<akomaNtoso xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13" xsi:schemaLocation="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13 ./akomantoso30.xsd">
  <debate name="Official Report">
    <meta>
      <identification source="#debates">
        <FRBRWork>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-19" name="#generation"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#author" href="/ie/oireachtas/house/dail/34"/>
          <FRBRcountry value="ie"/>
          <FRBRname value="debate"/>
        </FRBRWork>
        <FRBRExpression>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate/mul@/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate/mul@"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-19" name="#reported"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
          <FRBRlanguage language="eng"/>
        </FRBRExpression>
        <FRBRManifestation>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate/mul@/main.xml"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-19/debate/mul@.akn"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-21" name="#publication"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
        </FRBRManifestation>
      </identification>
      <references source="#debates">
        <TLCPerson eId="AengusOSnodaighSF" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aengus-Ó-Snodaigh.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Aengus Ó Snodaigh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AidanFarrelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aidan-Farrelly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Aidan Farrelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BarryHeneghan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Barry-Heneghan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Barry Heneghan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BarryWard" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Barry-Ward.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Barry Ward"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BrianBrennan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Brian-Brennan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Brian Brennan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CathalCrowe" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cathal-Crowe.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Cathal Crowe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CathyBennett" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cathy-Bennett.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Cathy Bennett"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CharlesWard" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Charles-Ward.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Charles Ward"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CiaranAhern" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ciarán-Ahern.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Ciarán Ahern"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ClaireKerrane" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Claire-Kerrane.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Claire Kerrane"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ConorDMcGuinness" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Conor-D-McGuinness.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Conor D. McGuinness"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ConorSheehan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Conor-Sheehan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Conor Sheehan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DarrenORourke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Darren-O'Rourke.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Darren O'Rourke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DavidCullinane" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/David-Cullinane.S.2011-05-25" showAs="David Cullinane"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EdwardTimmins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Edward-Timmins.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Edward Timmins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EoghanKenny" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eoghan-Kenny.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Eoghan Kenny"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EoinOBroin" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eoin-Ó-Broin.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Eoin Ó Broin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="FionntanOSuilleabhain" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Fionntán-Ó-Súilleabháin.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GeorgeLawlor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/George-Lawlor.D.2024-11-29" showAs="George Lawlor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GillianToole" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Gillian-Toole.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Gillian Toole"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesBrowne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-Browne.D.2016-10-03" showAs="James Browne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesGeogheganFG" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-Geoghegan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="James Geoghegan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesOConnor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-O'Connor.D.2020-02-08" showAs="James O'Connor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenCummins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jen-Cummins.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Jen Cummins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenniferCarrollMacNeill" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jennifer-Carroll-MacNeill.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Jennifer Carroll MacNeill"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenniferMurnaneOConnor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jennifer-Murnane-O'Connor.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Jennifer Murnane O'Connor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeCooney" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-Cooney.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Joe Cooney"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeNeville" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-Neville.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Joe Neville"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnConnolly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Connolly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="John Connolly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnCummins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Cummins.S.2020-03-30" showAs="John Cummins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnLahart" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Lahart.D.2016-10-03" showAs="John Lahart"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnMcGuinness" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-McGuinness.D.1997-06-26" showAs="John McGuinness"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnPaulOShea" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Paul-O'Shea.D.2024-11-29" showAs="John Paul O'Shea"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KeiraKeogh" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Keira-Keogh.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Keira Keogh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KieranODonnell" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Kieran-O'Donnell.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Kieran O'Donnell"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="LouiseOReilly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Louise-O'Reilly.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Louise O'Reilly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaireDevine" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Máire-Devine.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Máire Devine"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MalcolmByrne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Malcolm-Byrne.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Malcolm Byrne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarieSherlock" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Marie-Sherlock.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Marie Sherlock"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkWall" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Wall.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Mark Wall"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkWard" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Ward.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Mark Ward"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinDaly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Daly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Martin Daly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinKenny" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Kenny.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Martin Kenny"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaryButler" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mary-Butler.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Mary Butler"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MattCarthy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Matt-Carthy.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Matt Carthy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MattieMcGrath" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mattie-McGrath.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Mattie McGrath"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMoynihan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Moynihan.D.1997-06-26" showAs="Michael Moynihan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMurphy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Murphy.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Michael Murphy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichealCarrigy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Micheál-Carrigy.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Micheál Carrigy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NaoiseOCearuil" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Naoise-Ó-Cearúil.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Naoise Ó Cearúil"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NaoiseOMuiri" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Naoise-Ó-Muirí.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Naoise Ó Muirí"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NoelMcCarthy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Noel-McCarthy.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Noel McCarthy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PadraigOSullivan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pádraig-O'Sullivan.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Pádraig O'Sullivan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PadraigRice" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pádraig-Rice.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Pádraig Rice"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulDonnelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Donnelly.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Paul Donnelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulLawless" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Lawless.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Paul Lawless"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulMcAuliffe" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-McAuliffe.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Paul McAuliffe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulMurphy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Murphy.D.2014-10-10" showAs="Paul Murphy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PearseDoherty" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pearse-Doherty.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Pearse Doherty"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PeterRoche" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Peter-Roche.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Peter Roche"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RichardBoydBarrett" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Richard-Boyd-Barrett.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Richard Boyd Barrett"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RichardODonoghue" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Richard-O'Donoghue.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Richard O'Donoghue"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobertODonoghue" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robert-O'Donoghue.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Robert O'Donoghue"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobertTroy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robert-Troy.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Robert Troy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RoryHearne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Rory-Hearne.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Rory Hearne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RuairiOmurchu" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ruairí-Ó-Murchú.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Ruairí Ó Murchú"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeamusMcGrath" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Séamus-McGrath.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Séamus McGrath"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanOFearghaillFF" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Ó-Fearghaíl.S.2000-06-09" showAs="Seán Ó Fearghaíl"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ShaneMoynihan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Shane-Moynihan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Shane Moynihan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ShayBrennan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Shay-Brennan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Shay Brennan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SimonHarris" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Simon-Harris.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Simon Harris"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="TomBrabazon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Tom-Brabazon.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Tom Brabazon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="TonyMcCormack" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Tony-McCormack.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Tony McCormack"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="WillieODea" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Willie-O'Dea.D.1982-03-09" showAs="Willie O'Dea"/>
        <TLCEvent eId="bill.2026.66.dail.2" href="/ie/oireachtas/bill/2026/66/dail/2" showAs="School Meals Nutritional Standards Bill 2026: Second Stage [Private Members] (Dáil)"/>
        <TLCRole eId="An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/office/an_cathaoirleach_gníomhach" showAs="An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Health" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/office/health" showAs="Health"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Housing" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/office/housing" showAs="Housing"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_for_Health" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister/health" showAs="Minister for Health"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister/housing__local_government__heritage" showAs="Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Education_and_Youth" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/education__youth" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Education and Youth"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/finance" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Finance"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/health" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Health"/>
      </references>
    </meta>
    <preface>
      <block name="title_ga">
        <docTitle>DÍOSPÓIREACHTAÍ PARLAIMINTE</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="title_en">
        <docTitle>PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_ga">
        <docProponent>DÁIL ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_en">
        <docProponent>DÁIL ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="status_ga">
        <docStatus>TUAIRISC OIFIGIÚIL</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="status_en">
        <docStatus>(OFFICIAL REPORT)</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="date_ga">
        <docDate date="2026-11-19">Déardaoin, 19 Samhain 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block name="date_en">
        <docDate date="2026-11-19">Thursday, 19 November 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block name="volume">
        <docNumber refersTo="#vol_1095">Vol. 1095</docNumber>
      </block>
      <block name="number">
        <docNumber refersTo="#no_1">No. 1</docNumber>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_en">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_ga">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
    </preface>
    <debateBody>
      <debateSection name="prelude" eId="dbsect_1">
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_1">Chuaigh an Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy John Paul O'Shea) i gceannas ar 8.47 a.m.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_2">Paidir agus Machnamh.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_3">Prayer and Reflection.</summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_2">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:47:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_3">
          <heading>Hospital Overcrowding<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:47:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#DavidCullinane" to="#Health" eId="pq_1">
            <p eId="para_1">1. <b>Deputy David Cullinane</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> her plans to tackle hospital overcrowding this winter. [82235/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_1">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:47:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_2">Over the past number of weeks we have obviously had a very lengthy public debate about public hospitals, overcrowding in those hospitals and the number of patients on trolleys, which leads to a lack of dignity for patients and difficulties for staff. What more can be done in the next few weeks to support hospitals? We have had a very lengthy discussion about Cork University Hospital but there are many more hospitals that have extreme pressures and it is important all those hospitals and the staff who work in them, especially in the emergency departments, are given all the resources they need.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" as="#Minister_for_Health" eId="spk_2">
            <from>Minister for Health (Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:47:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_3">I thank the Deputy. Patient safety and the continuity of essential health services is my priority for the winter period.</p>
            <p eId="para_4"> As we are all aware, urgent and emergency care services are currently experiencing very significant demand with emergency department attendances now 7% higher than 2025. The HSE is forecasting that winter 2026-2027 will be busier still, with 736,000 emergency department attendances forecast between November and March, with the largest increase expected in December.</p>
            <p eId="para_5"> Every single hospital with an emergency department is pressured and in highlighting those that have higher trolley numbers I do not wish to take from the excellent work that is being done in the hospitals that do not have the same congestion but still experience the same demand. Demand is equal everywhere. However, congestion remains largely concentrated in a limited number of hospital sites that consistently account for 60% of the 8 a.m. trolley numbers. They are Limerick, Cork, St. Vincent's, Galway, Mayo, Sligo, Mercy and Tallaght. Focused interventions are being implemented at these hospitals to strengthen operational control, accelerate discharge pathways, optimise bed capacity and maximise the availability and use of community and step-down supports. For example, HSE South West region is supporting CUH through initiatives aimed at improving access to and utilisation of community and step-down beds in Mallow and Bantry. There are also examples in other regions.</p>
            <p eId="para_6"> However, many sites consistently perform well, demonstrating consistent green performance can be delivered in the face of strong demand growth.</p>
            <p eId="para_7">Sites such as Waterford, Tullamore, Connolly, Portlaoise, Cavan and Portiuncula remain within their thresholds nearly every day. The performance of two other sites is worth noting. Drogheda, a model 3 hospital, has treated more patients in the ED than many model 4 hospitals, yet it has been green on 97% of days this year. Kerry, which was very congested at the start of the year, has shown steady improvement and was green on every day in October. This speaks to the value of operational grip achieved in both of those hospitals. It was achieved by having a plan for every patient, focused bed capacity management both inside and outside the hospital, proactive management of diagnostics and timely discharge. In my next response I will give some specific examples of additionality in the winter.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_3">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_8">The public wants to hear a Government, and indeed an Oireachtas, saying we are going to have a zero-tolerance approach to hospital trolleys and overcrowding. It was 20 years ago that Enda Kenny famously said he would end the scandal of patients on trolleys, and in every year that has passed since, the figures have got worse. In October of this year, according to the INMO, 12,700 patients were on trolleys or in overcrowded situations. We know from the figures that a lot of them are patients over 75 who in some cases are waiting for over 24 hours. It has got to the point that as well as patients waiting on trolleys for that length of time, there are also patients sitting on chairs. It has got to the point that not every patient will even get a trolley. Many are waiting in pain on chairs. I have seen them and spoken to them in my local hospital. It has a good record on trolleys but that is not to say people are not waiting in the emergency department on chairs.</p>
            <p eId="para_9"> We need to do more. Does the Government have a zero-tolerance approach to hospital trolleys, and if it does, why is it getting worse and worse every month?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_4" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_10">Yes, I certainly do and I attend the trolley call a couple of times a week as best I can to be there and see what is going on. Performance actually improved, as I understand it, in the years 2024 and 2025. It has disimproved in 2026, for two reasons. First, demand is up. As for the second, I wrote to the HSE board in February specifying the model we had achieved to improve operational grip and reduce the trolley number must be sustained, that is, the daily trolley call and the work that goes into that. That was changed in May and we lost operational grip through the summer as a consequence. It was reinstated in September, but there has been lost operational grip throughout 2026 in a way I am not satisfied with. However, this winter I see hospitals beginning to recover and I have asked for a focused plan for each hospital, which I have received. Examples include extended diagnostic access in Beaumont over weekends, commencing medical social work services in emergency departments on Sundays in the Mater and different measures to try to improve patient flow. Operational grip is the key differentiator at site level, region level and national level and that has not improved in 2026 in the way it did in 2025.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_5">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_11">Overcrowding in hospitals is not without its consequences for patients and staff. We have seen tragic consequences in the past in Limerick and other hospitals. Patients can die. All the international evidence points to poorer outcomes, patient risk and patient safety difficulties when there are overcrowded situations and hospitals operating at full occupancy.</p>
            <p eId="para_12"> The Minister is right when she talks about operational grip, but that has to include the Government and her as Minister. It is also about resources. I remember being at a meeting in Limerick with the then head of the HSE. He had to concede that there were patients presenting to hospitals who needed to be admitted to a bed but the beds were not there. I also remember the Minister's previous Government, with a Fianna Fáil Minister for Health, announcing to great fanfare 3,000 beds, broken down by hospital and targets for each hospital. The money is not there to build those beds. There were targets for each year but we have not met them. If hospitals do not have the beds and if there are employment controls in place that prevent hospitals such as Cork and elsewhere from having the staff they see the need to ensure patient safety, that is on the Government and the Minister.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_6" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_13">It is also on the Oireachtas and the voted budget, but different hospitals use their budgets differently. A key thing we did this week under the hospital avoidance initiative was the Ballina injury unit. The Roscommon injury unit has 20,000 patients a year. The Ballina unit will now provide for 8,000 to 10,000 patients who would otherwise be attending Mayo University Hospital in Castlebar. It is a really huge and very necessary support. Of course, we would have liked it earlier, but it is there now and it is very important. The Deputy is right; the greatest risk to patient safety relates to an admitted patient of the hospital waiting in the emergency department. You have to manage risk all the time and Colm Henry talks about this. That is why it is so important hospitals use the step-down facilities, that they discharge people in different ways and that doing so is their priority. I agree with the Deputy. I regularly participate in the daily operational oversight calls. It is a huge priority for me. You will also hear that some electives are being cancelled as a consequence of this focus on urgent and emergency care. We always prioritise time-sensitive elective cancer surgery. The clinical director signs off on that every week where that absolutely has to happen. It is a balance, especially in the winter, but every winter we wind down elective care in anticipation of increased attendances through the respiratory virus season.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_4">
          <heading>Hospital Staff<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#DavidCullinane" to="#Health" eId="pq_2">
            <p eId="para_14">2. <b>Deputy David Cullinane</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> if she will permit hospitals to recruit under regional direction into priority posts to ensure safe staffing levels this winter. [82236/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_7">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_15">This question is on employment controls, which we touched on earlier. One hundred and thirty-seven directors of nursing and midwifery have penned an open letter about employment controls. I think they have written to the Minister as well but they have certainly made their feelings about the controls known. We have therefore heard from patients, directors of nursing and hospital management. We are hearing it from politicians and people can see with their own eyes what is happening in hospitals but also in primary and community care, where far too many people are waiting. There seems to be an issue with controls on recruitment being put in place and how long it takes the health service to recruit. All the while, we have so many people on waiting lists and all the pressures we have in hospitals.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_8" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_16">I thank the Deputy. As always, continuity of services is essential. The strengthened controls are in place to ensure recruitment is planned and prioritised towards the services and locations of greatest patient need while remaining affordable within the pay allocations.</p>
            <p eId="para_17"> Health regions are well placed to understand local pressures and patient need. They are responsible for identifying and prioritising staffing requirements using evidence-based workforce tools such as the framework for safe nurse staffing and skill mix, which is employed in every emergency department in the country. There are 26 adult emergency departments and 39 acute hospitals, with 96% of identified baseline staffing requirements delivered nationally.</p>
            <p eId="para_18"> There is no recruitment embargo in the HSE. This year we had provision to hire 3,300 people contingent on a reduction in agency. We have hired 4,000 people. The Deputy and I spoke about the Estimates in committee earlier in the year and talked about the budget, how it was planned and the additionality. We have gone way beyond the additionality, and there does have to be a measure of control and planning.</p>
            <p eId="para_19"> Because of my concern for patient safety, which the Deputy correctly shares, notwithstanding that we have hired 4,000 people and hired graduate nurses, we are looking at hundreds of agency conversion posts, all of which is a good thing. I have specifically sought that the HSE identify region by region those posts it feels would make a difference either to patient safety within a hospital or, crucially, to patient flow to help get people out of the hospital. A general number was identified but I have yet to receive the specifics of that from the HSE and it is important that I do. I asked for it a good three weeks ago because it is not just those positions for now but goes into the new year. Obviously, we cannot recruit that number of new people in this period.</p>
            <p eId="para_20"> Take for example the community nursing unit in Letterkenny. That is a key patient safety imperative for Letterkenny hospital. It should have been prioritised in HSE West and North West this year but it was not and the staff are not there yet. We will not get the building until December, but nevertheless, that is the kind of planning that is necessary and that we will see next year with the strategic recruitment plans.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_9">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_21">I asked the CEO of the HSE yesterday who makes the call to sign off on roles, especially posts that have been identified by acute hospitals and community care, and she said it was her and the HSE centrally. As such, there is no doubt in my mind that very stringent controls are having an impact on the ability of hospitals to recruit staff. Notwithstanding all the additional staff who I accept have been recruited, and I welcome every single additional staff member, there are still gaps, vacancies and need because our population is growing, the nature of care is changing and we are not getting value for money. Despite efforts, we are still spending far too much on agency. Overtime has gone up each and every month over the last number of years. I have the figures on that. Overtime has gone up and agency spend hit almost €1 billion last year, yet we have employment controls in place that mean it is very bureaucratic and far too difficult to get those posts. The Minister gave the example of Letterkenny. There is frustration there, but why is that the case? That is what she and the rest of us need to get to bottom of to ensure that priority posts are filled as quickly as possible.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_10" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T08:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_22">I took Letterkenny as an example but it was obvious at the beginning of the year that those posts would be necessary.</p>
            <p eId="para_23">I was there in 2025 as the building was being constructed. We originally expected to have the building in September. It will now be in December, although I am open to correction on that.</p>
            <p eId="para_24"> Nevertheless, it is true that there are things we can plan for. We can plan for graduate nurses. We can plan when we know that a building is to be opened, as we did in Limerick. We planned those staff to be there before the 96 beds were opened. That should be planned and ready to go. It is that kind of strategic recruitment that is necessary where we know that we are hiring staff because we are creating new beds and that there is not a tension or conflict between that. There is not an embargo. It is up to the CEO of the HSE to prioritise those posts. There is a budget element from the agency conversion. There is also the respect and predictability of graduate nurses coming into the system. From a patient safety perspective, where there are posts that would improve patient safety or patient flow, which is the same thing, I have asked for them and I expect the HSE to prioritise those posts, as we in this House prioritise patient safety.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#DavidCullinane" eId="spk_11">
            <from>Deputy David Cullinane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_25">We have said repeatedly that patient safety is the core priority. When we are talking about employment controls and recruitment, I accept that we have to get value for money and that there have to be efficiencies, but we also have to get it right. I raised with the Minister a number of times now over the last number of days an issue of inefficiency in my county of Waterford in relation to scans being done out of hours. The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, is here. I am sure she is aware of it. I spoke to the hospital manager. We have a hospital management team that is doing a first-class job in Waterford. The Minister, the Minister of State and I have recognised that. They put in place an initiative five years ago or more to ensure they would get the most out of very expensive scanning equipment. Now it seems that the out-of-hours extended hours service was stopped by the HSE. Again, this seems to be a financial consideration. Whatever the reasoning behind it, we have to get to the bottom of it and we have to reinstate that. I am not getting into how the payments are made. I am simply making the point that patients should not suffer and cancer patients should not have to wait for scans.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_12" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_26">I could not agree with the Deputy more. He is right; we need to get to the bottom of specifically why that has ended and what the circumstances were.</p>
            <p eId="para_27"> I might point to something else, however, namely endoscopy. Our endoscopy waiting lists have gone up this year. Other lists have come down, but endoscopy wait times have gone up. I cannot describe how frustrated I am. I have pointed this out repeatedly. We have excellent endoscopy suites in model 2 hospitals, whether it is Roscommon or Bantry, and we not using them to the full extent. I have looked at the timesheets. We are not using them to the full extent. In prioritising who we recruit, we recruit to staff those facilities off the HSE time rather than any sort of insourcing and outsourcing arrangement with HSE staff, but those facilities are being used all the time. I do not see the utilisation that we should see as representatives of taxpayers and patients having invested in these suites. That is another example. There are different ways of coming to that.</p>
            <p eId="para_28"> I thank the Deputy for raising value for money. We cannot keep hiring into hospitals that work from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Where would the people go? The hospitals have to run differently. It is a tension, of course, because reform is difficult. People do not always like change, but that is what we have to deliver on behalf of the taxpayer and patient.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_5">
          <heading>Hospital Staff<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#PadraigRice" to="#Health" eId="pq_3">
            <p eId="para_29">3. <b>Deputy Pádraig Rice</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> if she will commission an independent assessment of the staffing need at Cork University Hospital.  [82422/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_13">
            <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_30">There has been a lot of debate in recent months around Cork University Hospital, CUH, and particularly what has been said by the CEO. Not enough attention has been given, however, to what has been said by the nine clinical directors who wrote to the Taoiseach and local public representatives. Has the Minister read that letter? Will she progress the solutions they clearly set out in it? They have six key calls. Key among those is securing independent assessment of CUH's whole-time equivalent, WTE, ceiling and the true vacancy rate within the hospital. Will the Minister progress those solutions to the issue in front of us?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_14" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_31">I thank the Deputy. I take the concerns about Cork University Hospital very seriously. It is a busy model 4 hospital. It is the second largest hospital in the country and provides important services to a large and growing population. An acute hospital of this scale and complexity will inevitably have pressures.</p>
            <p eId="para_32"> When the concerns were raised more publicly, my first response was a patient safety response. It was to ask the chief clinical officer to assess what was happening. He visited the region and spoke to all the team there. I do not know the specific location of the meeting, but he spoke to everybody in the region and did an assessment, which was broadly reassuring. For example, we can see that Cork is ahead of the national picture in some areas and behind in the national picture in other areas. It is experiencing urgent and emergency pressures. However, the assessment is broadly reassuring. Crucially, there were no increases in mortality incidents or category 1 incidents and the safe staffing framework was in place. There were none of the other metrics that are picked up when patient safety becomes an issue. That is an important assessment done by the chief clinical officer.</p>
            <p eId="para_33"> Of course, I also checked in with the national patient safety office, which reported something broadly similar, always with the caveat that something can happen on any day in any hospital. It is also important to acknowledge that the HIQA, which is an independent statutory patient safety authority, has engaged and had an announced inspection on 5 and 6 November to monitor against the national standards for safer, better healthcare. It is important that we hear from HIQA before making any further decisions. I do not wish to cut across the established statutory governance and patient safety processes that we have in this State. If patient safety concerns are being asserted, it is important that the State respond with the patient safety architecture to assess, monitor and see what the situation is in relation to patient safety. At the same time, the staffing concerns that have been identified are being rigorously assessed by Sonya Cotter, the new integrated healthcare area, IHA, manager for CUH. She is working through the current deployment of staff and what is asserted as necessary over whatever period that is to work out where that situation is. I expect a report from Sonya Cotter in the next period.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_15">
            <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_34">There is a real difference of opinion about the staffing within the hospital. This is what has been set out by the clinical directors regarding how the ceiling is calculated, how many people are on sick leave and maternity leave, how it is counted when there is cover for those posts, how many people have shared posts with the university, how many people have citywide posts, how many agency staff have been promoted to permanent staff and how they factored into the ceiling, and the baseline for the ceiling. There are serious issues around how these calculations have been done. They are quite contested. I asked the Minister if she has seen this letter from the clinical directors, which t set out in detail these concerns about the ceiling. That would help put forward a solution to this problem. What they are asking for is separate to the HIQA process. HIQA is looking at patient safety. This is an independent assessment of the headcount, the staffing, how many people are working in the hospital and how many people are available to work in the hospital so that we can all have a clear view of how many people are working there and have an adequate independent assessment of that because there is clearly a difference of opinion between what the HSE nationally is saying and what the hospital locally is saying. That is the solution.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_16" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_35">I have seen that letter. Forgive me, I do not have it in front of me, but I recall it, for example, identifying a CT scanner not working. I think there are four CT scanners in CUH. It also has the largest number of radiographers of any hospital in the country. It has 97 radiographers. My question in the first instance would be what the deployment of the radiographers is and how that works. It is very important to say that CUH is a HSE hospital, as are Waterford and Galway. I have never heard the particular articulation of what an independent assessment means or looks like and how that is situated against the statutory governance of the HSE. Who is this person and how does that work? I heard on the radio that this would take one day. I do not believe that is so. It is very important that HIQA be allowed to conduct its process. We have a statutory governance system here. HIQA, which is the patient safety authority, is engaged in a process. As the Minister for Health, I am not going to cut across that process, nor do I believe that any other Deputy should cut across that process. The HSE governance is overseen by the board, but first and foremost, I want to hear from the new analysis of Sonya Cotter, who is there. I also want to hear from HIQA. Any further analysis of what is happening at CUH must necessarily be informed by both of those processes. It is very important that we receive both.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_17">
            <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_36">We must accept that this hospital is under extraordinary pressure. Emergency department presentations are up 12%. Attendances by people aged over 75 are up 14%. Neurosurgical emergencies are up 25%. There is huge demand on the services. We need a population-based resource allocation that responds to real demands. We also know that HSE South West is under-resourced. It has fewer beds per 1,000 of population than any other region. CUH has the largest bed deficit in the Government's own bed expansion plan, requiring 341 by 2031. Only 18 new acute beds were delivered last year. Seventeen beds were opened with no dedicated funding for staff and are being maintained through overtime agency staff. Twenty-one acute beds for completion this winter still have no staff approved and risk remaining unavailable during the peak winter period because the staffing has not been approved for those beds. We have an expansion of beds there and no staff for them. They are left in limbo. The region is under-resourced in terms of bed capacity according to the Government's own reports.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_18" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_37">I hear the numbers the Deputy is referencing, but I do not hear him reference all the facilities in HSE South West. For example, I opened 24 beds in Mallow this year.</p>
            <p eId="para_38">We have gone from 37 beds to 95 beds. That is important for CUH.</p>
            <p eId="para_39"> I remember being on the trolley call in Cork on 7 or 8 November, and on a Sunday morning there were 42 patients on trolleys in Cork. There were nine empty beds in Mallow and four surge beds. Some 13 people could have been in Mallow where beds lay empty in November this year, while 42 people were on trolleys in CUH on a Sunday morning. On the utilisation of bed capacity more broadly, the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, opened a new community nursing unit in Killarney that is just as important for CUH because it is the regional hospital and people need to stepdown back to Kerry as much as anything else.</p>
            <p eId="para_40"> We are increasing bed capacity everywhere but the beds have to be used. I do not say this to try to be in conflict. I have raised the utilisation of beds more broadly all year. I have raised the utilisation of endoscopy services in Bantry. I have to give the Deputy that example and suggest to him that it is not just beds in CUH that matter, although they do. We have extremely important plans for bed expansion in CUH but it is just as important to the people of the region that people move out of a model four hospital into a stepdown facility and that does not happen consistently. That needs to improve. It is just one example from this month.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_6">
          <heading>Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#GillianToole" to="#Health" eId="pq_4">
            <p eId="para_41">4. <b>Deputy Gillian Toole</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> the specific public healthcare supports that are available to patients with symptoms of long Covid; and the reviews of clinics and outcomes for patients that are carried out; and where the results are published.  [82175/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#GillianToole" eId="spk_19">
            <from>Deputy Gillian Toole<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_42">What are the specific public healthcare supports available to patients with symptoms of long Covid? What reviews of clinics and outcomes for patients are carried out? Where are those results published?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_20" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_43">I thank the Deputy. I want to recognise the continuing impact of long Covid on patients. Our focus is on providing care, strengthening services and ensuring that evidence informs our response. The HSE has established six specialist clinics across the country, with a national pathway spanning general practice, community and hospital services. Multidisciplinary teams continue to provide assessment, rehabilitation and follow-up care. These specialties include infectious diseases, neurology, nursing, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, psychology and psychiatry. </p>
