
          <p eId="para_226">The Minister seemed to reject this analysis last week at the agriculture committee and implied that it is subjective data. It is the data from GRI. The bare facts are that the greyhound racing industry is a dying one. Year on year, decade after decade, Irish people are rejecting it for the cruelty it represents, yet taxpayers' money continues to prop it up. We have given €380 million to greyhound racing since 2001, while attendances have dropped by 75% since 2005. Let us imagine if that money went to local sports clubs or domestic violence refuges. It seems we are largely pumping money into online betting and gambling rather than community infrastructure.</p>
          <p eId="para_227"> We have this debate every year because of how the funding has been designed. The tied funding simply makes no sense. Greyhound funding has to be decoupled from horse racing. They are entirely different industries. The continued tied funding between the two undermines the importance of horse racing. It is a disservice to the horse racing industry that it is matched with the lack of animal welfare standards we see in the greyhound racing industry because horse racing has higher standards and a higher economic benefit in return to the country.</p>
          <p eId="para_228"> Ireland needs to seriously confront the greyhound welfare reality rather than continuing to defend the indefensible. The report from the Parliamentary Budget Office made it clear that it is unjustifiable that we spend millions of euro on this every year while attendance figures drop. Again, the Minister indicated last week that the report is somehow subjective, which was a bit shocking because the PBO is an independent body and it reviews the value of Government expenditure. It is something that we respect generally. The Tánaiste also said the Government should always be willing to be apprised of the views of the PBO. I hope the Minister will seriously consider the report.</p>
          <p eId="para_229"> Many countries are moving away from greyhound racing. Scotland, Wales and New Zealand have all banned commercial racing this year, leaving us in a small minority of countries that still allow this barbaric practice. Public money should protect animals, not fund an industry that puts animal welfare at risk.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MalcolmNoonan" eId="spk_72">
          <from>Senator Malcolm Noonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_230">The Green Party will oppose this motion, in particular in relation to the greyhound industry. Just in case previous support is thrown at me: we were in government and that sometimes comprises taking the bad with the good. The reality in terms of figures has been pointed out. Of the 11,618 greyhounds born and microchipped in 2021, 5,333 were exported overseas, 3,311 are dead and only 1,522 were rehomed, with 439 kept as pets.</p>
          <p eId="para_231"> There was a time this was a family sport but that was before it became an industry. There is no doubt that the issues around animal cruelty have to be resolved by the industry. The issue of gambling was mentioned. While some may not gamble at race events, there are many people who do and that causes huge misery in families, particularly at Christmas time. This industry has to get its act together because it simply is not doing so. Public opinion is against it. We know that and that the issues around the rehoming of animals and animal welfare are not being addressed by the greyhound sector. It is a multimillion euro industry in decline. While we talk about this being part of our culture, animal cruelty should not be part of our culture. These issues need to be resolved by the sector.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AliceMaryHiggins" eId="spk_73">
          <from>Senator Alice-Mary Higgins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_232">We have these discussions every year and the evidence keeps mounting in one direction. It is unfortunate that again and again we see the hiding of the greyhound industry behind the horse racing industry in this motion. It always means that we do not have a full discussion about the horse racing industry and the importance of horses in many different aspects of our society and our culture because the necessary focus is on greyhound racing where we are seeing the most egregious breaches and the most appalling standards.</p>
          <p eId="para_233"> The Parliamentary Budget Office is an objective office that comes up with the facts, and the facts stand up. It pointed to a 45% decline in the past few years. Greyhound Racing Ireland itself points to a 75% decline over the past two decades. This industry is not driven by public demand. It is an industry that is subsidised to the level of 45%. Some 45% of the money being made is a State subsidy. There are two questions. One relates to its existence and regulations in terms of whether greyhound racing should be prohibited and how it should be regulated. The other is whether this is a good use of public money. It does not really stand up on a base level that we pour public money into something that does not make economic sense or deliver. I do not know any other industry where 45% of it is being bankrolled by the State.</p>
          <p eId="para_234"> If we wish to subsidise rural activities and rural life and animal welfare, there is a number of other areas. Let us compare the amounts. More than €20 million is going to greyhound racing in Ireland versus €6 million to 101 animal welfare charities across Ireland. All those animal welfare charities, many of which are based in rural areas and employ people, would like to employ more people, including vets and others if they had the resources and they were properly funded, but they are getting €6 million and the greyhound racing industry is getting €20 million. It is then generating animal abuse and animal welfare issues that those charities are having to mop up. We see it in the 8,400 dead greyhounds, as reported, in the numerous breaches, and in the injuries.</p>
          <p eId="para_235"> Much is made of the provisions around rehoming. They need to be placed in context. The rehoming of greyhounds is not some commitment to welfare from the industry. It is required under section 29 of the greyhound racing legislation. It resulted from an amendment Senator Ruane and I made to the legislation and led to an obligation in respect of rehoming. What we have seen is a deterioration. I will have to get figures for this year but as of last year we know that there were memos in 2002 where the Irish Greyhound Owners and Breeders Federation sent out notes encouraging greyhound owners not to use rescue or rehoming services that were critical of the industry. The cost of rehoming through the Irish Retired Greyhound Trust is €8,000 because of the preferred partners it uses while the cost of rehoming a dog through animal welfare organisations is €1,000. Even within that one tiny welfare gesture of rehoming, the focus is on those who will not embarrass the industry by pointing to the egregious breaches.</p>
          <p eId="para_236"> The question is where the industry will go now. The fact that artificial insemination, which was flagged in 2019, is continuing is what leads to the overbreeding and the huge numbers. As long as that is not addressed, we will see the huge oversupply. As to the question of what the greyhounds do if we do not have this industry, they, bred naturally, can continue to run. We see that in those who love the greyhounds they own right across this country. They do not need to put them through a false commercial veil to extract a little profit from betting and exploitation.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_74">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_237">I am under a bit of pressure here, as is the Minister, because the Order of Business that we all agreed this morning means I must call him not later than 12.40 p.m. to respond to the contributions of Senators. Senators Davitt, Lynch, Kennelly and Cathal Byrne are all indicating. They can read the clock. We have got until 12.40 p.m. I suggest that I give them each two minutes. Is that agreeable to the House? Agreed.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AidanDavitt" eId="spk_75">
          <from>Senator Aidan Davitt<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_238">Senator Kennelly was here before me.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_76">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_239">I have the order here in front of me. Senator Davitt is first but he is allowing Senator Kennelly the floor.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MikeKennelly" eId="spk_77">
          <from>Senator Mike Kennelly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_240">I welcome the Minister to the House. I want to speak in support of the regulations and the continued investment in the horse and greyhound racing fund. Let me be absolutely clear that I am proud to support this and I will make no apologies to anybody here. Coming from rural Kerry, I have seen at first hand the benefits that both horse and greyhound racing have given to rural Ireland. I grew up around both industries. I was involved in both industries and I know the people involved. I know the early mornings, the late nights, the sacrifices and the commitment required to care properly for dogs and horses.</p>
          <p eId="para_241"> In north Kerry, racing is part of who we are. We are fortunate to have a rich sporting tradition, with facilities and communities built around tracks such as the famous Listowel Racecourse every June and September and the scenic Killarney Racecourse every May, July and August. Some of the country’s most respected greyhound coursing clubs are in Kerry, such as Kilflynn, Ballyheigue, Abbeydorney, Castleisland, Listowel and Tralee, as well as in Abbeyfeale just over the border from me, which has famous coursing people. There is also the greyhound stadium in Tralee, and when I say "stadium", that is what it is.</p>
          <p eId="para_242"> Around these venues are trainers, breeders, owners, stable staff, kennel staff, transport operators, farriers, vets and countless volunteers who keep these traditions alive. They are ordinary working people. They are farmers, tradespeople, small business owners and families who have devoted their lives to the sports and to the welfare of their animals. Yet time and again, they are subjected to sweeping attacks from sections of the Opposition who show little respect for the decent, hard-working people behind these industries.</p>
          <p eId="para_243"> Let us be clear that nobody supports cruelty and nobody supports neglect. Anyone involved in mistreating animals should face the full force of the law. What I object to is the lazy and unfair practice of taking isolated incidents and using them to smear an entire regulated industry and the thousands of people who participate responsibly in it every single day. If some of those who regularly attack greyhound racing were genuinely concerned about animal welfare, perhaps they would spend less time targeting law-abiding owners and trainers and more time focusing on actual cases. I want to respond to Senator Andrews and I ask the Acting Chair to bear with me for one more minute.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_78">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_244">Senator Kennelly is eating into Senator Davitt's time.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MikeKennelly" eId="spk_79">
          <from>Senator Mike Kennelly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_245">I apologise. Recently, Rhona McGlynn pleaded guilty to offences relating to the neglect of 22 dogs. Of those 22 dogs, some were greyhounds. Some of the greyhounds taken from the property were found in dreadful conditions. Some of the hounds found at that location were sent to the My Lovely Horse Animal Rescue charity. There is a breakdown in animal welfare across this country and how we protect animals.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_80">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_246">I respect the issue. It is a very serious issue but I really must move on to the next speaker. Senator Davitt has the floor.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AidanDavitt" eId="spk_81">
          <from>Senator Aidan Davitt<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_247">I welcome the Minister, who has my full support for this motion. We are delighted to have the Minister in the House to talk about spending money on horse racing and greyhound racing. I have been listening to all of the negativity, and what seems to be glee, from the Opposition about greyhound racing numbers and attendances. I am also a bit amused by the converts here to Irish horse racing. I have never heard so many compliments from that side of the House in relation to Irish horse racing. I have listened to Members dogging Irish horse racing repeatedly over the years. I am delighted to see that it now seems to be A, B, C and G. We must have left out D for ducks because it is "anything but coursing and greyhounds". Maybe my fellow Senators have a point; I have listened intently and perhaps they have a point because they have converted so graciously on how horse racing has been run. It is certainly worth following through on their logic and seeing what we can do with greyhound racing to bring it to a better place.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AliceMaryHiggins" eId="spk_82">
          <from>Senator Alice-Mary Higgins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_248">Senator-----</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_12">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#AidanDavitt" eId="spk_83">
          <from>Senator Aidan Davitt<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_249">I never mentioned Senator Higgins and I certainly did not interrupt her when she was speaking.</p>
          <p eId="para_250"> I commend what I have heard and the change in stance by a lot of the Opposition. The point they make is that we will have to look at the model used successfully by Horse Racing Ireland and try to find the best model that will work for greyhound racing. That is the way forward. The Opposition has made very good points today. We can modernise, look at what has been learned by horse racing over the years and see how it can help to improve greyhound racing. We have the stadiums, the infrastructure and the support of the Government. With a little help and encouragement in the right direction, and maybe a proper business model, it could be looked at again. Following our horse racing brethren, we can find a winning formula to support the heritage and culture we have all grown up with.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EileenLynch" eId="spk_84">