            <p eId="para_44"> I acknowledge the difficulty in staffing vacancies and access to services, in particular in Limerick. A campaign to recruit a consultant in March 2026 was unsuccessful, unfortunately, and there is now a further recruitment campaign planned for early 2027. In the interim, until we can recruit that consultant, new referrals are being redirected to CUH primarily, while care continues to be maintained for existing patients.</p>
            <p eId="para_45"> The HSE is reviewing its interim model of care to reflect emerging evidence and changing patient needs. Although progress has been slower than intended, the recent recruitment of a new programme manager provides additional capacity to accelerate that work. HIQA's previous budget review found that the model of care aligns well with international practice.</p>
            <p eId="para_46"> With respect to patient outcomes, two important population studies in Ireland have been undertaken and gave useful evidence about health outcomes explained by people following Covid-19, namely the HSE's follow-up after disease acquisition, FADA, survey and the 2024 Healthy Ireland survey. Healthy Ireland found that 92% of people returned their usual health after Covid-19 infection, with 80% recovering one month after initial infection. Of course, the Deputy has highlighted people experiencing long Covid who commonly report problems, including fatigue, cognitive difficulties, joint or muscle pain, sleep disturbance and breathlessness. The findings of the studies to which I referred will continue to inform service development, planning and the review of the model of care.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#GillianToole" eId="spk_21">
            <from>Deputy Gillian Toole<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_47">I refer to the HSE framework and the six public clinics. As it currently stands, St. James's has none. I do not know about Beaumont or St. Vincent's. In December 2022, the Mater clinic ceased. The one in Cork is in existence. Limerick has staffing issues. Tallaght ceased operation in July 2024. For my constituents, there is no access. The only route is the private route, which is not working for them. There is no service. </p>
            <p eId="para_48"> Having checked with HSE Live, option four on the telephone line, the Covid option, is not available and has not been over the past number of days. There is no information available. Many of my constituents fall into the category of people who had no symptoms or only mild symptoms and then retrospectively developed long Covid. They are in limbo with no supports or rehabilitation plan. They need our support. The evaluation committee takes no cognisance whatsoever of clinics or product in its deliberations. There is a massive gap and my constituents are right in the middle. What is the plan?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_22" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_49">I thank the Deputy. It is very important to hear about the experience of her constituents. I would like to follow up on that separately with the Deputy. While the information I have is that there are specialist clinics in Beaumont, St. James's, St. Vincent's, Cork, Galway and Limerick, recruitment difficulties have affected access in some locations. All six clinics are operational but genuine service challenges exist, as the Deputy has said. Therefore, the provision is not identical in every location. </p>
            <p eId="para_50"> I need to understand exactly what the Deputy's constituents are experiencing and see what we can do. Waiting times vary considerably between clinics and disciplines. For example, University Hospital Galway reports the shortest waiting time for a medical appointment, at two weeks, and same day physiotherapy, although new occupational therapy appointments are unavailable, whereas Beaumont offers access across four disciplines, with waits ranging from two to three weeks for psychology and eight to ten weeks for psychiatry services. The position is different everywhere and I need to understand exactly what the Deputy's constituents are experiencing. I thank her for raising the matter.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#GillianToole" eId="spk_23">
            <from>Deputy Gillian Toole<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_51">I look forward to discussing this with the Minister on a one-to-one basis. A previous question of mine in the vein of long Covid has not yet been answered. On HSE Live or any other reliable healthcare website, in terms of differentiation between long Covid and adverse events resulting from Covid vaccination, the symptoms are identical. What deliberation is taking place to separate matters? </p>
            <p eId="para_52"> Page 89 of the programme for Government refers to the provision of care on an ongoing basis. We will have to be able to differentiate between long Covid, post-Covid and possible adverse events. That is possibly something for a further discussion. Again, I have constituents who, in good faith, Covid tested for their work in aviation and healthcare on a routine basis and had negative test results, but then fell into the long Covid category. There is a grey area that needs to be teased out, and again it is outside the remit of the evaluation committee. I do not expect the Minister to answer that question now; I want to flag it for the future.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_24" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_53">I thank the Deputy. I hear what she is saying. She is right; I do not have the answer to her question here today. Perhaps she and I might have a more direct chat, understand the situation better and decide which steps I can take to get better information than I have today.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_7">
        <heading>Ceisteanna Eile - Other Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_8">
          <heading>Mental Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#WillieODea" to="#Health" eId="pq_5">
            <p eId="para_54">5. <b>Deputy Willie O'Dea</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> the way in which she is increasing mental health supports across all Integrated Care Programme for Older People teams.  [82024/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_25">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_55">I thank the Minister of State for taking the question. We know that significant supports have gone into adult mental health services and the psychiatry of later life. I would appreciate if the Minister of State would outline the additional supports available. I have some concerns and the Minister of State has expressed concern about the consistency of services throughout the country. There are black spots in the country in terms of services for older people.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" eId="spk_26">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Mary Butler)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_56">I thank the Deputy for his important question. We do not often get to speak about mental healthcare programmes for older people, especially, as I call it, the psychiatry of later life. Other people call it the psychiatry of old age. It is important. As the Deputy knows, Sharing the Vision is our mental health policy and continues to drive Ireland's transformative whole-of-system mental health reform agenda. The policy places significant emphasis on promoting tailored community based services for older people. </p>
            <p eId="para_57"> As the Deputy knows, Sharing the Vision is successful because we have a national implementation and monitoring committee that sits over me and the Minister. It includes members of the HSE and Department and, most importantly, the lived experience of people delivering supports on the ground. The committee meets every quarter regionally. It is meeting in the midlands this afternoon to discuss the implementation of short-, medium- and long-term plans.</p>
            <p eId="para_58"> Positive progress has been achieved in the development of liaison based services. Some five demonstration sites for the psychiatry of older age have been established. Following evaluation and gap analysis, additional commitments were secured through budget 2026 and 2027. Work is also continuing to strengthen and expand psychiatry of later life services.</p>
            <p eId="para_59">There are now more than 30 teams operational nationwide. With the support of the Minister, I secured an additional 24 posts for next year. We are conscious that there are gaps in the services and areas where it can be a little more difficult than in others. I have to compliment the psychiatry of later life and the way it works. In most instances, when the psychiatrist initially comes to the person’s house, it reduces the stigma of that person getting involved in the mental health services. There is follow-up from the clinical nurse specialist, CNS, who will continue to come, week after week, to support that person. I have seen it working in action. It is a fantastic facility that we do not often get the chance to talk about.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_27">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_60">I fully support the Minister of State’s view on the psychiatry of later life. It is a very important service for elderly people, who often live with hidden depression, hidden anxiety, the stresses of growing older, loneliness and also a sense that their lives may be coming towards an end. However, we have a psychiatry of later life referral rejection rate of 43% in Roscommon and north Galway. That, in itself, is remarkable because it suggests that experienced GPs in the community do not know what they are doing, or are not trained or sufficiently trained to decide who needs to have a psychiatry of later life consultation. In the same area, in the Tuam-Loughrea service, there is referral rejection rate of only 21%, and in the Tuam-Galway service, there is a rejection rate of just 16%. There is something wrong if, in one area of counties Galway and Roscommon, the Roscommon and north Galway service is standing out again due to its rejection referral rate. There is a pattern here. It happens in CAMHS and in adult services also.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_28" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_61">We cannot beat the lived experience of Deputy Daly, who is practising on the ground and able to provide us with those statistics. That is a massive difference. The Deputy is right that we have seen this across CAMHS as well, and it varies significantly from the level of acceptances of referrals from the GP. Only yesterday, for example, I launched a new advanced model of care for adults with ADHD in consultation with the Irish College of GPs, and going forward, over 1,200 GPs will be involved. It is important to have that interaction. What the Deputy has raised is concerning. Nobody would refer somebody for psychiatry of later life lightly. We have an ageing population because we are lucky to have one of the highest life expectancies in Europe. However, there are a lot of people in their elderly years who, for the first time in their life, because of, say, Covid or bereavement, find it very difficult to put one foot in front of the other on a daily basis. I will certainly take this back to the region on the Deputy's behalf.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_29">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_62">I fully accept the bona fides of the Minister of State on this matter. I know that her commitment to mental health in general, but also to the psychiatry of later life, cannot be questioned. The concern is that although we are spending funds and funding these services, we have a situation where the total referrals of counties Roscommon and Galway have a 27% rejection rate. Here is one issue. There is no routine collection of data on the first referral or the offer of a first appointment. The service will say that everyone is offered an appointment within three months but, of course, it can offer an appointment within three months if it is going to reject 43% of the referrals.</p>
            <p eId="para_63"> I also want to put on record that the service is excellent. Once someone gets to the service, it is excellent. It is a hugely valuable service in the community, supporting GPs, public health nurses and the families of older people who are living with mental health issues.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_30" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_64">I thank the Deputy for that. As he knows, the new Mental Health Act was passed this year and will make a significant difference to the oversight of community services. We have already had standards provided by the Mental Health Commission in relation to the 1,200 people who live in community residences across the island. My Department is looking at those, and they will be turned into secondary legislation where necessary. The oversight and governance model that we will have across all community fields, including CAMHS, is important. There is a connection across all of these schemes. Understandably, the variations are a worry for me. We see it the whole time across CAMHS. Some teams have a rejection rate of 33%, whereas others can have a rejection rate of up to 69%. We need to standardise the model everywhere. No two cases are the same, as we know. I thank the Deputy for raising his concerns.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_9">
          <heading>Hospital Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#MichaelMurphy" to="#Health" eId="pq_6">
            <p eId="para_65">6. <b>Deputy Michael Murphy</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> when the second floor of the new St. Anthony’s community nursing unit in Clonmel will become operational; the reasons for the delay in opening the remaining 25 beds; the staffing and funding requirements necessary to bring these beds into service; and if she will provide a definitive timeline for their opening.  [80476/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MichaelMurphy" eId="spk_31">
            <from>Deputy Michael Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_66">I ask the Minister for an update on the recently opened St. Anthony’s nursing unit in Clonmel. It is great to see the initial 25 beds up and running. Can the Minister give a definitive timeline for the opening of the remaining 25 beds? There is a real urgency in this regard.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_32" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_67">It is wonderful to see the St. Anthony’s community nursing unit open. The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, informs me that she turned the sod on it, and it is excellent to see it now operational. However, we want to have all of the beds open. We have the new 50-bed Clonmel residential care centre. As the Deputy said, there are currently 25 beds open and operational in the facility, including 22 long-stay beds and three palliative care beds. All of those beds are occupied, as the Deputy is aware better than I. The HSE Dublin and South East is currently working on a staffing plan to open the remaining beds that are registered in the facility. I have been advised that a phased opening of additional bed capacity will commence shortly. Recruitment of staff is under way to open ten of the beds before the end of 2026, and a further recruitment campaign will then be launched to open the remaining beds that are currently registered. That will take place in quarter one of 2027. The full operationalisation of the new Clonmel residential care centre is an absolute priority for me, the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, who is working on this assiduously, the Department of Health and the HSE.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMurphy" eId="spk_33">
            <from>Deputy Michael Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_68">I welcome the fact that an additional ten beds will be opened before the end of the year at St. Anthony’s. I am conscious that we are speaking about a physical building but, of course, it is so much more than that. It has a fantastic reputation, which is all down to the staff and the level of care. It would be remiss of me not to thank the Minister for that vote of confidence in Clonmel and the investment by the Government in this 50-bed unit. I also mention the success of the minor injuries unit in Cashel. I welcome that ten beds will be open before the end of the year. I would press upon the Minister the issue of opening the remaining beds in the first quarter of next year, and I ask her to keep a close eye. It would be remiss of me not to also mention that the three palliative care beds on the ground floor are very welcome. I thank everybody involved. I also acknowledge the work of the Minister of State, Deputy Butler.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_34" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_69">I acknowledge the importance of those three palliative care beds. I also acknowledge how hard the local community advocated and articulated the need for that. I know there was a loss of three beds elsewhere. It is important that we have this within such a beautiful facility as St. Anthony’s. I know how lovely it is because I have heard that. There is a priority to open the ten beds before the end of 2026. Of course, that is enormously important for Tipperary University Hospital and its general manager, Maria Barry. I acknowledge the great work she is doing there and the great work that all of the team there is doing together to improve patient safety, keep people off trolleys and make sure the step-down facilities are available. This is just as important for that hospital as it is for the whole region, and just as important for patient safety as for any other thing. I know that Tipperary is using those beds and that all of them are full. That is a credit to its concern for patient safety. It is up to us to make sure the recruitment of staff can progress early next year and that those remaining beds are open.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMurphy" eId="spk_35">
            <from>Deputy Michael Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_70">I thank the Minister for referencing Tipperary University Hospital and the fantastic work that Maria Barry and her team are doing. I am in regular contact with Ms Barry. It would be remiss of me not to mention that we would always welcome additional investment. There are great plans, and there is a particular need to invest in the emergency department and paediatric department at Tipperary University Hospital. The Minister is aware that we have a real challenge. I know that quite a number of beds are taken up, so we need to release those patients - a figure of up to 30 has been mentioned to me by senior management. The sooner we can open these additional beds in St. Anthony’s, the sooner we can address what is somewhat of a crisis in Tipperary University Hospital. I want to come back to the original point and welcome the ten additional beds that will be opened before the end of this year, and the Minister’s commitment that the remaining beds will be opened by quarter one of 2027.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_36" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_71">I compliment Tipperary University Hospital, although it has been a bit challenged this year, not only for reducing the number of people on trolleys, but also for leaning into its Saturday clinics, which are important for the people of Tipperary. It now has a weekly cardiology diagnostic clinic open on Saturdays from 8.30 a.m. until 5.30 p.m. It is wonderful to see Ms Barry driving ahead with the Saturday working agenda for the benefit of all of those people - the Deputy’s constituents - in Tipperary.</p>
            <p eId="para_72">Certainly I am an enormous supporter of that hospital, of Ms Barry and all of her team and of the facilities that support it, such as the minor injury unit, which is a key part of keeping people out of the emergency department and is just as important as the step-down facilities in St. Anthony's.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_10">
          <heading>Nicotine Inhaling Products<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#ShaneMoynihan" to="#Health" eId="pq_7">
            <p eId="para_73">7. <b>Deputy Shane Moynihan</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> whether test purchasing inspections are being conducted in vape shops to assess compliance with associated regulations, the number of such inspections undertaken in 2025 and to date in 2026 and the number and nature of breaches identified. [81872/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#ShaneMoynihan" eId="spk_37">
            <from>Deputy Shane Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_74">My question concerns whether test purchasing inspections are being conducted in vape shops to assess compliance with associated regulations, especially pending the commencement of the 2026 public health Acts, the number of inspections taken in 2025 and to date in 2026 and the number and nature of breaches identified.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_38" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_75">I am taking this question on behalf of the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, who sends her apologies. She is dealing with EU engagements relating to the drugs strategy this morning. Section 28 of the Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) Act 2023 prohibits the sale of tobacco products and nicotine inhaling products to children. This law is enforced by the HSE national environmental health service through test purchase inspections. I am advised by the HSE that 230 test purchase inspections for nicotine inhaling products were conducted in 2025. In 50 of those inspections, a nicotine inhaling product was sold to a child. A total of 342 test purchase inspections have been conducted up to the end of October 2026. In 42 of those, a nicotine inhaling product was sold to a child.</p>
            <p eId="para_76"> In cases of non-compliance, the HSE takes a prosecution to the District Court and publishes details of relevant convictions on the HSE website. This excludes cases where a judge has applied the Probation Act. As we all know and agree, no retailer should be selling these products to children. We have strengthened enforcement for retailers who break the law. As of August this year, all retailers must apply for an annual licence to sell tobacco and nicotine inhaling products. On top of existing penalties, convictions for selling to children will now include minimum licence suspension periods. Conviction for two or more offences can lead to licence revocation. The Minister of State's officials will monitor the impact of these new measures.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ShaneMoynihan" eId="spk_39">
            <from>Deputy Shane Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_77">I want to call out the great progress that the Government, including the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, has made on strengthening the regulation of vaping products, particularly those measures included in the 2026 public health Act. A few weeks ago, I raised with the Minister the growing number of vape shops that we see proliferating all over the country, particularly in Clondalkin in my constituency. That is why it is important that enforcement is taken very seriously, particularly given the strength of the measures that are being implemented in the 2026 public health Acts. This is why test purchasing is really important. The numbers presented by the Minister of State today are very stark. Enforcement to monitor the level of compliance of these outlets needs to be of tantamount importance, especially now that there are more requirements of retailers with regard to single use vapes and how vapes are packaged and displayed. The 2025 figures read to me like a 25% rate of lack of compliance. This has fallen to a rate of 12.5% so far this year but we await the outcomes in the statistics.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_40" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_78">In 2025, there were 725 inspections of e-cigarette manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers. I initially gave the figure for retailers. There were 725 inspections to assess compliance with the EU tobacco products directive. This was an increase from 310 in 2024 so the environmental health service has really upped the ante in relation to enforcement of tobacco and nicotine inhaling products. It has become a huge priority as part of the 2026 national service plan. A total of 30 additional staff have been allocated to the national environmental health service and recruitment of these posts is ongoing. Funding has also been allocated in budget 2027 for a whole-time equivalent increase to enforce upcoming nicotine and single-use vape legislation.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ShaneMoynihan" eId="spk_41">
            <from>Deputy Shane Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_79">I thank the Minister of State for that additional data. I welcome the fact that the environmental health service of the HSE is going to be expanded to deal with this. This is right given the expanded regulations that will be in place following the commencement of the Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) (Amendment) Act 2026. I will make one general point, which is that we are looking at almost 6,000 licences granted nationally for retailers of e-cigarettes, vapes and cigarettes but the test product inspections make up only 230 of that. The rate of inspection will need to go significantly higher, to more like 1,000 over the coming year, to really get the message across to those people who would sell products to those under 18, display them incorrectly or sell flavours they are not allowed to sell that the law will not tolerate it whatsoever. Vapes are ostensibly nicotine replacement products but are being used as a bridge into more serious drugs and drugs that cause more harm to young people as well, which is why we need to really snap it out at source. I will also raise the proliferation of these shops with the Minister for housing later on today. I know the Minister for Health has expressed her support for that initiative.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_42" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_80">We have to compliment the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, for the significant progress that has been made to reduce the appeal and the availability of vapes and nicotine products to young people with significant legislation involving a licensing system, a ban on sale from vending machines and pop-up shops, a ban on single use vapes and regulations on flavours, packaging, display and advertising. As a result, Ireland will now have one of the strongest regimes for these products in the EU. While Ireland is moving ahead, EU-wide law would be the most effective approach. A proposal for a revised EU tobacco products directive is expected before the end of the year. I agree with the Deputy's sentiment in relation to the amount of vape shops that have popped up all over the country. However, I welcome the fact that I saw a notice in the shop window of Dealz stating that it would no longer sell these products so obviously the legislation and the enforcement are starting to work. I will discuss the Deputy's comments with the Minister of State.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_11">
          <heading>Mental Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#ClaireKerrane" to="#Health" eId="pq_12">
            <p eId="para_81">12. <b>Deputy Claire Kerrane</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> further to Parliamentary Question No. 70847/26, the efforts that are being made to fill a psychology post in the mental health service in Ballinasloe. [82066/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#ClaireKerrane" eId="spk_43">
            <from>Deputy Claire Kerrane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_82">I want to ask the Minister of State about a psychology post that has been vacant in Ballinasloe since May 2023. Will she provide with an update in relation to that post for mental health services in Ballinasloe?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_44" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_83">As Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, I am aware of the key role that psychologists play in supporting people with mental health difficulties. They are critical in supporting the delivery of an incredibly wide range of services for individuals, groups, their families and their community. They play a significant part in the multidisciplinary team approach we are taking to support people. This day last week, I travelled to Galway Bay Hotel to address the Psychological Society of Ireland conference where over 600 delegates gathered in Galway for over three days. It was an excellent conference. </p>
            <p eId="para_84"> Delivery of health services, including mental health posts, remains the responsibility of the relevant HSE region, which in this case is HSE West and North West. As the Deputy is aware, the HSE has introduced measures to control pay expenditure in response to its financial position. Recruitment decisions in HSE West and North West, as with the wider HSE, must align with national pay and staffing controls. The Deputy is telling me that this post has been vacant since 2023. In the meantime, interim arrangements have been implemented to support service delivery for this post by the HSE. Psychology input is currently being provided on a one day per week basis - 0.2 of a whole-time equivalent - to support priority clinical needs and waiting list management. In addition, psychology services are being supported through cross-cover arrangements from psychologists working within the wider service. I know this is not ideal but there is a recognition that the post has not been filled for quite some time. It is important to point out that regions now have accountability for managing their budgets. This includes looking at their spending on agency, making savings and reinvesting those savings in these vital posts in our core community teams.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ClaireKerrane" eId="spk_45">
            <from>Deputy Claire Kerrane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_85">We really need a psychologist in the mental health services in Ballinasloe, which I think is next to Darndale on the Pobal index in terms of the levels of deprivation. It is a town with very many needs and challenges and we need a psychologist within the mental health service. The Minister of State might check as my information is that there is a psychologist every second week. There are almost 50 people on the waiting list. There is a long history in terms of mental health in Ballinasloe. The Minister of State will be aware of St. Brigid’s Hospital, which was the mental health hospital that was there for a very long time. The posts in mental health and psychology are really important. We are also without a child and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS, service in Ballinasloe, which has seen young people having to travel to Roscommon town. Many of them are not able to do that and the schools have told us that themselves. That CAMHS service for young people is also missing. We really do need to beef up the mental health services in Ballinasloe. It is a very large town, there are needs there and there is a waiting list. I ask the Minister of State to look at this post ahead of the HSE budget plan that is coming.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_46" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_86">I will certainly take a look at the Ballinasloe region on the back of what the Deputy raised. Over budgets 2026 and 2027, I have secured 580 new whole-time equivalent posts for priority developments in mental health across the whole country.</p>
            <p eId="para_87">I expect these posts to be prioritised and recruited by the regions. I am clawing back any funding unspent on these posts for 2026, holding that money at the centre of the HSE, along with the new posts for 2027, and only releasing it to the regions when the posts are filled, which is very important.</p>
            <p eId="para_88"> I also want to touch on one other thing which may help some of the Deputy's constituents. Talk therapies are becoming a core component of mental health service provision across all levels of care. In September of last year, I launched, for the very first time, free counselling for men. I am absolutely delighted to say today, as we will be celebrating Movember later on in the day, that over 10,000 men have now accessed these supports for the very first time at <i>yourmentalhealth.ie/men</i>. These supports are free and there are no waiting lists. They have been a huge success. It is not the answer to the Deputy's issue, but at the same time it might help some of her constituents.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ClaireKerrane" eId="spk_47">
            <from>Deputy Claire Kerrane<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_89">I thank the Aire Stáit. I appreciate her agreeing to look at that vacant post in Ballinasloe. I ask that she would look at it ahead of the service plan for the HSE. It is a vacancy that needs to be filled. Will she look at the waiting list and the level of need that is there? Psychology is so important because, as the Minister of State said, it is for people in mental health difficulty. When someone is in mental health difficulty they need to see a professional and speak to them today or tomorrow.</p>
            <p eId="para_90"> Yesterday, I had to contact a mother of a 12-year-old in Roscommon and tell her that the reply from the HSE is that her 12-year-old will see a psychologist in four years because of the primary care waiting list. He will be turning 13 soon and he will not see that psychologist until he is closer to 17. It is really hard to go back to a mother and say that. Where these posts are vacant, we need to see why they are vacant and we need to make every effort possible to fill them. They are absolutely critical for our children, our young people and our adults who are suffering. When it is a mental health difficulty the support is needed now, not in four years.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_48" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_91">I appreciate what the Deputy said. While I cannot speak to any individual case we do have other supports in that particular area. I have funded family resource centres and we also have a very good Jigsaw team in that area. We also have one of the CAMHS Connect hubs in the Roscommon area, which is to cover a huge catchment area. I am really disappointed to hear about somebody being told they would potentially have to wait 48 months, which is simply unacceptable to me and to the Minister for a young child.</p>
            <p eId="para_92"> I want to touch on the new crisis resolution service for adults which is now up and running. It has demonstrated significant reductions in mental health related emergency department presentations. For example, there has been a reduction of 18% in University Hospital Galway. I also give a shout out to the Solace café in Galway. It was the first one that I opened in 2021. It is immediately opposite the hospital and it does phenomenal work there four or five days a week - in the evening especially - to support people. I will look at that Ballinasloe post for the Deputy.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JohnPaulOShea" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_49">
            <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy John Paul O'Shea)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_93">With the permission of the House we will revert to Question No. 10 from Deputy Marie Sherlock.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_12">
          <heading>Medical Cards<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#MarieSherlock" to="#Health" eId="pq_10">
            <p eId="para_94">10. <b>Deputy Marie Sherlock</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> whether all routine blood tests, recommended by a GP, are covered by the General Medical Services, GMS, scheme; if she is aware of a situation where private primary care network providers are in some cases charging patients for routine blood tests; the recourse a medical card holder has in these situations; the way in which the primary care reimbursement service is responding to the situation; and if the strategic review on general practice will contain clear recommendations for a new GMS contract which will ensure that all necessary tests and treatments are not charged. [82078/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_50">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_95">As the Minister will know, there are 1.5 million people who are in receipt of the medical card. They are obviously entitled to it because of their means. I am looking for a very clear statement from the Minister as to the treatment of blood tests by GPs. I have situations where patients who are on the medical card come to me and they are charged €35, others are charged €10 and some are not charged at all. We need to hear a clear and unequivocal statement from the Minister as to what the precise arrangements are under the GMS scheme.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_51" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_96">I thank Deputy Sherlock. Under the terms of the GMS contract, GPs are required to provide medical card and GP visit card holders with "all proper and necessary treatment of a kind usually undertaken by a general practitioner". Cardholders should not be charged for services falling within the scope of that contractual obligation. Whether a blood test is clinically necessary to support the diagnosis, monitoring or treatment of a patient is a matter for the treating GP, having regard to the individual person's circumstances. Where the taking of a blood sample is clinically necessary and falls within the services required to be provided under the GMS contract, there is no provision for that patient to be charged for that service.</p>
            <p eId="para_97"> I am aware there has been a difference of interpretation between the Department and the HSE, on the one hand, and the Irish Medical Organisation, IMO, on the other, regarding the extent to which the taking of blood samples forms part of a GP’s obligations under the existing GMS contract, but that is a different thing. I am also aware of reports that charges have been applied, as the Deputy said, to some GMS patients for this service. Where a medical card or GP visit cardholder believes that they have been incorrectly charged for a service that should have been provided under the GMS contract, they should raise that matter with their local health office. Local management can then engage with the GP concerned and investigate the circumstances of the complaint. Where it is established that a charge was incorrectly applied, arrangements may be made for the patient to be refunded, as appropriate.</p>
            <p eId="para_98"> More broadly, the strategic review of general practice is examining the range of issues affecting the future development of general practice and will help map the path towards the Sláintecare objective of universal GP care. It will also inform the future contractual framework for general practice and any necessary reforms. I consider it important that any future contractual arrangements support greater clarity for patients and GPs on the services to be provided under the contract, including the appropriate provision of phlebotomy services. As I stated, the Department's position is clear in that regard, as is mine. These issues will, however, need to be further addressed in the context of future contractual engagement with general practice.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_52">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_99">I thank the Minister for that very clear statement. I have two cases of an 82-year-old woman and a 76-year-old man, who are both solely reliant on the State pension, so means are very tight. To be asked to pay for a blood test in the course of their care by the GP is simply not acceptable. The critical thing here is the recourse to the HSE office. I pay tribute to the number of HSE workers, particularly in Dublin North-Central and Dublin North-East, who do very good work when it is reported to them. They follow up with the GP. However, often it is the case that when people do report to the HSE then they are worried about the relationship between themselves and their doctor. In some ways it should not fall to the person to have to report their GP to the HSE. I ask for a clear and unambiguous media or social media campaign from the Department of Health stating explicitly what the arrangements should be. Otherwise, it will go under the radar, there will be people who will not report to the HSE and this practice will continue.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_53" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_100">I hear what the Deputy is saying. I do not want to suggest that all GPs are behaving in this way either. I know the Deputy is not suggesting that either. Where something goes wrong in any context, it is important that there is a reporting channel. I cannot say it more clearly. Routine phlebotomy services, the taking of blood samples for testing, are covered under the GMS contract. That is the way it is. Blood tests undertaken in the context of the GP chronic disease management programme are covered by the CDM fees paid to GPs. Whether a blood test is clinically necessary to support the diagnosis, monitoring or treatment of a patient is a matter for the treating GP, having regard to their circumstances. Obviously, taking a blood sample in those circumstances is clinically necessary and it falls within the contract. I do not know what different way to say it to make it clear. While there has been that difference of opinion in certain circumstances, we will take that up in the next negotiation arising from the strategic review of GP care. I hear what the Deputy is saying and the two examples she has raised. I cannot say it any more clearly than on the floor of the Dáil.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_54">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_101">I thank the Minister. What I would request is that within the Department of Health's advertising budget that some initiative is taken in that regard.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_55" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_102">There is no advertising budget.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_56">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_103">I ask that a direction be given to the HSE. I have one example of a man being charged €35 and because he refused to pay the bloods were not taken. He arrived into his GP practice the following week and there was a sign up saying the cost was €35 for private patients and €25 for medical card patients. That is how blatant it is. To be clear, there are lots of GPs who do not change at all.</p>
            <p eId="para_104"> The other key issue here is when we are going to see the strategic review of GP care. It has been long promised and is long delayed. We need to see it because there are huge issues. As the Minister knows, I have been speaking for a long time since I came into the role as spokesperson on health about the need to expand GP coverage across the country. We need to see that review. When is that going to happen?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_57" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_105">To be clear, the strategic review will not include specific clinical matters or individual contractual matters. I have not received the report yet. I understood it would be this year. I will come back to the Deputy later in the day on that.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_13">
          <heading>Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#MarieSherlock" to="#Health" eId="pq_53">
            <p eId="para_106">53. <b>Deputy Marie Sherlock</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> the share of general practice access to community diagnostics, GPACD, referrals that go to publicly owned diagnostic service providers. [82072/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_58">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_107">I did not expect that we would get to this question. This relates to the excellent general practice access to community diagnostics scheme, which was initiated as part of the enhanced community care in 2019. This allows GPs to refer patients who come in with particular issues to MRIs, X-rays or CT scans. What cutbacks, if any, are proposed by the HSE on that scheme at the moment? I also ask about public diagnostics because, as I understand it, they are solely referred to third-party medical imaging providers.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_59" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_108">I do not have a brief but there are some things that are related to it. Access to community diagnostics is very important and effective. However, we need to be careful that there are not multiple referrals for the same thing from different sources. One of the most important things in that regard is the electronic health record and how we can track patients to ensure they are getting the services they need quickly and are not on multiple waiting lists. We see that in other areas. We want access as quickly as possible to identify issues where they arise. From visiting different places, I fear that some of our diagnostic centres are becoming overwhelmed with repeat referrals from different places for the same patient. We have to sort that out and the electronic record is a big part of that. This week I secured Cabinet approval to move to the next stage of electronic health records. We need to careful that we are not extending waiting times by having multiple referrals for the same person.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_60">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_109">I understand a report commissioned by the Minister earlier this year has been sitting in the Department of Health since the summer regarding the cost of third-party diagnostic imaging providers and the types of referrals. Will she publish that? What is contained in the report? Based on what I hear from GPs, I understand that somebody who presents with any sort of issue with a knee, hip or shoulder in circumstances where there are grounds to believe that there is a specific orthopaedic or other issue can at least get the diagnostic as it will allow the GP to advocate on behalf of their patient that there is a specific issue that an orthopaedic surgeon or another consultant might be able to address as opposed to having to wait for two years before getting the diagnostic, during which time the patient will be walking around not sure whether there is an issue or not.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_61" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_110">That is the purpose of it and that is why we have also extended it to allow physiotherapists to be able to refer in that way. In order to enable the quickest access, we need to make sure there are not multiple referrals for any patient, as that is leading to delays.</p>
            <p eId="para_111"> I do not believe I have received that report, but the Deputy will forgive me because I am doing this from memory. Sometimes I might have seen something six weeks ago and it is not in the front of my mind. I do not believe I have seen that report, but I will correct the record of the House if I have.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_62">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_112">I look forward to that report. I want to understand whether cutbacks to that scheme are planned. I am concerned that we might make the waiting list longer if that scheme were to be cut back in any shape or form. Critically - this is the fundamental question here - we need to understand if any public capacity that GPs can refer to has been developed since 2019. As I understand it, under the scheme they can only refer to third-party medical diagnostic providers. I seek clarification on that. Ultimately, we end up with a really good referral scheme with a lot of money being wasted going into the hands of third-party providers when the State needs to be developing that capacity itself. I appreciate that there are enormous resource constraints in every hospital and the hospitals need to deal with their own demand when people present to or are admitted into hospitals. We need to make sure there is a pathway from the GP into public diagnostics as opposed to private.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_63" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_113">I could not agree more which is why I am constantly talking about the need to use all the CT, MRI and echo machines and everything else. Earlier I gave the example of Tipperary University Hospital which is now doing cardiac diagnostics on Saturdays. We need to use the facilities that are there and make sure we are deploying resources in a way that uses those public resources. I agree completely; I do not want to be referring things to third-party providers. We have a tension between trying to get things done quickly and making sure people get quick access to diagnostics as we implement the public-only consultant contract and all the ancillary elements of that.</p>
            <p eId="para_114"> However, we have diagnostic equipment in the public system that is not being used to its full extent. I can give the recent example of CUH where four CT scanners were available and two of them were operational with a very high number of radiographers and still private capacity is being used. We are not using our public facilities well enough. For example, we need to prioritise staffing for the endoscopy suites in Bantry and Roscommon to make sure they run until 8 p.m., 9 p.m. or 10 p.m. instead of closing earlier in the day. I am completely with the Deputy on using our public facilities better and I am glad to hear that she is with me on that so that we together move forward the reforms that are necessary to use that.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_14">
          <heading>Mental Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#TomBrabazon" to="#Health" eId="pq_15">
            <p eId="para_115">15. <b>Deputy Tom Brabazon</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> whether consideration is being given to reforming the delivery of emergency mental health services to reduce reliance on hospital emergency departments and ensure that individuals experiencing a mental health crisis can access timely and appropriate specialist care. [81697/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#TomBrabazon" eId="spk_64">
            <from>Deputy Tom Brabazon<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_116">Last week a briefing was held in the audiovisual room for the "It's OK not to be OK" campaign. We heard directly from people about what it is like to go looking for help in a mental health crisis and how long they have to wait. In some cases, people are waiting 24 hours in an accident and emergency department before they are seen and that is simply not good enough. If someone goes to an accident and emergency department because they are having suicidal thoughts and are afraid of what they might do, they have done the right thing by asking for help and they should not be left waiting so long to be assessed.</p>
            <p eId="para_117"> Would the Minister of State consider a dedicated mental health emergency department, somewhere people in crisis could go day or night to be assessed directly by a mental health team without first having to wait in a general accident and emergency department, which, as we know, are all clogged up? Cold such a project be piloted in Dublin? In the meantime, what can the Department do to make sure that those who go to an accident and emergency department with a mental health crisis are seen sooner?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_65" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T09:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_118">I thank the Deputy for his question. I commend Theresa Kelly from the "It's OK not to be OK" campaign. The Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, and I met Theresa a couple of weeks ago along with the Deputy and others to discuss this important campaign.</p>
            <p eId="para_119"> The Deputy is correct in saying that emergency departments are not the most appropriate environment for people experiencing a mental health crisis. That is why I, as Minister of State with responsibility for mental health, have prioritised the development and roll-out of community-based alternatives that provide earlier intervention and more appropriate support and reduce the need for people to present to emergency departments.</p>
            <p eId="para_120"> The goals are very clear. We continue to shift services into communities and invest in earlier intervention to make sure more people can access appropriate timely support as close to home as possible. Budget 2027 made further commitments to this area. The €10 million ring-fenced for investment into crisis support and suicide prevention will build on the significant expansion of crisis services over recent years. There are plenty of pathways for people presenting to emergency departments with mental health issues, especially those who may have an enduring mental health condition. A lot of people who may also have addiction issues are presenting as well. That is not often mentioned when I am being asked to deal with people presenting. There are huge issues with people presenting with mental health challenges and addiction to drugs or alcohol, and that has to be factored in as well.</p>
            <p eId="para_121"> We are seeing a huge expansion to the likes of the Solace Cafés. Six Solace Cafés are open across the country and there is funding for three more this year. Funding has been allocated for six new Solace Cafés next year in Wexford, north Tipperary, Carlow, Louth, mid-west Dublin and Dublin's north inner city, as an alternative to having to present to an emergency department. These are open out of hours from 6 p.m. until about 10 p.m. They support people with enduring mental health conditions. That is one area where we are making progress.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#TomBrabazon" eId="spk_66">
            <from>Deputy Tom Brabazon<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_122">I warmly welcome the provision of the two Solas Cafés in Dublin, in particular. It is a wonderful pilot that the Minister is rolling out. There is some concern that they should be open 24-7 rather than on a 9-to-5 basis. I wonder if the Minister of State can make a commitment on that basis.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_67" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_123">There is absolutely no way I can give the Deputy the commitment to open a Solas crisis café 24-7. We have lots of support during the day to support people. The focus has been on the response out of hours. Where I can give a commitment is in relation to suicide crisis assessment nurses, SCAN, services. We are investing heavily in a range of community-based alternatives to emergency departments, including crisis resolution teams, as I said, and the suicide crisis assessment nurses services. As of budget 2027, next year, every single region in the country will have access to SCAN nurses. We will have over 65 SCAN nurses the length and breadth in the country. They work very closely with primary care and GPs. They are the people on the ground who provide huge supports to people who are in mental health distress. That is really important. Since we opened the Solas Café in Galway, for example, we have seen an 18% reduction in presentations to the emergency department. Since we opened the Solace Café in Limerick only 12 months ago, we have seen a 13% reduction in attendance at the emergency department. What we want to do is continue to give people options other than just having to present at an emergency department.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#TomBrabazon" eId="spk_68">
            <from>Deputy Tom Brabazon<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_124">I fully appreciate the Minister of State's passion and commitment to this whole area and the work she has done since she has been appointed to the role of Minister of State with responsibility for mental health. The Solace Cafés are really warmly welcomed. Can we just keep an open mind on their opening times? Flexibility in responding to mental health crises is key to proper provision.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_69" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_125">I just want to explain what a Solas Café is. It is not just some place people drop in to have a cup of tea and a chat. They are clinically-led but they include peer support and lived experience as well. We are using facilities that are not being used otherwise. In a crisis café, for example, we will be using a premises that is not otherwise used out of hours. We are making best use of our infrastructure. We are not building new facilities. When one team is finished in a premises, we can use it out of hours, making best use of our budget. It is really important.</p>
            <p eId="para_126"> The Deputy's first question was on whether we could have stand-alone emergency departments for mental health. We are seeing some of that already happening. A couple of months ago, I visited Portlaoise hospital in the midlands. It has a dedicated desk specifically for people who are presenting with mental health challenges. However, it has an approved centre and it has a department of psychiatry there and that is not always possible with all our acute hospitals. It is very innovative and I am very interested in what it is doing.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_15">
          <heading>Health Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#SeanOFearghaillFF" to="#Health" eId="pq_43">
            <p eId="para_127">43. <b>Deputy Seán Ó Fearghaíl</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> the way in which she is expanding GP access to community diagnostics. [81950/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_70">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_128">As the Minister knows - I heard her comments to Deputy Sherlock already this morning in relation to community diagnostics - this is a hugely important part of delivering Sláintecare. It is also a hugely important part of creating pathways in the community away from the emergency rooms of our acute hospitals, which are already overcrowded and where care is very expensive. I would appreciate if the Minister could give me an update on that, please.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_71" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_129">I am sorry; I do not have the written response to that question. The Deputy referred to the earlier question on community diagnostics. We do not have the brief for questions that far ahead. People have not come to the Chamber to take their questions. I will have to give that response to the Deputy after.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_72">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_130">I accept that. I apologise if we have jumped ahead.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_73" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_131">It is no problem at all. We generally have the replies; it is just that nobody has turned up this morning so we do not have it.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MartinDaly" eId="spk_74">
            <from>Deputy Martin Daly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_132">I will just put on the record one issue I have in relation to this which might be of interest regarding the delivery of integrated care. We have a very successful primary care centre in Tuam in County Galway, which serves east Galway and Roscommon, and a diagnostic centre there run by the HSE, which is for ultrasound scanning and plain films. For some reason, the wait times for plain X-rays started to extend to up to three months. What is more inexplicable, however, is that the ultrasound scan service was unilaterally cancelled without any notice to general practitioners in the area who were referring from places like Roscommon, Ballygar, Loughrea and Portumna to that service in Tuam. The reason given was that there was a lack of a half-time clerical staff to carry out their duties. A whole service in the community has collapsed but what is worse is that patients have been referred into that centre seeking a possible diagnosis and the GPs have not been told that the service was ended. The only way they find out is if their patients come back to them and tell them they did not get that scan in Tuam Primary Care Centre. Now, they are being redirected into the hospital through emergency rooms if the GP believes they need an urgent scan.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_75" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_133">I thank the Deputy.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_16">
          <heading>Health Screening Programmes<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#CathalCrowe" to="#Health" eId="pq_28">
            <p eId="para_134">28. <b>Deputy Cathal Crowe</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> her plans for a fully funded DEXA screening programme for women over 50, given that women face an increased risk of osteoporosis after menopause yet loss of bone density often goes undetected until a fracture occurs; and if she agrees that DEXA scans can identify low bone density early and help guide treatment to reduce fracture risk and protect mobility and independence. [76099/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#CathalCrowe" eId="spk_76">
            <from>Deputy Cathal Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_135">I wish to ask the Minister her plans for a fully funded DEXA screening programme for women over 50, given that women face an increased risk of osteoporosis after menopause yet loss of bone density often goes undetected until a fracture occurs. Does she agrees that DEXA scans can identify low bone density early and help guide treatment to reduce fracture risk and protect mobility and independence?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_77" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_136">As Minister for Health, I am committed to enhancing Ireland's population screening programmes. They are a vital component of our health services. The consideration of any proposed changes to the screening programmes is facilitated through evidence-driven protocols that are well established.</p>
            <p eId="para_137"> The national screening advisory committee, NSAC, is the expert group that considers proposed changes to Ireland's screening programmes. It assesses the evidence in a robust and transparent manner and against internationally accepted criteria before making recommendations to me, as Minister. It is, of course, important, and I know the Deputy will agree, that we have rigorous processes in place to ensure our screening programmes are effective, quality-assured, validated and operating to safe standards and also that the benefits outweigh the harms.</p>
            <p eId="para_138"> In its 2025 call for submissions, NSAC did receive a proposal related to bone screening. After consideration of the evidence, it concluded that the ongoing monitoring of risk factors, diagnosis and treatment for bone health issues, including osteoporosis, should be facilitated through existing primary care services.</p>
            <p eId="para_139"> The GP access to diagnostics scheme is available for referrals by GPs to the full adult population, aged over 16 years, delivering community-based radiology scans, including DEXA scans, in approved locations. The scheme provides GPs with access to a defined list or scope of examinations, with the clinical examination scope reviewed and updated to make sure it is an effective service.</p>
            <p eId="para_140"> What I am saying is that it is already possible through the GP scheme and there is access. NSAC, the evidence-based authority, is not recommending a different screening programme as such but, rather, to continue through primary care facilities.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#CathalCrowe" eId="spk_78">
            <from>Deputy Cathal Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_141">I guess prevention is the best cure here. My late grandmother had a very bad fracture in her 80s. It is not just the fracture. It is what happens thereafter with the deterioration of health. Unfortunately, it has very negative outcomes for a lot of women. Sometimes, people move through life in ignorant bliss. They do not realise that their bones may not be as dense as they once thought. They may have osteoporosis. It may be undiagnosed or they may have been blindly ignoring medical advice along the way. For many reasons, the more that bone density can be scanned <i>vis-à-vis</i> DEXA scanning is good. I welcome the Minister's response. It is positive.</p>
            <p eId="para_142"> What is the regional output of this? Are there parts of the country where there is a very good scanning programme? Are there plans to beef that up on a more regional basis?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_79" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_143">I cannot speak to the difference regionally today although I will try to find that for the Deputy. What I can say to him is that last year, in 2025, almost 250,000 community-based radiology diagnostic scans were provided. This year, we have had 146,000 provided. Again, it is on referral by GP. Of course, GPs will be aware of the particular risk factors of being a woman over 50 in the context of osteoporosis and bone density. I will try to get a regional breakdown for the Deputy. I am not sure if I can separate it by DEXA scan, but I will try.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#CathalCrowe" eId="spk_80">
            <from>Deputy Cathal Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_144">I am guessing the Minister remembers the ad in the late eighties and nineties: “Them bones, them bones need calcium". I will not sing it but I am sure she can visualise it. There was a major public health campaign during those years to encourage children and particularly older age cohorts to drink milk. It was always the traditional way of building calcium and bone density. However, the consumption of milk has gone way down. I know it is just one aspect. There are many aspects like lifestyle and getting checked out regularly. That ad campaign, however, was so effective that we can all still remember the song 25 or 30 years later. Would the Minister consider a public awareness campaign encouraging people to drink more milk and look at calcium intake to mitigate the onset of osteoporosis later in life, and in particular to target that campaign on female health? Unfortunately, that is where osteoporosis is prevalent. I apologise if I was unprepared for the question to be taken. I should be watching the TV a bit more closely in my office. I had the wrong question in my mind when I came in, so I apologise for any confusion caused.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_81" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_145">It has gone more quickly this morning than we would have expected. Of course, for the rest of the day I will have in my head that, "A child's got more bones than a grown-up's got". It was very effective. I will also say that this is a particular risk factor for women at perimenopause and menopausal age. We are trying to support women in all of those ways. That is another way in which a GP or women's health doctor of whatever kind will identify a particular risk factor for women of that age. I am confident that we have the community diagnostics scheme there too. We will keep it under review with NSAC and its call for submissions. However, the Deputy and I are evidence-based parliamentarians. If the committee says to continue doing it this way, we will take its guidance on that. I hear his point about that really cool ad.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_17">
          <heading>Healthcare Policy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#MarieSherlock" to="#Health" eId="pq_94">
            <p eId="para_146">94. <b>Deputy Marie Sherlock</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> to publish the recommendations of the national vaginal mesh Implant oversight group; and to set a timeline for implementation of the recommendations. [82074/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_82">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_147">I know the Minister feels very strongly about women's health. I am asking about a report that has been sitting in the Department of Health since 2023 from the national vaginal mesh implant oversight group. Vaginal mesh surgery was paused in this country in 2018. The then CMO undertook a review that issued 19 recommendations. A number of years later, the oversight group was established and there is a set of recommendations in the Department that have yet to be actioned. When will that report be published and will the Minister action the recommendations?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_83" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_148">Many patients experience positive outcomes from the use of transvaginal mesh. However, concerns about the safety of those devices have also arisen in many countries. Mesh devices have been associated with significant complications in a minority of women. In these women, those complications are reported to be severe and life-altering. Indeed, I have met women who have had life-altering consequences. In 2018, the CMO asked the HSE to pause all mesh procedures where it was clinically safe to do so. That was pending implementation of the recommendations set out in the CMO report on the use of urogynaecological mesh in surgical procedures. The HSE vaginal mesh implant oversight group provided the Department with a report on the progress made to implement the recommendations and the appropriateness of resuming urogynaecological mesh procedures in February 2025. That is with the chief medical officer and the chief nursing officer. It is an extremely complex issue, but patient safety and patient choice have to be prioritised. It is not acceptable to me that this has remained unresolved for many years. We have on the one hand patients who have had life-altering consequences of this going wrong and very serious safety consideration, but we understand some of the benefits that may be there for women who have had this procedure or may wish for this procedure. I have requested a definitive timeline for when the recommendations will be fully implemented and a decision made. I know the chief medical officer is engaged with this, but I have also asked that all of the involved patient groups be fully engaged with before any decision is announced. I expect this to be resolved in early 2027.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_84">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_149">It is eight years since any vaginal mesh implant surgery has taken place in this country. There was obviously good reason for pausing it at the time. However, it is not acceptable that there has been this delay. We can compare it with other countries that have resumed surgery, particularly the UK, but Ireland still has no surgery taking place. We know there are thousands of women who suffer from either urinary incontinence or pelvic organ prolapse. These are serious, often hidden, conditions and women are often reluctant to present, but when they do they need proper care and treatment. I am heartened to hear there will be a report forthcoming soon, but we need to see that and have a clear timeline on it. If I heard the Minister correctly, it has been with the CMO and chief nursing officer since 2025. We are now coming to the end of 2026 and there are women suffering out there who need a response.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_85" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_150">I accept that. It is very complex. There are two very different views on this and on the benefits and safety. It has been extremely complex. I do not want to speak further than that except to say that I have asked a number of times how it is being assessed and analysed. I expect a resolution to it. It cannot go on, notwithstanding its complexity not just domestically but internationally. It is also important that, whatever the decision based on medical advice is, we talk to people who have been really impacted by this in both directions.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_86">
            <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_151">I acknowledge there has been significant progress in terms of awareness and action with regard to women's health over the past number of years. I know the Minister feels passionately about that. It is not acceptable that women have to travel abroad when there is a clear clinical need for that surgery. That is what is happening right now. I repeat the point that we need to make sure that those actions are carried out. Obviously safety is paramount, but when I talk to patients, patient groups and gynaecologists, they strongly indicate that the pace of progress on this has been far too slow and they need clear guidance and a green light on safe surgery resuming in this country.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" eId="spk_87" as="#Minister_for_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_152">I make the case that is not a universal view. I appreciate the Deputy has spoken to people with a particular view. I know she is not attempting to do it, but neither she nor I are going to determine the outcome of what it is medically. I do not want to assume one thing or another. It is complicated. I will discuss it with the chief medical officer again this week and we will proceed on an evidenced and safe basis.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_18">
          <heading>Hospital Facilities<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#RuairiOmurchu" to="#Health" eId="pq_32">
            <p eId="para_153">32. <b>Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú</b> asked the <b>Minister for Health</b> the reason there is no target opening date for the ten-bed extension to the department of psychiatry in Drogheda; and when the Department expects the extension to be operational. [81897/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#RuairiOmurchu" eId="spk_88">
            <from>Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_154">I ask the Minister of State why there is no target opening date for the ten-bed extension to the department of psychiatry in Crosslanes, Drogheda. When does the Department of Health expect that the extension to be operational? This is something we have been awaiting for a considerable time. I had a parliamentary question answer back that referred to the process and where it falls but, unfortunately, this ten-bed extension is not where it needs to be. We have low coverage of beds in my part of the world for mental health services, so we need this as soon as possible.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_89" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_155">Unfortunately, I am not in a position to give the Deputy an answer to that question because I do not have written replies for the questions that far down the list. I have to put on record that I have been six and a half years in the Department of Health and this is the strangest oral questions session I have ever come across. Of the six initial priority questions there were only four questions submitted. Then questions Nos. 11, 13, 14 and 16 to 25, inclusive, were no-shows. I apologise for not having a response to the Deputy's question but I will endeavour to get one for him later today and come back on that approved centre. I do not have all the details of our capital plans on the tip of my tongue. If he asked me a service-related question I may be in a better position to answer.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RuairiOmurchu" eId="spk_90">
            <from>Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_156">That is okay. I will read a reply from 29 October into the record for clarity. I accept everything the Minister of State says. I did not expect to be in here asking question No. 32. The reply states:</p>
            <p class="indent_1" eId="para_157">The Health Service Executive has been requested to reply directly ... The proposed 10-bed extension at the Department of Psychiatry, Crosslanes, Drogheda is progressing through the HSE Capital Management Framework and is going through the pre tender approval stage. As the project remains subject to the necessary approval requirements, Capital and Estates is not currently in a position to provide a definitive timeline for delivery. Capital and Estates will continue to progress the proposal through the remaining approval stages in line with established capital governance processes.</p>
            <p eId="para_158"> It has taken a long time to get here and a fair amount of that was in limbo. As much as we want to see as much community care as possible, the fact is there are people who need this. I have spoken to the Minister of State before and will ask a more general question.</p>
            <p eId="para_159">Additional authorised officers are being employed. Are we going to look at the role and remit of authorised officers, because I believe it is different in a number of other jurisdictions, where they may have a greater level of power? I am talking about those specific cases where people do not want help but need it and are causing huge hassle to themselves and others and even putting themselves in huge danger. I have brought up some issues like this with the Minister previously but, unfortunately, I have even more.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#CathalCrowe" eId="spk_91">
            <from>Deputy Cathal Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_160">I support what Deputy Ó Murchú has said. This is important when psychiatric units are being planned - in this case, a 12-bed unit. What I have seen in the past is that different types of psychiatric care are put together and that does not always work. The example I would give is drug-induced psychosis and postpartum psychosis, which are chalk and cheese, yet when women are admitted for postpartum psychosis, which, it needs to be put on record, is very different from postnatal depression, they are put in an acute unit for care alongside people who have drug-induced psychosis. They are chalk and cheese, and that is rather demeaning to them. These new units are incredible. They are fantastic. We need more of them, but we just need a little bit of definition about what care needs are provided within them and whether we are mixing people who have totally polarised mental health needs within that realm.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_92" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_161">There were a lot of questions. A total of €470 million in capital funding has been secured, working the Minister here, as part of the national development plan out to 2030 in relation to infrastructure for mental health. Six priority sites will see new approved centres for departments of psychiatry constructed. Within that, for the first time ever, there are plans to develop the new mother and baby unit - we do not have one anywhere in the country, north or south - on the St. Vincent's site to support mothers who have given birth and who might have an enduring mental health condition so that they will not be separated from their babies.</p>
            <p eId="para_162"> In relation to Deputy Ó Murchú's question about authorised officers, that relates to the Mental Health Act, the implementation phase of which we are going through at present. We currently have 126 authorised officers in the country working, I assume, with the HSE. A lot of work is under way with the Mental Health Commission. While 33% of all cases are involuntarily detained by the Garda, it will no longer be doing that when the plan is enacted. Therefore, I expect we will need to have somewhere close to 450 or 500 authorised officers. We will certainly need full-time authorised officers in the larger cities and towns.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RuairiOmurchu" eId="spk_93">
            <from>Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_163">I agree there is obviously a need for people who are working specifically in this field because it is a huge issue. We probably need to review the role. Sometimes the engagement of other clinicians can create a difficulty, whereas all you are trying to do is get somebody in front of a clinical psychiatrist or whatever. Even so, I get it; we need to protect people's freedom.</p>
            <p eId="para_164"> Under the Mental Health Act that is still in operation and the one that is to come in, there is a need for guidelines to be issued. I know the HSE will complain that it attempted to engage with GPs and very few engaged with it, but we need to find the means. The same goes for the Garda. In many cases, people know that gardaí will get a GP, the GP will come in, and if the person can present themselves as reasonable for a couple of minutes, never mind what they have done before or will do after, they may not be given the help they should get. I am not sure everyone is <i>au fait</i> with the legislation, even as it exists.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_94" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_165">Everybody will not have to be <i>au fait</i> with the legislation until it is implemented. It is a huge body of work to implement it, but the Deputy must remember that the Act will be very clear. In the case of involuntary detention, especially of somebody who does not capacity to make a decision for themselves, the Act is crystal clear. It will be the consultant psychiatrist who will make the ultimate decision. It will not be the authorised officer or the GP. They will make the referral but the decision on whether a person is involuntarily detained, with or without capacity, will be made by the psychiatrist and the Act is very clear on that. We spent a huge amount of time discussing it. We have to leave those decisions to people who are qualified to make them. I have no qualification to determine whether a person will be involuntarily or voluntarily detained, with or without capacity. Professional psychiatrists have trained for eight or nine years to be able to make this decision.</p>
            <p eId="para_166"> Sometimes it can be lost in translation, but a person with a mental health disorder can be very distressed and very upset, but they are also very ill and we have to remember that.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_4">
            <i> Questions Nos. 8, 9, 11, 13, 14, 16 to 27, inclusive, 29 to 31, inclusive, 33 to 42, inclusive, 44 to 52, inclusive, 54 to 93, inclusive, and 95 to 140, inclusive, taken with Written Answers.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_19">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ar Sonraíodh Uain Dóibh - Priority Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_20">
          <heading>Homeless Persons Supports<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#EoinOBroin" to="#Housing" eId="pq_141">
            <p eId="para_167">141. <b>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> the reason for the delay implementing the recommendations of the interim report on Mortality in the Single Homeless Population 2020 (details supplied). [82392/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_95">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_168">I ask the Minister to set out for the House the reasons for the long delay in the implementation of the life-saving recommendations of the<i>
							</i>interim report on Mortality in the Single Homeless Population 2020 by Dr. Austin O'Carroll, published in 2021 and supported both by the Minister's Department and the Department of Health.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage" eId="spk_96">
            <from>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage (Deputy James Browne)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_169">I thank the Deputy for what is an important question in relation to the implementation of the recommendations of the interim report on Mortality in the Single Homeless Population 2020.</p>
            <p eId="para_170"> The death of any person in emergency accommodation or rough sleeping is an absolute tragedy no matter the circumstances. The report Dr. O'Carroll completed for the Dublin Region Homeless Executive, DRHE, analysed the available data concerning deaths in homeless services for 2020 to identify learning for homeless and health services that could help tailor the provision of care for homeless people.</p>
            <p eId="para_171"> Dr. O'Carroll’s report makes recommendations in the area of data analysis and collection, learning from death in homelessness, seeking to reduce the mortality of people experiencing homelessness, and research with regard to data. I can confirm the Department of Health has engaged with the Health Research Board, HRB, to collect data on all deaths which occur among people who are homeless nationally to address the need to improve understanding of premature mortality and provide more complete and accurate national data to inform policy.</p>
            <p eId="para_172"> In terms of learning, the report makes a recommendation for the development of a critical incident framework between the DRHE and the HSE and I can confirm that in Dublin, policy and procedures for the review of service provision following a death in homeless services is being established by the HSE and the DRHE.</p>
            <p eId="para_173"> The report also notes the value of the housing first model in reducing long-term homelessness. Housing first is a key policy response to reduce homelessness, especially for the most vulnerable individuals, and a key initiative under Delivering Homes, Building Communities is the further expansion of the housing first programme to create 2,000 tenancies to help eliminate long-term homelessness. The report highlights the importance of interagency co-operation in providing homeless and health supports and a statutory management group exists for each regional forum which is compromised of representatives from the relevant housing authorities and the HSE.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_97">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_174">In 2022, the last year for which we have full data, 124 people experiencing homelessness lost their lives. These are people who live at the very tough intersection of chronic homelessness, addiction, mental ill-health and, in many cases, State neglect. What is really important about Dr. O'Carroll's report is that he set out a series of recommendations, the purpose of which was to learn from each of those tragedies to improve the services provided for people experiencing homelessness and reduce those deaths. These are not accidents or events of nature; they are utterly preventable deaths. What I find shocking is that five years on, somewhere in the region of 600 people will have died in that period and the key recommendation for mandatory reporting, for critical incident reviews after each death and for a five-year overarching review have not been implemented. If they had, lives would have been saved. Can the Minister give the House some reassurance that a greater level of urgency from his Department and the Department of Health will be introduced so that these recommendations can be implemented and lives can be saved?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_98" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_175">Since I became Minister for housing, one of the things I have been trying to push is that we cannot treat people in homelessness or emergency accommodation as a homogeneous group. Sometimes that is how they are perceived. Obviously, the vast majority of people who are in homelessness is as a result of the housing crisis. Nonetheless, we have a significant number of people who are in emergency accommodation, hostels or rough sleeping who have additional needs, whether addiction, mental health or otherwise. We have to ensure we focus on the needs of that group of people and that they are not lost in the broader housing situation. I have tried to bring a focus on that and we have had a number of meetings with the health services at the Cabinet committee on housing to drive that message. The HSE is, in fairness, engaging significantly with the Department of housing. I have to give credit to the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. I get the Deputy’s point and we are keen to work on that.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_99">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_176">Antonia Edgeworth was a young woman well-known in Dún Laoghaire where she grew up and worked. She was also among Dublin city centre's homeless population. She was found dead in a tent on Henry Street only a matter of weeks ago. I extend my condolences to her family and friends. We have to ask the question: if the recommendations of Dr. O'Carroll, a GP with decades of experience working with exactly the cohort of people the Minister is talking about, those with the most chronic and complex needs within our homeless population, had been implemented, would Antonia have received the interventions she required to save her life?</p>
            <p eId="para_177"> I urge the Minister, given he has only been in position for two years, to engage with this issue with an even greater level of urgency. I have asked the Oireachtas housing committee to invite the Minister, his officials, and the Minister for Health and her officials to attend the committee early next year to discuss this because this is a group of people who too often get ignored in the debates about homelessness. I ask the Minister to come back to us early in the new year to set out when we are going to have mandatory reporting, critical incident reviews and that crucial five-year review through the Minister’s co-ordination with colleagues in the Department and the Minister of Health.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_100" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_178">I share the Deputy’s concerns that within the broader housing challenges, a cohort of very vulnerable people are overlooked. We have always had these vulnerable people and we have to ensure they are getting the supports they need, whether through housing first, particular healthcare from the HSE or whatever those supports may be. We must catch people before they get into that particular situation and have those particular supports ready for them. I am happy to engage with the Deputy on this. It is a concern of mine too. I have been acting on that concern with the Minister for Health but I agree we need to go further.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_21">
          <heading>Housing Provision<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#RoryHearne" to="#Housing" eId="pq_142">
            <p eId="para_179">142. <b>Deputy Rory Hearne</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> his plans to increase the number of affordable purchase homes built directly by the State. [82002/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_101">
            <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_180">I ask the Minister to outline how the Government is providing affordable homes for the locked-out generation. Yesterday we saw CSO figures showing that the median price for a home is now €400,000 nationally, 28% above Celtic tiger levels. The Government's delivery of local authority direct affordable housing is absolutely pathetic and inadequate. What is it going to do to make a step-change in the delivery of affordable homes so that young people in this country can actually affordably buy a home of their own?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_102" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_181">I thank the Deputy for his question. We have been making a number of step-changes. Housing delivery is up. We are building at the fastest pace in Europe. Planning permissions are up as are commencements. We are at the highest number of first-time mortgage drawdowns since 2007. Home ownership is rising again. However, we have an awful lot more to do. The starter homes programme is part of the Government’s housing action plan. Delivering Homes, Building Communities is supporting affordable homes through many mechanisms such as the first-home scheme, the local authority starter homes for purchase scheme, and the Revenue help-to-buy scheme. By placing home ownership at the centre of the Government's housing policy, these schemes are helping to bridge the affordability gap to home ownership by providing shared-equity mortgages backed by the State and participating high-street banks, and helping first-time buyers with their deposits in the form an income tax rebate of up to €35,000. This was recently increased in the budget.</p>
            <p eId="para_182"> Under the housing action plan, which reinforces and expands the range of existing affordable housing measures being implemented by the Government for affordable purchase and cost rental, the starter-homes programme aims to deliver an average of 15,000 housing supports annually to 2030, and to back up this level of ambition, total Exchequer capital investment in the starter home programme in 2025 was just over €1 billion, with a further €1.2 billion available this year. The huge level of investment underpinned more than 18,000 affordable supports in the full year of 2025. I expect a similarly high level of support for this year and next year.</p>
            <p eId="para_183"> Under the affordable housing fund alone, which is available to all local authorities to drive the delivery of new starter homes for purchase and for rent in the local area, 7,000 starter purchase homes have been supported across 28 local authorities.</p>
            <p eId="para_184">As promised in the new housing plan, we are working to ensure starter homes for purchase are available everywhere they are needed, and this year alone, new schemes have been approved in five local authorities that have not previously had starter homes for purchase schemes, namely, Roscommon, Cavan, Donegal, Tipperary and Kerry. State investment for starter homes from the purchase fund alone is over €600 million so far. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_103">