          <from>Senator Eileen Lynch<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_251">I welcome the Minister to the House to discuss this important increase in the horse and greyhound racing fund. I very much support it and agree with my colleagues on this side of the House who have supported it. I am a big fan and an active racegoer in terms of horse racing but greyhound racing has always been more my forte. In my household, my father, grandfather and mother have had greyhounds since the 1940s. As somebody said earlier, it is something I am very proud of. I have never backed away from it. I have received an awful lot of abuse, both online and in person, because of it. The Minister will recall that I spoke on this matter at the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food last week. The abuse I have received online over the past week has been horrendous. There has been a lot of support as well, though.</p>
          <p eId="para_252"> I want to call out what we have heard from the Opposition today about this being a dying sport and the numbers being down. There are a few points I want to clarify regarding the debate at the agriculture committee last week and in the Dáil yesterday, beginning with attendance. While there has been a decrease in attendance, and I am not denying that, nobody seems to take account of the fact that there are now 33 race meetings a week, 15 of which are Sports Information Services, SIS, meetings. At SIS meetings, the races are livestreamed, there is no fee to enter and no record is kept of attendance. They are generally held in the morning, so attendance is lower. There are 18 evening meetings throughout the country every week. It is very unfair to base average attendance, as I have seen the Opposition do, on dividing the total number of attendees by 33 rather than 18. This needs to be stated and put on the record because I have yet to hear somebody else say it.</p>
          <p eId="para_253"> Another matter I want to clarify concerns figures thrown out by the Opposition today in respect of deceased dogs, without any context. As Senator Kennelly said, and speaking as somebody who has been involved in this industry all my life, I do not stand for cruelty and I do not condone in any way cruelty towards greyhounds or any other animal. Figures have been thrown out without context. We have generally seen in this House, in committee and in the Lower House a figure of a 66% mortality rate for greyhounds. That is simply not true. The figure is used without looking at the fact that the overall figure excludes greyhounds exported to the UK and those still in active racing. I have no problem dealing with the facts and I appreciate that we need to do more for welfare but we need a bit of context and reality when we are dealing with figures.</p>
          <p eId="para_254"> The Opposition also said today that this was a dying industry. I was in Shelbourne Park in September for the derby. I was in Curraheen Park, my local track, for the laurels in October. There were massive crowds there. Yes, attendance is down and figures are being quoted to show it has been down over the past 20 years but that is also the case for a lot of sports. GAA attendances are down. This is the reality of life at the moment. Culture is changing, patterns are changing and the way in which people go to events is changing.</p>
          <p eId="para_255"> The way in which people in the greyhound industry are, quite literally and pardon the pun, hounded is horrific. I have seen protesters shout abuse at youngsters, including four- and five-year-old kids, going to the track. This is not as prevalent now because, to be fair, the protesters seem to have lost interest. I have been going to the track with my father since I was about two years of age, pretty much before I could walk. We are treated like criminals by people who do not understand the sport or what it means to the people who are involved. Yes, we have big trainers, such as Graham Holland and Peter Cronin, but there are also people who have one or two dogs, or who no longer have a dog but still go to the track or who still have a retired dog. The way in which we are treated by people speaking about an industry they do not understand is quite simply horrific.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CathalByrne" eId="spk_85">
          <from>Senator Cathal Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_256">I welcome the opportunity to make a short contribution to the debate.</p>
          <p eId="para_257">I very much support the motion. It is important that when we have this conversation, we also discuss the reality of the number of jobs in rural Ireland that this motion and this horse and greyhound racing fund supports. I am thinking of the 4,000 jobs that are backed by the greyhound industry, including those many people who work on the tracks, vets, those who work in the kennels, trainers and breeders of dogs. It is very noticeable that in the contributions from the Opposition today, we just did not hear about the jobs. It is as if they do not want to recognise there are people who support their families through working with dogs and horses. It is very much important that those people's contribution is actually recognised in this Chamber.</p>
          <p eId="para_258"> It is very important that we have a fair and honest debate on these issues and the levels of abuse that are targeted at people who train and own dogs. It was rightly called out earlier and it is very important that we condemn that. When we come to a Chamber like this, we can have a fair and honest battle of ideas. I welcome the fact that Sinn Féin has changed its position and will support this today. It is important that is acknowledged because that was not the case last year, the year before that or two years before that. In fairness, they have come on board on now. In conclusion, I acknowledge the hard-working people who work day in, day out at Wexford Racecourse and Enniscorthy Greyhound Stadium and the contribution they make, particularly to local, charitable fundraisers and the money that generates for so many worthy causes right across County Wexford.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MartinHeydon" as="#Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine" eId="spk_86">
          <from>Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine (Deputy Martin Heydon)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_259">I thank all Senators for their contributions. This is the end of a process with me having spent considerable time at the agriculture committee last week discussing the horse and greyhound fund. We spent an hour in the Dáil on it yesterday and an hour in the Upper House today. The debate last night in the Dáil struck me as a very significant example of a very clear urban-rural divide. I am really sorry to hear about what happened to Senator Lynch and the abuse she suffered because I was before the committee last week and I thought her contribution was extremely eloquent, articulate and passionate but very fair. We are moving to a society that lacks tolerance and understanding of other people's way of life, acceptance and views of things. I do not expect everyone to agree with it but I do not expect people to abuse others for saying something articulately and as well as the Senator outlined it. She passionately represented those people.</p>
          <p eId="para_260"> When Senator Flaherty spoke earlier about Bunty, I did not know Bunty but the thread running through all of the contributions from Senators McCarthy, Brady and Flaherty, Senator Byrne from Wexford and Senator Kennelly from Kerry was the people in our industries. The Aidan O'Briens and the top trainers get the headlines, along with the jockeys on the racing side and the top trainers on the greyhound side, but many people breed these animals, are involved in elements along the way, employ other people and contribute thousands of jobs and economic activity. This is their livelihoods but it is also their life. When that person retires, they plan to go to the racing and articulate that more.</p>
          <p eId="para_261"> That is something that has to be taken on board and the majority of people, particularly in the Dáil yesterday more than here today, who openly criticised that pursuit and looked to have it stopped do not attend those events or have them in any part of their life. It is easy to stand up in a Chamber and say I do not want that activity I do not attend or participate in to happen again without thinking of the consequences for thousands of people, particularly older people, for whom it is a significant way of life. It is a rural pursuit that is culturally intrinsic to how they have lived their lives. For that to be taken away from them is an idea I do not like.</p>
          <p eId="para_262"> We absolutely have the highest of ambitions and standards for animal welfare. We can always do better and we put more money in to do better. The funding increase is based on the Indecon report and the RCÉ and HRI strategic plans and the programme for Government, which all clearly outline achieving higher standards of animal welfare, which is absolutely the ambition. We continue to invest in it because we recognise that and it is as much to safeguard these industries as much as anything. Some analysis was made here earlier about comparison with sports. There is a reason I, as the Minister for agriculture, am the person here talking about the horse and greyhound fund. It is an industry. It spent a short time under the Department of sport but we are not comparing it with other sports because the difference is recognised and it is rightly back in its natural home of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. That is because horse racing and breeding and greyhound racing and breeding is integral agricultural activity. It is intrinsically economic activity that employs thousands of people, predominantly in rural communities the length and breadth of this country. That is why the Government has proudly supported this sector.</p>
          <p eId="para_263"> I respect the right of colleagues in this House and others to have a differing and opposing view but I ask for tolerance in that debate. In terms of the points raised, Senator Andrews talked about a lack of transparency. It is absolutely not true to say there is a lack of transparency. An amount has been invested on the greyhound side in terms of increased data and we very much contributed to the Parliamentary Budget Office report through the data we had gathered. If there is no transparency, we would have not had that data to contribute to the report. Unfortunately, Senator Stephenson is not here but she talked about animal cruelty and greyhounds being forced to race. That fundamentally misunderstands what a greyhound's natural inclination is to do. Like a thoroughbred horse, they are happiest and it is their natural inclination to run and race. That is what they want to do. We have so many measures in place to make sure they can do that safely on track and significantly, on the greyhound side, there have been significant investments. I worked in Punchestown Racecourse 26 years ago. Back then, the standards were extremely high in terms of supports for the welfare of the horse and jockeys. They are even higher now again. That involves investment, which comes back and shows that.</p>
          <p eId="para_264"> I thank all colleagues for their contributions. I ask people to have tolerance and understanding of the different perspectives there are, allow people to express those views in a way where we respect each others perspective and let us not use figures to paint a picture that is not accurate when hundreds of thousands of people attend greyhound race meetings each year. As Senator Lynch alluded to, this year's derby had an increased crowd and a great attendance. Many people derive so much enjoyment from it, as well as that economic activity that is so important to rural Ireland. With that, I commend this regulation to the House.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_87">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_265">Before I put the question to the House, I welcome Deputy Brian Brennan from the constituency of Wicklow-Wexford, with his friends Father Derek Doyle and John Devane from Rathdrum. They are very welcome. I also welcome the young women from Presentation College in the Carlow-Kilkenny constituency. They are very welcome too and I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House. They might think of coming here themselves some day in the future and they would be very welcome.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MalcolmNoonan" eId="spk_88">
          <from>Senator Malcolm Noonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_266">I just wanted to say it has been a respectful debate.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MartinHeydon" eId="spk_89" as="#Minister_for_Agriculture,_Food_and_the_Marine">
          <from>Deputy Martin Heydon<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_267">It was. I was referencing the Dáil debate.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ParaicBrady" eId="spk_90">
          <from>Senator Paraic Brady<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_268">Yes, this debate was respectful.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MalcolmNoonan" eId="spk_91">
          <from>Senator Malcolm Noonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_269">I just wanted to say that. Both sides have respected each other.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryFitzpatrick" as="#Acting_Chairperson" eId="spk_92">
          <from>Acting Chairperson (Senator Mary Fitzpatrick)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_270">There is unanimous agreement. Everybody has acted very respectfully and at the same time, their voices have been heard. That is how it should be.</p>
        </speech>
        <debateSection name="division" eId="dbsect_13">
          <summary eId="sum_13">Question put: </summary>
          <summary title="division" eId="sum_14">The Seanad divided: Tá, <quantity refersTo="#ta" normalized="27" eId="qty_1">27</quantity>; Níl, <quantity refersTo="#nil" normalized="5" eId="qty_2">5</quantity>.</summary>
          <debateSection name="ta" eId="dbsect_14">
            <p eId="para_271">Tá</p>
            <p eId="para_272">
              <person refersTo="#GarretAhearn">Ahearn, Garret.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_273">
              <person refersTo="#NiallBlaneyIND">Blaney, Niall.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_274">
              <person refersTo="#ManusBoyle">Boyle, Manus.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_275">
              <person refersTo="#ParaicBrady">Brady, Paraic.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_276">
              <person refersTo="#CathalByrne">Byrne, Cathal.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_277">
              <person refersTo="#PatCasey">Casey, Pat.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_278">
              <person refersTo="#JoanneCollins">Collins, Joanne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_279">