            <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_185">The Minister's commitment to home ownership is in complete contrast to what he is doing to young people and generations who are trying to afford the rents. We have also seen rents reaching record levels. In terms of affordability and starter homes, these figures are all spin. How many of those that are being delivered are genuinely affordable homes that people can buy? The figures show that in the first six months of the year, just 565 of the almost 5,000 starter homes, or just 12% of the so-called starter homes, are actually affordable homes people can buy. Approximately 37% of what are classified as starter homes are from the vacant property and refurbishment grants, a significant portion of which we know are going to landlords, multiple property owners. There is spin within the figures. It is not actually directly delivering affordable homes people can buy. It is about subsidising the market. In the capital city, Dublin City Council has built just 80 affordable purchase homes in the last 18 months. How is that supposed to deliver affordable homes for a generation locked out in Dublin city? </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_104" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_186">As the Deputy will have seen this week, we now have the highest number of first-time mortgage drawdowns since 2007. He will have seen the other statistics as well, of course, on the increases in the granting of planning permission, commencements and delivery. This is all getting keys into people's hands on a basis of affordability. If people need a social home or an affordable home, there are mechanisms for them to get one. It might be affordable purchase, or it may also be the first home scheme, help to buy or any of the other schemes that are there to help people. People can also buy their own home privately. Home ownership, as I said, is actually going up again. I am the first to acknowledge we have an awful lot more to do, but there is now significant momentum behind housing delivery and getting into solving the housing challenges across the country. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_105">
            <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_187">I come back to the increase in number of first-time buyers drawing down. A significant proportion of those who are buying homes are on quite high incomes. Middle-income workers cannot afford a home. Affordable homes, delivered by the State, are a key way to address that, but the Government's numbers are pathetic. The only people actually benefiting from the housing crisis now, and for whom the housing system is working, are the vulture fund landlords and the big developers. The Government's affordable housing is not delivering. The changes to rental rules, which the Minister will not acknowledge, are absolutely crucifying people. People are being evicted because of the new rental changes the Minister has brought in but he will not acknowledge that. Eighteen thousand people are homeless and the Minister tries to brush it off. He does not even acknowledge that we have an emergency. He says one person in homelessness is too many. Of course it is, but that is trite in comparison with what the Minister could actually be doing to prevent homelessness. He could put in place a ban on evictions, and also get the councils and set up a State construction company to directly build affordable housing rather than benefiting the vulture funds. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_106" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_188">We have a State construction company, namely, the Land Development Agency, LDA. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_107">
            <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_189">It is not directly building. It is hiring private builders. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_108" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_190">We also have local authorities across the country, which are housing authorities whose job it is to deliver housing. We have no end of mechanisms for delivering homes. Some of those local authorities, as well as the LDA, are really stepping up now to deliver homes across the country. Some local authorities are not, and I am going to highlight those more and more to deliver on their remit. </p>
            <p eId="para_191"> This year sees the highest number of mortgage drawdowns since 2007. The Deputy has to recognise that we are making inroads. As I said, I am the first to recognise that we have to do an awful lot more and I am going to continue to drive the delivery of housing, whether that is rural one-off homes, whether it is in our villages, towns or cities, and whether it is social, affordable, or private. I will drive on to continue to do what we have been doing to date and do more. </p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_22">
          <heading>Homeless Persons Supports<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#EoinOBroin" to="#Housing" eId="pq_143">
            <p eId="para_192">143. <b>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> the breakdown of the €20 million announced alongside the child and family homeless action plan, by Department and funding programme. [82393/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_109">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_193">Last week, when the Minister announced the Child and Family Homelessness Action Plan, a figure of €20 million for homelessness prevention across three Departments mentioned. Will he set out how much will be allocated to each of the three Departments involved and what it will be spent on? Will it be new spending above allocations already announced for next year or just from within the existing financial envelope? </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_110" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_194">Addressing homelessness, in particular child and family homelessness, remains a key priority for the Government and for me. The publication of the Child and Family Homelessness Action Plan is a key milestone in addressing child and family homelessness and improving outcomes faced by families experiencing homelessness. I want to make sure that it is not just a plan on paper but one that is implemented and delivered. The Government has committed €20 million to support the implementation of the plan. This includes dedicated funding allocations in budget 2027 that were secured specifically to deliver actions across a number of Departments - namely, the Departments of Housing, Local Government and Heritage; Children, Disability and Equality; Health; and Justice, Home Affairs and Migration - and reflecting the cross-government approach of the plan. </p>
            <p eId="para_195"> The detailed allocation of this funding is being finalised as part of the Revised Estimates volume. Further information on departmental allocations will be available once the Revised Estimates process is concluded. In the case of my own Department, the €11 million allocated for these actions forms part of the overall homelessness funding provision of €593 million for 2027 and was specifically identified and secured to support delivery of commitments under the plan. This includes actions such as the roll-out of effective tenancy support services across all local authority regions and the expansion of the supported housing for families scheme. </p>
            <p eId="para_196"> Delivering Homes, Building Communities, an action plan on housing supply and targeting homelessness is a comprehensive and integrated housing and homelessness plan based on two key pillars, namely, activating the supply of 300,000 more homes and supporting people to have a home of their own. Increased supply is key to addressing homelessness, meeting need, and addressing the challenges in the housing market. Therefore, we are building more than ever in recent times, and a record level of investment is being provided for the delivery of housing this year, with €5.2 billion in Exchequer capital funding, complemented by investment through the Land Development Agency and lending from the Housing Finance Agency, bringing the total capital funding for housing in 2026 to over €9 billion. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_111">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_197">As the Minister knows, his Department published the latest homelessness figures on Friday last. There are over 18,000 people, including almost 6,000 children in emergency accommodation funded by the Department. When we add in all those other adults and children in emergency accommodation funded by other Departments or sleeping rough, more than 22,000 people are recognised as homeless. While the publication of the plan was welcomed by the homelessness services sector, it also used words like "disappointing" and "underwhelming" in its response. The fact the Minister did not even have an in-person launch and submit the plan to scrutiny by the media, but issued a soft launch, speaks volumes. The idea that a paltry €11 million in additional expenditure for homelessness prevention shows any level of commitment from the Government is utter nonsense. The overwhelming majority of the spend on homelessness services, emergency accommodation, is private emergency. When will the Minister start taking homelessness prevention seriously and implement, for example, all of the recommendations of the Irish homeless policy group, published earlier this year, which have been ignored in the action plan?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_112" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_198">For 2027, we are providing €593 million to address all forms of homelessness, and the Child and Family Homelessness Action Plan is only one element of our overall approach to this. Of course, even that funding is only one part of it, because we will ultimately address homelessness by providing sufficient housing for our growing population. We delivered a record number of social housing last year. I expect we will set a new record for delivery of social housing this year. That is how we get address homelessness as well, by providing people with safe and secure homes.</p>
            <p eId="para_199"> We do have far too many people in homelessness. As I always say, one is too many, and I make no apologies for saying that. We have to make sure that we prevent as many as possible from going into homelessness and that we exit them as quickly as possible, but while they are in that position, they are given any necessary supports. </p>
            <p eId="para_200"> It is also important to highlight that the number of families and individuals who are in homelessness is not static. We do exit a very significant number of people from homelessness but, unfortunately, we do have more people going in, and we need to increase our prevention measures as well.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_113">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_201">Despite the modest increase in social housing delivery and the enormous increase in expenditure on emergency accommodation, month on month and year on year, the number of adults and children forced into unsuitable, inadequate emergency accommodations grows. </p>
            <p eId="para_202">That is the reality. What that means is the plan the Minister has on the new social housing delivery side simply is not working. One of the strongest criticisms of the action plan is that it has no targets. For example, the Minister cannot say in 2027 how many people will be exited and what the reductions will be in the total number of people experiencing homelessness. This is not an action plan but a set of actions, some of which have merit but none of which give any evidence that we are going to see a reduction. The homeless policy group set out ten core actions that would achieve the objective of reducing long-term homelessness. Sinn Féin published a 12-point action plan earlier this year setting out clear actions. All the Minister has done is given us some vague commitments and a paltry amount of money at €11 million. As a consequence, things are going to get worse. When is the Minister going to start matching his words with real commitments to tackle and end long-term homelessness?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_114" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_203">As the Deputy is fully aware, the €11 million from my Department is only part of the €20 million fund. The €11 million in the Department is part of a wider homelessness funding provision of €593 million for next year. It is an action plan. There are 43 specific actions in it to prevent families from entering homelessness and to improve supports for those currently in emergency accommodation. It is going to be closely monitored with a subcommittee. The DSG will comprise representatives from key Departments and State bodies, as well as representatives from the non-governmental sector in relation to homelessness. It will be chaired by the Department of the Taoiseach at assistant secretary general level. This is working collaboratively between myself and the Taoiseach to ensure that these 43 actions are, in fact, implemented, with the director role from the Department of the Taoiseach overseeing part of this.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_23">
          <heading>Homeless Persons Supports<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#ConorSheehan" to="#Housing" eId="pq_144">
            <p eId="para_204">144. <b>Deputy Conor Sheehan</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> to provide a full breakdown of the dedicated funding ring-fenced for the implementation of the action plan on child and family homelessness; if the €20 million allocation for homelessness prevention represents new, additional Exchequer funding beyond the existing homeless services budget; to detail the way in which this funding will reduce the State's reliance on private emergency accommodation providers; the mechanism for quarterly progress reports to Dáil Éireann; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [81991/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_115" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_205">I thank Deputy Sheehan for his question in relation to the new action plan on child and family homelessness. A total of €20 million has been committed to support the delivery of the 43 actions contained in the child and family homeless action plan. The publication of the plan was a key commitment under Delivering Homes, Building Communities, and sets out a co-ordinated cross-government programme of measures to prevent and reduce child and family homelessness and improve outcomes for families. This plan is critical. The plan brings together actions across housing, health, education, childcare, youth services and family supports to ensure an improved and more co-ordinated response to child and family homelessness.</p>
            <p eId="para_206"> In the Department, funding of €11 million was secured to support actions, such as the expansion of the supported housing for families scheme, the roll-out of effective tenancy support services across all local authority regions and scaling local authority-led housing supports for families exiting IPAS accommodation. It will also strengthen local authority integration supports and community forums and ensure adequate resourcing of housing support officers and family homeless action teams. It will also provide improved access to education through the provision of Leap cards for children in emergency accommodation, where required, and expand the provision of accessible emergency accommodation, increase the use of modular accommodation as a high-quality alternative to emergency accommodation and support implementation of the national quality standards framework for emergency accommodation.</p>
            <p eId="para_207"> Preventing homelessness in the first instance is a key priority. The plan includes a range of measures aimed at reducing presentations to homeless services and helping people to remain in their homes, thereby reducing demand for private emergency accommodation. In addition, the plan includes measures to expand the use of modular accommodation on local authority-owned land and to utilise licensing options as higher quality alternatives to traditional emergency accommodation. Over time, these measures will help to reduce the State's reliance on private emergency accommodation providers. The Government is committed to ensuring that all actions set out in the plan are progressed within the 12 months of implementation. The delivery oversight group is currently being established under the auspices of the national homeless action committee.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ConorSheehan" eId="spk_116">
            <from>Deputy Conor Sheehan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_208">Last week, the figure for people in emergency accommodation passed 18,000. It passed 18,000 for the first time in the history of the State. I welcome the publication of the action plan. I regret that it has been delayed so much and that the Minister did not even formally launch it. Some of the language in the action plan concerns me. There are a lot of references to "start to progress" and the word "taskforce" appears multiple times. Let us be clear. To be a success, this plan must result in fewer children entering homelessness, no child spending more than six months in homelessness and more children exiting homelessness. It is disappointing that the plan does not actually have targets in it, given that the Minister said in his reply that it is critical. What is the Minister's measure of success at three months, six months, nine months and 12 months in terms of this action plan?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_117" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_209">I thank the Deputy for his comments. I agree that this plan is critical. I am determined that it is not a plan on paper and that it will be implemented. That is why, in terms of the oversight of its implementation, I am including NGOs from the homeless sector that will be part of the oversight group. The oversight group will be chaired by an assistant secretary general from the Department of the Taoiseach to ensure that the measures in there decided by the Department of housing that are in other Departments are being implemented as well. I will have a role in it too to ensure that this is being implemented. There are now over 18,000 people in homelessness. The number has been rising. It is unacceptable to me. I am taking every measure I can to get a handle on homelessness. Doing measures such as increasing the supply of social housing is critical to that in order that we can get people into their permanent homes. We will continue to take other measures as well.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#ConorSheehan" eId="spk_118">
            <from>Deputy Conor Sheehan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_210">The plan is also notable for what is not in it. There is no reference to the recommendations of the homeless policy group. There is also no reference to the recommendations of the report on homelessness by the Oireachtas housing committee, which was published earlier this year. This plan will only work if it is combined with other measures such as reversal of cuts to the tenant in situ scheme from 2025, a no-fault eviction ban or, at the very least, a ban on evicting children into homelessness, as we have proposed. The plan makes reference to expanding the role of family resource centres, but I note that this was done without consulting the family resource centre sector. Will the Minister commit that every child in homelessness will have a dedicated child support worker? How exactly is this plan going to feed back to the Oireachtas housing committee in terms of monitoring its progress? As I said, there are 43 recommendations. The clock has already started ticking.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_119" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_211">There are 43 actions within this plan. I am determined that those actions are, in fact, implemented. I have outlined how we are going to oversee its delivery. One of the key things done by the former housing Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, and is being continued and furthered by myself, is the involvement of the NGO sector, which is at the coalface of dealing with homelessness. They do extraordinary work, so they do. They are informing our decision-making and are also a part of overseeing the implementation of all of our policies. I chair the national homeless action committee and bring those NGOs together on a regular basis. I am determined to get these 43 actions implemented. I will ensure that they are done.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_24">
          <heading>Housing Policy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#PaulMurphy" to="#Housing" eId="pq_145">
            <p eId="para_212">145. <b>Deputy Paul Murphy</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> if he anticipates that merging social housing and cost rental will lead to higher rents for council and housing assistance payment, HAP, tenants; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [82420/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_120">
            <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T10:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_213">In a couple of hours' time, South Dublin County Council will vote on proposed rent hikes for council HAP and homeless HAP tenants of an average of about 25%. Similar votes will happen across the country in the coming weeks. This question is about the wider plan the Government has to merge social housing and cost rental, which would effectively mean the end of differential rent and rents that are a multiple of what people are currently paying.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_121" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_214">I thank Deputy Murphy for his question on the merging of social housing and cost-rental housing. This is a proposal by the Housing Commission. Action 6.12 of Delivering Homes, Building Communities 2025-2030 provides for a pathfinder project to explore the recommendation of the Housing Commission that social housing and cost-rental housing could, over time, evolve into a single affordable rental sector based on cost-recovery principles. The purpose of the pathfinder project is to examine whether a sustainable public housing model that combines aspects of the current social housing and cost-rental housing systems could be developed. It will consider a wide range of policy, legislative, financial and operational issues, including how rental income generated within the system might be retained and reinvested to support the delivery, management and maintenance of homes. The objective is to examine whether such an approach could support the long-term sustainability of public housing provision, while continuing to meet housing need.</p>
            <p eId="para_215"> It is important to emphasise that no decision has been taken by the Government to implement such a model. The Housing Commission recommendation is being examined through a pathfinder process, precisely so the implications of any potential future approach can be properly assessed. The work is exploratory in nature and is intended to inform future policy considerations. I want to be clear that there is no proposal, arising from this work, to increase rents for existing local authority tenants or households supported by the housing assistance payment. Any future proposals that emerge from the pathfinder project will be subject to detailed consideration by the Government, including careful assessment of affordability, tenant protections, equality and social impacts, financial sustainability and wider housing policy objectives. Accordingly, I do not anticipate any impact on current rent arrangements for council tenants or HAP-supported households as a result of the pathfinder project. Its purpose is to assess options, examine implications and support evidence-based decision-making on the future development of public housing policy.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_122">
            <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_216">The problem with what the Minister said is that, right now, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael across the country are voting for massive rent increases for social housing, rent increases which would simply be illegal if they were in the private sector. Some people under South Dublin County Council will get a rent increase of 53%. This is the section of the population most at risk of poverty and the Government is hiking their rents. Those people will correctly look at the Government's programme, which talks explicitly about merging social and cost-rental housing over time and a pathfinder project to do that. I would like the Minister to spell out what it will mean for rents. </p>
            <p eId="para_217"> Let us look at Citywest, where a three-bedroom cost-rental apartment costs €1,750 per month and O'Devaney Gardens, where a three-bedroom apartment costs €1,895 per month. The problem with the Government's cost-rental model is that ordinary tenants are expected to pay, not on the basis of what they can afford, which is the model of differential rent, but instead to pay for the profits of all the developers, banks and so on in the system of delivering these houses.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_123" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_218">I have to re-emphasise that the current project is a pathfinder project to assess and analyse the merger proposed by the Housing Commission. I am regularly criticised here for not implementing the Housing Commission's report. We are doing a pathfinder project to see what it would look like if it were implemented. There are no plans to implement it at all, at the moment or in the future. We are examining the Housing Commission's recommendation to see what impact, if any, it would have on tenants with regard to protection measures, affordability, equality, social impacts, financial impacts and wider housing policy initiatives. All we are doing at the moment is checking out the proposal to see what it looks like. There will be ample opportunity to discuss any outcomes from the pathfinder project, not just for the Government but for the Oireachtas committee and, no doubt, the Dáil.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_124">
            <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_219">The Government is not going to do a pathfinder project to look into it and then throw it in the bin. It is at least considering the option referenced in its plan to merge social housing and cost rental. Will the Minister spell out what it would mean? Would it mean the end of a differential rent system, which is a fair system based on people paying a percentage of their income and, therefore, what they can afford? Would it mean the whole system would be based on cost rental, which, in reality, is a small discount on market rates that are completely unaffordable and where ordinary tenants are expected to pay for the profits of the developers, banks and everyone else who plays a role in the building of these homes? Can the Minister confirm that it would mean council tenants would be paying up to €2,000 for three-bedroom apartments or homes they simply cannot afford?</p>
            <p eId="para_220"> The answer to any problem with funding social housing is to raise the income limits. From our perspective, we should get rid of the income limits altogether. Let us have universal access to public housing and then the differential model would more than pay for the social housing we need.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_125" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_221">I will say it for the third time. There is no plan to implement a merger of social housing and cost-rental housing. We are examining one proposal by the Housing Commission using a pathfinder project to see what it would look like and to look at any consequences, intended or unintended, which can be discussed here and in the Oireachtas committee. There are no implications for renters, so I do not really know where the Deputy is coming from. Is he saying a Government or Department cannot even review something, without him drawing endless connections from it to scare renters? That is all he is doing. He needs to be honest with social housing renters.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_126">
            <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_222">The Government are the ones raising rents. The Government is raising rents all over the place.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_127" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_223">There is no plan. There is absolutely no plan, as he is setting out.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_25">
          <heading>Housing Provision<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#SeamusMcGrath" to="#Housing" eId="pq_146">
            <p eId="para_224">146. <b>Deputy Séamus McGrath</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> the timeframe for the qualifying income limits for social housing to be reviewed. [82162/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_128" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_225">I thank the Deputy for raising this matter of the review of qualifying income limits for social housing. It is a matter the Deputy has much pursued out of concern for his constituents. Applications for social housing support are assessed by the relevant local authority, in accordance with the eligibility and needs criteria set down in section 20 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2009 and associated social housing assessment regulations 2011, as amended.</p>
            <p eId="para_226"> The 2011 regulations prescribe maximum net income limits for each local authority in different bands, according to the area concerned, with income defined and assessed according to a standard household-means policy. Local authorities have no discretion to exceed the limits that apply in their administrative areas. The policy provides for a range of income disregards and local authorities also have discretion to disregard income that is one-off, temporary or short term in nature and outside the regular pattern of a person's annual income. The income bands are expressed in terms of a maximum net income threshold for a single person household, with an allowance of 5% for each additional adult household member, subject to a maximum allowance under this category of 10%, and a separate 2.5% allowance for each child. The baseline social housing income thresholds are €40,000, €35,000 and €30,000 for bands 1, 2 and 3 respectively. These thresholds are net income, that is, gross household income less income tax, PRSI, universal social charge and additional superannuation contribution.</p>
            <p eId="para_227"> The Department has been examining the existing income limits in the context of the current market and household income conditions, including the suitability or otherwise of the current framework having regard to the significantly changed landscape since the standardised income limits were introduced. This includes examining the findings of research commissioned by my Department and this work is ongoing. In that context, there is an important balance, which I, as Minister, and the Government must strike in this regard. Increasing eligibility and access to social housing supports has a direct budgetary demand, which must be managed in light of the existing significant investment in housing overall. In parallel, I acknowledge the increase in household income and basic social welfare rates since the last time these limits were updated.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_129">
            <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_228">Gabhaim buíochas leis an Aire. As the Minister stated, I have raised this issue with him on a number of occasions and he signalled his intention to review this as urgently as possible, which I welcome. The core issue is that people on modest incomes do not qualify for social housing and the same individuals and couples do not qualify for other schemes the State provides to assist people with housing, so they are falling between the schemes. We need to urgently review the income limits so they can qualify.</p>
            <p eId="para_229"> All of us here can recount stories. Recently, I had a case of an individual who had been on the list for a number of years. He was about to be offered an apartment, but the council reviewed his income and he was marginally over the income limit. As the Minister outlined, there is little or no discretion at local authority level in relation to the income assessed.</p>
            <p eId="para_230">That particular individual will not receive the apartment and his file will be closed. If we increase the income limits in the near future, does that individual go back on the list? Do they get their time back and so on? There are myriad questions there but we need to urgently review it. I again urge the Minister to do that at the earliest possible time.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_130" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_231">I again thank Deputy McGrath for raising this issue. I am aware it is giving rise to concerns across the country in terms of the various limits. The limits were last increased by the then Minister, Deputy O'Brien, on 1 January 2023 when €5,000 was applied to all social housing income thresholds across the country. The thresholds now start from €30,000, €35,000 and €40,000 depending on whether you are in band 1, 2 or 3, respectively.</p>
            <p eId="para_232"> I am examining very carefully what changes should and can be made. I acknowledge that in the intervening time, incomes have increased but so have other social welfare supports. Nonetheless, I have to be conscious that any increase in the limits will also bring a current expenditure increase as a result of the increasing number of people who would become entitled to HAP. That current expenditure is something that needs to be considered within the budgetary cycle.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_131">
            <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_233">I thank the Minister. I appreciate his commitment to review this. He has to strike a balance between widening the eligibility for social housing and the implications that has for HAP expenditure. As it stands, there is a gap between people who do not qualify for social housing and the other schemes the State provides and we cannot ignore that any longer. We have to provide some support to the cohort of people on a net income of €50,000, €60,000 and so on. It is acting as a disincentive to work and we all know cases where people are not taking up a promotion, not working overtime and in some cases reducing their weekly working hours, so they fall within the limit. That is unsatisfactory and we need to address it. I welcome the Minister's commitment to look at this as quickly as possible and I look forward to the update in the near future.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_132" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_234">I again thank Deputy McGrath for the question. It is an important one. As I said, the limits have been increased since 1 January 2023. Nonetheless, incomes have increased in that time, as have social welfare payments and social protection supports. I am very conscious of always watching that gap. Who can afford to buy a home themselves? Who needs affordable supports, whether the help-to-buy scheme, first home scheme, affordable purchase or other measures? Who needs a home under direct social housing supports? My aim is to ensure everybody gets a home they can afford on that spectrum and we keep that spectrum under very close scrutiny.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_26">
        <heading>Ceisteanna Eile - Other Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_27">
          <heading>Housing Provision<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#NoelMcCarthy" to="#Housing" eId="pq_147">
            <p eId="para_235">147. <b>Deputy Noel McCarthy</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> his Department's plans to increase social housing eligibility income limits. [82010/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#NoelMcCarthy" eId="spk_133">
            <from>Deputy Noel McCarthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_236">My question is the same as Deputy McGrath's in that it is on income limits. The Minister has already given a response. Like Deputy McGrath, I welcome the Minister's commitment to review the limits. People come to the offices of Deputies across the House with the same problems Deputy McGrath outlined. The most important thing the Minister said in his second reply was that he wants to see people getting their own home. That was very encouraging.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_134" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_237">I thank Deputy McCarthy for raising the issue of social housing eligibility income limits. It is a very important question and the Deputy has been working on this matter for some time and raised the concern on a number of occasions. We keep these social housing income limits under review. They were last increased on 1 January 2023 by the then Minister for housing, Deputy O'Brien. There was an increase of €5,000 across all those limits. Again, I acknowledge incomes have increased, as have social welfare payments. Nonetheless, it is not as straightforward as increasing the limits. Any increase in those limits would bring a current expenditure cost I have be conscious of in the wider context of our budget.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#NoelMcCarthy" eId="spk_135">
            <from>Deputy Noel McCarthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_238">I thank the Minister for his response. It is encouraging to hear the Department is examining income limits given current market conditions and changes in household income levels. Change is much needed, with the last increase having been at the beginning of 2023, as the Minister said. I appreciate households must strictly adhere to the criteria but, as a result, we are seeing applicants barely over the income limit not being accepted. Families must then consider the possibility of greatly reducing their working hours to fit within the income limits. This reduced income must have been earned in the 12 months preceding the application. With this in mind, will the Minister outline whether his Department is considering any specific changes that would see a reduction in the earning period in advance of applying for the social housing list?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_136" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_239">I thank the Deputy very much. One thing to be conscious of is that even if we raise the income limits, we will end up with another cut-off point. There are always, unfortunately, going to people who are just outside those limits. We have empowered local authorities to take a number of measures to try to address some of the concerns that may arise with individual families. I assure the Deputy his concern about social housing eligibility income limits are very much to the forefront of my mind and we will continue to keep them under review.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#NoelMcCarthy" eId="spk_137">
            <from>Deputy Noel McCarthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_240">I thank the Minister again. I appreciate the changing of any income limit is a complex issue that requires much analysis and social thresholds are a matter Deputies across the House raise regularly. However, I am pleased to see the Department and the Minister are making some progress. Finally, as part of any examination of income limits, will local authorities be given any additional powers to consider in exceptional circumstances those who are just over the limit for admission to the list?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_138" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_241">I thank the Deputy. Exceptional cases will be considered in any broader review of social housing income limits. Most families will always be in some sort of exceptional circumstances. Unfortunately, it is the reality of the nature of life. Cut-off points can feel quite difficult for families and as a TD and previously as a councillor I had to deal with those cut-off points. That is the nature of it, unfortunately, but I will certainly take into consideration what the Deputy has raised.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_28">
          <heading>Land Development Agency<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#PaulMcAuliffe" to="#Housing" eId="pq_148">
            <p eId="para_242">148. <b>Deputy Paul McAuliffe</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> following the recent announcement of the LDA's proposal to develop the site of the former Ballymun Shopping Centre, Silloge Road, if he will ensure that the development will have adequate retail and community space to respond to the needs of the wider community. [81755/26]</p>
          </question>
          <question by="#PaulMcAuliffe" to="#Housing" eId="pq_157">
            <p eId="para_243">157. <b>Deputy Paul McAuliffe</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> to ensure that the proposed development of the site of the former Ballymun Shopping Centre, Silloge Road by the LDA will have a mix of cost rental and affordable purchase housing to respond to the needs of the wider community. [81861/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_139" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_244">I propose to take Questions Nos. 148 and 157 together.</p>
            <p eId="para_245"> I welcome the Deputy's questions on the recent announcement of the Land Development Agency's proposal to develop the site of the former Ballymun Shopping Centre on Sillogue Road. The Deputy wants assurances the development will have adequate retail and community space to respond to the needs of the wider community. He is 100% correct. While my drive is to build houses they have to form part of a community and the word "community" demonstrates exactly what makes Ireland unique. We are so strong on the word "community" and we want to ensure in everything we are doing that we are building communities. It is why I put the word into our housing plan, Delivering Homes, Building Communities.</p>
            <p eId="para_246"> The Land Development Agency plays a key role in the delivery of new houses under our plan. The LDA is actively developing housing on State and market-acquired lands and is working in partnership with local authorities to develop large-scale mixed tenure schemes of starter homes for purchase and rent along with social housing on local authority-owned sites. The LDA published its second report on relevant public lands in April 2025. That identified 102 parcels of State land as having potential to deliver housing, including the site of the former Ballymun Shopping Centre. I understand the LDA has submitted a large-scale residential development planning application for Dublin City Council for the development of homes and amenities on this site.</p>
            <p eId="para_247">Subject to the grant of planning, a total of 564 new homes spread over three residential blocks will be delivered on the site of the old Ballymun shopping centre. The development will include a crèche as well as community and cultural facilities. These facilities are intended to support existing and future residents and will contribute to a more integrated neighbourhood. The proposal also includes open spaces, which will add to Ballymun's network of parks, streets and public places, and these well-designed outdoor areas will help to create opportunities for play, rest, meeting and everyday social interaction. It is important to note that the provision of community facilities is a reserved function of the elected members in accordance with section 67(2) of the Local Government Act 2001.</p>
            <p eId="para_248"> In addition, the proposed development will also place a strong emphasis on sustainable transport and active travel. The planning application submitted by the LDA features over 1,100 bicycle parking spaces for the residents and visitors and a new mobility hub. In addition to 177 car parking spaces, provision for ten car club parking spaces, seven motorcycle spaces and two service bays are also proposed. The development is to be built alongside the proposed Ballymun MetroLink station, ensuring enhanced connectivity to Dublin city centre and north County Dublin.</p>
            <p eId="para_249"> It also offers a significant opportunity to support the continued regeneration of the Ballymun town centre, helping to create a vibrant, sustainable urban neighbourhood. The LDA is working closely with Dublin City Council, local stakeholders and the wider community to support the regeneration of the area and progress the next stage of the project. As part of this engagement, the LDA held a public consultation in July, which included the creation of a dedicated information and communication channel, as well as the facilitation of a drop-in information clinic. Following this progress, the LDA published a consultation and stakeholder engagement report in October, which is available on its dedicated project webpage.</p>
            <p eId="para_250"> Regarding the tenancy mix, the tenure mix of a particular area will be informed by the relevant local authority through the housing development action plan process. These plans take account of identifiable housing need within their area and will include collaboration with their delivery partners, including the Land Development Agency and the approved housing bodies, as applicable. These plans will be completed and published by local authorities shortly and will help to determine what types of housing are needed and will help drive delivery.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_140">
            <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_251">This site is incredibly important. It is at the very heart of Ballymun. The Minister rightly said that it will be at the location of the Ballymun metro station. It has the potential to have really good quality public transport. It has a great location right in the middle of our community. It also will have a significant impact on the community. It is public land owned by Dublin City Council. We are building public housing on it. I welcome that. I also welcome the involvement of the LDA in this project. It is something that I have called for some time. Dublin City is already maxed out in terms of the number of projects that it has going on in Ballymun on other sites in terms of delivering affordable purchase, cost rental and social homes. The additional support the LDA can bring in this case is very welcome. However, I encourage it to continue to deal with the local authority, and particularly with the local authority's elected members, to ensure they are included in the process.</p>
            <p eId="para_252"> There are still a lot of decisions left in this. It is inevitable that there will be a cost rental element to this. There is a social housing element to it. I want to make sure that within the structure there is an element for affordable purchase here. We have almost 600 units. It is going to be managed by the LDA. Within that, surely a management structure can be put in place to ensure that affordable purchase can be accommodated. This is not a small-scale development by the Land Development Agency. It should include all three elements. It should also include community space and crèche space, which are included in the plans. I will not speak about a live planning application. It also should integrate into the existing Ballymun community and the surrounding areas. As we have some empty retail units, the idea of calling for more retail might be seem not logical, but it is about creating a sense of a public domain, a high street and community. All those things are crucial on this site.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_141" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_253">I could not agree with the Deputy more. This is an important development. It is at the heart of Ballymun. It is important that we get it right and not just in terms of housing delivery, but by ensuring people can have homes in their local community and having the right tenure mix of those homes. It is also about ensuring that the delivery of these homes is part of that community and strengthens that community. It is close to public transport. It is very close to all the other amenities within Ballymun. It is an extraordinary opportunity if we get it right and I believe it will be done right through that partnership of the LDA, the local authority and the Department of housing to ensure that it can strengthen Ballymun and allow Ballymun to thrive. There is a fantastic community out there. We want to see it thrive and to give the necessary community supports that are needed out there as well.</p>