              <person refersTo="#MartinConway">Conway, Martin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_280">
              <person refersTo="#OllieCrowe">Crowe, Ollie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_281">
              <person refersTo="#AidanDavitt">Davitt, Aidan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_282">
              <person refersTo="#MarkDuffy">Duffy, Mark.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_283">
              <person refersTo="#JoeFlaherty">Flaherty, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_284">
              <person refersTo="#RobbieGallagher">Gallagher, Robbie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_285">
              <person refersTo="#ImeldaGoldsboro">Goldsboro, Imelda.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_286">
              <person refersTo="#MikeKennelly">Kennelly, Mike.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_287">
              <person refersTo="#EileenLynch">Lynch, Eileen.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_288">
              <person refersTo="#RayMcAdam">McAdam, Ray.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_289">
              <person refersTo="#AubreyMcCarthy">McCarthy, Aubrey.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_290">
              <person refersTo="#MargaretMurphyOMahony">Murphy O'Mahony, Margaret.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_291">
              <person refersTo="#LindaNelsonMurray">Nelson Murray, Linda.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_292">
              <person refersTo="#EvanneNiChuilinn">Ní Chuilinn, Evanne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_293">
              <person refersTo="#NoelODonovan">O'Donovan, Noel.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_294">
              <person refersTo="#JoeOReilly">O'Reilly, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_295">
              <person refersTo="#SarahOReilly">O'Reilly, Sarah.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_296">
              <person refersTo="#AnneRabbitte">Rabbitte, Anne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_297">
              <person refersTo="#PaulineTully">Tully, Pauline.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_298">
              <person refersTo="#DiarmuidWilson">Wilson, Diarmuid.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <debateSection name="nil" eId="dbsect_15">
            <p eId="para_299">Níl</p>
            <p eId="para_300">
              <person refersTo="#TomClonan">Clonan, Tom.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_301">
              <person refersTo="#NessaCosgrove">Cosgrove, Nessa.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_302">
              <person refersTo="#AliceMaryHiggins">Higgins, Alice-Mary.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_303">
              <person refersTo="#MalcolmNoonan">Noonan, Malcolm.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_304">
              <person refersTo="#PatriciaStephenson">Stephenson, Patricia.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <summary title="tellers" eId="sum_15">Tellers: Tá, Senators Cathal Byrne and Pat Casey; Níl, Senators Malcolm Noonan and Alice-Mary Higgins.</summary>
          <summary title="decision" refersTo="#carried" eId="sum_16">Question declared carried.</summary>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="motion" eId="dbsect_16">
        <heading>Protected Disclosures: Motion<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_93">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_305">I welcome the guests of Deputy Natasha Newsome Drennan who are here. Most important of all, the Deputy's mother is in the Distinguished Visitors Gallery. How are you doing? You are most welcome to Seanad Éireann. Our guests are all part of the Ballyhale-Kells group. They are most welcome and I thank them for being here.</p>
          <p eId="para_306"> I welcome the Minister of State to the House. This is No. 68, motion No. 7. It is to be proposed by Senator McDowell and seconded by Senator Boyhan. The proposer and seconder have a combined total speaking time of 16 minutes.</p>
          <p eId="para_307"> Before we get to the Members' contributions, I remind Members of Standing Order 55(3), which relates to the Chair's responsibility to rule on the appropriate use of privilege. We have a long-standing tradition of parliamentary privilege in Seanad Éireann and Dáil Éireann. There is an awesome responsibility on Members in using that privilege. Today's debate is on protected disclosures concerning matters of public importance and public concern. Members must be free to address the substantive matters involved. I am conscious that the use of parliamentary privilege is an important part of the protection of the public good and enables Members to exercise their parliamentary functions effectively. When it comes to that responsibility, I also point out Standing Order 53, which recognises the consideration of utterances that may have an adverse effect on a person. I ask Members to bear in mind this balance between the Members' freedom to debate a matter of public importance and the rights of those affected. </p>
          <p eId="para_308"> For the benefit of Members, I will clarify the question of a matter being <i>sub judice</i>. Standing Order 49 reads:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_309">Subject always to the legislative powers of Seanad Éireann ... and unless otherwise precluded under Standing Orders, a member shall not be prevented from raising in the Seanad any matter of general public importance, even where court proceedings have been initiated: Provided that:—</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_310">(1) the matter raised shall be clearly related to public policy;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_311">(2) a matter may not be raised where it relates to a case where notice has been served, and which is to be heard before a jury or is then being heard before a jury;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_312">(3) a matter shall not be raised in such an overt manner so that it appears to be an attempt by the Seanad to encroach on the functions of the Courts or a Judicial Tribunal;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_313">(4)(i) members may only raise matters in a substantive manner ... where due notice is required;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_314">[...]</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_315">(5) when permission to raise a matter has been granted, there will continue to be an onus on members to avoid, if at all possible, comment which might in effect prejudice the outcome of proceedings.</p>
          <p eId="para_316"> Issues regarding privilege and utterances that may have an adverse effect are covered under Standing Order 52, which states:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_317">“adversely affected by an utterance” means that a person has been referred to in proceedings by name or in such a way as to be readily identifiable, and there is a significant likelihood that that person, to a substantial degree—</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_318">(<i>a</i>) has been adversely affected in reputation, or in respect of dealings or associations with others,</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_319">(<i>b</i>) has been injured in occupation, trade, office or financial credit, or</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_320">(<i>c</i>) has had his or her privacy unreasonably invaded,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_321">by reason of that reference to him or her: Provided that an utterance which has had an adverse effect on a person will not necessarily constitute an abuse of privilege within the meaning of these Standing Orders.</p>
          <p eId="para_322"> I want to make sure Members take that into account. They should also consider the public interest, which is covered in Standing Order 53(9). I am a very big advocate of the public interest. I expect Members to act in the public interest when speaking in the Chamber and to champion the public interest because they have the power of privilege. Standing Order 53(9) reads:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_323">For the purposes of this Standing Order, “public interest” includes, but is not limited to, consideration of the following matters:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_324">(<i>a</i>) the degree to which the utterance is in relation to, and in furtherance of, a matter of public policy,</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_325">(<i>b</i>) the degree to which it relates to a matter of significant public concern,</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_326">(<i>c</i>) whether the utterance was made in the course of the performance of a member’s parliamentary duty,</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_327">(<i>d</i>) the degree to which it was made in a responsible manner, including its relevance to the proceedings, and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_328">(<i>e</i>) the degree to which the utterance adversely affects an identifiable person.</p>
          <p eId="para_329"> I read that out for the benefit of Members. I know many are well aware of these Standing Orders but, for the benefit of this debate and all debates, Members must act in the public interest. I am a very strong advocate of the use of privilege in the public interest. I thank the Minister of State for coming to the House. I now call on Senator McDowell.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_94">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_330">I move:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_331">That Seanad Éireann calls on the Government to restore confidence in the protected disclosures system as it affects Ireland’s policing and security services.</p>
          <p eId="para_332"> At the outset, I will stress that I full endorse and agree with the comments the Cathaoirleach has made about the relationship between parliamentary privilege and the need to respect the rights of others and the integrity of the judicial process. Nothing that I propose to say today should be taken as an attempt to encroach on the judicial sphere in any way, especially in relation to a criminal trial, which I understand has now been fixed for 5 April 2027.</p>
          <p eId="para_333"> I have and have always had the greatest respect of An Garda Síochána as an institution. From my earliest days as a barrister and through my days as a TD, Attorney General, Minister for justice and Tánaiste, I have always stood for An Garda Síochána. In my term of office, I did my best to legislate coherently on the relationship between the Government and An Garda Síochána in the 2005 Act and the amending Act in 2007, which was brought in to take account of some of the recommendations of the Morris tribunal in respect of malpractice by members of An Garda Síochána in the county of Donegal.</p>
          <p eId="para_334"> The integrity of An Garda Síochána is something that concerns everyone. An effective police force requires the support of the people. That support is built on the foundations of a conviction among the public that An Garda Síochána is an institution of integrity and that it is an institution which, in its own constitution, has both the means and the methods to address abuse of power within An Garda Síochána, misbehaviour by its members and misuse of authority to suppress the truth or to act against the public interest.</p>
          <p eId="para_335">It is essential that this system of law and remedies should be clearly understood and should operate clearly and without challenge.</p>
          <p eId="para_336"> In my time as Minister for Justice, I set up a confidential recipient system for members of An Garda Síochána who were concerned about malpractice, corruption and abuses of power by An Garda Síochána under the terms of the Garda Síochána Act 2005, and a statutory instrument guaranteeing independent investigation of such allegations, especially those made by members of An Garda Síochána themselves, was introduced.</p>
          <p eId="para_337"> After that period, a number of things happened. The first thing of significance that happened was that not the next Government but the one after that introduced legislation to establish what was described as an independent policing authority. By way of a footnote to today's debate, I want to say that that was a mistake. The reality is that the authority that is most relevant to An Garda Síochána is that provided by the Constitution, which is that the executive power of the State is vested in the Government and the members of the Government, particularly the Minister for justice and his or her colleagues at Cabinet, and that they are accountable to Dáil Éireann. It is probably one of the great diseases of modern Ireland that the executive service in Ireland has suffered from something akin, in political terms, to multiple sclerosis. It has slowly degraded its own capacity to make decisions and has elevated, at every hand's turn, a desire to hand out its executive powers to so-called independent bodies established by statute.</p>
          <p eId="para_338"> The Irish people have a right to look to the Government to have proper control over our national police and intelligence service. That responsibility cannot be abdicated. It cannot be give to others. It is not properly given to others. In the end, the series of structures put in place under the two Acts that were brought in subsequently have only clouded the issue of who is ultimately accountable to the Irish people when things go wrong in our policing service.</p>
          <p eId="para_339"> On Thursday, 17 July 2025, I raised the issues which were the subject of the RTÉ programme on whistleblowing and protected disclosures in this House. I did so in general terms, very mindful of the fact that, at that time, there were criminal proceedings in being. I asked for a debate on the subject. I want to remind the House of what Deputy Seán Kyne, who was then a Senator, said in reply to my request for a discussion on these matters. He stated:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_340">Senator McDowell put on the record issues regarding the armoury section of An Garda Síochána and called for a debate with the Minister for justice, Deputy O’Callaghan. I will certainly request that debate. It is an important issue and he has obviously put a lot on the public record in this Chamber. In doing so, I hope it gains traction and that this is examined. A new Garda Commissioner will be appointed in the next number of weeks and I am sure the Minister will engage with that new Commissioner on matters such as this.</p>
          <p eId="para_341"> Unfortunately, no such engagement or debate took place. In the meantime, the "RTÉ Investigates" team did their research for the programme that was broadcast.</p>
          <p eId="para_342"> This was not my first experience of the issue that lay behind this matter. Way back in 2021, I was approached by a then-serving member of the Defence Forces who had been recommended for appointment as Captain of the Guard in Leinster House. He was expecting to take up his new duties, and the next thing was that members of An Garda Síochána, under section 29 of the Offences against the State Act, searched his house. This was as a by-product of a criminal investigation which is still ongoing. The result was that his security clearance was removed and his progression by way of promotion within the Army was stopped. The Ombudsman at the time took up his case. In the end, the Minister intervened at the request of the Ombudsman and granted him a promotion in rank that had been wrongly denied to him on foot of a trial within the Army in which nearly all of the counts against him were withdrawn. He finally had to effectively settle his case by accepting that he had not kept proper records. The office of the Captain of the Guard in Leinster House has remained vacant from then until now.</p>
          <p eId="para_343"> That was one person's career which was very severely affected by the matters I raised back in July 2025. I had been aware of it for four years previously. Other people, though - and I was not aware of this when I raised the matter in the House - were having their careers within An Garda Síochána destroyed at the time. I refer to Rose Sweeney, a civilian employed in An Garda Síochána, about whom the public has heard. She is now effectively on one-third of her remuneration. Deputies from Donegal approached me recently and said that the way in which she has been treated has been nothing short of scandalous.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_95">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_344">I know we have referred to it being in the public-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_96">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_345">I have her permission to mention her.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_97">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_346">I am aware of that. It is in the public arena. I do not have oversight of every detail that the Senator has. I ask him to be conscious of it being in the public arena.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_98">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_347">I have her permission to raise these matters, and they have been ventilated in public. I am not saying something new.</p>
          <p eId="para_348"> I refer to Dr. Donal Corcoran, who also appeared in that programme. I also refer to one of the most honourable policemen I have ever come across in my time, one of the most innocent and hardworking individuals and a person whose career and whose standing and reputation are unimpeached at any level in An Garda Síochána, Detective Superintendent Brian O'Reilly, who was later made head of the technical branch and the armoury section of An Garda Síochána.</p>
          <p eId="para_349"> It is important to put on record that these people made protected disclosures in relation to not merely the matter that is the subject of criminal prosecution now but also other very serious matters. They made these protected disclosures because they found that they were being sidelined from progressing their functions within An Garda Síochána by people who did not want what they were investigating to be properly investigated. That is the sad conclusion to which I have been pushed by the events that have transpired. For Detective Superintendent O'Reilly to be put in the position where his health was so badly compromised by the way he was treated that he effectively had to retire from his functions is shocking, especially since he has done nothing wrong and since nobody has pointed the finger at him and said he should not have done this or should not have done that. That man is suffering now. So is Rose Sweeney. Donal Corcoran is in the same position. Without referring to any pending criminal case, I am saying that those people have been swept aside and their careers have been destroyed.</p>
          <p eId="para_350">Then we come across what is put down by way of an amendment by the Government to our resolution. It starts off with one untruth after another, I am sorry to say. It seeks to delete all of the words in our short motion and to substitute the following:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_351">- there are effective structures, policies and procedures in place across the criminal justice sector, including in An Garda Síochána, to ensure the management of protected disclosures and to provide support to people who make disclosures under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014; </p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_352">- the protected disclosures systems operating in Ireland’s policing and security services are functioning well; </p>
          <p eId="para_353"> None of that is true. That is absolutely untrue. I have detective gardaí come to me in the street and other places and say that what I am saying is correct and what is being covered up at Government level is untrue. Most gardaí have no confidence in the protected disclosure system in An Garda Síochána. Most gardaí do not accept that, for example, Lieutenant Colonel Ray Lane was properly kept out of an investigation when the independent officers of An Garda Síochána who were charged with investigating certain matters proposed him to provide expert evidence. Most gardaí know that what I am saying is correct and that those two first recitations in the amendment by the Government to this motion are simply untrue.</p>
          <p eId="para_354"> Worse than all of that - I will not go through all of the text of the Government's amendment - is the statement that "a new and strengthened Protected Disclosures Unit was established in ... 2025". That is rubbish. The people who were independent were taken out of the system and it was all put in under the office of the assistant commissioner for governance and accountability in An Garda Síochána, which also has responsibility for the Garda anti-corruption unit. Nothing was strengthened. Everything that was good about the old system was weakened. I just want to say this: this will not go away. The Ministers, Deputy O'Callaghan and Deputy McEntee, and the entire Government will not escape, in the end, full accountability for what has happened and the way in which the protected disclosures regime has effectively been neutered in the interests of covering up wrongdoing in An Garda Síochána.</p>
          <p eId="para_355"> I will leave it at that, as I think Senator Boyhan wants to second the motion.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VictorBoyhan" eId="spk_99">
          <from>Senator Victor Boyhan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_356">I second the motion.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RobbieGallagher" eId="spk_100">
          <from>Senator Robbie Gallagher<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_357">I move amendment No. 1:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_358">To delete all the words after “That Seanad Éireann” and substitute the following: </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_359">“recognises that:</p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_360">- there are effective structures, policies and procedures in place across the criminal justice sector, including in An Garda Síochána, to ensure the management of protected disclosures and to provide support to people who make disclosures under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_361">- the protected disclosures systems operating in Ireland’s policing and security services are functioning well; </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_362">notes that: </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_363">- the protected disclosures legislation is the responsibility of the Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_364">- a review of the operation of the Protected Disclosures Act is due to take place in the coming year; </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_365">recognises that: </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_366">- the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024 established the Garda Board, the Policing and Community Safety Authority (replacing the Policing Authority and Garda Síochána Inspectorate) and Fiosrú – the Office of the Police Ombudsman; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_367">- the Act was designed to enhance governance, oversight and accountability in relation to the delivery of policing and security services by An Garda Síochána; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_368">- the Act provided for the establishment of an Audit and Risk Committee of the Garda Board which has among its functions the provision of advice related to the appropriateness, effectiveness and efficiency of the procedures of An Garda Síochána relating to protected disclosures; </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_369">notes that: </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_370">- An Garda Síochána has implemented a number of measures to strengthen protected disclosure mechanisms within the organisation in recent years; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_371">- a new and strengthened Protected Disclosures Unit was established in January 2025 within the Office of the Assistant Commissioner for Governance and Accountability, which also has responsibility for the Garda Anti-Corruption Unit and the Garda Professional Standards Unit; additional and dedicated staff with the training and qualifications to undertake their role were assigned to the office; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_372">- extensive training has been provided to managers across An Garda Síochána; in addition, all personnel who make protected disclosures are advised of support services; </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_373">recognises that: </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_374">- An Garda Síochána emphasises that it encourages and supports employees in disclosing wrongdoing and that all allegations made to An Garda Síochána are treated seriously and examined for any potential disciplinary or criminal matters that may arise; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_375">- there are multiple independent avenues for Garda personnel to make disclosures to ensure that these are treated with the appropriate level of independent consideration; </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_376">- the Government is satisfied that there are robust procedures and protections for those who make disclosures; and </p>
          <p class="indent_3" eId="para_377">- the Government is satisfied that the protected disclosures systems in Ireland’s policing and security services are effective and functioning well.” </p>
          <p eId="para_378"> The Minister of State is very welcome back to the House. I thank her for taking time out to be here to discuss this hugely important issue. At the outset, I will take this opportunity to compliment the men and women of An Garda Síochána who daily go out and put their lives at risk in order to protect us all. When they go out, they do not know what they will face when they put on their uniforms. It is important that when we have an opportunity to compliment them and say how precious we feel they are, we always take it.</p>
          <p eId="para_379"> It is also important that the men and women of An Garda Síochána have confidence in a system whereby, if they come across wrongdoing in the force during the course of their work, they can come forward and explain and highlight their concerns. I encourage every single member of An Garda Síochána who comes across something they strongly believe is not right or is criminally wrong to come forward.</p>
          <p eId="para_380"> I listened attentively to my learned colleague, whom I have the utmost respect for, Senator McDowell, outline the details of his concerns in relation to the protected disclosures system. I am not over the same detail as the right honourable Senator is, but I do not doubt his bona fides for one single minute. From our point of view, I have total confidence in the Minister for justice, Deputy O'Callaghan. I also have total confidence in the current Garda Commissioner of An Garda Síochána. I am conscious of the fact, like Senator McDowell outlined, that there are legal proceedings pending here. I am confident that, if it is discovered at some point that there is wrongdoing, it will be highlighted and acted upon and those responsible for that wrongdoing will face the full wrath of the law.</p>
          <p eId="para_381"> I do not want to comment too much other than to repeat what I am after saying. I encourage members of An Garda Síochána to please come forward when they see wrongdoing. I have confidence in the people at the helm, namely, the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, and the Garda Commissioner, to address the genuine concerns of wrongdoing that members of An Garda Síochána come forward with and that those found responsible will be rooted out of the organisation, as there is no home for them. If wrongdoing is taking place - I cannot say for certain it is - it is an insult to every single man and woman in An Garda Síochána who goes out daily and puts their life at risk for the benefit of us all. I have confidence that both the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, and the new Garda Commissioner will address the issues as they arise.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EileenLynch" eId="spk_101">
          <from>Senator Eileen Lynch<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_382">Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta Callaghan. Gabhaim buíochas léi as a bheith anseo inniu. I second the Government's amendment, as proposed by my colleague Senator Gallagher, concerning the protected disclosures system within Ireland's policing and security services.</p>
          <p eId="para_383"> I acknowledge the importance of the issue raised by Senator McDowell and thank him for putting it on the agenda today. Protected disclosures are essential to ensuring accountability, transparency and integrity within our public institutions, particularly in An Garda Síochána where public confidence is fundamental to its very existence. Every person working within our policing and security services must have confidence that if they witness wrongdoing, they can report it safely, have their concerns taken seriously and be protected from any kind of bias or penalisation as a result of reporting something.</p>