            <p eId="para_254"> The outline from the LDA is a very positive one in terms of what it is going to deliver. I agree that it is positive that the Land Development Agency is involved in the project. It shows the level that it is scaling up now in terms of housing delivery across the country but in particular in Dublin. That whole regeneration piece is critical to what we are doing within my Department. It is not just about building houses. It is also about tackling dereliction across the country. I commend the LDA for its work and the rate at which it is scaling up and delivering homes across the area. Ballymun is a very important project. I thank the Deputy for all of his input and will continue to strive for further delivery to ensure that Ballymun can thrive.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_142">
            <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_255">We will not declare success just yet. However, I am appreciative of the work of the officials in the Department who have met with me on a number of occasions regarding this site, and to the LDA. It is now about making sure that the tenure mix is right. One of the issues that we have had is with retail in Ballymun. Ballymun has one of the highest levels of social housing in the State and that has an impact. Due to the income limits for social housing, this can result in there being low incomes in the general area, which can have an impact on retail spend and so on. The answer to that is to significantly increase the income limits. I would not be thinking around it. I would not be raising it up by €5,000 or €6,000; I would be going for €10,000 or €20,000 on the income limits for social housing. That is for a different question, however. Perhaps, the merger of cost rental and social that was referenced earlier is about doing that and creating that additional buck. As a result of those low incomes, it has been hard to support a retail base in our area. That is why we have to make sure that this development has affordable purchase, cost rental and social - all three - in it.</p>
            <p eId="para_256"> I will go back to the point that until now a lot of the public developments have either been cost rental or social. They have not allowed for affordable purchase. This is the State's housing development agency. It is a big site. It intends to have long-term ownership here. There is no reason it cannot make an element of the development affordable purchase and put in place a management structure, which it is going to have for the rest of the building anyway, to allow for owners within that building. That is not about gentrification. It is about allowing the kids in Ballymun who benefited from all the education programmes we invested in and went on to third level to come back and buy a home in their community. If we are building this number of homes, there should be affordable purchase at the heart of it.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_143" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_257">We will continue to engage with the local community. I expect the LDA will continue to engage with the local community and deliver quality homes in a strong community setting. Again, I thank the Deputy for his work in this area and continuing to drive for the betterment of Ballymun.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_5">
            <i>Question No. 149 taken with Written Answers.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_29">
          <heading>Housing Policy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#SeanOFearghaillFF" to="#Housing" eId="pq_150">
            <p eId="para_258">150. <b>Deputy Seán Ó Fearghaíl</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> the way in which he is supporting the delivery of new affordable purchase homes. [81951/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_144">
            <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_259">I thank Deputy Ó Fearghaíl for passing on this question. I ask the Minister to outline his plans to step up the delivery of affordable purchase properties or starter home properties.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_145" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_260">Deputy McGrath is taking Deputy Ó Fearghaíl's question. The question concerns the delivery of new affordable purchase homes and the starter homes programme. A key component of the Government's housing strategy, Delivering Homes, Building Communities, is supporting affordable home ownership through a suite of measures, including the first home scheme, the local authority's starter homes for purchase scheme and the Revenue help-to-buy scheme.</p>
            <p eId="para_261">By placing home ownership at the centre of housing policy, these initiatives are helping to bridge affordability gap faced by many first-time buyers who share equity supports backed by the State and participating lenders, as well as the help to buy scheme which provides an income tax rebate of up to €35,000 towards a deposit. </p>
            <p eId="para_262"> The Government is making home ownership more accessible to individuals and families across the country. The housing plan reinforces and expands the range of affordable housing measures currently being delivered by Government. Encompassing affordable purchase and cost rental options in this framework, the starter homes programme is targeting the delivery of an average of 15,000 affordable housing supports annually to 2030. </p>
            <p eId="para_263"> Reflecting this level of ambition, Exchequer capital investment in the starter homes programme exceeded €1 billion in 2025, with a further €1.2 billion available this year. This substantial investment supported more than 80,000 affordable housing supports during 2025. A similarly strong level of delivery is expected this year and in the years ahead. The impact of this investment is being felt in communities throughout the country. The affordable housing fund, which is available to all local authorities, continues to play a central role in supporting the delivery of new starter homes for purchase and rent. To date, funding of more than €624 million has been approved under the fund supporting the delivery of approximately 7,000 affordable purchase homes across 28 local authority areas. </p>
            <p eId="para_264"> As promised, in the new housing plan, we are working to ensure starter homes for purchase are available everywhere they are needed. This year alone, new schemes have been approved in five local authorities that have not previously had starter home for purchase schemes.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_146">
            <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_265">I thank the Minister. I acknowledge he has a very ambitious programme for starter homes, which is fully acknowledged by me. I recognise it is not just about affordable purchase homes. It also includes the first-home scheme, the vacant property refurbishment grant and the help to buy scheme. </p>
            <p eId="para_266"> It goes back to the argument I made earlier on social housing income limits. We know people who fall outside that, that is, people on middle and modest incomes, are very often not able to take the next step in terms of home ownership. We need to support them in terms of affordable housing schemes. Unfortunately, our numbers in recent years have not been of the standard required. Last year, fewer than a thousand affordable purchase homes were provided, compared to social housing delivery which has been fantastic at over 9,000 units. What we have done in social housing is what we need to do in affordable purchase housing so that we can give people a step on the ladder to home ownership, which is so valued among individuals and couples.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_147" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_267">Every local authority is delivering on affordable purchase this year. As I said, new schemes have been approved in five local authorities for starter homes for purchase, namely Roscommon, Cavan, Donegal, Tipperary and Kerry. That State investment for starter homes for purchase under this fund alone is over €600 million. Very much looking ahead, local authorities commence the updating of their housing delivery action plans for review by my Department and these plans will set out how the starter homes programme will be implemented locally for the remainder of the decade, ensuring delivery is in line with clearly identified affordable housing need in each area.</p>
            <p eId="para_268"> My Department, alongside the Housing Agency and the housing delivery co-ordination office of the Local Government Management Agency, will continue to support local authorities in expanding and strengthening their starter homes programmes as new opportunities, including those for direct build projects, are identified and brought forward by those local authorities. As I said, I want every local authority to step up to deliver affordable homes for purchase across the country.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_148">
            <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_269">I thank the Minister. I acknowledge the work that is being done and completely agree with him that local authorities need to step up to the plate. I can be frustrated by the slow progress in the delivery of some affordable purchase schemes and we certainly need to continue to put a focus on that. </p>
            <p eId="para_270"> Regarding Deputy McAuliffe's point on Ballymun and a mix of units, we are seeing great supply in terms of cost rental and social housing in many State supported schemes through the LDA, approved housing bodies and so on. However, all too often affordable purchase is not part of that mix. Deputy McAuliffe made a very strong case regarding Ballymun. The railyard development in Cork city is a fantastic development comprising over 217 units but no affordable purchase units are available. That is very frustrating for people who are living in the area and want to purchase a property. We have to get the mix right and do so as a matter of urgency so that those schemes that are developed and supported by the State include an affordable purchase element in order to give people the opportunity to secure home ownership in the areas in which they want to live.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_149" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_271">I again thank the Deputy. To support the delivery of starter homes by local authorities, the affordable housing fund is open to applications and available to support local authorities to deliver starter purchase and cost-rental homes in their local area. Overall funding of €720 million has been approved from the affordable housing fund for 28 local authorities to support the delivery of over 7,900 starter purchase and cost-rental homes. </p>
            <p eId="para_272"> On starter purchase homes, funding of over €624 million has been approved for 28 local authority to support the delivery of over 7,000 starter purchase homes. From 2022 to the end of quarter 2 of 2026, over 3,400 local authorities starter purchase and cost-rental homes have been delivered, with almost 600 local authority starter purchase and cost-rental homes delivered in the first half of 2026. As I said, these approvals support a commitment under the programme for Government and action 7.5 on delivering homes and building communities to work with local authorities to bring forward affordable housing fund proposals in areas that do not currently have projects in place.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_6">
            <i>Question No. 151 taken with Written Answers.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_7">
            <i>Question No. 153 taken with Written Answers.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_30">
          <heading>Housing Policy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#BrianBrennan" to="#Housing" eId="pq_154">
            <p eId="para_273">154. <b>Deputy Brian Brennan</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> if he will consider extending eligibility criteria for the above the shop grant so that properties held through limited companies, small partnerships, or other business structures can apply. [82009/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#BrianBrennan" eId="spk_150">
            <from>Deputy Brian Brennan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_274">Regarding local government and housing, will the Minister consider extending the eligibility criteria for the above the shop grant so that properties held through limited companies, small partnerships or business structures can apply?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_151" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_275">I thank the Deputy for his question. It is an important question on the above the shop grant in terms of properties held through limited companies, small partnerships or other business models being apply for it. Addressing vacancy dereliction is a key priority for the Government, as reflected in the housing plan, Delivering Homes, Building Communities. The vacant property refurbishment grant funded under the croí cónaithe towns fund has had tremendous impact on supporting people to refurbish and revitalise previously abandoned homes and properties across the country. Of course, in turn, that revitalises communities. </p>
            <p eId="para_276"> It has been especially impactful in rural Ireland, with Donegal and Cork the two highest recipients in terms of the number of grants paid out. It is also had a hugely positive impact in every county. Almost €400 million has been paid out to over 7,000 recipients so far under the scheme, including over 600 payments in Donegal and over 400 payments across Wexford and Wicklow, for example. </p>
            <p eId="para_277"> The vacant property refurbishment grant provides a payment of up to €50,000 to support the refurbishment of vacant properties for occupation as a principal private residence and for the properties which would be made available for rent, with up to €70,000 available where the property is currently derelict. </p>
            <p eId="para_278"> Under the housing plan, a commitment was given to provide additional supports for refurbishment and conversion of above the shop vacant space for use as homes. The vacant above the shop grant was launched in April 2026, with a package of up to €140,000 being made available for where vacant above the shop space is being converted or refurbished for residential use and the commercial element is remaining. </p>
            <p eId="para_279"> The additional grant amount for these properties recognises the complexities involved in bringing the space into residential use, in particular where a commercial element is being retained. The package includes, for example, an expert advice grant of up to €5,000. The grant is available to individuals and sole traders. It is not currently available to registered companies or developers. The housing plan committed to exploring an extension of the vacant above the shop grant for such properties owned by small micro companies and this work is currently being undertaken.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#BrianBrennan" eId="spk_152">
            <from>Deputy Brian Brennan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_280">I thank the Minister. I warmly welcome his reply. I would encourage him to extend the criteria. The worst thing one can see in any village or town in Ireland is a derelict shop or premises. If such properties were brought back into life, there would be footfall. I am thinking of a towns like Carnew and Arklow in County Wicklow. If properties were refurbished, there would be footfall to keep coffee shops going. The heart and soul of any town or village in Ireland is its main street. There is nothing worse than driving through a town and seeing empty premises spread throughout the streets. It is a cancer in our towns. It is as simple as that. The work that has been done and the grants available are absolutely incredible. I plead with the Minister to expand the criteria because it has an effect on the heart and soul of every town and village in Ireland.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_153" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_281">Again, I thank Deputy Brennan for raising this question. He is right and provided a good example of a village, Carnew, with which I am very familiar. It is a fantastic community and a lovely village that can benefit from these types of supports.</p>
            <p eId="para_282">I want these to benefit all of rural Ireland and make rural Ireland a key plank of what I am doing as Minister for housing. The Deputy can look at the other measures that I and the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, have introduced, for example, on rural one-off housing. We want rural Ireland to thrive and we want people to be able to live there. That means that the main streets in those villages and small towns need to be able to thrive. They have gone through a very difficult period over recent decades as society has changed, and much of the economy that would have supported those main streets has changed as well.</p>
            <p eId="para_283"> In relation to companies, it is important to remember that there are other measures available to companies, such as the repair and leasing scheme, which is very much targeted at use by companies, as well as the living city initiative and other tax offset measures that can be available to companies but would not be available to individuals. There are also the planning exemptions for the conversion of certain commercial properties to residential use.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#BrianBrennan" eId="spk_154">
            <from>Deputy Brian Brennan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_284">I thank the Minister and the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, for their work in this area, but we need to keep the pressure on. On a point I have discussed many times in the House, while we are implementing wonderful laws, it is important that the council carries out work in relation to dereliction, and that this is brought forward. We have to try to support this. The idea is to get as many people as possible working and living in their own towns and villages. The goal for everybody should be to keep our communities, schools and clubs alive by bringing properties back into circulation. That is the key part. We should do everything possible and move every block in front of us in order to get to that situation. I believe that while great work is being done, more could be done. This is an anomaly. If the criteria could be expanded, it would be appreciated. We will see it on the ground, with towns and villages coming to life.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_155" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_285">I take the Deputy’s point. He touched on an important part, which is our local authorities, and why some local authorities are really driving on with the refurbishment grants when others do not seem to be matching the kind of pace and scale that we want to see. We want all of those local authorities to be driving on with what the Department is funding and supporting. However, we have to bear in mind that companies often have advantages that ordinary people or sole traders who get the grants do not have. When they are set up with a company model, although it can depend on the make-up of the individual company, they can avail of significant tax breaks, such as tax write-offs or VAT refunds, for example, when carrying out works, that ordinary people or sole traders may not be able to get the benefit from. We are examining this. We will give it careful consideration.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_8">
            <i> Questions Nos. 155 and 156 taken with Written Answers.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_9">
            <i> Question No. 157 taken with Question No. 148.</i>
          </summary>
          <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_156">
            <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_286">We will go back to Question No. 152 in the name of Deputy Connolly.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_31">
          <heading>Housing Policy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#JohnConnolly" to="#Housing" eId="pq_152">
            <p eId="para_287">152. <b>Deputy John Connolly</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> the consideration he is giving to increasing the income threshold for social housing applicants. [81492/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#JohnConnolly" eId="spk_157">
            <from>Deputy John Connolly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_288">I thank the Chair. Unfortunately, I was late because I was at a committee meeting. I understand the question may have been asked earlier, but I appreciate the opportunity. I ask the Minister to provide details of the consideration he is giving to increasing the income thresholds for social housing applicants. My understanding is that it has been some time since the thresholds were reviewed. We know that more and more people are now in need of housing and housing support because the cost of housing has increased significantly. I ask the Minister to provide an update on his consideration of the issue.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_158" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_289">I thank Deputy Connolly for raising this important matter of increasing the income thresholds for social housing applicants. Applications for social housing support are assessed by the relevant local authority in accordance with the eligibility and need criteria set down in section 20 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2009 and the associated Social Housing Assessment Regulations 2011, as amended. Those regulations prescribe maximum net income limits for each local authority in different bands according to the area concerned, with income being defined and assessed according to a standard household means policy. Local authorities have no discretion to exceed the limits applying to their administrative areas. The policy provides for a range of income disregards, and local authorities also have discretion to disregard income that is once-off, temporary or short-term in nature, and outside the regular pattern of a person’s annual income. The income bands are expressed in terms of maximum net income thresholds for a single-person household, with an allowance of 5% for each additional adult household member, subject to a maximum allowance under this category of 10% and, separately, a 2.5% allowance for each child.</p>
            <p eId="para_290"> The baseline social housing income thresholds are €40,000, €35,000 and €30,000 for bands one, two and three, respectively. These thresholds are net income, that is, gross household income less income tax, PRSI, universal social charge and additional superannuation contributions. My Department has been examining the existing income limits in the context of current market and household income conditions, including the suitability or otherwise of the current framework, having regard to the significantly changed landscape since the standardised income limits were introduced. This includes examining the findings of research commissioned by my Department, and this work is ongoing.</p>
            <p eId="para_291"> In that context, there is an important balance that I, as Minister, and the Government must strike in this regard. On the one hand, increasing eligibility and access to social housing supports has a direct budgetary demand that must be managed in light of the existing and significant investment in housing overall. In parallel, I acknowledge the increase in household income and basic social welfare rates since the last time these limits were updated, together with the continuing affordability challenges that lower-income households overall are experiencing.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_159">
            <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_292">Question No. 152 and Question No. 160 from Deputy Ó Broin are similar. I ask that we take them together.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JohnConnolly" eId="spk_160">
            <from>Deputy John Connolly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_293">That is okay. I welcome the Minister’s answer. I welcome in particular that he mentioned there is research ongoing within his Department on this issue. That is pressing, I feel, and I would like some clarity as to when that research might be concluded and when this can be reviewed. I fully recognise that there will be a budgetary impact of this, which is obvious, but I still think it is necessary. We need to make sure that those people who have the lowest incomes are included in our social housing provision. As the Minister noted, there has been an increase in the minimum wage and social welfare payments, which is pushing people above the threshold. Personally, I feel that, more broadly, we should be including more people in the application process for public housing and providing public housing for more people. I would appreciate an update on that research.</p>
            <p eId="para_294"> The Minister mentioned the bands. It is an issue that has a direct impact on my area, given there are different income bands for Galway City Council and Galway County Council. That is causing difficulty.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_161">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_295">I am genuinely concerned by the change in language in the Minister’s answers to these questions today compared with what he said to us previously. In fact, there has been a significant reduction in HAP expenditure since the Minister’s predecessor, Deputy Darragh O’Brien, increased the thresholds from the start of 2023. If we go from 2022 to last year, there has been a reduction of 8.5% in HAP expenditure, which is €45 million less, and that is despite the income threshold increases. Given the Revised Estimates he is bringing forward, the Minister knows there is a significant drop in expenditure on HAP again in 2026, almost in the same region as the drop over the past five years.</p>
            <p eId="para_296"> The Minister’s talk about budgetary considerations seems to suggest it is unlikely we will see any changes to the social housing income thresholds this year, or until the next budgetary cycle. Will the Minister clarify if that is not the case? Can he also give us some indication of a timeline for a decision? As his colleague said, the bands, particularly band three, make no sense whatsoever. Every single month, people are losing their positions on the list, so there is an urgency about this. Before, we were quite constructive in our dialogue, but I am concerned by the change in language that I am hearing today.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_162" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_297">I thank Deputy Connolly for his question, and also Deputy Ó Broin, who has a similar question. I am glad to have the opportunity to address them. I am simply stating an obvious fact, which is that there is a current expenditure element with an increase in the housing limits or the bands. I very much acknowledge, as I have done a couple of times already today, that the limits were last increased on 1 January 2023, and it is coming up to four years since that happened. Social protection payments have increased in that time, the minimum wage has increased and general wages have increased, but the limits have not kept pace with that. Nonetheless, it does not simply require a stroke of my pen to increase those limits. They bring current expenditure with them. I have a current expenditure budget, and I have to balance that budget in the best way I can, between the different demands on the Department.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JohnConnolly" eId="spk_163">
            <from>Deputy John Connolly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_298">I might use this opportunity to ask the Minister to bring clarity to one other related point. It concerns the impact that the income threshold has on the ability of any person or family to avail of emergency accommodation.</p>
            <p eId="para_299">I rarely do this but I want to bring to the Minister's attention some personal testimony involving a young family with four young children and an expectant mother<b>
							</b>that was brought to me recently. They receive the family income supplement, which has increased. The main income in the family is the minimum wage, which has increased, putting them above the threshold for Galway County Council. Very worryingly, Galway County Council has advised this family that because they are above the income threshold, they are no longer to be offered emergency accommodation. They are homeless. We need clear guidance on this to local authorities. Is the provision of emergency accommodation related to the income thresholds for social housing? It would be very welcome if the Minister could provide that clarity today.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_164">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_300">Of course, when the Minister is taking any decision, if there are budget implications, they have to be considered, but the facts from the last increase in the social housing income thresholds were that it did not lead to an increase in overall expenditure. HAP expenditure reduced. That had nothing to do with the decision. It is the nature of HAP expenditure. The allocation for next year is lower than the original allocation for this year. </p>
            <p eId="para_301"> Even if there is an impact on expenditure, an increasing number of households who are hovering just around the thresholds, particularly in western counties where the base rate is €30,000 for a single person, are in an incredibly precarious position because they have no access to private or cost-rental accommodation. It is also important to note that in the years after Darragh O'Brien last increased the social housing income thresholds, the number of new households coming onto the list, according to the summary of social housing needs assessment, was the same as in the previous years, at about 14,000. Interestingly, therefore, it did not necessarily have the impact of increasing the overall numbers but it did meet people who needed to be on those lists and access those supports. Do we have a timeline? We have been discussing this for a year and there really does need to be some indication of when the Minister hopes to make a decision.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_165" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_302">I again thank both Deputies for their questions and their interest in the income thresholds for social housing. There is both the theoretical and the actual. I remember when the then Minister, Deputy O'Brien, was increasing the social housing limits, concern was expressed that a certain number of people would qualify for HAP and that this would have a significant cost. That did not manifest itself. My view is that as we go further up the limits, the proportion of people who actually want to avail of HAP as a proportion actually shrinks because they will have other means of resolving their housing situation. Therefore, there is both the theoretical number of people entitled to HAP versus those who would actually use it. That is always a challenge I have as a Minister in calculating potential current expenditure. We have to try to establish that. I acknowledge that there is a challenge here but it is one I have to address within my own budget. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#EoinOBroin" eId="spk_166">
            <from>Deputy Eoin Ó Broin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_303">The answer to the other question is "No". There is no link between the two. The county is breaking the housing Acts. </p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_32">
          <heading>Solar Energy Guidelines<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#JamesOConnor" to="#Housing" eId="pq_159">
            <p eId="para_304">159. <b>Deputy James O'Connor</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> if he will outline when his Department will publish planning guidelines for solar farms. [82082/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#PeterRoche" eId="spk_167">
            <from>Deputy Peter Roche<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_305">What progress is being made on dealing with the national planning guidelines for large-scale solar and wind energy developments while wanting to sustain Ireland's clean energy objectives? </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_168" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_306">This is an important question involving national planning policy and guidance for large-scale solar energy developments and wind farm developments to support the delivery of Ireland's clean energy objectives. In line with commitments in the programme for Government 2025, the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment holds policy responsibility for renewable energy matters. It is working with my Department on the preparation of a national planning statement relating to onshore wind and solar energy development. These will support Ireland's climate action plan targets to increase the share of electricity generated from renewable sources to 80% by 2030. The Department of climate is working closely with my Department to identify the factors relevant to the preparation of both national policy statements, including appropriate environmental reporting, public consultation requirements and European obligations such as the renewable energy directive, otherwise known as RED III. </p>
            <p eId="para_307"> For wind energy, this includes considerations such as noise, setback distance, shadow flicker, community obligation, community dividend and grid connections. The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment, which has primary responsibility for environmental noise matters, has been working to advance guidance on the highly technical areas to my Department for the drafting of the national planning statement. This work is substantially complete. Both Departments are committed to advancing this work as quickly as possible with a view to establishing a draft public consultation as soon as possible. However, this is subject to statutory environmental assessments being carried out and appropriate approval requirements. In the interim, the current 2006 wind energy development guidelines remain in force. </p>
            <p eId="para_308"> The scoping process for the solar energy development national planning segment is at an early stage. However, I am satisfied that the existing and evolving planning system, supported by wider Government policy, provides a framework, again working with the Department of climate, which holds the policy control in this area. Proposals for individual solar developments remain subject to the statutory requirements of the planning and development Acts and are considered by relevant planning authorities and An Coimisiún Pleanála as appropriate. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PeterRoche" eId="spk_169">
            <from>Deputy Peter Roche<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_309">I appreciate that a lot of work is happening. Like many other representatives in this House, I have been hearing for some time that the planning guidelines, particularly pertaining to wind energy developments where there are turbines 185 m high, were to be furnished last spring. We heard in more recent times that they would arrive before Christmas. What I and others like me want to know is when we can expect the new planning guidelines pertaining to both wind and solar to be made available. I am aware that it will be a draft that is published and it will invite public consultation, but I want to know if at all possible when I can anticipate telling my constituents that the planning guidelines for the 185 m high turbines are <i>in situ</i>. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_170" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_310">I certainly hear the Deputy's concerns relating to this area and I know he has raised this matter on a couple of occasions. My Department is working with the Department of climate, which holds responsibility for the policy decisions in key aspects of wind energy such as high setback, etc. Nonetheless, it is my own Department, through a national planning statement, that then translates those policies into planning rules to ensure that both the correct language and consistency are used and that there are no contradictions with other planning rules. Any other Department that has policies that require a national planning statement works out the policy and then feeds it into our own Department for implementation. We are working with the Department of climate, which is working very carefully. The guidelines are at an advanced stage but there are a lot of considerations and there has to be public consultation. Significant environmental considerations need to be taken into account, involving processes and procedures that will have to be gone through once we have a draft. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PeterRoche" eId="spk_171">
            <from>Deputy Peter Roche<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_311">I appreciate that, but it does not change my mind. I am quite anxious at this point that the promises made by this Government, that the planning guidelines would be published, will be realised. I appreciate and respect all the anomalies with regard to environmental considerations. The Minister indicated that the body of work is almost complete. I would appreciate if that could be expedited to the end. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_172" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_312">I assure the Deputy that this is a priority for both Departments. We understand the importance and implications around ensuring that it is done effectively and as quickly as possible. Nonetheless, there are legal processes, especially under environmental rules in European law, that we must abide by. We have to go through those processes. Unfortunately, they do take time, but we have to go through them to ensure we have a robust framework in place. </p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="question" eId="dbsect_33">
          <heading>Housing Provision<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <question by="#ShayBrennan" to="#Housing" eId="pq_158">
            <p eId="para_313">158. <b>Deputy Shay Brennan</b> asked the <b>Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage</b> for an update on the starter home supports delivered to date in 2026. [81682/26]</p>
          </question>
          <speech by="#JoeCooney" eId="spk_173">
            <from>Deputy Joe Cooney<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_314">Following recent amendments to the defective concrete blocks scheme, it is very likely the number of appeals will increase. I know families in Clare who have withdrawn appeals after waiting 13 months without progress, while one family are approaching three years of waiting for a decision. Given the existing delays and the likely increase in the number of appeals to come, what additional resources will the Minister provide to the appeals panel? </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_174" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T11:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_315">I thank Deputy Cooney for raising a very important question, one he has raised on multiple occasions.</p>
            <p eId="para_316">It relates to defective concrete block appeals panels and ensuring they are adequately resourced to deal with the expected increase in appeals arising from the recent amendments to the scheme. Those appeals may increase as a result of the changes we have made to ensure that the defective concrete blocks proposals are effective for people who need them under the block grant scheme. One hundred and ninety-nine appeals have been submitted to date. I assure the Deputy that funding for additional administrative resources within the panel itself has previously been provided by my Department to assist it and ensure it can carry out its work. We will continue to do so to ensure those decisions are made as quickly as possible.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JoeCooney" eId="spk_175">
            <from>Deputy Joe Cooney<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_317">Each time I raise concerns about delays, I am told the appeals panel is statutorily independent in decision-making. I fully accept that. However, being independent in decision-making is not the same as being independent of operational oversight of how long decisions are taken. This points to whether the panel is resourced properly. The Department website lists seven members on the panel. Appeals are heard by boards of three, meaning two boards can operate at the same time. The legislation allows for up to ten members. That could allow three boards to operate, increasing concurrent hearing capacity to 50%. Families are stressed out living in damaged homes, sometimes for years, without knowing how or when they can move forward while costs are also increasing. Given the delays we know about, why has the panel not been expanded to its complement of ten? </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JamesBrowne" eId="spk_176" as="#Minister_for_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy James Browne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_318">I thank the Deputy for his important question about defective concrete block appeals. I accept there was a slowness at the beginning in hearing those appeals. Adequate resources are with the appeals panel. Decisions are now being made quickly. I assure the Deputy that we are closely monitoring those decisions to ensure they are being made in a timely fashion and moving as quickly as possible. I thank the Deputy. </p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_10">
            <i> Is féidir teacht ar Cheisteanna Scríofa ar www.oireachtas.ie.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_11">
            <i> Written Answers are published on the Oireachtas website.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_34">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_177">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_319">Aréir, vótáil an Rialtas seo in aghaidh deis a thabhairt do mhuintir na hÉireann a dtuairimí a thabhairt ar a phlean deireadh a chur leis an glas triarach. Ba gníomh náireach a bhí anseo. Cad é an fáth a bhfuil an Rialtas chomh scanraithe roimh na daoine. Caithfidh sé tuairim an phobail a lorg. Cuir an cheist seo ar na daoine i reifreann agus lig don phobal an cinneadh a dhéanamh.</p>
          <p eId="para_320"> Last night, the Government voted to block the Irish people having their say on its plan to abolish the triple lock. That was a shameful act. Removing the triple lock paves the way for this Government, or any future Government, to send Irish troops anywhere in the world, and potentially to any conflict in the world, without a UN resolution. This represents a fundamental and potentially catastrophic shift in Ireland's foreign policy. It is a decisive move away from our proud tradition of peacekeeping towards military alignment. Such a decision will have serious and far-reaching consequences for Ireland, for this generation and for those to come. It is not for the Government, or indeed for Micheál Martin, to make this call. This right lies with the Irish people and the Irish people only. We have heard the spin, the excuses from the Government, the repeated efforts to muddy the waters, and they all fall away under scrutiny. The undeniable reality is that this is about hitching Ireland to the EU's rush to rearm, pouring hundreds of billions of euro into weapons of war and deeper militarisation at a time when working people are struggling to pay the bills and build affordable lives.</p>
          <p eId="para_321"> The Government's position is that the triple lock will keep Ireland's neutrality intact. That is not true. There was a time when Fine Gael was more honest about its intentions. "Fine Gael sets course to end neutrality". That is the headline from <i>The Irish Times</i> in 2003 covering the publication of the party's policy beyond neutrality. Fine Gael described Ireland's neutrality as a sham. Enda Kenny, in a keynote speech at the time, said, "Fine Gael does not regret the end of neutrality". That document called for the abolition of the triple lock as a key step in moving Ireland away from neutrality. Now, in 2026, the Government wants the people to believe that scrapping the triple lock will leave neutrality untouched. That is completely and utterly dishonest, and the Tánaiste knows it.</p>
          <p eId="para_322"> The stand-out development for me has been how Fine Gael has managed to co-opt Fianna Fáil leadership into adopting its policy to end Ireland's neutrality. We have heard quote after quote from former Fianna Fáil leaders and senior figures who rightly in the past cited the importance of the triple lock. Today, the Fianna Fáil leader, Micheál Martin, seeks to scrap that core neutrality, rowing in behind the Fine Gael position. It says it all that not one representative of Fianna Fáil was prepared to stand up in the debate this week to defend that position. Indeed, not one of them actually turned up for the debate. Scrapping the triple lock is wrong. It represents a fundamental and dangerous attack on Ireland's neutrality. Pushing ahead with it without a mandate from the people is betrayal. </p>
          <p eId="para_323"> I have a simple question for the Tánaiste. Why is this Government so afraid of the Irish people? Why is it denying them their say on the Government's plan to scrap the triple lock? It must seek their permission. It should have the courage of its so-called convictions. If the Tánaiste did have the guts, he would have no problem standing up there, facing me down and saying that he has no doubt the Irish people will back him and that he will put it to the people. I will tell him this: if the Government puts it to the people, they will give it a resounding "No". They want our neutrality intact. They do not support the Government's plan to end neutrality. They do not support its plan to end the triple lock.</p>