          <p eId="para_384"> However, I do not accept the suggestion that our protected disclosures system is fundamentally flawed or failing and that appropriate safeguards are not in place. I note that considerable work has been undertaken in recent years to strengthen legislation, to improve reporting procedures and to provide greater independent oversight. The Protected Disclosures Act 2014 established the legislative framework for protecting workers who report wrongdoing. It was significantly strengthened by the Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Act 2022, which transposed the EU whistleblower protection directive into Irish law.</p>
          <p eId="para_385"> Importantly, workers are not confined to reporting concerns through their immediate management structures. That is vital for the protected disclosures system to work effectively. There are multiple reporting channels available, including prescribed persons and the Office of the Protected Disclosures Commissioner. This is particularly important within An Garda Síochána where personnel have to operate within a disciplined and hierarchical organisation. No garda or, indeed, employee anywhere should ever feel that they must choose between doing the right thing and protecting their career.</p>
          <p eId="para_386"> I would like to highlight the significant reforms that were introduced through the Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024. This legislation established the Garda board, the Policing and Community Safety Authority and Fiosrú, the Office of the Police Ombudsman. These reforms were specifically designed to strengthen governance, oversight and accountability within policing. The legislation also provides for an audit and risk committee of the Garda board, which has responsibility for advising on the effectiveness and appropriateness of Garda procedures relating to protected disclosures. That is an important additional safeguard.</p>
          <p eId="para_387">There have also been practical improvements within An Garda Síochána. The new protected disclosures unit, which was launched in January 2025, was established within the office of the assistant commissioner for governance and accountability. Additional dedicated staff with appropriate training have been assigned to this role. Extensive training has also been provided to Garda managers, while personnel making protected disclosures are advised of the support services available to them.</p>
          <p eId="para_388"> These are substantial improvements and they demonstrate that the organisation is taking its responsibilities seriously. When it comes to this matter, there are always improvements to be made and I absolutely take on board what Senator McDowell has said. It is very difficult to get this to a perfect level, but improvements are being made, if maybe not at the rate we would like. It is important, however, to acknowledge that.</p>
          <p eId="para_389"> I have also been discussing, and the Minister has spoken about, the procedures that exist. It is important, though, not just that they exist but whether they actually work effectively in practice. That is the test of any of these measures. It is very appropriate that we would continue to scrutinise that aspect but when doing so, we must be careful not to undermine confidence in these mechanisms that we want people to use. If we continually suggest that the entire system is incapable of protecting whistleblowers, we definitely risk discouraging individuals from coming forward.</p>
          <p eId="para_390"> I also welcome the statutory review of the operation of the Protected Disclosures Act, which is due to take place in the coming year. This will provide an opportunity to assess how the legislation is operating in practice and identify further improvements that are required. I do not believe there is a contradiction between recognising that robust procedures are currently in place and accepting that they continually need to be reviewed and continually need to be improved. Public confidence does not just depend on legislation but on leadership and culture within these organisations and fair treatment of those who actually come forward. It is important that the Government takes these responsibilities seriously.</p>
          <p eId="para_391"> While a lot of work has been done, it does not mean that individual concerns should in any way be dismissed. When shortcomings arise, and they do arise in certain cases, they have to be addressed and it is important that they are. Our objective has to remain that we have a system whereby wrongdoing can be reported safely, allegations are examined fairly and public confidence in policing is maintained. That is the approach outlined in this Government amendment and I would like to support it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JoanneCollins" eId="spk_102">
          <from>Senator Joanne Collins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_392">Sinn Féin supports Senator McDowell's motion calling on the Government to restore confidence in the protected disclosures system within our policing and security services. I commend Senator McDowell on bringing this motion forward. It is very important. It is a very important piece.</p>
          <p eId="para_393"> We have repeatedly raised concerns about the treatment of Garda whistleblowers and the failure to ensure that allegations of wrongdoing, misconduct and public safety concerns are properly investigated. The experience of whistleblowers, including the revelations surrounding the treatment of Maurice McCabe, should have been a turning point. We were promised a culture of transparency, accountability and protection for those who speak out, yet serious questions still continue to arise about whether those protections are working in practice.</p>
          <p eId="para_394"> A protected disclosure system is only effective if people have confidence in it. Garda members and others working within our policing and security services must be able to raise legitimate concerns without fear of intimidation, career damage, retaliation or being exposed. Where allegations concern senior management or the very structures responsible for investigating those disclosures, there must be genuine independence and robust oversight. The Government cannot simply point to legislation or procedures on paper. It must demonstrate that those protections are working in reality, that disclosures are investigated impartially and that those responsible for wrongdoing are held accountable.</p>
          <p eId="para_395"> Restoring confidence requires more than assurances; it requires transparency, independent scrutiny and a willingness to confront failures wherever or whenever they occur. Those who speak out in the public interest must be protected and not punished. We stand here in the House and talk about needing more gardaí, whether it be community gardaí or more gardaí for our roads policing units. If they feel like they are not being supported when it comes to situations like this where they need to make a disclosure, I think we will have a serious problem when it comes to recruitment. We need to get this right.</p>
          <p eId="para_396"> Senator McDowell has worked in this area for long enough that I think he is, I will not say an expert, but close enough to an expert, I would imagine. He has dealt with all sides. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_103">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_397">He is an expert. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JoanneCollins" eId="spk_104">
          <from>Senator Joanne Collins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_398">He is an expert. I do not like naming people as experts. He has worked on all sides of the spectrum when it comes to this and I was disappointed to see an amendment being tabled. This is really important and is for the betterment of our services. The members of these services need to have that support and reassurance that it is being taken seriously and that they will be protected. In every sector of life, we need people to stand up and to have confidence that they can stand up and say something has gone wrong. That is the sentiment behind this motion.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PatriciaStephenson" eId="spk_105">
          <from>Senator Patricia Stephenson<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_399">Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. I must say I am a bit shocked as well about the amendment.. I think we could all agree with the phrasing of it. I cannot imagine anyone would take umbrage at the idea that the public and all of us should all have confidence in the protected disclosures mechanism. It seems odd that we would not all stand over that. It is okay to say that things have gone wrong, things have not happened the way we would like and we will seek to strengthen and improve them. That is what Senator McDowell's very simple, straightforward motion does and I cannot imagine why we would not support it in its entirety.</p>
          <p eId="para_400"> It is an important debate because we have seen serious allegations from whistleblowers about how they have been treated by the State, bringing us back to why we have the Garda protected disclosures office in the first place. The office was initiated ten years ago after the smear campaign against Maurice McCabe by his colleagues in An Garda Síochána. Maurice McCabe was treated appallingly for doing the right and just thing. It seems that now we are seeing a worrying repeat of this behaviour towards whistleblowers. Emphasis seems to be being placed on preventing whistleblowers from speaking out rather than encouraging them to come forward. This leads to a culture of secrecy and a culture of punishment for those who speak up.</p>
          <p eId="para_401"> Given the repeated pattern of smear campaigns and of undermining whistleblowers, can we really expect anyone to have the moral courage to put their head above the parapet? We have heard calls across the House for our gardaí to come forward in these instances, to come forward if they see wrongdoing. Why would you? Why would you come forward if your livelihood is at risk, if your ability to pay your rent is at risk and if your ability to live outside of poverty is at risk? Why would you come forward? The signal we are giving whistleblowers today is that they will be penalised and punished if they flag serious, worrying concerns. That is what we have seen in recent times. Why would they risk their financial security? Why would they risk their livelihoods? Why would they risk their reputations? Who would take such a risk when the evidence is there that the State will not protect them but rather that its institutions will throw them under the bus?</p>
          <p eId="para_402"> We have recently had the public cases of Mr. Brian O'Reilly and Dr. Donal Corcoran, who have come forward. Brian O'Reilly raised concerns about the safety of gun holsters and received, he says, penalties for doing so, including disciplinary action. He has been on ordinary sick pay, as a result earning 50% of his salary. He was in the High Court last week trying to get enhanced sick pay, which he argues he was denied because he spoke up.</p>
          <p eId="para_403"> These are highly experienced professionals who have dedicated their lives to public service and to serving communities and who have stood up for something they believed in. When they have seen something wrong, they have put their heads above the parapet and stood up. They actually did their jobs properly and are being punished for it. They are not being lauded for their courage; they are being beaten down. We are seeing the continued penalisation of whistleblowers, good people who saw something wrong and correctly alerted superiors. Rather than being protected for their efforts, they are being victimised and penalised by the State, which purports to protect them.</p>
          <p eId="para_404"> It is shameful but not only shameful because it is actually dangerous. Why would anyone come forward and alert others to serious safety concerns given how dismissively they are treated? More worrying has been the reported handling of these protected disclosures by the Minister, Deputy McEntee, during her time as Minister for Justice. Her office allegedly passed the protected disclosures on to the wrong body and reportedly included identifying information about the whistleblower in question in information sent back to the Garda, which is completely unacceptable. There seems to be no expectation that anyone is going to take an ounce of accountability for this. Other allegations include senior Garda management concealing safety breaches and malpractice. Donal Corcoran was actually working in the whistleblower unit. The alleged cover up and malpractice was so bad that the very people working in the protected disclosures unit felt they had to become whistleblowers themselves.</p>
          <p eId="para_405">Dr. Corcoran was removed from the protected disclosures office because he spoke out, he alleges, about the significant malpractice in the handling of these cases. This should set off alarm bells for all of us. Someone actually working in the unit felt that he had to alert about the malpractice around how they were being handled.</p>
          <p eId="para_406"> We need to have answers on how all of this was allowed to happen. The handling of these cases has been incredible. We have reports of files being delayed or closed without proper resolution and serious safety breaches being covered up, and Dr. Corcoran says his work on these disclosures was blocked by senior management. We urgently need a reform plan.</p>
          <p eId="para_407"> This is not only an issue of individual accountability. It is pervasive and insidious. The entire system of protected disclosures need to be reformed to ensure structural change and to put an end to systemic failures. As I understand it, the process on paper for protected disclosures is actually the gold standard but the issue is not about the process; it is about how the process is implemented and about the culture of cover-up and secrecy.</p>
          <p eId="para_408"> There is no respect for the importance of whistleblowing. It is seen as betrayal of the State rather than an act of courage in the interest of the public. Public trust in whistleblowing and protected disclosures is at rock bottom. Would-be whistleblowers are being deterred. A culture of secrecy and impunity is rife and this is dangerous. It is dangerous not only for An Garda Síochána but for the wider public that relies on the Garda for safety. It is also dangerous for anyone working in any industry when they see something unsafe. It could be a breach of a health and safety standard in the food industry. It could be poisoning in our environment, something that makes the society we live in less safe. The people working in those industries will see what is happening to other whistleblowers and rather than calling out danger, they will stay silent because they will be worried about retribution.</p>