          <p eId="para_324"> Put it to the people. Let the people have their say. Not me or the Tánaiste; let the Irish people determine this issue. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_178">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_325">I can assure Deputy Doherty that I have no issue facing him down any day of the week and particularly when it comes to a lecture about Óglaigh na hÉireann or the Defence Forces in this country. It is very clear that the triple lock is broken. It is very clear that is not working and that we need to fix it. This is actually about taking back control of our sovereignty. Why he would want a situation where he would trust governments of foreign countries more than the national Parliament in this country is really beyond me. The idea that we would continue to outsource decisions as to where to send Irish peacekeepers to the UN Security Council, where imperialist powers like Russia hold a veto over where they are deployed, simply does not make any sense. It is not just a veto on our sovereignty; it becomes an effective veto on our long and proud history of peacekeeping. What these changes will do is allow us to renew our peacekeeping. In many practical ways, as the Members all know, if we do not do this, it will very seriously limit the ability of men and women in Óglaigh na hÉireann to participate in peacekeeping missions.</p>
          <p eId="para_326"> I do not know about the Deputy, but I have been in Lebanon. I have been in Camp Shamrock and on the Blue Line. I have watched the incredible pride and distinction with which men and women of Óglaigh na hÉireann serve. I do not want them to have to leave right now. I do not believe the people of this country want them to leave right now, but they have to leave because President Trump and President Putin want them to leave. That is not sovereignty, it is cowardice. It is deciding that this mature Republic cannot make decisions about our own Defence Forces ourselves, without asking Donald, Vladimir or somebody else if it is all right. That is not a way for a mature republic to behave. The Deputy does not need to believe me or listen to me. He should listen to the only Member of this House who has actually served abroad with the UN on a peacekeeping mission, Deputy Catherine Callaghan. He should listen to Cathal Berry, our former Independent colleague in this House-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_179">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_327">He is a lobbyist. </p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_12">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_180">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_328">He served the country and wore a uniform. Has Deputy Murphy? Can he show a modicum of respect? </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_181">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_329">People did not like what he had to say. They voted him out. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_182">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_330">Can the Deputy show a modicum of respect----- </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_183">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_331">Please, Deputy Murphy, some order. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_184">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_332">-----for people who wear the uniform of this country and serve with distinction? He should listen to the views of the former Chief of Staff Mark Mellett. He should listen to expert analysts like Declan Power and to people who know what they are talking about-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_185">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_333">Listen to the people. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_186">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_334">------and who have been on the front line of peacekeeping missions, where Deputy Murphy has never been-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_187">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_335">Or Tom Clonan. I would listen to Tom Clonan. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_188">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_336">-----nor has he ever visited them. These are people who have served with distinction.</p>
          <p eId="para_337"> This is not a radical concept. It is a very basic concept that decisions that are made about where we deploy peacekeepers are made in this House, not in the Duma or the White House. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AengusOSnodaighSF" eId="spk_189">
          <from>Deputy Aengus Ó Snodaigh<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_338">Or not in Brussels. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_190">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_339">That is an entirely appropriate thing to do.</p>
          <p eId="para_340"> The issue of a referendum is a legitimate point to raise, but let us also be honest around the issue. We have only ever had referendums in this country when we have adopted a Constitution, added to or subtracted from a Constitution, or when we have tried to delete or reform something in the Constitution. There is nothing changing in this Constitution. As Deputy Doherty knows, Article 29.4 in the Constitution, which he and most of the others in the Opposition voted against, although the Labour Party did not, is very clear. I cannot decide, the Opposition cannot decide and this place cannot decide to join common defence alliances. It is there in Article 29.4. Nothing changes.</p>
          <p eId="para_341"> Please tell the people the truth. The Minister for Defence had to come into this House last week and the Taoiseach had to come in this week. Think about why they had to do this.</p>
          <p eId="para_342">The misinformation you are spreading is putting troops at risk. It is putting Irish men and women serving today at risk because you are spreading lies and mistruths about them.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_191">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_343">Shameful.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_192">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_344">Shame on you. Let us have an honest debate. This Constitution means we cannot join common defences and it is not changing.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_193">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_345">We can join NATO though.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_194">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_346">Nothing in the legislation changes it but without it, we are limiting the opportunities for this country to continue its proud peacekeeping service and limiting the opportunities of the men and women of Óglaigh na hÉireann to have those chances to serve abroad with distinction. We have their back, we support them and shame on you for misinforming people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_195">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_347">Does the Tánaiste know who I listen to? I listen to Senator Tom Clonan.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_13">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_196">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_348">Have a bit of respect when I am telling you what he said. He commanded Irish peacekeeping troops in Lebanon under fire. What did he tell the Irish people? He said that you and Micheál Martin are putting those troops at risk because you are ending the triple lock. That comes from a commander of Irish peacekeepers in the line of fire, not me and not you. What you are doing here is Fine Gael's long-term ambition to end neutrality and you have found a willing accomplice in Micheál Martin.</p>
          <p eId="para_349"> Fine Gael used to be honest about this. Your former Taoiseach was very clear. Fine Gael does not regret the end of neutrality. The problem is that you are dishonest. You will not tell the Irish people what you really intend because ending the triple lock, as you pointed out in your policy, is the first step in eroding neutrality. It should not be for you or even me to decide this matter. It is for the Irish people because this is a big issue. Former governments gave a solemn commitment in different referendums that the triple lock would remain. If you have any guts and any convictions in what you stand for-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_197">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_350">Thank you, Deputy Doherty.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_198">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_351">-----and if you believe the Irish people are with you on this, then put it to the people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_199">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_352">Resume your seat, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_200">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_353">Let us have a referendum. Let us go on the campaign. Let the Irish people decide whether they believe in Fine Gael's policy-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_201">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_354">Deputy Doherty, please conclude.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_202">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_355">----- of ending neutrality-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_203">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_356">The Tánaiste to respond.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_204">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_357">-----or if they believe in where we stand here on this side of the House-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_205">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_358">Deputy Doherty, resume your seat.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_206">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_359">-----that neutrality is a core principle that needs to be protected.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_207">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_360">First, stop misrepresenting the Taoiseach. We should have an honest debate. The Taoiseach of this country established the Commission on the Future of the Defence Forces. The Taoiseach of this country has been very truthful and honest with the people in relation to the triple lock, time and again. When we went into the last general election, there was no doubt about what Micheál Martin's position was in relation to the triple lock and you should not misrepresent the Taoiseach in his absence. I encourage you to say it to his face because it is not true.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_208">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_361">He is a willing accomplice. I will say it to his face any day. He is toeing the line of Fine Gael.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_209">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_362">Deputy Doherty, allow the Tánaiste to respond.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_210">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_363">He is Fine Gael's lapdog now. Your backbenchers know that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_211">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_364">Continue, Tánaiste.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_212">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_365">Go raibh maith agat, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. I will.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_213">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_366">And Tom Clonan, what did he say?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_214">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_367">Deputy Doherty, these bullyboy tactics-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_215">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_368">Deputy Doherty, please.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_216">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_369">Stop bullying me and stop roaring and shouting across the Chamber. Just allow me to speak, please. We have a provision in our Constitution. You voted against it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_217">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_370">Tom Clonan.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_218">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_371">You voted not to do it. You have scaremongered the people in every EU referendum.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_219">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_372">What do you say to Tom Clonan?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_220">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_373">There has never been an EU referendum where Sinn Féin has not told the people of Ireland that we are sending their kids to war.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_221">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_374">What do you say to Tom Clonan?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_222">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_375">There are not many parties in this House that actually ask kids to take up arms.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_223">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_376">Put it to the people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_224">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_377">Thank you very much.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_225">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_378">You will excuse me for not being able to take a lecture from you on defence and security.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_226">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_379">Put it to the people. Have some gumption.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_227">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_380">This is a simple measure to reform the triple lock.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_228">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_381">Show some backbone. Put it to the people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_229">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_382">Deputy Doherty, allow the Tánaiste to conclude. He is not going to listen.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_230">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_383">Am I allowed to start? I will conclude but I will conclude when I am given an opportunity to speak in this House and am not shouted down.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_231">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_384">Resume your seat then.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_232">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_385">I welcome the fact Sinn Féin now recognises that there is only one Óglaigh na hÉireann in this country. We should trust this Parliament in terms of where it is going-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_233">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_386">What about Tom Clonan?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_234">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_387">----- and not foreign governments.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_235">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_388">Put it to the people. God bless Fine Gael.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_236">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_389">Let me put this to the people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_237">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_390">Absolutely. Let the people decide.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_238">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_391">Deputy Doherty, please-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PearseDoherty" eId="spk_239">
          <from>Deputy Pearse Doherty<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_392">Do not wave the Constitution at me.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_240">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_393">Do not reply. Direct your remarks through the Chair.</p>
          <p eId="para_394"> I want to say this to everyone in the House. On a regular basis-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnCummins" eId="spk_241">
          <from>Deputy John Cummins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_395">Come on, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_242">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_396">Stop pointing your finger. I say this to everyone in the House. Letters of complaint come in from people who view this. The one thing they ask is when the Chair tries to call order why the other Member or the offending Member does not sit down and does not respect the Chair. They constantly ask that. The next question after that is what we can do about it. In fact, there is very little the Chair can do about it and Members should know that. Whoever is in this Chair is relying on whoever is speaking on the floor to conduct themselves and to ensure they abide by Standing Orders. I ask Members to do that because from the correspondence I receive, the public are not happy with the way we conduct our business on a Thursday.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#" eId="spk_243">
          <from> Deputies<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_397">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" eId="spk_244" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach">
          <from>Deputy Mark Wall<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_398">As parents, the Tánaiste and I both know there is nothing we would not try to do for our children. That is why I am raising today major problems with the fuel allowance scheme. It is punishing some of the most vulnerable people in the country and impacting their children. There was a lot of focus on the Tánaiste's Ard-Fheis comments about the long-term unemployed. He said that social welfare must always be there for the people who need support. I hope he will listen carefully and take action today. In his speech, he did not mention the cost of energy and how Fine Gael would lower prices. I remind him that there is a cost-of-living crisis in this country.</p>
          <p eId="para_399"> Hundreds of thousands of families across the country do not know how they will heat their homes this winter. Between gas and electricity combined, more than half a million households are in arrears. What was there in the budget to help? There was no sign of the much-needed energy credits. Even the broke British Government could manage the targeted £100 household energy payment and it scrapped gas network standing charges.</p>
          <p eId="para_400"> The budget here provided for a €5 a week increase in fuel allowance but it stripped away the four extra weeks given last March. Most worryingly, the income limit was only increased for single people over 66 and this is where the problem is. A full review of the fuel allowance means test is badly needed. Based on the cases I am hearing across the country, many families and households are either having their fuel allowance taken from them or being refused. Figures from 2025 show that over 12,000 people were refused fuel allowance. The Department does not record the reasons for refusal or whether they were previously in receipt. That needs to change.</p>
          <p eId="para_401"> We have a housing crisis with 18,000 homeless. I have lost count of the number of older people in touch with my office losing their fuel allowance when their adult child has had to move back home. It would cost the State far more if it had to provide housing supports for those adults. As I said earlier, as parents, we would do anything for our children but it is costing them their heat now. If they were in receipt of HAP, it would be over €750 a month for a single person. It is penny wise and pound foolish.</p>
          <p eId="para_402"> People who need support are not getting it. I could list dozens of cases but the common thread is people struggling to get by, trying to help their children who are struggling. I raised the matter with the Minister this week during the debate on the Social Welfare Bill. In fairness, the Minister, Deputy Calleary, agreed to take a look at a number of examples while telling me that this could significantly change the household base target for the scheme next year. I do not agree, given the examples coming into my office. I am now asking Tánaiste to intervene as the Minister for Finance and leader of Fine Gael. He rightly said that social welfare must always be there for the people who need it most. Will he agree to extend the limits for adults and carry out a full review of the means test for fuel allowance to address the hard cases where people are losing out by a few euro in income and those who provide a roof over the head of a family member?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_245">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_403">I thank Deputy Wall for raising the issue. I also thank him for referencing my comments on social welfare in a much more balanced way than I have heard them referenced on some previous occasions. I note with interest that the Labour Party government in the UK has taken a very similar approach in recognising that we should never be satisfied leaving anyone languishing on social welfare and we should always aspire to help people at every opportunity. When Fine Gael and Labour were in government together, the former Labour Party leader, Joan Burton, took a very similar approach. So, I welcome the opportunity to discuss this.</p>
          <p eId="para_404"> The Deputy has made a constructive suggestion. He will understand why on the floor of the Dáil I will not commit the Minister, Deputy Calleary, or the Government to further changes on the fuel allowance. The point he has made deserves a fair hearing. We have already brought about a number of changes to try to improve the fuel allowance system. I can quote that more people than ever before are receiving the fuel allowance. There have been changes to means tests in recent years to make sure that is the case. We have made changes in relation to older people because the cost of heating the home is the same, regardless of whether there are two people or one person living in the house. If the husband or wife passes away, the surviving spouse was losing the fuel allowance. That is one anomaly that was highlighted in this House and we have now acted on it. The Deputy made the point that we have also increased the rate.</p>
          <p eId="para_405"> I am sympathetic to his broad point that a person whose adult child moves back into the home might themselves tipped over the limit. The Deputy is asking that we look at that. I know he raised that with the Minister for Social Protection this week and I am sure he will give that consideration in future iterations. We have taken a number of measures in the here and now to try to assist people with their fuel costs, the fuel allowance being one.</p>
          <p eId="para_406">There is also the reduction in the VAT rate on people's gas and electricity bills to 9% and leaving it there for quite a number of years. There have been reductions in the carbon tax on home heating oil and gas and, obviously, the reductions in excise on petrol and diesel. We are also trying to help people through a variety of other ways. We cannot just help with the energy costs through energy measures, whether that is reducing people's income tax bills from the new year or reducing people's childcare costs during 2027. All those issues need to be looked at in the round. On foot of the Deputy raising the issue in the Chamber today, I will certainly ask that the Minister, Deputy Calleary, continues to engage with him on this. We never want to see - none of us should ever want to see - anomalies or poverty drops that exist within the system when, as the Deputy said, any parent would do anything they can to help their child.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" eId="spk_246" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach">
          <from>Deputy Mark Wall<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_407">I thank the Tánaiste. I want to give him an example of what I am talking about. I know of a mother who is on disability allowance. Her son turned 18 and she lost the fuel allowance. Another mother aged 70 with a husband aged 73 has medical equipment that eats up electricity. Their adult child has additional needs but works part-time, which is his lifeline. They do not qualify for fuel allowance. I know of a father on disability allowance whose daughter is working two and a half days per week while she is in college. They lost their fuel allowance. The most recent budget extended the fuel allowance to carers but figures provided to me show that only 4% of the recipients qualified for fuel allowance. It is simply not good enough for the carers who are saving this State €20 billion each year. I also know of many bereaved widows and partners who are being excluded from the fuel allowance. The Tánaiste mentioned that himself. This system needs reform. People are suffering. People are cold. They need flexibility and the system needs to be flexible. At the moment, it is not and too many people are on the outside.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_247">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_408">As a rule, I do not like to stand up and argue against points in which there is logic and there is logic in the point the Deputy is making. When we have a means test, the downside of any means test is there are always people who just come out the other side of it. We obviously need to continue to keep these things under review. We have increased the level of means in recent budgets and that has brought more people in. We have ensured that around 50,000 additional households now benefit from fuel allowance as a result of measures we have taken over the course of the last 12 months too. I accept there is always more to do, however. The Deputy made the point about the child - who will always be the parents' child - who reaches adulthood and tips the family over the balance, or the person who takes up a few hours of part-time work, is not an unfair point. We will continue to look for opportunities to reform and enhance the fuel allowance system but also, crucially, to make sure there are not these anomalies that exist. I would argue that we have taken a number of them out in recent years but I am happy to constructively further engage with the Deputy and I will ask the Minister to do that also. I thank the Deputy for highlighting those examples to me.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_248">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_409">I welcome everyone to the Public Gallery, particularly students from Carlow, Danesfort and Presentation Secondary School Kilkenny, who are here with Deputy Newsome Drennan. I welcome them all and hope they enjoy their day in Leinster House.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_249">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_410">I want to congratulate the Tánaiste.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_250">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_411">I doubt it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_251">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_412">For more than 20 years, his party has been trying to get rid of neutrality and is now weeks away from striking a massive blow against it. In 2003, the Tánaiste's party produced a policy document, Beyond Neutrality, which advocated abandoning our long-standing commitment to neutrality, which is a principled stance treasured by the Irish people since James Connolly declared, "neither king nor kaiser, but Ireland", and blocked conscription into the British Army during the First World War. At the centre of the Beyond Neutrality policy was a proposal to scrap the triple lock, which it described as a "political straitjacket" . The Tánaiste calls it a straitjacket; I call it guardrails. However, the Tánaiste is right that it stops the Government of the day sending troops wherever it wants or wherever the US or NATO asks it to. It ensures that our troops can only be sent on genuine UN peacekeeping missions.</p>
          <p eId="para_413"> A certain Deputy Micheál Martin captured it well in 2013 in the Dáil, saying:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_414">It appears that Fine Gael is arguing that Ireland is failing in its European responsibilities and is allowing Russia and China to have a veto over our peacekeeping activities. [Sound familiar?] This is nothing more than an out-of-touch ideological obsession on the part of Fine Gael. [It is a pity that ideological obsession is now shared.] The current policy works and it has complete popular legitimacy. There is no reason whatsoever to change it.</p>
          <p eId="para_415"> Whatever the Tánaiste has done, it has worked. Micheál Martin is now more Blueshirt than the Blueshirts themselves. He has completely converted to a Redmondite outlook on the world. The Tánaiste is not there yet, however.</p>
          <p eId="para_416"> Public opinion is stubbornly pro-neutrality and that public opinion is mobilising right across the country. Thousands of people will attend an Irish Neutrality League protest this Saturday at 2 p.m. at the Garden of Remembrance. The number of telephone calls, emails and visits to TDs is going to grow and grow. That public opinion is now having an effect on the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil, some of whom are beginning to realise that Micheál Martin is making them indistinguishable from Fine Gael. Deputy O'Dea and nine other Fianna Fáil TDs have put forward an amendment proposing that soldiers could only be sent abroad in line with a UN General Assembly resolution approved by a majority of the world's states. This takes the Security Council out of it entirely. Will the Government support that amendment? If it rejects it, it has exposed the reality that this has never been about a supposed Security Council veto by Russia, China or anyone else. It is about freeing the Government up to act without any regard to the United Nations and without any regard to international law. The Government claims, quite ridiculously, that it wants to get rid of the triple lock in order to be able to do peacekeeping. Will it stop misleading the people? Will it admit that the only reason to get rid of it is so that it can send troops on missions that have nothing to do with genuine peacekeeping? Crucially, will it allow the people to decide on such an important question?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_252">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_417">I thank Deputy Murphy. I should have known when he said he was congratulating me that there was going to be a twist on where he was going with this. I could see that one coming.</p>
          <p eId="para_418"> Let me be very clear. Anybody who wants to speak about the geopolitical world and suggest that the world in 2026 is the same as the world in 2013 has missed a hell of a lot of developments. Peacekeeping in Lebanon was not a risk in 2013. I always thought there was a political consensus in this House, and I do not mean this rudely, maybe not from the Deputy but from most people - maybe from him, I do not know - and most parties that we wanted to be able to participate in peacekeeping in Lebanon. I do not know how many Members of the Oireachtas have been there. More should go there. I have been there. That is going to have to end now. What is the Deputy's solution? Other than me walking in to the UN, banging on the table and saying, "Reform the Security Council" and hoping everyone says, "Grand, we will do that, Simon", what does he think we should do to support the people of Lebanon in January when that peacekeeping mission ends in about 12 months' time? What should we do? Should we just say, "Goodnight, good luck. We are out of here, best of luck"? That is not what the Irish people want to do. It is certainly not what the many brave men and women of Óglaigh na hÉireann have worked for extensively and for which some have lost their lives. It is not what I wish to do in their names either.</p>
          <p eId="para_419"> The Deputy referenced "king nor kaiser". The reality is there is an irony in that because while we might not have kaisers, in maintaining the triple lock, we are continuing to outsource decisions about the deployment of Irish troops to others. We factually are. The Deputy can agree or disagree with whether that is a good idea or a bad idea, but it is true. It is true that, today, we cannot send peacekeepers abroad, except in very narrow circumstances and numbers, without the mandate of the UN Security Council. It is true-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_253">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_420">Or the General Assembly.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_254">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_421">Which the Deputy also knows has not happened. It is true that there is a small number of member states of the UN Security Council that have a veto in relation to that and it is true that those countries include Russia, China and the US. Those things are true. The Deputy and I can debate whether they are good or bad or right or wrong, but they are true. Why can we not trust ourselves as a Dáil - the people democratically elected by Ireland - to make decisions? I hear so much about sovereignty, pride in the country and a mature republic. However, is it a mature republic that has to ask, "Is that okay, Vladimir?" or "Are you all right with that, Donald?" Come on. I do not want to be particularly offensive on this, but the Deputy has never seen a discussion about defence, security or foreign policy where he has not said that we are all going to war. He never has. Every European debate, every referendum and every discussion, he brings us down this neutrality cul-de-sac.</p>
          <p eId="para_422"> I am the leader of Fine Gael. The Fine Gael policy is very clear in relation to neutrality. We fully support it. The world has changed. We do not want to change neutrality at all. Neutrality is a really important part of our foreign policy. There is no proposal to change that. The Constitution provides protection in terms of the common defence around Article 29.4. It really does. Let us have a rational debate around it. We can have different views in relation to it but nobody is being sent to war and nobody's children are being sent to war, we are not joining NATO and military neutrality is not in danger. Can we at least just be truthful in relation to that?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_255">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_423">Yes, let us be truthful, so the Tánaiste might please answer the question. Will he support the amendment from the Fianna Fáil backbenchers?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_256">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_424">I am sorry, I meant to answer that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_257">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_425">It gets at the reality that it is not the triple lock that states we cannot send troops anywhere we want to do what we call peacekeeping. It is something called international law.</p>
          <p eId="para_426">The UN Charter is absolutely clear. Troops can be sent abroad to do peacekeeping when it is agreed by the United Nations. That can happen at the Security Council or the General Assembly. If the Government rejects this amendment they are proving to people that this is nothing to do with real peacekeeping whatsoever.</p>
          <p eId="para_427"> The second point is about why we cannot trust you. Jesus, I do not know why we might not be able to trust you. Maybe it is because you have been campaigning to get rid of neutrality for more than 20 years. Why can we not trust you? Maybe it is because when the US invaded Iraq the Government allowed them to use Shannon Airport to facilitate that invasion. It allowed millions of troops to go through. Why can we not trust you? Maybe it is because I think it is two years since I handed the Tánaiste a folder with examples of all the munitions illegally transported through our airspace and he has not done a single thing about it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_258">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_428">Thank you, Deputy Murphy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_259">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_429">Why can we not trust you? It is because you are absolutely in hock to one agenda. We say neither king nor kaiser. We say neither Washington nor Beijing and neither Brussels nor Moscow. However, this Government is aligned to-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_260">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_430">Deputy Murphy, resume your seat.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_261">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_431">It wants to get us aligned with them. The Tánaiste should answer the question and be clear the Lebanon mission he is proposing has absolutely nothing to do-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#" eId="spk_262">
          <from> A Deputy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_432">That is their second Leaders' Questions</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_263">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_433">Deputy Murphy. I call the Tánaiste.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_264">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_434">The Minister for Defence said clearly in this House on Second Stage that she will consider and work through amendments that people engage with. That is why we have debates and discussions in this House. We have Government TDs in both parties and Independents who constructively contribute to debates, and we have Opposition TDs who constructively contribute to debates. Of course, Ministers will come to Committee Stage and Report Stage to tease through the issues. Ministers will decide if they need to bring forward amendments or whether there is merit in other amendments. That is how democracy works. It is not about trusting me or the Deputy. He and I do not agree on too much, or on very little anyway. It is about trusting the Irish people. They elect the Deputy. They elect me. They elect this Parliament.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_265">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_435">Let them vote then.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_266">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_436">They elect us here.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_267">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_437">The Government does not have a mandate for this.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_268">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_438">Deputy Murphy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_269">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_439">We had President Zelenskyy here. I am not even sure if the Deputy gave him a round of applause. His position on foreign policy is so out of touch with where the majority of people are.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_270">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_440">Check with the people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_271">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_441">It is really confusing that he has now found himself in a position where he believes that other countries should start taking decisions as to where to send our troops. He would not have us in the European Union. He would not have us involved in any peacekeeping mission. I think he is neutral at best on Ukraine. His foreign policy is out of line. He tries to present it reasonably in this House. It is extreme. It is extreme left and it is not in line with middle Ireland. They know-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_272">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_442">Let the people decide.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_273">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_443">They have decided. They have elected this Parliament-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMurphy" eId="spk_274">
          <from>Deputy Paul Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_444">The Government has no mandate for this.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_275">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_445">-----and we have a mandate to make decisions and laws. We have no mandate to change this without the people and there is nothing in this being changed.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardBoydBarrett" eId="spk_276">
          <from>Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_446">No mandate for us to change our neutrality.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardODonoghue" eId="spk_277">
          <from>Deputy Richard O'Donoghue<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_447">I raise 31 houses that were purchased in Limerick county. Eleven of the houses were kept by Clúid and 18 were purchased by Limerick City and County Council. Two were incremental and affordable through financing by Limerick City and County Council. In 2023, shortly after these houses were purchased they showed issues with defects. Recently, Limerick county council has taken on the works to repair its stock of 18 of these houses, and they are only three and a half years old. The developer that built these houses did not enter into any dialogue and left the local authority to fix the houses. To date, these houses have cost Limerick City and County Council, our taxpayers and the Government €100,000. This developer is now building in Cork, Kerry and Limerick. These houses were signed off by engineers. The contractors did their work, but the developer is responsible for the development and has walked away from it and left the cost.</p>
          <p eId="para_448"> My question is not against any developers because we want to build houses. I am a contractor myself. We want to buy houses, build houses and get houses for people who need them, but we want a quality build. If there was a defect they should own up to their responsibility and fix it. Three and a half years down the line they have ignored it. Now it is costing the State €100,000 in three and a half years, but this person is still giving houses to our local authorities, not only in Limerick but in other counties, and they are being signed off by engineers. We now have an issue where a woman who bought the 19th house under the affordable scheme, purchased by Limerick county council, has a defect in her house and is being told to take it up with the developer. She is in the middle of two of the houses. There are local authority houses either side of her, but the county council signed off on the house and on the loan to give her the house, so they should fix the defect and go after the developer.</p>
          <p eId="para_449"> These houses have to be built to quality. Anybody supplying houses to our Government and local authorities has to have an engineer's check. I want the engineers who signed off on these houses checked. I want the developer who signed off on these houses checked and I want accountability. This person and their development company should not have any house awarded until all houses are checked and he pays back the €100,000 to Limerick county council for the defects that have been found in these houses.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_278">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_450">I thank the Deputy for raising this matter and the manner in which he has raised it. He will understand that I am not across all of the details - far from it. I obviously do not want to say anything that cuts across processes other than to say that the issue he has highlighted is a serious one and one of great distress to the homeowners he referenced. I am conscious the Deputy is knowledgeable in these areas from a professional point of view. Generally, there are issues in relation to bonds and rules about being taken in charge. In the first instance, it would be for the local authority to satisfy itself and if necessary to engage with relevant regulatory authorities and-or the Department of housing.</p>
          <p eId="para_451"> The Deputy is right that we all want to build houses but we need to make sure they are quality homes and are safe and secure. I say that without prejudice to these homes, which I do not know about. That is why there is a commitment in the programme for Government to establish a new building standards agency to try to pull all of this together. In fact, I think recruitment for the head of that agency is under way as the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, informs me. In the first instance, I suggest engagement with the local authority, and for the local authority to engage with Government, should there be issues that Government or the regulatory authorities need to be aware of. That would be useful so we can establish the facts. As the Deputy said, there are rules. I do not know the details of this case but there are rules and standards and professionals who need to be involved in signing off on certain projects. It is important that the responsibility each part of that chain has is exercised rather than it being heaped back onto the taxpayer or the poor individual homeowner. I am happy to receive further information from the Deputy in that regard.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardODonoghue" eId="spk_279">
          <from>Deputy Richard O'Donoghue<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_452">County councillors in that district, including from the Tánaiste's party, before these houses were purchased, advised the local authority to be aware and it did not listen. People in the local authority raised concerns with management in the local authority and told them to be aware. It still purchased the houses. The reason it has not come to Government is that somebody made a big mistake. Not only that, a Minister of this House from County Limerick stood promoting this particular developer in housing on a recent video post for a supply being done in our area. I have no issue with that if they were quality houses, but this is going on three and a half years. The Minister would have known there were things that had not been paid for and defective houses. He knew, yet he stood in to say these houses were being built and he was delighted to welcome them. This is the problem. I do not have a problem with a developer supplying houses. I do not have a problem with a Minister welcoming houses, but they need to do research on the three and a half years where the local authority had issues with the same developer, and not promote them but fix the problem.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_280">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_453">I am endeavouring to be helpful on this issue because I am conscious of the distress any homeowner would be in if they bought or received a home from a local authority only to find themselves inheriting a home with defects. I take that seriously and Government takes that seriously. We have seen examples of that across the country in recent times. It has caused significant distress to people and significant cost to homeowners and to the taxpayer. What I cannot do, nor would the Deputy expect me to, is engage in a back-and-forth on the details on the floor of the Dáil because I simply do not have them. I do not know about issues like bonds, taking in charge and the process. However, the Minister for housing and I would be happy to receive any such information. They could then perhaps engage with the local authority and reply to the Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_35">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ó na Comhaltaí Eile - Other Members’ Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#BarryHeneghan" eId="spk_281">