          <p eId="para_409"> For a healthy democracy, whistleblowing is actually crucial. It is key. It is not a little extra nice thing to have. Accountability and truth are fundamental and right now, there are major indications that we do not have the assurance of that. We need to know what the Department is going to do to remedy this.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_106">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_410">The Minister is welcome to the House. Let me begin by saying this clearly: An Garda Síochána does vital work every day. Gardaí protect communities, respond to danger, investigate crimes, support victims and often put themselves at risk on our behalf. They deserve our respect, our support and safe equipment. I wish to acknowledge the commitment of all ranks of An Garda Síochána to the European Presidency. While stretching their resources to the limit, they provided normal, day-to-day policing, dealing with murders and various other crimes while providing security for EU leaders. Nothing in this speech should be taken as criticism of the vast majority of Garda members who serve the public with commitment and courage but respect for the Garda means refusing to look away when the system around it fails.</p>
          <p eId="para_411"> The "RTÉ Investigates" documentary raised deeply serious allegations about how protected disclosures are handled within An Garda Síochána. Four current members spoke - three of whom I could mention, one I will not - including Dr. Donal Corcoran, the former head of the protected disclosures unit, Ms Rose Sweeney, and Detective Superintendent Brian O’Reilly. They allege that whistleblowers were resisted, marginalised, disciplined and penalised for raising concerns.</p>
          <p eId="para_412"> These are not minor administrative complaints. They concern whether gardaí can speak up about wrongdoing and public safety without fear of retaliation. A protected disclosures system only works if people can report concerns and those concerns receive a rigorous, independent, fair and timely investigation.</p>
          <p eId="para_413"> The allegations include defective gun holsters, the handling of firearms, a missing gun and claims that concerns were not independently assessed. The Irish Council for Civil Liberties, ICCL, says these matters are central to the murder of one garda and the serious injury of another. </p>
          <p eId="para_414"> We must be careful. Allegations must be tested by evidence but serious allegations about public safety and the treatment of whistleblowers cannot be buried in internal reviews, delayed indefinitely or sent back to the very organisation under scrutiny. The Government must stop treating confidence as something that can be restored with a statement. Confidence is restored by action.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_107">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_415">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_108">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_416">First, I call on the Government to establish an independent, statutory public inquiry into the handling of protected disclosures in An Garda Síochána. It must examine whether whistleblowers were penalised, whether disclosure files were delayed or interfered with, whether senior management obstructed investigations and whether safety concerns about firearms and holsters were properly addressed. The ICCL, Garda Representative Association and Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors have all called for such an inquiry.</p>
          <p eId="para_417"> Second, the Government must guarantee immediate protection for those who have spoken. No whistleblower should lose their role, face disciplinary action or be isolated because he or she told the truth.</p>
          <p eId="para_418"> Third, serious allegations about An Garda Síochána must be investigated independently. The Garda cannot be both the subject of a complaint and the sole judge of it.</p>
          <p eId="para_419"> Fourth, the Government must publish clear timelines, decisions and accountability. Every disclosure deserves an answer. Delay is not neutrality. Silence is not protection.</p>
          <p eId="para_420"> The gardaí who serve this State deserve a leadership and a system worthy of their service. The public deserves a police force that welcomes scrutiny, learns from its failure and protects those who speak out. If we want the Garda to protect us, we must protect the gardaí who protect the system by speaking the truth.</p>
          <p eId="para_421"> On the amendment that has been put forward by the Government, the honourable thing for the Minister to do would be to withdraw it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_109">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_422">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_110">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_423">It is a lie. It is a falsehood. We need transparency and a government that is prepared to stand up and take on the forces that would undermine the very organisation that protects this State. I call on the Minister to stand up and do the decent thing: withdraw the amendment and accept the motion as tabled by my colleague Senator McDowell.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_111">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_424">Well said.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_112">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_425">What has happened in this State that there are four people today who have no income and have been marginalised and pushed aside? What does that do for my colleague who called for gardaí with problems to come forward? I would be petrified of my life to come forward if I was a garda with a complaint under the current system. We need it cleaned out and I believe the Garda Commissioner and some senior gardaí support this. However, there are some there who have questions to answer. The public inquiry is the way forward. I ask the Minister to take his courage in his hands today and withdraw the amendment.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulineTully" eId="spk_113">
          <from>Senator Pauline Tully<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_426">As my colleague Senator Collins said, we are supporting the motion. I thank Senator McDowell and commend him on putting this very important motion on the schedule today. I, too, am disappointed that the Government could not support this and had to table an amendment that makes absolutely no sense.</p>
          <p eId="para_427"> The first paragraph states:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_428">- there are effective structures, policies and procedures in place across the criminal justice sector, including in An Garda Síochána, to ensure the management of</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_429">protected disclosures and to provide support to people who make disclosures [...]</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_430">- the protected disclosures systems operating in Ireland’s policing and security services are functioning well;</p>
          <p eId="para_431"> Nothing could be further from the truth. I do not know what world the Government is living in if it actually thinks those words are true. I challenge the Minister, or indeed Members from the Government parties, to find me one person from An Garda Síochána who has made a protected disclosure, and who has continued and flourished in their jobs. I ask them to find me one, because there are not any.</p>
          <p eId="para_432"> In its current form, the Protected Disclosures Act is not worth the paper it is written on. It is being used solely to identify the people making the disclosure and to make their lives hell. I watched the RTÉ programme a few months ago and I was shocked by the revelations. I know somebody else who was looking to watch it afterwards on the RTÉ Player and it had been removed. I am not sure if it is back on RTÉ Player or not since. It is really strange that is was removed. What did RTÉ not want more and more people to see?</p>
          <p eId="para_433"> The amendment states: "An Garda Síochána emphasises that it encourages and supports employees in disclosing wrongdoing and that all allegations made to An Garda Síochána are treated seriously and examined for any potential disciplinary or criminal matters that may arise;".</p>
          <p eId="para_434"> Again, people are punished for speaking out and I believe it is an effort to dissuade others from doing so and protect certain people within power in the organisation. Protected disclosures should be seen as a method to identify wrongdoing, address it, ensure it is discontinued and protect the members and the public. People who speak up do not feel like that; they feel the institution and its senior echelons are protected, while they are not.</p>
          <p eId="para_435"> A whistleblower system works if people are not afraid to speak out, if a disclosure is investigated, if lessons are learned and if the person making the disclosure is not victimised. This is happening under the watch of the Minister. It happened under the watch of his predecessors and they have something to answer for.</p>
          <p eId="para_436">They have a responsibility to address what is currently a shambles.</p>
          <p eId="para_437"> We have no way of knowing how many protected disclosures actually lead to recommendations being made. There is one on record because it was reported on in the media. It is impossible to know because the legislation ensures that information cannot be sought.</p>
          <p eId="para_438"> In 2020, Margaret Loftus made a protected disclosure. The disclosure was made known to the people she made the disclosure about, before it was even investigated. If has finally been investigated, recommendations have been made and are being presented to the Garda Commissioner very soon but Margaret will not be entitled to see the recommendations. She will never know if they are implemented. Even the investigators in Fiosrú will not know or will not be told if the recommendations will be implemented. There is also no legal obligation on the Garda Commissioner to implement the recommendations, following the investigation. I think all of that needs to be addressed. What is the point in having an investigation, and recommendations being made when they are ignored? Also, the person making a protected disclosure is not even made aware of the recommendations or what happened to them afterwards.</p>
          <p eId="para_439"> It has been mentioned that the workings will be reviewed next year. A lot more than that is needed. It needs to be reviewed, overhauled and made right because, as the motion initially called for, we need to have confidence in the system. The Garda Síochána and, indeed, any organisation should value those who tell the truth in the interests of improving the workings of the organisation. They should not see it as a reflection on them for some reason, or a failure. A good leader would see this as a way of improving the workings of the organisation for staff and the public. I have the height of respect for members of An Garda Síochána. I have a very good relationship locally with the gardaí in Cavan. If a garda sees or experiences something that he or she knows is wrong then he or she has a duty to report it but there is a responsibility to protect that person, investigate the issue and address the issue, if there is one.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SarahOReilly" eId="spk_114">
          <from>Senator Sarah O'Reilly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_440">I, too, support Senator McDowell's motion and acknowledge the serious need for confidence to be restored in the protected disclosures system. I, too, was struck by the words in the Government's amendment that "the Government is satisfied that the protected disclosures systems in Ireland’s policing and security services are effective and functioning well." When we consider the dysfunction and what I would describe as wrongdoing, which these whistleblowers have described, it is quite unbelievable that the Government can say with a straight face that the system is "functioning well."</p>
          <p eId="para_441"> In 2019, a protected disclosure was sent alleging that 40 holsters had been issued to 1,500 gardaí. Borne out of genuine concern about the safety of gardaí who go out every day to protect and serve the public, GSOC tried to investigate but An Garda Síochána seemed not to co-operate. Why?</p>
          <p eId="para_442"> A year later, Detective Garda Colm Horkan was murdered after being shot six times with his own gun. If the system is working then why do questions remain about the forensic examination of his holster? Six years later his family is still waiting for answers.</p>
          <p eId="para_443"> The disclosures are not limited to one tragic event. We have reports of defective ammunition, reported disposal of 500,000 rounds of ammunition, and issues with firearms storage, recording, fraud, financial wrongdoing and procurement irregularities. With all respect, that does not sound like a system that is "effective and functioning well."</p>
          <p eId="para_444"> The people who raised concerns, people with courage, who have unblemished records and who are of sound character, have been penalised. They are facing professional consequences and have been the subject of alleged whisper campaigns. I believe the legal system is being misused to shield grave misconduct. The DPP sent RTÉ two warnings before the whistleblower programme was even aired. Why?</p>
          <p eId="para_445"> Micheál Martin stood up in the Dáil and said, in defence of the Minister, Deputy McEntee, that Government Ministers were not allowed to be involved in protected disclosures. That is simply not true. Under the Protected Disclosures Act, a worker can make a protected disclosure to the relevant Minister in specific circumstances. A disclosure made in confidence was then redirected by the Minister, Deputy McEntee, to the very organisation this disclosure was concerned about.</p>
          <p eId="para_446"> Protected disclosures should be an opportunity to identify issues and put things right. They should be used to improve the organisation. I believe that we need a full public inquiry if there is any hope of restoring trust in the system. All this has had a chilling affect on future whistleblowers. What will happen now with them? I assume that some or many will stay silent. Is that mission accomplished?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_115">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_447">The Minister of State and her officials are very welcome. I thank them for coming to the House. I know that she is not the author of these amendments. She is a person for whom I have great respect. I know her to be a person of great integrity and what follows is not a criticism of the Minister of State. I echo what has been said by Senator Craughwell. This is a moment where we could have some moral courage from the Government. </p>