          <from>Deputy Barry Heneghan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_454">I thank every man and woman working in Beaumont Hospital, the doctors, nurses, healthcare assistants, porters, cleaners and ambulance crews. They work tirelessly under enormous pressure and I hear nothing but extraordinary praise for their care and work. However, the staff are not the problem. They are holding together a system that is letting down patients, my constituents, those all across the east of Ireland and people who come here with head injuries.</p>
          <p eId="para_455">I have raised Beaumont repeatedly, in the Dáil and through parliamentary questions, because people across my constituency are frightened by what they are seeing. I have been in the kitchen of a mother who lost her husband because he was too afraid to wait 22 hours again in accident and emergency. I have spoken to constituents who described their 73-year-old father, less than two weeks after major lung surgery, spending almost 26 hours in Beaumont Hospital. His clinical care was excellent, and I commend the Minister on the work she has done in relation to that, but I believe she would be aware and agree that the problem is not only the accident and emergency. It is a whole hospital capacity and management problem. When admitted patients cannot get a ward, accident and emergency becomes the hospital's overflow area. Operations may be cancelled because there is no bed afterwards. The pressure ends up on the corridors, on exhausted staff and on vulnerable people who I represent. We need to redesign the patient journey. I have spoken to all workers across the hospital and previous consultants in the hospital on this.</p>
          <p eId="para_456"> We are coming up to the winter where people will be coming in at higher rates of admittance. I ask that Beaumont Lodge could possibly be used as an overflow area for people after surgery. The Beaumont Lodge beds are there. We need to redesign that patient journey. Could the audit reports of X-rays and blood tests from outside clinics not have to be repeated in Beaumont? I have submitted parliamentary questions on this previously. Other countries do this. If systems cannot share valid results, we need to fix the systems rather than wasting patients' time, wasting hospital resources and prolonging someone's access to care. I would love to see the hospital board, executive leadership and the HSE held accountable for the measurable results, including an independent review of the patient flow and management decisions. From questions I have submitted to the Minister and to the HSE, I am aware that there are some data that come out but it must extend beyond.</p>
          <p eId="para_457"> Planning permission for the new accident and emergency was granted in May 2025. A reply to one of my parliamentary questions cited quarter 2 of 2030 as construction delivery date. In October 2026, we were told that the sequence is radiation oncology first, then the 95-bed block and only then the new accident and emergency. A tender for the interim modular expansion was advertised in July. I am asking to move Beaumont from plans into delivery for my constituents and those from afar. It needs beds. It needs safer care. It needs a better system and I am looking for an update on that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_282">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_458">I thank the Deputy for the question. At the outset, I want to acknowledge the great work being done in Beaumont Hospital. I acknowledge the team in Beaumont Hospital, everybody from management to the clinical director and the regional clinical director, in particular, as the Minister reminds me. This is a region and a hospital that is well performing. That is not to say, of course, hospitals cannot have challenges from time to time but I remember, even from my own time as Minister for Health to where we are now, the journey of reform and progress Beaumont has been on is really quite extraordinary. I acknowledge them, that work and the leadership of the Minister in relation to this. It is a hospital that has had a very good year by quite a number of metrics.</p>
          <p eId="para_459"> The Deputy is right to highlight the need to continue to invest in capacity and expansion. There are a number of very significant proposals for capital investment in Beaumont but it is important that these projects are sequenced in the right way from a clinical activity point of view. That is why, quite intelligently, it was given to the hospital to decide the clear order of priority in terms of the delivery of the projects. My understanding, similar to what the Deputy said, is that the first project the hospital identified from a priority point of view is a major extension to the radiation oncology centre. The enabling works are under way. Main construction will or is expected to commence in 2027. That is, from a sequencing point of view, what has been identified as priority number one.</p>
          <p eId="para_460"> This will then be followed by a new inpatient bed block. I understand that this new ward block will be near to the expanded oncology centre development, hence the importance of the sequencing. The works need to be phased to try and minimise disruption while carrying out those works. That inpatient block will obviously add significant increased capacity and help relieve pressure on the emergency department. We can all fully understand that while the pressure might materialise in any hospital in the emergency department, sometimes the solution to alleviating that pressure is up to the hospital, so the radiation oncology centre will be first and closely beside it then the inpatient ward block.</p>
          <p eId="para_461"> In the short term, additional emergency capacity will be provided through that two-storey modular extension the Deputy referenced. This will expand the reception area and the waiting area, relocate support services and, importantly, free up clinical space. It will help improve patient pathways too. My understanding is the main contractor for this work has been appointed and site mobilisation and construction commencement are under way. The work is now under way on this ED extension. The project completion date, including the delivery of the modular unit, is July 2027. We are extremely committed to Beaumont Hospital.</p>
          <p eId="para_462"> We are extremely committed to the region as well. It is good to see the region working well too, whether it is the hybrid theatre and 20-bed chestnut unit being operational or the Swords surgical hub providing capacity for around 10,000 procedures annually. All of this, in growing that capacity for the north-east region, is important.</p>
          <p eId="para_463"> I acknowledge the good work being done in Beaumont. Those capital projects, sequenced in the order that the hospital has chosen, will have a really positive benefit.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#BarryHeneghan" eId="spk_283">
          <from>Deputy Barry Heneghan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_464">Ceapaim go bhfuil sé tábhachtach an cheist a chuir mé a fhreagairt. A winter solution could be to embrace the 250 beds in Beaumont Lodge to be part of the hospital for the winter. We could use maybe 20 of the beds for post-op surgeries, freeing up beds for people in accident and emergency. I would appreciate any further update on the timetable, with the published dates for the 95-bed inpatient block and confirmation on the modular expansion contract alongside immediate fixes to the triage seating, trolleys and corridor safety.</p>
          <p eId="para_465"> I understand the work that the Minister has done. I have been and seen what she has done in the hospital. The issue is that the hard-working staff - the men and women from the bottom to the top of seniority in the hospital - are working in a system that could be changed and optimised. If the published monthly performance targets had clear accountability to Beaumont's board, this would help, especially the time admitted patients wait for a bed in the ward. Some of my constituents have sadly lost their life as they did not want to wait 26 hours in an accident and emergency.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_284">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_466">As I said, we never know, obviously, the clinical reasons or rationale, but I have to acknowledge I used to see a health service that used to talk about every hospital as though it was uniformly performing. That does not serve patients well at all. I have to acknowledge that Beaumont is performing and engaging very well across the system. I understand from the Minister very specific plans are being submitted by Beaumont in relation to winter solutions or additional measures. I take on board what the Deputy says in relation to that too but I believe it is bringing forward some very specific proposals that we believe will help support the hospital during the winter period. I also welcome the work that has been done by the Minister, the HSE and the hospital group around a CT scanner. There is an additional CT scanner, I believe, in the ED. I should think that is now operational, which is helpful too.</p>
          <p eId="para_467"> We can send the Deputy and TDs for the area a note along the lines of what I have said today in terms of the timelines. On that modular extension, my understanding now is that the main contractor for the work has been appointed, construction commencement is now under way and I believe the project completion date is targeted for July 2027.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_36">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ar Pholasaí nó ar Reachtaíocht - Questions on Policy or Legislation<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MattCarthy" eId="spk_285">
          <from>Deputy Matt Carthy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_468">I want to raise with the Tánaiste the serious case facing Mandy Kelly, whose two sons were abducted by their father while on a family holiday in Egypt. These are Irish citizens, born in Ireland, who travelled to their father's home country for a holiday and never returned. Their mother, Mandy, has been separated from her two sons for the past five years. She does not know where they are living, whether they are attending school or how they are being cared for. She has been through both the Irish and Egyptian court systems, as the Tánaiste knows. They have all found in her favour but despite all repeated efforts, the rulings have not been enforced. For nearly five years - the Tánaiste will be aware of this case - Mandy has done everything that is and could be required of her. She is bearing what no mother should have to bear. I am asking the Tánaiste to ensure that he, the Taoiseach and all leaders within Government do whatever is possible in order to help Mandy secure the return of her two sons.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_286">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_469">I thank Deputy Carthy. I certainly will and we certainly are. I have had directly at least two meetings with Mandy Kelly but I have also directly raised it, during my time as Taoiseach, with the Egyptian President. The Taoiseach has raised it also. The Minister for foreign affairs has been actively involved and we take every opportunity to diplomatically raise this issue too. We are also providing consular assistance. On foot of the Deputy raising this again today, I will ask that the Minister for foreign affairs come back to him and update him on the work that is under way in relation to that. Our hearts go out to Mandy, her family and her children in terms of what they are enduring. It is unimaginable. We will certainly do all that we can to support them.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#AidanFarrelly" eId="spk_287">
          <from>Deputy Aidan Farrelly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_470">What is this Government's problem with public transport, specifically school transport?</p>
          <p eId="para_471">The Government is gouging parents and families in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis. Next year the cost of going to school on a school bus is going from €100 to €350 per child. That is a potential €650 cap for families. These increases impact 180,000 children and young people throughout the country. Is the Government so tone-deaf to the realities facing families right now that it thinks this is acceptable? It is simply unacceptable. Last week, the Social Democrats introduced a motion to reverse the public transport fare increases coming down the line in January. We now know there will be a €250 increase to send a child to school on a bus. Will the Government reverse the decision and keep the cost at €100 per school year and get a grip on reality?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_288">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_472">We will not, and I say that to be honest because the big issue we have, from a school transport point of view and that I see in my constituency, is availability. There are parents who come to me who are happy to purchase a ticket but who need a bus or a bus driver. We have significantly reduced the costs of school transport and we have restored those costs somewhat. However, we had a situation where - and we have to be honest with our constituents - we had fully-funded buses which were not full while other kids were not able to get on a bus. I have been contacted by countless people who are frustrated that there is a bus with two spare seats but they cannot get one. There has to be a balanced approach to all of this.</p>
          <p eId="para_473"> Look at the cost and divide it by the number of school days. We help people with the cost of living in a variety of ways. The bigger issue here is availability of places and reforming the system. Some of the changes are around allowing people over the age of 70 to drive. That is the direction we want to go in, along with more investment in the school transport system. In my constituency of Wicklow, it is about places and routes that work, principally. That is where the big focus is going to be.</p>
          <p eId="para_474"> Obviously, there are a number of ways in which we are endeavouring to help people with the cost of living and we have, objectively and significantly reduced education costs in this country, whether through free school books or free school meals. In general, we have reduced public transport costs for young people too.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EoghanKenny" eId="spk_289">
          <from>Deputy Eoghan Kenny<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_475">I, too, wish to raise the issue of school transport. The significant costs of school transport, going from €100 to €350 per child at second level and from €250 to €650 for a family with two children attending secondary school from September of next year, are too high. Free education is a myth in this country. We cannot stand over saying we have a free education system when we see these increases in the costs of school transport, and the return of State examination fees. While I welcome developments in the free book scheme and the hot school meals, and I will always welcome them, an increase in the costs of school transport to this extent, of 250%, completely contradicts this myth of a free education system in this country. Will the Tánaiste, as the Minister for Finance, reverse the decision to increase the costs of school transport from next September onwards?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_290">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_476">I thank the Deputy. The Government's position on the budget day situation is clear and is as outlined. I would not go as far as to agree with the Deputy on its impact on free education. There are parts of this country where a student can get a school bus and there are parts where they cannot get one. There is a very different reality in urban Ireland versus rural Ireland. We have significantly and objectively reduced the cost of education by any metric. Compared to when the Deputy and I were going to school, the books are now free and there are free school meals in primary schools. We have made a lot of progress in relation to this but we have to balance this. While there is always additional help for those most in need, a lot of parents want to see places available on buses and that they can put a bum on a seat. That has been the big issue, certainly in my constituency office, above and beyond issues around cost.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CharlesWard" eId="spk_291">
          <from>Deputy Charles Ward<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_477">The community on Arranmore island in County Donegal is incredibly concerned about the staffing levels of the fire services. Its service has been reduced from five crew members to just three in the past few months due to retirements. There have been no replacements, or recruitment since 2016. The people of Arranmore have been left in a very vulnerable situation. They are concerned for their safety and that of the community and feel they are being discriminated against. That is why I am asking why Arranmore fire station is not afforded the same status as a mainland station because it should be. There should be a minimum of six firefighters on Arranmore but there is not. This has been flagged for months and it is now time for the Government to intervene. There are 500 people on the island and I am one of them. People need and deserve to feel safe and there is a vulnerability there that needs to be addressed. I ask the Tánaiste to intervene to ensure the islanders on Arranmore are afforded the same protection as people on the mainland.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_292">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_478">I thank Deputy Ward for raising this issue. He is right, in that no matter where you live in the country, you should be able to expect safety and those vital emergency public services. My understanding is we have agreed safe staffing figures in relation to fire services. I am not saying that is in place, or I am not disputing what the Deputy is saying. However, the Government expects those to be implemented. The responsibility lies with the local authority, as the fire authority, and with the chief fire officer, principally. On foot of the Deputy raising this, I will ask the Department to liaise with Donegal County Council and come back to him on this matter.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardODonoghue" eId="spk_293">
          <from>Deputy Richard O'Donoghue<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_479">I am looking for a date for the new planning regulations for rural housing. I have looked for extensions on planning, which the local authority has helped with but if you ask for further information, you cannot look for an extension of time. These people will qualify under the proposed new planning guidelines. It costs between €5,000 and €10,000 to put in a planning application. People are waiting and it is costing money they do not have. They are building their own houses while waiting for the new planning guidelines. Can we please have a date for them?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_294">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_480">I thank Deputy O'Donoghue for raising this issue. I would argue the man beside me, the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, has done more on this issue in recent months than has been done in many years. There is a real enthusiasm for these new guidelines for the reasons the Deputy outlined. We are seeing the biggest overhaul of planning guidelines around rural housing in two decades and a shift away from what have been overly-rigid and restrictive planning practices that have held rural communities back for far too long. The Deputy knows there is a process that has to be gone through, whether we like it or not, and that process is under way. As soon as that is completed, they will be published. It is a priority for Government to get this done as quickly as possible. Not all of the factors are entirely within our control, so I do not want to mislead the Deputy as the guidelines are out in terms of the environmental assessment. However, we will keep the pressure on and continue to closely monitor the situation regarding timelines. I expect them early in the new year but as quickly as possible.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#TonyMcCormack" eId="spk_295">
          <from>Deputy Tony McCormack<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_481">With Black Friday approaching, consumers will be bombarded with advertising offering massive discounts and bargains, some of which may be misleading. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, CCPC, recently found that 73% of consumers do not trust Black Friday discounts to be accurate. This is not just about protecting consumers but it is also about protecting small retailers, which are trying to compete fairly and honestly. When a large company misleads customers with false discounts, it can take business away from the smaller retailers, which are playing by the rules. The problem is that some of the fines are simply too small. A €5,000 fine could be devastating for a small retailer but for a multinational corporation, making millions of euro in profits, it is hardly noticed. Will the Government introduce fines based on the size of the turnover of a business, making the punishment serious enough that misleading customers is simply not worth the risk? When can we expect these stronger powers to be introduced?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_296">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_482">I thank Deputy McCormack for raising this important issue. He is correct. The CCPC does a very good job but, as a House, we need to empower it to do more in relation to consumer protection. Our colleague, the Minister, Deputy Burke, is preparing legislation that will further enhance the powers of the CCPC. We can certainly give consideration to the Deputy’s proposal regarding the size of fines and how they are applied to companies with different turnovers. I thank the Deputy for the constructive suggestion and I will ask that the Minister engages with him on this new draft law.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichealCarrigy" eId="spk_297" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach">
          <from>Deputy Micheál Carrigy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T12:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_483">I wish to highlight the need for additional Garda resources in County Longford. Recent shootings believed to be drug-related alongside crime and anti-social behaviour throughout the town are causing real concern. Thankfully, nobody was harmed in the most recent incident. I command the local gardaí and community safety partnership on their ongoing work to keep our communities safe. However, Longford has been left behind, with only one new Garda assigned to the entire Mayo-Roscommon-Longford division this entire year despite numerous attestations from Templemore.</p>
          <p eId="para_484"> Delays in the courts must also be addressed as they undermine efforts to tackle crime effectively. We recently had a situation where bail conditions were lifted on someone who was caught with a €3 million worth of drugs to attend a wedding ceremony in the UK. That is absolutely outrageous. I have consistently engaged with local gardaí and raised the need for greater resources. Longford deserves its fair share. Despite the actions of a small minority, our county is thriving thanks to community groups, local businesses, the local authority and the chamber, running many initiatives such as Festive Fridays and one @ one, many supported by the Government.</p>
          <p eId="para_485">We need additional support to protect that progress and help Longford continue to thrive.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_298">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_486">I thank the Deputy for raising the issue. It is great to see all the progress being made in Longford. I enjoy visiting Longford frequently with Deputy Carrigy. When we were at some the agricultural shows during the summer, we met the community safety partnership and saw the really good work being done on community safety. As a Government, we want to support that in terms of Garda numbers. My understanding is there are now 121 gardaí directly assigned to stations in Longford. That is out of the 582 gardaí assigned to Mayo, Roscommon and Longford as a division. We are now back at record Garda numbers, with more gardaí than ever before in the history of the State. Templemore is back at full capacity and the Government is considering what more we can do to grow that capacity. However, I take the Deputy's point that he wants to see more gardaí on the beat in Longford. On foot of him raising the issue, I will ask the Minister for justice to bring those views to the attention of the Garda Commissioner.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#FionntanOSuilleabhain" eId="spk_299">
          <from>Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_487">The dereliction in Arklow town centre and the need for a flagship multi-use community facility that will lift the town centre and have a domino effect for businesses is a need with which the Tánaiste, as a Wicklow TD, is very familiar. There are two related priorities for a long-neglected town of 16,000 people. The new towns and cities regeneration investment fund, formerly the URDF, prioritises vacant, underused and derelict town centre sites and, crucially, public realm enhancement and community infrastructure. That is a multi-use venue for Arklow's many groups at a main street location. As a Wicklow TD, will the Tánaiste work with Wicklow County Council to assist in the delivery of such a town-centre venue and also tackle the scourge of dereliction in Arklow town centre?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_300">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_488">I will, indeed. I am still not over the partition of Wicklow in terms of the division between the Wicklow and Wicklow-Wexford constituencies, but I am proudly a person from Wicklow, even though it is in the Deputy's constituency now, and I know the town of Arklow very well. I thank the Deputy for highlighting these important issues. As he said, we have allocated significant funding to the council. We want to work with Wicklow County Council on this. Between the wastewater treatment facility, the flood relief scheme and the plans for the derelict property tax, which we will legislate for here on Report Stage of the Finance Bill next week, there are all the ingredients needed there that I think should really benefit a town like Arklow. I am happy to work with the Deputy and across the political divide to try to make progress on this project for Arklow.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarieSherlock" eId="spk_301">
          <from>Deputy Marie Sherlock<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_489">I want to raise the issue of public transport in Dublin. As we know, congestion on the M50 is at dangerously high levels. People are packed like sardines on the Luas every day. Some 55 million journeys were undertaken last year and we know travel times are extremely long, and all of that with emissions going up rather than down in the transport sector. Five years ago, the Government made a big announcement with regards to the DART+ project. Two years ago, the railway order, for the DART+ South West project was granted, and yet there is no funding from Government and not even a mention in the national development plan. What is the Tánaiste doing to respond to the increasing congestion and the increasing demand for public transport for people coming into Dublin and also for the communities I represent that are dealing with that congestion on a daily basis?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_302">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_490">Deputy Sherlock makes a very fair point. While obviously there is congestion for people coming in and out of Dublin to work, there are also people she represents who live in Dublin who are enduring this level of congestion and the environmental impact of it as they go about their daily lives. On foot of the Deputy raising the issue, I will seek an update from the Minister for Transport on the DART+ project. I make the point that we have made very significant capital allocations in relation to public transport and to the Department of Transport, but I will ask the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, to come back directly to the Deputy on the project.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MattieMcGrath" eId="spk_303">
          <from>Deputy Mattie McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_491">I want to raise the scandalous situation of 28 farmers on Sliabh na mBan who have had their BISS payments delayed following the devastating fires of the summer. I have been engaging with the affected farmers and Darragh Scott of south Tipperary IFA. This is a totally unacceptable situation. These farmers are effectively being treated as guilty until proved innocent, forced to undertake huge administrative exercises to prove they were not responsible for the fire. Did you ever hear the bate of it? There is sense of meitheal among these farmers on Sliabh na mBan who stopped the fire. Some of the farmers are now in their 90s. How are they expected to do this? They worked tirelessly to extinguish the fire and save the mountain. Some farmers submitted additional information and documentation demanded by the Department, including sworn affidavits and letters from the fire service as far back as September or early October. It appears that the Department is withholding payments until all 28 farmers have submitted these affidavits. This is a terrible situation, and it is a pity. Will the Tánaiste confirm that these farmers will be paid and give a commitment that their cases will be processed individually rather than all 28 together? Some of them are abroad and some of them are very elderly, as I said. It is a very onerous task to get the affidavit signed and these people are being criminalised. I saw the sense of meitheal and the spirit of the farmers. Deputy Michael Murphy was there with me. I thank the Tánaiste and his team for coming to Clonmel and Limerick Junction last week. We need some bit of sensitivity here. The meitheal meant that the community hall supplied food and everybody helped. These farmers spent a lot of money quenching the fire. They need their normal payments and they cannot be punished like this. "Cad a dhéanfaimid feasta gan adhmad?" used to be the slogan in Kilcash. Now it is, "Cad a dhéanfaimid feasta gan airgead?"</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_304">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_492">The Leas-Cheann Comhairle was having difficulty stopping the Deputy because he was in full flow on an important issue. I thank the Deputy for raising the issue and for his remarks about me visiting Tipperary last week. I very much enjoyed it. He is correct to use the word "meitheal" regarding Sliabh na mBan. Indeed, I wrote to the chief executive of Tipperary County Council after the fire to acknowledge that meitheal and that real sense of the community pulling together, so it is disappointing to hear what the Deputy is saying about how the farmers feel they are being treated. On foot of the Deputy raising this issue, I will discuss it with the Minister for agriculture. I am also happy to engage with the IFA on this matter to see how we can assist</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CathyBennett" eId="spk_305">
          <from>Deputy Cathy Bennett<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_493">I want to follow on from Deputy Carthy in relation to Mandy Kelly, who has been without her children for five years now. I am asking the Tánaiste to intervene. I heard him mention that the President of Egypt knows. I compliment the Department of foreign affairs on the work it has done but we are still in the same situation. Mandy does not have her children. If it was any of us, we would be fighting long and hard to ensure our children were here. The Tánaiste would not like to see his children stuck in Egypt, so I am asking him to intervene today to help Mandy. It is a very unfair situation. She has been through loops. She has been in Egypt ten times at this stage. The Government needs to do something to protect Irish citizens.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_306">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_494">I genuinely assure the Deputy - and I think we can all work on this on a cross-party basis, as we do - that the Irish Government is doing and will do everything it can to assist Mandy and her children, as the Deputy specifically referenced. None of us can imagine as parents what that must feel like or the horror that Mandy is enduring. I reiterate that it has been raised and is being raised at the very highest levels within the Egyptian Government, with the President of Egypt directly on a number of occasions, and with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Egypt on a number of occasions. As the Deputy rightly said, good work has been done by the Department of foreign affairs officials too and I know the Minister, Deputy McEntee, is fully apprised and involved in this too. On foot of Deputies Bennett and Carthy raising the issue, I will ask the Minister to seek a further update and come back directly to the Deputies on it.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GeorgeLawlor" eId="spk_307">
          <from>Deputy George Lawlor<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_495">I want to raise an issue of the dreadfully low income thresholds for accessing social housing supports. I will give the example of my own county of Wexford where, for two adults and two children, the income threshold is €38,500. Anyone above that is taken off the housing list and not given any support such as HAP. We should bear in mind that this week the average rent in Wexford was listed at €1,663. In a year, it is just below €20,000. If that €20,000 is taken off the €38,500, that leaves people in poverty. In addition, if someone is in receipt of the working family payment, that is added to their income. A payment to take people out of poverty actually puts them back into poverty when they are added together. I ask the Tánaiste to look at this. He has a Minister of State for housing beside him to maybe advise as well.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_308">
          <from> Simon Harris<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_496">I am well advised. I thank the Deputy for raising this issue. Instinctively, I think the point he is making is very valid. In the past, we have reviewed those thresholds and we are committed to keeping them under review. I will make what I hope is a helpful point. Now that we are increasing the capacity of social homes being built in the country again, naturally it should follow that we also then look at the limits and means test in relation to that and how it interacts with the housing assistance payment. There is some work going on in the Department of housing in relation to this and I will seek an update from it in terms of a timeline for when the Government may consider options on this. I will use the example the Deputy gave from Wexford as part of that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SeamusMcGrath" eId="spk_309">
          <from>Deputy Séamus McGrath<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_497">I want to raise the issue of the living cities initiative. As the Tánaiste knows, this is an important scheme that provide tax incentives for the refurbishment of vacant and underutilised properties. In budget 2026 the scheme was extended and the criteria were broadened. I think the Tánaiste knows the Cork Business Association has been asking for the qualifying regeneration areas to be reviewed. I understand the Tánaiste met the association and heard its case directly. It is important that we widen the scheme and make it as applicable as possible across the city.</p>
          <p eId="para_498">I ask the Tánaiste to support a review of this scheme as soon as possible in order that we can ensure that the scheme is taken up to the greatest extent possible.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_310">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_499">I thank Deputy McGrath for raising this issue. As he correctly says, I have had engagements with him and associations in Cork, including the Cork Business Association. I also met the chief executive of Cork City Council on this and a number of other matters as well in the not-too-distant past. The Deputy will correct me if I go wrong, but my understanding is work is under way in terms of future Cork. I think it is the initiative around the future of Cork city and how we can regenerate the city. I had suggested to the council that it may wish to consider that as part of that. That may give the Government a basis on which to consider it. The living city initiative is working well. We have made a decision as a Government to expand it, but I take the point about some of the maps and there is a particular concern in Cork around the maps. I am sympathetic to that, but it would be useful if we could look at it as part of the overall regeneration plan being worked on for the city.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulLawless" eId="spk_311">
          <from>Deputy Paul Lawless<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_500">More than 250,000 people were removed from hospital waiting lists in a 2.5-year period. This was for not responding to a periodic letter. It is normal that the HSE sends out periodic validation forms to people on waiting lists. The HSE checks to see whether or not they wish to continue with their appointment and so on. If the patient does not answer in a short period, they are removed. I am concerned with the level of patients removed in relation to this. This year, 77,000 patients have been removed. In 2024, almost 100,000 patients have been removed. The numbers are quite incredible. Is there a better way of doing this in 2026? How many of these people have been wrongly removed? The window is quite short. Many of the people are quite elderly, and it is easy to essentially mislay a letter. I am asking the Minister to review this. I am asking her to consider whether people are wrongly being removed. Can we develop a better system in 2026?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill" as="#Minister_for_Health" eId="spk_312">
          <from>Minister for Health (Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_501">I thank the Deputy. I am very pleased to see him because he had submitted two questions for oral questions earlier and I did not see him then. We prepared good answers for him in relation to Mayo and other things. It is good to see him here.</p>
          <p eId="para_502"> The Deputy is aware that the NTPF is the body that goes through waiting list validations to make sure that we have the quickest access for those people who need appointments. Yes, a proportion of people are removed for very good reasons. It is supervised by the NTPF, largely. With an electronic health record system, that will be further improved. We did suggest that hospitals move to a an email-based system. Of course, that would then exclude other people. An electronic health record will enable us to see who has been referred for what and the cross-over. It may very well be that people have procedures in other regions or other areas, but the validation is a normal part of any waiting list management programme.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#NaoiseOMuiri" eId="spk_313">
          <from>Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_503">The awful recent attack on that family home in Waterford has once again highlighted the scourge of drug-related intimidation in Ireland, as debated in the Dáil earlier this week. Criminal gangs deliberately target vulnerable groups, people struggling with addiction, but the impact goes way past the victims themselves. It is an issue everywhere. We talked about it during the parliamentary party meeting. It is an issue in my area of Dublin Bay North, but it is also a national issue. Gardaí dealt with around 600 cases of drug-related intimidation in 2025, but the figure is likely to be a lot higher because people are afraid to come forward. This intimidation exploits people at some of the lowest points in their lives. What is the Government doing on this issue? We need to take a whole-of-government approach to stamping this out.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_314">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_504">I thank Deputy Ó Muirí for raising this issue. This is one of the biggest and least-discussed issues going on in communities across Ireland right now. We have seen some horrific incidents, not least in Waterford, in recent times. It is in every community across Ireland. There is a sense of fear and worry. I attended a support group meeting of parents whose children had been caught up in drug addiction. I heard those families, everyday families like yours or mine, who found, through no fault of their own, their children in the clutches of drug gangs. They raised the sense of intimidation and the fear. Sometimes there was even a fear of going to An Garda Síochána. We have to do more and we have to do better in relation to this. The first thing we have to do is talk about it a hell of a lot more. Every local authority, through these community safety partnerships, needs to be bringing people and stakeholders together to look at what needs to be done. We need to tackle this with the same vigour that we tackled the gangland crimes when we set up the Criminal Assets Bureau. I passionately believe that. I acknowledge some good work being done by An Garda in relation to this. It has a drug-related intimidation reporting programme and Operation Fógra. It also has drug-related intimidation and violence engagement, DRIVE, which is funded through the Department of Health. It is a national, inter-agency initiative. It is working now on a national scale ensuring consistent and comprehensive supports in all regions. I would welcome an early debate in this House on this issue of drug intimidation and how we take a unified, cross-party approach to stamping this out.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#DarrenORourke" eId="spk_315">
          <from>Deputy Darren O'Rourke<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_505">The public accounts committee heard that the school transport budget is increasing exponentially due to the failure of the Government to provide appropriate special education school places locally. Children are forced to travel inordinate distances on a daily basis. A total of 60% of the budget is now being spent on 13% of students. To prop up this failing system, the Government is planning to introduce school transport hikes of 250% for a post-primary school child, going from €100 to €350. This has come as a real shock to families. It is simply unaffordable on top of uniforms, devices, activities and so-called voluntary contributions. Will the Tánaiste review this decision? It is simply unaffordable a time of a cost-of-living crisis.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_316">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_506">I have reiterated the Government's position in relation to this. It is investment in school transport to further provide opportunities in terms of buses, places and routes that I know the Deputy sees in Meath, that I see in Wicklow and that we see across the country. Nobody wants to see a child having to travel a long distance to access a special class or special school. I met the Minister for education on this earlier this week. A number of reforms and work are under way, led by the Minister, Deputy Naughton. We have now opened 587 new special classes this year alone. We are spending over €3.8 billion on special education. The new inclusive education forum, which is due to have its first meeting next week, or certainly sometime this month, can have a proper deep-dive examination of how we can get this inclusive model of education right. The position on school transport is as outlined in the budget, however.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMurphy" eId="spk_317">
          <from>Deputy Michael Murphy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_507">I thank the Tánaiste for coming to my constituency of Tipperary South on Friday. He had an opportunity to see at first hand the very best of community in my constituency. In particular, I want to shine a light on his visit to Clonmel Rugby Club. He saw the extent to which it is a centre of excellence. It is run by volunteers at the heart of community. Like many clubs across my constituency, it is currently making applications for sports capital funding. I know those applications have to be in by February. When can clubs across my constituency expect a decision? More importantly, what is the Tánaiste's wider message for those clubs in my constituency currently working on an application for sports capital funding?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_318">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_508">I thank Deputy Murphy for raising this with me. I also thank him for bringing me to Clonmel Rugby Club last Friday. I gave a commitment in the rugby club last Friday that I would wear its club tie today. I have worn that. That is a commitment made and a commitment kept. I thank the club for that kind gift. What I was struck by when I was in Clonmel Rugby Club was what I see when I go to community facilities and sports clubs across Ireland. It is the sense of volunteerism, pulling together and giving young people, boys and girls, the opportunity, the collective sense of pride and success in sport, the health and all the benefits that come with it. As I said to the club, we have opened a sports capital application process. We opened it on 19 October. It will remain open until 26 February. I encourage all clubs to look at the criteria and make sure they get the right application in. We hope to be in a position to allocate that funding later in 2027. We need to keep going in terms of a regular rhythm of investment in sport because it is transformational. It is transformational in terms of sporting success, of course, but it is much more than that in terms of community. I really enjoyed the visit to Clonmel and go raibh maith agaibh for the tie.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnMcGuinness" eId="spk_319">
          <from> An Leas-Cheann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_509">The tie works, Deputy Murphy. You might let the rest of us know.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_320">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_510">I will have to wear a different tie every week.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="topical" eId="dbsect_37">
        <heading>Ábhair Shaincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Matters<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#MichealCarrigy" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_321">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Micheál Carrigy)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_511">I advise the House of the following matters in respect of which notice has been given under Standing Order 39 and the name of the Member in each case:</p>
          <p eId="para_512"> Deputy William Aird - To discuss the withdrawal of respite services for children in a facility in County Laois.</p>