          <p eId="para_448"> I welcome the Private Members' motion tabled by my colleague, Senator McDowell. I share what Senator Craughwell said about An Garda Síochána. My father was a garda. His number was 12901. He trained in the 1950s and worked in Pearse Street Garda station, Store Street Garda station and Dublin Castle. My grandfather was a garda. He was one of the first gardaí in the State in 1922 - Joe Clonan. He told me that at the height of the Civil War when we had armed confrontation throughout the State that the gardaí would walk of their stations in all parts of Ireland on their own completely unarmed. Why would they do that? In order to promote faith and confidence in An Garda Síochána. They put their lives on the line and many of them paid the ultimate price for so doing. It strikes me when I cross the Border that we have a police force, however reformed from the RUC, the PSNI, that cannot police by consent, that polices through the use of force by carrying firearms, not just sidearms but automatic weapons, openly on the street. We want to be very careful here that the service, tradition, moral courage and physical bravery of people like my father, my grandfather and the people who brought forward these disclosures should be so dismissed and forgotten in the interests of what and protecting whom.</p>
          <p eId="para_449"> I looked at these amendments authored by Senator Ahearn and they remind me of a night out in Dublin. Knowing what we know about the treatment of Garda whistleblowers, people like Maurice McCabe and the current members, who were listed here by Senator Craughwell, an attempt has been made to destroy their lives and their families' lives; to destroy them and publicly to humiliate them. Yet - this is like a night out in Dublin - it states here: "there are effective structures, policies and procedures in place across the criminal justice sector, including in An Garda Síochána". Knowing what we know, then our first venue tonight is clearly the Laughter Lounge. If this a joke or sarcasm? Did Oliver Callan write this?</p>
          <p eId="para_450"> It continues: "the protected disclosures systems operating in Ireland’s policing and security services are functioning well." Oh my God, we have gone from the Laughter Lounge to the Comedy Club. Who could put their name to that in the knowledge of what has happened to these good men and women, and their families?</p>
          <p eId="para_451"> Two weeks ago, I sat down with Maurice McCabe in NUI Galway in the J.E. Cairnes business school. We compared our whistleblowing notes and the retaliation that was visited upon us. They tried to destroy Maurice McCabe and his family. I will not repeat the vile allegations that were made against him. We compared notes. Vile allegations were made against me. The two of us were the subject of reprisal over very many years. In the pattern of reprisal that has been visited upon some of my former colleagues in the Defence Forces by our good friends - the military authorities - and the Garda whistleblowers, the same dynamic is in play.</p>
          <p eId="para_452">These opening paragraphs are an absolute joke. They make a mockery of the integrity of the people who brought forward concerns. After visiting two comedy clubs, including the Laughter Lounge, which would make you hungry, what better than to eat a whole pile of word salad, particularly as the rest of it recognises that word salad?</p>
          <p eId="para_453"> Following a briefing that the Seanad Independent Group had, I recommend that whoever wrote this should upgrade to Copilot premium in order to get a better standard of word slop, because that is what this is. Let me be serious about this. This is all on the public record. How do I feel reading this? How will those whistleblowers feel reading it? They will be offended and dismayed because it in no way recognises or endorses their public service. I ask the Minister of State to withdraw this amendment. Senator McDowell may call a vote on this. Anybody who comes in and votes for these amendments will be voting against people of conscience in Ireland-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_116">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_454">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_117">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_455">-----whether they are in the HSE or other aspects of Irish life. They will be voting against them and their families and giving an endorsement to the type of language and thinking that would target and seek to visit reprisals on good people. Some people lost their lives because of the concerns that were raised. I ask the Minister of State to please do the right thing.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_118">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_456">Before I call the Minister of State, I welcome a former Member of this House, Malcolm Byrne, who is now a Deputy for Wexford, and Ciarán Rowsome, who won the Oireachtas politics and society quiz last year. Ciarán is welcome back. I presented him with the award on that occasion. Deputy Willie Aird is here as well, as are Deputy James Geoghegan and his guest Paul Huston, who is over from London.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CatherineArdagh" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Justice,_Home_Affairs_and_Migration" eId="spk_119">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration (Deputy Catherine Ardagh)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_457">I welcome the visitors to the Gallery. I thank everyone who contributed to today’s debate. I welcome the opportunity to address the House on the matter of the protected disclosures framework in place in Ireland.</p>
          <p eId="para_458"> Ireland has one of the most comprehensive protected disclosures frameworks across Europe. This is because of sustained legislative action and root-and-branch reform introduced by successive Governments over the past ten years or so. This Government takes extremely seriously any protected disclosures that are made by workers. Protected disclosures are an important mechanism to expose wrongdoing and strengthen accountability in our institutions. That is why we encourage workers to make protected disclosures. It is also why we legislated to provide multiple avenues for them to do so and why we ensure that all personnel who make protected disclosures are advised of the support services that are available to them.</p>
          <p eId="para_459"> Having effective policies and procedures in place across the justice sector, including in An Garda Síochána, is crucial. The overarching protected disclosures framework was introduced by the Government in 2014 and amended in 2022. The 2014 Act provided for the first time a broad legal framework protecting workers who disclose wrongdoing in their workplaces. We did not stop there. Recognising new challenges and following consultation, the Government moved to update the legislative framework through the enactment of the Protected Disclosures (Amendment) Act 2022, which transposed the EU directive on whistleblower protection. The Oireachtas also made several important changes to the 2014 Act. Most notably, it created the Office of the Protected Disclosures Commissioner and removed Ministers from the follow-up on and investigation of protected disclosures. This legislation strengthened protections for workers who suffer penalisation for raising concerns about wrongdoing. It provides greater certainty to those who report wrongdoing that the information they disclose will be properly acted on. It also introduced mandatory reporting channels for public bodies.</p>
          <p eId="para_460"> Across Departments and the wider justice sector, designated persons have been appointed and trained to deal with protected disclosures. Internal reporting procedures have been strengthened and governance structures have been adapted to ensure disclosures are handled appropriately and confidentially. Mandatory annual reporting requirements by public bodies provide transparency.</p>
          <p eId="para_461"> This represents substantial progress. However, we continue to augment and revise our protected disclosures framework. While a statutory review of the operation of the Protected Disclosures Act is due to take place in July of next year, the Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation has indicated an intention to commence the review at an earlier stage, with the launch of a public consultation expected in the coming weeks. The review will assess how the protected disclosures framework is operating in practice, both for those who make protected disclosures and for those responsible for receiving and managing reports of alleged wrongdoing. I encourage all interested stakeholders to participate in the consultation, so that their evidence can inform any recommendations that may emerge from the review.</p>
          <p eId="para_462"> The European Commission is currently evaluating the operation of the EU whistleblower protection directive across member states. The Department for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation will monitor the outcome of that process and consider any relevant findings as part of its ongoing policy work in this area.</p>
          <p eId="para_463"> The Policing, Security and Community Safety Act 2024 marked the most comprehensive reform of An Garda Síochána ever and followed on from the acceptance by the Government of the recommendations of the Commission on the Future of Policing report. Among the core aims of the Act was to strengthen and consolidate independent, external oversight of An Garda Síochána and enhance its internal governance. To deliver on this, three new bodies were established, each with distinct oversight roles. These are: the Garda Board; the Policing and Community Safety Authority and Fiosrú, the Office of the Police Ombudsman. These changes have significantly enhanced governance, oversight and accountability in the delivery of policing and security services by An Garda Síochána. The 2024 Act gives the Garda board and its audit committee important oversight roles in relation to the operation of the protected disclosure system in An Garda Síochána.</p>
          <p eId="para_464"> Among the functions of the audit and risk committee of the Garda board is the provision of advice concerning the appropriateness, effectiveness and efficiency of the procedures of An Garda Síochána relating to protected disclosures. This is a significant improvement in the governance of An Garda Síochána. Fiosrú, the Office of the Police Ombudsman, provides an independent, external body for workers of An Garda Síochána to report protected disclosures. The Policing and Community Safety Authority provides a further layer of oversight and accountability of the performance of An Garda Síochána. </p>
          <p eId="para_465"> As the House will be aware, the Garda Commissioner is responsible for the management and administration of the business of An Garda Síochána, including the organisation's obligations under the Protected Disclosures Act. I know that Garda Síochána considers the handling of protected disclosures to be of the utmost importance and that it is committed to ensuring the integrity of the structure and process for making and investigating all such reports. I am assured by the Garda Commissioner that all protected disclosures made to An Garda Síochána are treated seriously. An Garda Síochána has emphasised that it encourages and supports employees in disclosing wrongdoing and that all allegations are treated seriously and examined for any potential disciplinary or criminal matters that may arise. Furthermore, the Commissioner has taken a number of measures to strengthen the protected disclosure mechanisms and structures within An Garda Síochána.</p>
          <p eId="para_466"> A new protected disclosures unit was established in January 2025 within the office of the assistant commissioner for governance and accountability, which also has responsibility for the Garda anti-corruption unit and the professional standards unit. The office was assigned additional qualified and dedicated staff who have been trained to carry out their duties effectively. Transparency International Ireland has trained personnel from the protected disclosures unit and senior Garda managers, and also provides support and confidential advice to any member of An Garda Síochána who may be considering making a protected disclosure. Having regard to these changes and the substantial programme of Garda reform that has been undertaken over the past decade, I am satisfied that there is an effective system in place to deal with and oversee the handling of protected disclosures in An Garda Síochána.</p>
          <p eId="para_467"> It is important to note that no government can guarantee that every individual case will be resolved to the satisfaction of the complainant. Protected disclosures often concern complex issues involving past events and matters that may be in dispute. What the Government can do is provide clear procedures and effective legal protections. That is precisely what we have done. The Government has updated the legislation in order to improve the protected disclosures framework and make significant reforms to the governance of An Garda Síochána in recent years. An Garda Síochána has moved to strengthen and improve its policies and procedures on protected disclosures. These are significant reforms that have delivered real improvements.</p>
          <p eId="para_468"> The statutory review of the operation of the Protected Disclosures Act is being brought forward by the Minister for public expenditure and will provide an ideal opportunity for interested parties to contribute to the process and inform any recommendations that might emerge. On that basis, I commend the amendment to the motion to the House.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_120">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_469">I have listened to the Minister of State, for whom I have great respect and whose presence I welcome in the House to deliver her reply to the motion and to Members' comments. I have to say, not one word addressed as to why Dr. Donal Corcoran has effectively been sidelined. Not one word has been addressed as to why Detective Superintendent Brian O'Reilly has been sidelined. Not one word has been said as to why the other people involved in all this have been sidelined. The sickening thing about all of this is that unless the explanation was there was some conspiracy among ill-informed and foolish people to usurp their functions in An Garda Síochána - people who altogether somehow just committed career suicide - something was radically wrong. The Minister of State has come in here and does not even refer to the fact there were resignations in this unit. She also did not refer to the fact these people made protected disclosures protesting what they saw happening. Not one word has been addressed to this House on those subjects. </p>
          <p eId="para_470"> Why is that? It is because of a culture of complete denial and a culture of saying there is nothing to see here; we have a perfect system. Therefore, what RTÉ put out on the air, which had to be taken down because the DPP wrote threatening letters, does not matter. We are simply to forget about what was referred to in those programmes - into oblivion. That is shameful. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_121">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_471">Hear, hear. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_122">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_472">I have not heard the Ministers, Deputies O'Callaghan and McEntee, or the Minister of State say one word about these people who protested about what they saw happening. Not one word. Why is that? Did collective madness descend upon the investigative process inside An Garda Síochána? Did they all decide to go on a frolic of their own and imagine some wrongdoing that is completely unjustified? The answer is of course, the direct opposite. This so-called improvement, a strengthened protected disclosures unit, is a cover-up for the fact that all those people who showed any independence were swept aside, ignored, challenged and threatened with disciplinary action.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#" eId="spk_123">
          <from> Senators<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_473">Hear, hear. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_124">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_474">That is what happened.</p>
          <p eId="para_475"> Nobody has said that did not happen and nobody has come before Dáil Éireann, where this has been extensively debated, or this House to say these people got it wrong. Instead, they say it is their protected disclosures and they cannot be referred to in public at all. That too is a lie because they have all said the Government is perfectly capable of doing so. Rose Sweeney, Lieutenant Colonel Ray Lane, Donal Corcoran and Brian O'Reilly have all said they withdraw any question of confidentiality and that their allegations should just be dealt with but the response is no, we cannot. </p>
          <p eId="para_476"> Have we no shame? I am not a troublemaker. For five years and upwards, I have been aware of the background to this. I have seen it develop piece by piece but the bit I never saw was that there were honourable and decent people in An Garda Síochána who knew what I knew and who were prepared to do something about it and have it properly investigated. That is the problem. They had to be got rid of. Rose Sweeney had to be brought before her superiors to explain who helped her frame her document questioning the McMenamin report. Donal Corcoran had to be removed from the whole scene and Brian O'Reilly had to be told he would be moved elsewhere. This is the head of the Garda Technical Bureau and the head of this unit being swept aside. All because those people knew something deeply wrong had happened and was happening. Worse still, there are people in An Garda Síochána now who procured those holsters. There are also people there now - and they are not people who are too different - who managed to get the Department of justice to import weapon parts for a private gun club while telling the Department these were Garda importations to get the public to pay for them. That is what happened. Not one of them has been disciplined. Fiosrú is useless. It has done nothing significant in all these circumstances. </p>
          <p eId="para_477"> Eventually, when the Protected Disclosures Commissioner said one person was to investigate all of this and that was to be the Secretary General of the Department of justice, the Minister caused a letter to be written saying she was handing it back to the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána to investigate it. We are supposed to accept this as reasonable.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_125">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_478">It is shameful.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_126">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_479">This is shameful and disgraceful. You could look at the Donal Corcorans, the Lieutenant Colonel Ray Lanes, the Rose Sweeneys and the Brian O'Reillys - I am not mentioning the other person whose trial is pending - and could ask why they are in the position they are in. As for the entire Government apparatus and Garda apparatus, Fiosrú and the independent policing board the Minister of State spoke so highly of in her reply, not one word of defence for any of those people has been uttered by anyone in authority in Ireland. There has not even been an acceptance that they are decent people whose careers have been ruined. There has not been one word on how they were motivated by a strong sense of patriotic duty to carry out their independent function effectively. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TomClonan" eId="spk_127">
          <from>Senator Tom Clonan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_480">Hear, hear. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMcDowellPD" eId="spk_128">
          <from>Senator Michael McDowell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_481">Not one word has been spoken.</p>
          <p eId="para_482"> By the way, this is not the end of the matter. Anybody in the Departments of justice or public expenditure and reform who thinks this will be the end of the matter is seriously wrong. They are building a pile of firewood around themselves which, in the end, will consume them. </p>
          <p eId="para_483"> This is not going away and those people who are politically responsible for effectively saying there is nothing to be seen here will be those who will pay the ultimate price, not the decent people who stood up for what was right. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#" eId="spk_129">
          <from> Senators<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_484">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_130">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_485">Before we proceed, I welcome the O'Flynn family to the Visitors Gallery, where I understand somebody is celebrating their 80th birthday. It is nice to see them and I hope Michael got you loads of cake. Enjoy the birthday and thank you for coming. </p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_17"> Amendment put.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_18"> The Seanad divided by electronic means.</summary>
        <speech by="#GerardPCraughwell" eId="spk_131">
          <from>Senator Gerard P. Craughwell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_486">Under Standing Order 69(3)(<i>b</i>), I request that the division be taken again other than by electronic means. This is a really important issue and the public has the right to know the way individuals vote.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_132">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_487">As this is the first walk-through division, I will read out the Standing Orders. Under Standing Order 69, Conduct of divisions by electronic means, subsection (3) reads:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_488">On the announcement by the Cathaoirleach of the result of a division which has been taken by electronic means, any member may demand:—</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_489">[...]</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_490">(<i>b</i>) that the division be taken again otherwise than by electronic means; </p>
          <p eId="para_491"> Ironically, it is called "manually", but obviously it is a walk-through vote. The process is that Senators will remain in their designated seats until I put the question, and then the tellers will take up their positions on either side of the door where there are signs that say "Tá" and "Níl". I will then announce that the division proceed. Members will leave their seats, proceed by way of the middle aisle, pass through the "Tá" or "Níl" lobby, as appropriate, and then return to their seats. Their names will be recorded by the tellers, who will be acting for both sides, as they pass through either side of the door. When all Members have passed through, the clerks scrutinise the result, as they normally do for the electronic votes, and the result is handed back and announced.</p>
          <p eId="para_492"> As part of this, the Cathaoirleach can ask for the Members seeking the division to be conducted by a walk-through vote to rise. If fewer than five rise, the vote does not proceed. As Senator Craughwell is a teller, though, he does not need five to rise.</p>
        </speech>
        <debateSection name="division" eId="dbsect_17">
          <summary eId="sum_19">Amendment again put: </summary>
          <summary title="division" eId="sum_20">The Seanad divided: Tá, <quantity refersTo="#ta" normalized="23" eId="qty_3">23</quantity>; Níl, <quantity refersTo="#nil" normalized="12" eId="qty_4">12</quantity>.</summary>
          <debateSection name="ta" eId="dbsect_18">
            <p eId="para_493">Tá</p>
            <p eId="para_494">
              <person refersTo="#GarretAhearn">Ahearn, Garret.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_495">
              <person refersTo="#NiallBlaneyIND">Blaney, Niall.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_496">
              <person refersTo="#ManusBoyle">Boyle, Manus.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_497">
              <person refersTo="#ParaicBrady">Brady, Paraic.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_498">
              <person refersTo="#CathalByrne">Byrne, Cathal.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_499">
              <person refersTo="#PatCasey">Casey, Pat.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_500">
              <person refersTo="#MartinConway">Conway, Martin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_501">
              <person refersTo="#OllieCrowe">Crowe, Ollie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_502">
              <person refersTo="#AidanDavitt">Davitt, Aidan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_503">
              <person refersTo="#MarkDuffy">Duffy, Mark.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_504">
              <person refersTo="#JoeFlaherty">Flaherty, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_505">
              <person refersTo="#RobbieGallagher">Gallagher, Robbie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_506">
              <person refersTo="#ImeldaGoldsboro">Goldsboro, Imelda.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_507">
              <person refersTo="#MikeKennelly">Kennelly, Mike.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_508">
              <person refersTo="#EileenLynch">Lynch, Eileen.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_509">
              <person refersTo="#RayMcAdam">McAdam, Ray.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_510">
              <person refersTo="#MargaretMurphyOMahony">Murphy O'Mahony, Margaret.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_511">
              <person refersTo="#LindaNelsonMurray">Nelson Murray, Linda.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_512">
              <person refersTo="#EvanneNiChuilinn">Ní Chuilinn, Evanne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_513">
              <person refersTo="#NoelODonovan">O'Donovan, Noel.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_514">
              <person refersTo="#JoeOReilly">O'Reilly, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_515">
              <person refersTo="#AnneRabbitte">Rabbitte, Anne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_516">
              <person refersTo="#DiarmuidWilson">Wilson, Diarmuid.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <debateSection name="nil" eId="dbsect_19">
            <p eId="para_517">Níl</p>
            <p eId="para_518">
              <person refersTo="#ChrisAndrews">Andrews, Chris.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_519">
              <person refersTo="#VictorBoyhan">Boyhan, Victor.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_520">
              <person refersTo="#TomClonan">Clonan, Tom.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_521">
              <person refersTo="#JoanneCollins">Collins, Joanne.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_522">
              <person refersTo="#NessaCosgrove">Cosgrove, Nessa.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_523">
              <person refersTo="#GerardPCraughwell">Craughwell, Gerard P.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_524">
              <person refersTo="#AliceMaryHiggins">Higgins, Alice-Mary.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_525">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelMcDowellPD">McDowell, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_526">
              <person refersTo="#MalcolmNoonan">Noonan, Malcolm.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_527">
              <person refersTo="#SarahOReilly">O'Reilly, Sarah.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_528">
              <person refersTo="#PatriciaStephenson">Stephenson, Patricia.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_529">
              <person refersTo="#PaulineTully">Tully, Pauline.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <summary title="tellers" eId="sum_21">Tellers: Tá, Senators Cathal Byrne and Pat Casey; Níl, Senators Michael McDowell and Gerard P. Craughwell.</summary>
          <summary title="decision" refersTo="#carried" eId="sum_22">Amendment declared carried.</summary>
        </debateSection>
        <summary eId="sum_23"> Motion, as amended, put and declared carried. </summary>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_133">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_530">I welcome Deputies Joe Neville and Edward Timmins, and I already welcomed Deputy Willie Aird, and their guests to the Seanad Chamber.</p>
          <p eId="para_531"> When is it proposed to sit again?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GarretAhearn" eId="spk_134">
          <from>Senator Garret Ahearn<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_532">Next Tuesday, at 1 p.m.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkDaly" eId="spk_135">
          <from> An Cathaoirleach<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_533">Is that agreed? Agreed. </p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_24"> Cuireadh an Seanad ar athló ar 2.57 p.m. go dtí 1 p.m., Dé Máirt, an 24 Samhain 2026.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_25"> The Seanad adjourned at 2.57 p.m. until 1 p.m. on Tuesday, 24 November 2026.</summary>
      </debateSection>
    </debateBody>
  </debate>
</akomaNtoso>