          <p eId="para_513"> Deputy Malcolm Byrne - To discuss the roll-out of information and support programmes on the use of artificial intelligence in schools.</p>
          <p eId="para_514"> Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin - To discuss the growing uncertainty facing Dealz workers.</p>
          <p eId="para_515"> Deputy Ryan O'Meara - To discuss financial supports for community cafés.</p>
          <p eId="para_516"> Deputy Michael Murphy - To discuss road safety risks associated with horse-drawn vehicles on public roads.</p>
          <p eId="para_517"> Deputy Darren O'Rourke - To discuss recent frequent water outages in Ashbourne, County Meath.</p>
          <p eId="para_518"> Deputy Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire - To discuss the need for footpaths from Waterfall village to Bishopstown.</p>
          <p eId="para_519"> Deputy Erin McGreehan - To discuss the delivery and staffing of the additional 15-bed area at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda.</p>
          <p eId="para_520"> Deputy Ruairí Ó Murchú· - To discuss the way in which local specialist music retailers can become approved suppliers to schools.</p>
          <p eId="para_521"> Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan - To discuss an update on the shortage of residential accommodation for people with intellectual disabilities in Cork.</p>
          <p eId="para_522"> Deputies Robert O'Donoghue and Louise O'Reilly - To discuss proposed changes to the assessment process to access special classes and schools for children with needs. </p>
          <p eId="para_523"> Deputy Gary Gannon - To discuss DEIS status for a primary school in Dublin 3. </p>
          <p eId="para_524"> Deputies Aidan Farrelly and Shónagh Ní Raghallaigh - To discuss water supply disruption and related matters in County Kildare.</p>
          <p eId="para_525"> Deputy Jennifer Whitmore - To discuss Ireland's nature restoration plan.</p>
          <p eId="para_526"> Deputy Mark Wall - To discuss the provision of earlier trains.</p>
          <p eId="para_527"> The matters raised by Deputies Pádraig O'Sullivan, Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin, Ryan O'Meara, Jennifer Whitmore and Malcolm Byrne have been selected for discussion.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="topical" eId="dbsect_38">
        <heading>Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_39">
          <heading>Disability Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#PadraigOSullivan" eId="spk_322">
            <from>Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_528">I thank the Minister of State for taking the question. This does not relate to his Department, but I appreciate him taking the question. He is familiar with this. It has been raised often at parliamentary party meetings in the past 12 months, if not longer. It is the issue of residential care. I will focus on Cork, but I will speak about the national picture as well.</p>
            <p eId="para_529"> I will outline a few things at the beginning and give an example. On 6 November, a few weeks ago, there were 533 delayed transfers of care from our hospitals nationwide, 78 of which were categorised as being in the complex clinical category. That is typically people who have suffered a brain injury or severe trauma or have serious disabilities, including intellectual disabilities. To clarify further, on one day last week, 42 people who were fit to be discharged were in hospitals nationwide, but unfortunately there was nowhere for them to be discharged to. This is a common theme across the country, not just in my area.</p>
            <p eId="para_530"> People like Tony Murray and Sinéad McGrath of the Before we Die campaign have stepped up specifically to address this problem. The Cathaoirleach Gníomhach is also familiar with that group. They have stepped into the breach because for too long the State, the disability sector and charities more widely have neglected the whole area of residential care.</p>
            <p eId="para_531"> I am raising this again today because I received a response to a parliamentary question last week that left me dumbfounded. I brought it up at the health committee. I asked for the total number of residential places in HSE-funded disability services that are unoccupied and I could not believe the answer from the HSE. It is 319. That is how many funded beds are available through disability service providers but unoccupied. They have been paid for. They are funded by the HSE. I raised this last week at the Committee on Budgetary Oversight. I am not a member of the committee but I went to the meeting because HSE officials were there. I confronted a number of members of its senior financial team about it and they conceded that the number could be that high.</p>
            <p eId="para_532"> There are some provisos. Some of the settings might be coming out of congregation, there might be refurbishment and there is a transition where people are moving from one accommodation to another. The true figure might not be 319, but even if it is 50 or 100, or whatever figure people want to throw at it, these are paid-for beds that are unoccupied and we are facing a crisis in residential care.</p>
            <p eId="para_533"> There is a big campaign by the Before We Die group nationwide, as I said. Hundreds of people aged over 70 have in their care adults, in many cases young adults, with profound intellectual disabilities. They are worried about what will happen to their children when they die. It is unconscionable that we have anywhere near that number of beds and I reiterate that these are funded beds, paid for by the HSE, that are left unoccupied. Meanwhile, as I referenced at the outset, on one day last week, 42 people with intellectual disabilities were in hospitals and were fit to be discharged but had nowhere to go.</p>
            <p eId="para_534"> The Minister of State is not in the Department of Health and there is only so much he can say today, but this needs to be heard. I have passed on the reply to my parliamentary question to the relevant Minister. It is unconscionable in this day and age that the State is paying for beds and allowing them to lie idle.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance" eId="spk_323">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Deputy Robert Troy)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_535">The Minister thanks Deputy O'Sullivan for raising this important issue and for offering her the opportunity to respond, through me. I acknowledge the work the Deputy has done and continues to do in this regard.</p>
            <p eId="para_536"> The Minister, along with Department officials, continues to engage closely with the HSE on the provision of a range of services for people with disabilities, including residential services. A key focus of the Government and the HSE is an increased emphasis on longer term planning for residential services. The HSE funds over 9,000 residential placements, including 1,144 placements in HSE South West. In recognition of the high demand for residential services, increased funding provided to the HSE has supported the creation of over 1,000 new specialist disability residential places nationally since 2020. The HSE continues to work locally and nationally to enhance capacity across disability services and improve access to appropriate support. The HSE advises that it is committed to increasing quality service provision and building the capacity of services year on year, in line with budget allocations, to deliver services that match the priority support needs in the most timely, efficient and appropriate manner, although that is questionable, given what the Deputy has just said, to be frank.</p>
            <p eId="para_537"> The Department has engaged with the HSE about services in Cork specifically. The HSE advises that HSE South West disability services convene a monthly residential forum to ensure that existing and emerging residential vacancies in the region are identified and that referrals to the available places are made on the basis of compatibility and assessed need. This ensures provision and equity of access to funded residential placement vacancies. The residential forum is chaired by HSE South West disability services and the membership comprises HSE South West disability services, section 38 and section 39 service providers and select for-profit providers.</p>
            <p eId="para_538"> The demand for residential placements across Cork and Kerry continues to exceed available capacity. HSE South West disability services recognise the impact this has on people and their families and are actively working to address this need by engaging with multiple service providers to build additional capacity.</p>
            <p eId="para_539"> Due to a number of factors, the HSE advises that decision-making on the allocation of placements is informed by the prioritisation of assessed clinical needs, the complexity of cases and the support needs of applicants, as well as compatibility with existing residents and the funding available. A system called the disability support application management tool, DSAMT, is used as part of the process, which serves to ensure that the application process is equitable and transparent. HSE South West remains committed to improving access to residential services and welcomed the commitment in budget 2026 to fund planned residential placements. HSE South West continues to work with statutory, voluntary and independent providers to expand local residential capacity and a number of service developments that are under way in the region are expected to increase placement availability. </p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PadraigOSullivan" eId="spk_324">
            <from>Deputy Pádraig O'Sullivan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_540">There is nothing in that reply that I have not heard before or in previous responses to parliamentary questions. It is important that we speak plainly and truthfully in this House. If the State is paying the HSE for beds and the beds are unoccupied, we have a right to ask why. Why are 319 beds unoccupied? That is the fundamental question. If people pay for a service, they want to know what they are getting. Clearly, in the HSE's own words, it is not getting a service.</p>
            <p eId="para_541"> The Minister of State works hard on the area of disability in his constituency. Last week, when I asked one of the HSE finance people, Tony Canavan, who is from the west, how long these people are in hospital waiting to be discharged, and whether we are talking about days, weeks, months or years, he could not rule out that people might be waiting over a year in a hospital for a residential place to become available. It is incredible.</p>
            <p eId="para_542"> I have come across families who have abandoned loved ones at accident and emergency departments in the last 12 months. This is the reality. To be told that there are 319 unoccupied beds is unacceptable. People are fighting with the system, persisting, shouting as loud as they can for help, and here we are paying for beds and getting no return for it.</p>
            <p eId="para_543"> I will put one more thing on the record. I got to know a Cork woman recently who had to move to Kerry, unfortunately, to get a special school place for her child. Unfortunately, her child's situation deteriorated and he required a residential place. Where did the HSE send him with its clinical assessment and prioritisation of his needs? It sent him to Kildare. That is the type of crap that has been going on over recent years and we are hiding behind these formulaic responses from the HSE. It is about time people asked what we are getting. I want to know what is happening with those 319 beds.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_325" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_544">Again, I acknowledge the work Deputy O'Sullivan has done. The closing statement that has been shared with me talks about budget 2027 and how it has provided for 152 newly created residential placements, comprising 72 new planned residential placements under a new initiative and 80 new placements to meet urgent need. It also says we will be providing an additional €108 million for residential services.</p>
            <p eId="para_545">That is all very welcome and goes to show the commitment the elected Government has shown to the disability services. The Minister and Ministers of State, who make the decisions on resource funding, are putting the resources in place but the Deputy has identified clearly that often the permanent government and people within the arms of the State, in this case the HSE, do not utilise the money that has been allocated to them in an efficient manner. The Deputy identified 319 beds. I know so many families for whom this will be like a red rag to a bull. These families are waiting on placements for loved ones. Only yesterday I spoke to a colleague who told me about the difficulty they are having with an 85-year-old widowed lady who cannot get residential care for her adult son who has intellectual and physical disabilities. There is no defence for what I have learned here today, quite frankly. I guarantee the Deputy I will be raising it with my colleagues in the relevant Department on foot of his representation. Somebody has to be held answerable for why senior decision-makers within any State body could stand over a situation where people are left in unsuitable settings like acute hospitals and homes where residential care is needed while at the same time 319 places are unutilised. I cannot defend it and I will certainly raise it with the relevant Minister.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_40">
          <heading>Job Losses<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#FionntanOSuilleabhain" eId="spk_326">
            <from>Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_546">As the Minister of State will be aware, workers in Dealz shops across the country are facing enormous uncertainty about their future employment. Last week, I visited the Dealz shop in Gorey and met both staff and management. The overriding feeling among the workers was one of anxiety and uncertainty. They still do not know if they will have jobs at the end of November. Many are worried the pay cheque they receive on 28 November could be their last. To receive news like this in the run-up to Christmas is devastating and many of the workers have families, mortgages, rents and household bills to meet. They are facing into what should be a joyful time of year with genuine fear about what lies ahead.</p>
            <p eId="para_547"> The Dealz store in Gorey is a busy and important business on the main street. I believe it is the busiest store outside Dublin. If it were to close, it would be a significant blow to the local economy. We have already seen the closure of EuroGiant in Gorey and nobody wants to see another prominent retail premises added to the list of vacant units. We have witnessed the impact that retail closures can have on neighbouring towns such as Arklow. I addressed this with the Tánaiste just a half an hour ago during Questions on Policy or Legislation, as well as the need for a town centre venue in Arklow. We must do everything possible to prevent the trend of vacancy taking hold in Gorey. I am not sure if the Minister of State knows the town well but it has a very strong retail sector, with many locally owned businesses supporting employment and economic activity. It has built a reputation as a shopping destination. It attracts visitors from all over Ireland, from Kerry to Donegal. It is really great in that sense. Protecting jobs and maintaining confidence in the town centres, whether it is Gorey or Arklow, must be a priority. In the case of Gorey, traffic management and parking are also huge issues.</p>
            <p eId="para_548"> Returning to Dealz, I urge the Minister of State to engage directly with Gordon Brothers by getting on the phone today if he has not already done so, and ensure the Workplace Relations Commission stands ready to protect the rights and entitlements of the workers during this process. I submitted a parliamentary question on this matter. In the reply, which I received on 18 November, I was informed the Department had not received a collective redundancy notification from the company. Will the Minister of State provide an update to the House today? Has that position changed and what engagement has the Department had with the company to ensure workers are given clarity, certainty and protection at this very difficult and stressful time for them?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_327" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_549">I thank the Deputy for raising this important issue. I am taking the matter on behalf of the Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment, Deputy Burke. The Minister understands from media reports that the UK parent company of Dealz filed notice of its intention to appoint an administrator to the company in the UK and that the UK courts extended the deadline while it seeks to find a solution. The Minister fully appreciates this is an uncertain and difficult time for all involved. However, he does not wish to speculate on these media reports given that this is an evolving situation. The Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment has not received a collective redundancy notification from Dealz.</p>
            <p eId="para_550"> In circumstances where an employer becomes insolvent, there are robust protections in place for affected workers. Employees' entitlements are protected under the redundancy payments scheme and the insolvency payments scheme. These schemes guarantee employees' statutory redundancy payments and certain wage-related entitlements, including arrears of wages and minimum notice. In such circumstances, normal collective redundancy rules must still be complied with, either by the employer or by a responsible person such as the liquidator. These rules require a 30-day information and consultation process with employees' representatives. The Minister for Enterprise, Tourism and Employment must also be notified at least 30 days before the first redundancy takes effect.</p>
            <p eId="para_551"> Where job losses occur, the Intreo service of the Department of Social Protection can assist affected employees with income supports, employment opportunities and training programmes where required. The Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment has also published an information handbook on collective redundancies on its website. This handbook provides clear and accessible information on employees' rights and remedies, particularly in cases of company insolvency.</p>
            <p eId="para_552"> That is the statement the Minister has asked me to share with the Deputy. I do not know whether it adds to the information he already knows, but if he has any further questions he should feel free to ask them.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#FionntanOSuilleabhain" eId="spk_328">
            <from>Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_553">I appreciate that a procedure and a protocol have to be followed. As I said, however, this will be possibly the final pay cheque for Dealz staff in Gorey and across the State before Christmas. As the Minister of State knows, Dealz is part of Poundland in the UK and the issue has been raised in the House of Commons as well. I urge the Minister of State, apart from the protocols that are there, to engage directly by phone with Gordon Brothers and put the Workplace Relations Commission on notice that the workers' rights and entitlements will have to be protected across this State, including in Gorey.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertTroy" eId="spk_329" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance">
            <from>Deputy Robert Troy<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_554">I thank the Deputy. We all recognise this is a hugely uncertain time for the workers in Dealz. It is not just Dealz in Gorey given that the shops are in many constituencies, including in Mullingar in my own. All our thoughts are with the people who are facing an uncertain time. As the Deputy said, especially in the lead-up to Christmas, the one thing you want to have is certainty about your employment. It is an evolving situation. We do not know for a fact that the two chains are linked, that is, whether the jobs here will be protected or whether they will not. It would be good to have clarity on that situation. Regardless of the outcome of that, what I can offer as reassurance is that if the worst fears are realised and if there are redundancies in Dealz, the State stands ready. There are protections in place, as I outlined in my previous reply, and the Minister, the Department and the State will not be found wanting. That said, we do not know for certain what the future holds in this situation. We await that and we stand ready to provide all the supports we can should the worst of what is happening in the UK materialise in the subsidiary company here.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_41">
          <heading>Artificial Intelligence<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#MalcolmByrne" eId="spk_330">
            <from>Deputy Malcolm Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_555">I thank the Minister of State for taking this Topical Issue on artificial intelligence in schools. I had the privilege of being able to chat to some of our visitors from Gorey Community School, who were taking part in the Oireachtas politics and society quiz just prior to coming into the Chamber. They are in the Gallery with their teacher Ms Russell and, indeed, one of the winners of last year's Oireachtas politics and society quiz, Ciarán Rowsome, is here as well. A Chathaoirligh, I expect we may see him on the floor here at some stage in the future asking questions long after we have departed.</p>
            <p eId="para_556">I welcome the students from Gorey Community School.</p>
            <p eId="para_557"> For that school, and indeed for schools all over the country, with the rapidly changing technology that is artificial intelligence and the impact it is having on society, it is critical that AI be embedded in a safe way within our education system. I am a little concerned that the Department of education is not moving quickly enough to be able to assure teachers as to what can be done and to ensure that students can use AI safely. When the Minister, Deputy Naughton, addressed the teacher conferences in April, I am afraid she adopted the classic Civil Service approach of kicking something down the road on the issue and she set up a review group. My problem is that the review group has met only twice since April. For a transformative technology that students and teachers are using, we are not looking sufficiently at embedding it within our education system in a safe way and providing the necessary support, particularly to teachers.</p>
            <p eId="para_558"> I contrast this with, for instance, Estonia. Estonia has partnered with a number of the tech companies, including OpenAI and Google. Teachers there have much more control over what comes into their classroom. They have developed learning models using AI. The teacher determines whether it comes into the classroom and over 98% of classrooms have now adopted it.</p>
            <p eId="para_559"> I want us to have a much more planned approach to how we will use AI within our education system. We have to have ring-fenced funding to provide for upskilling teachers, not just technology teachers but those throughout our education system, so that they will understand how they can use it as a learning tool. Teachers are certainly using it already for planning their classes and so on, but we should provide the support for them to be able to use it as a tool. That ring-fenced funding is critical. I am somewhat critical of Oide, which within the Department is meant to be rolling out new educational tools. There should be a more proactive approach to encouraging their use, even through pilots. Where teachers come up with innovative ways to use AI to facilitate and encourage learning, that should be facilitated. Oide is not being sufficiently proactive in encouraging the use of some of the new educational tools that are coming out.</p>
            <p eId="para_560"> The Minister of State will be aware that some of the plans for leaving certificate reform have had to be put on hold because of what has been happening with AI. The National Council for Curriculum and Assessment needs to look at how AI will be integrated into the learning processes. It does not matter whether it is accountancy or business studies or whatever subject because AI, quantum computing and new technology are going to shape all those disciplines into the future, so it should be embedded into the curriculum. More broadly, we have to ensure a programme of literacy around AI and new technologies. I hope the Minister of State will give me some assurance that the Department is taking the issue seriously.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMoynihan" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Education_and_Youth" eId="spk_331">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Education and Youth (Deputy Michael Moynihan)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_561">I thank the Deputy for his question. I welcome the Gorey Community School pupils here today, as well as their teacher, Ms Russell. I congratulate the students on their achievements and wish them the very best into the future. It is always great when we are talking about a subject on education to see young people who are in the education system and are constantly challenging us as decision-makers and policymakers in terms of the future of education and how best that can be developed. One of the most important and evolving areas is the use of AI in education. There is evidence that AI is becoming part of our everyday life and this includes our schools. Without a strong foundation in digital literacy, learners may struggle to engage safely and effectively with AI tools. Digital literacy and skills are currently embedded throughout the curriculum for primary through to post-primary, ensuring that there are opportunities for learners to engage with technology, media and information critically, creatively and safely while building their digital literacy. AI tools and technology are evolving at pace. Teachers and learners are engaging with these emerging technologies. With the rate of change challenging traditional approaches to the development of policy and practice, it places a huge responsibility on the Department of Education and Youth to ensure that teachers and learners are equipped to use AI thoughtfully, critically and responsibly.</p>
            <p eId="para_562"> My Department does not mandate the use of any digital technology as schools have autonomy to decide their own approaches as to their use of technology, which includes the use of AI. Guidance provided by the Department of education and evidence from research set out that teachers and school learners should establish a clear purpose for AI use, identifying specific needs or challenges where technology can support teaching, learning, leadership and management. To make these decisions effectively, teachers and school learners need access to the relevant professional learning opportunities and practical supports and resources. There is an array of supports in this area. The Department of education published guidance on AI in schools last year. The guidance supports teachers and school learners to build their understanding and confidence in engaging with AI responsibly and appropriately. Version 2 of the guidance will be published early next month.</p>
            <p eId="para_563"> My Department has also had a range of direct training and resources for teachers and school learners. Oide Technology in Education was established on behalf of my Department and has a dedicated online AI hub. The AI hub provides support for teachers to develop their understanding of the practical applications and implications of AI. It has a range of professional learning material and resources, including online courses on AI, good practice and an expert video series, as well as other professional learning initiatives. Significant work has been undertaken by Webwise, which focuses on developing AI literacy, critical thinking and responsible digital citizenship, to support children, young people, parents and educators to navigate GenAI safely and confidentially. These are available through its website. The Department of Education and Youth is also developing further training and supports using learnings from a range of European AI initiatives and pilots that the Department and Oide are involved in. Learning the outputs from the technical support instrument of FutureProof Education: Supporting Schools in the AI Evolution will include toolkits and professional learning modules on various aspects of AI in teaching and learning. Earlier this year, my colleague the Minister for Education and Youth, Hildegard Naughton, established an AI-in-schools external advisory task force to further support the Department in developing supports. </p>
            <p eId="para_564"> I will come back in with a couple of points that I wish to make in my closing remarks.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MalcolmByrne" eId="spk_332">
            <from>Deputy Malcolm Byrne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_565">I thank the Minister of State. I welcome his indication that an updated version of guidance will be published next month. He has provided me with some reassurance. However, it is critical that students and teachers are actively involved in this process. As much as this issue is discussed in every boardroom and staff room, we need to see it discussed in every classroom. I want reassurance that we are not going to be left behind in this space. I know from talking to teachers that they want to engage much more in using this technology as a tool. It is not a goal in itself; it is a tool. Students want to use it as a tool and are using it. However, it is about ensuring that it can be used safely and responsibly. I welcome what the Minister of State said.</p>
            <p eId="para_566"> I would like Oide to become more proactive. A lot of teachers are very innovative, as are a lot of students. At the young scientist competition in January every year, Young Social Innovators and all the various programmes we see young people using AI and tech tools to be able to learn and to explore new topics. Within the Department, Oide needs to be much more proactive to encourage that and to encourage pilots. I sometimes worry that the Department is too cautious and conservative. That is not to say we should not have guardrails in place, but this technology is moving very quickly. We have always been very proud of how innovative our education system is. We should be to the fore in embracing this new technology and ensuring that all of our students have access to it and can use it responsibly.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMoynihan" eId="spk_333" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Education_and_Youth">
            <from>Deputy Michael Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_567">I thank the Deputy. He is correct; we can see the use of AI and technology among students from schools across the country, no more than in Gorey, at the young scientist exhibition and the expertise that is brought there. At the Education Buildings Ireland 2026 conference last week at the RDS, a number of companies were showing their wares in the area of construction.</p>
            <p eId="para_568">Some of the exhibitors said former exhibitors at the Young Scientist and Technology Exhibition had brought their technology and learning to the workforce and have set up companies. </p>
            <p eId="para_569"> I want to be very clear that the Minister, Deputy Naughton, and I are acutely aware of the challenges being faced with AI. The Deputy mentioned boardrooms and everything else. Everybody understands the challenges presented by AI and we are duty bound to make sure that teachers, school learners and the entire education system are equipped with the best possible resources from the Department. We take this very seriously because it affects the next generation. It is about embracing the technology that is there. Some of our team explained to me this morning how fast the technology is changing, not just on a yearly basis but by the month in terms of some stuff that can be done now that could not be done on 1 September and so forth.</p>
            <p eId="para_570"> I understand the situation and we are taking it extremely seriously right across the Department. I do not think we have the opportunity to be cautious on this because it is travelling at such speed. We have to be ahead of it and equip teachers, school communities and, by extension, school learners with the best possible advice on AI. We will be held accountable for that. We are very much aware of the challenges and are dealing with them in the best possible way we can across the Department.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichealCarrigy" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_334">
            <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Micheál Carrigy)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_571">I welcome the students from Gorey Community School and their teacher, Ms Russell. They are very welcome to the House. Two Members from their local constituency are looking after them today.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_42">
          <heading>Special Educational Needs<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#RobertODonoghue" eId="spk_335">
            <from>Deputy Robert O'Donoghue<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_572">The Minister of State probably knows more about our constituency than any other Member not representing the constituency at this point. On Monday, Deputy O'Reilly and other representatives from Dublin Fingal West, including me, met principals and deputy principals from across Balbriggan. They came to us to express serious concerns about how the proposed changes to special education have been communicated and the uncertainty surrounding what the changes could mean for children, families and schools. </p>
            <p eId="para_573"> While no formal policy has been put forward as yet, the concerns among school leaders and education staff are real. They believe that the current model is already struggling to function effectively and introducing changes without proper consultation, planning and resources could create considerable disruption for schools. Every child deserves the opportunity to reach their full potential, to have appropriate assessment and diagnosis, to have the right supports when they are needed and access to an appropriate school place. We must also ensure that the voices of children and their families are heard and are central to the process. Parents must be listened to, involved and supported. They cannot become an afterthought in decisions that will directly shape their children's future. </p>
            <p eId="para_574"> There is real concern that these changes are premature, in particular at a time when school staff already face enormous pressures and demands. We must recognise that children's needs are not all the same. There are care, educational and behavioural needs and complex individual circumstances. A one-size-fits-all approach will not work. There are other and better ways to support children with additional needs. I urge the Minister of State to listen to the people on the ground: principals, teachers, special needs assistants and families. If we want to get this right for children, then we must listen to the people who work with and support them every day. Can the Minister of State guarantee that consultation will be carried out with teachers and principals at as early a stage as possible?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#LouiseOReilly" eId="spk_336">
            <from>Deputy Louise O'Reilly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_575">I thank principal Gillian O'Brien from St. Mologa's for facilitating the meeting on Monday with elected representatives and others. It was an important meeting. I want to underline that these are very busy people. They are running schools. They have an awful lot on. They had to make time to meet their representatives during their busy day because this issue is causing them such concern. The concern expressed was not for themselves - I need the Minister of State to hear this - but for the children who will be impacted. </p>
            <p eId="para_576"> The Minister of State knows that rumours and ideas circulate and kites fly. Enough of that goes on and it is unfair, in particular to those who are teaching children with special educational needs, their parents and, more importantly, the children. They asked us some very simple questions. The announcement regarding the proposed removal of the assessment of need and formal diagnosis as eligibility requirements was made by the Minister's colleague, Deputy Foley, in November 2025. We know that a communication was sent to the patron and management bodies a few weeks ago and they were made aware of it, but they do not have any information. </p>
            <p eId="para_577"> Their questions were very simple. They want to know where their voice will be heard, rather than being told people are listening. They want to know whether there is a structured process for these principals. I did not count up the length of experience but there were probably decades of experience at the meeting - that is not to out anyone's age. The principals have a lot of experience and spoke on behalf of the children. They want to know, in a formal structured way, how the parents, children, teachers and school community will be heard as part of this process.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMoynihan" eId="spk_337" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Education_and_Youth">
            <from>Deputy Michael Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_578">There is a formal statement on what I want to say, but I want to speak to the specific issue. I thank the Deputies for raising the issue with me. Their colleague raised it in the Seanad on Tuesday. All Oireachtas Members who were at the meeting on Monday morning have spoken to me about it. I appreciate the principals who sat down with Members on Monday and wanted to speak to them about this issue. </p>
            <p eId="para_579"> I want to be extremely clear. Special education is evolving. I cannot be clearer that no decisions have been made regarding any changes. Work is ongoing at a desperately early stage. We have to make sure we have the best possible special education into the future. I know at primary school level the amount of investment given by principals, school leaders, school teachers and SNAs across the education system. At post-primary, they have really stepped up to the mark over the last year or so in providing specialised education, for which I thank them. No decision is being taken at this point in time. I want the message to go out that if there are any changes, they have to be made with the best will of everybody concerned because we will bring nobody together unless we have the voices of teachers, unions, school management and families. </p>
            <p eId="para_580"> We have to admit that over the past number of years we have built up a hugely bureaucratic system for families trying to access education or health services or therapies. I genuinely believe that we need serious engagement with everybody concerned to try to break down those barriers and remove the challenges faced by parents and school communities every day of the week. We are looking across the system to figure out how we can have a new system in place that does the best for the child and ensures they have ready access to specialised education. We have seen those barriers broken down in terms of summer provision and access to special education in mainstream education. I admire how the Deputies work across their constituency. I have no idea how many education queries I have answered. I welcome the opportunity to speak on this. </p>
            <p eId="para_581"> This Topical Issue provides me with the opportunity to reassure the Deputies and the principals they met that no decisions have been made and any decision that will be made will have to have the confidence of educators, be they teachers, teaching unions or school leadership. As the Deputies pointed out, principals are very busy people and are doing extraordinary work across the education system. I have visited in excess of 200 schools the length and breadth of the country over the past year and a half and will continue to do so. I applaud the work they are doing. I reassure the Deputies the work will have to be done in collaboration and partnership. Discussions will have to take place to see whether we can have a better or more streamlined system.</p>
            <p eId="para_582">No decisions will be taken unless we have the confidence of the education community and the families.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RobertODonoghue" eId="spk_338">
            <from>Deputy Robert O'Donoghue<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_583">I thank the Minister of State for the frankness of the answer. No decisions have been made, it is at a desperately early stage, and the voices of teachers, students, management and parents will be heard. They will have to have confidence in it and it is good to hear the Minister of State give us that confidence.</p>
            <p eId="para_584"> As my constituency colleague mentioned with regard to what was heard at the meeting on Monday, teachers are very busy. What struck me was that they were talking about forward planning and how they can be ready for whatever changes may come in the future. We have spoken about the access and inclusion model, AIM, on a number of occasions in the House and outside it. To use the AIM figures to help forward planning from the early years sector into primary school is a good way to forward plan for primary schools.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#LouiseOReilly" eId="spk_339">
            <from>Deputy Louise O'Reilly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_585">I thank the Minister of State for his reply and for being frank, which will be very much appreciated. What he said was that no decisions have been made in relation to any changes, which is welcome, and that it is at a desperately early stage. Now is the time to hear the voice of the teachers, so hopefully, in his final reply, the Minister of State will be able to tell us in a structured way how they can make their voices heard. They can make their voices heard through their representatives and we are available to meet them. I know that the school principal, Ms O'Brien, and others will reconvene, busy as they are, to meet the Minister of State. I offer him the invitation to come to Balbriggan to talk to the principals and deputy principals and to hear their concerns at first hand. Now is the time at what the Minister of State has described as the desperately early stage.</p>
            <p eId="para_586"> The children in my constituency face really long waits for assessments of need. They wait 55 months or more for therapies. This is in the ether. The Minister of State has gone some way towards allaying the concerns, and I thank him for that, but if he would hear from them directly, that would be important. If he can, at this desperately early stage, as he says, he might tell us how the voice of the teacher, the voice of the parent and, most importantly, the voice of children will be incorporated into this process in a structured way.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#MichaelMoynihan" eId="spk_340" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Education_and_Youth">
            <from>Deputy Michael Moynihan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_587">I will make two points: it is in the early stages and there is no done deal or anything like that. I want to reassure the Deputies on that point.</p>
            <p eId="para_588"> The teacher unions have written to us formally. I take their comments very seriously. Ultimately, we need to have the co-operation of everybody. In correspondence and discussions I have had with principals and communities, they have all said the same thing, which is that they want to do the right thing. We do not want to build up another bureaucratic system that parents and schools have to go through and that nobody has confidence in. We are going to listen to every single one of them.</p>
            <p eId="para_589"> I have no difficulty with a meeting. I could make five halves of myself with the number of schools that are looking to meet me. I would love to meet the school principals and school communities because they tell the absolute truth of the challenges they face on the ground. I speak to school principals, teachers and SNAs every day of the week about their concerns. I do not have any difficulty in meeting groups of principals at all.</p>
            <p eId="para_590"> The point I want to make is that we are going to have a robust system in place that will ensure the confidence of the sector. We have built up a bureaucratic system. Deputy O’Reilly mentioned the waiting time of 55 months for an AON. All of those structures were built up. That was because we were afraid to try to see what the root issue is and how we can best apply the resources of the State, so the child has the best possible chance in life and school communities are resourced properly to ensure they can accommodate that child. As we know, education is about equipping them for adulthood, so we have to be very mindful of that. The Minister, Deputy Naughton, and I have had many discussions on this. We will tackle the issues and try to break down the barriers that are in place to make sure there is easier and better access and that we have the confidence of the education community in doing that.</p>
          </speech>
          <summary eId="sum_14">
            <i> Cuireadh an Dáil ar fionraí ar 2.05 p.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 2.46 p.m.</i>
          </summary>
          <summary eId="sum_15">
            <i> Sitting suspended at 2.05 p.m. and resumed at 2.46 p.m.</i>
          </summary>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="statement" eId="dbsect_43">
        <heading>International Men's Day: Statements<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#KieranODonnell" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" eId="spk_341">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Kieran O'Donnell)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_591">I welcome the opportunity to address the House on men’s health today and to mark International Men’s Day. This is an important opportunity to recognise the contribution that men and boys make to our families, communities and society. While there has been real progress, we also need to look at where men continue to experience poorer health outcomes. We need to understand why those inequalities persist and what more we can do about them.</p>
          <p eId="para_592"> Men in Ireland are living longer and healthier lives than previous generations. We have seen improvements in life expectancy, cancer survival and mortality from major diseases. The rate of suicide has also reduced over the longer term. However, there remain differences in health outcomes between men and women. In 2023, men’s life expectancy was three and a half years lower than women’s. In 2022, 40.2% of deaths among men occurred before the age of 75. The rate of premature death among men was approximately 40% higher than among women. These are not abstract statistics. They represent fathers, sons, brothers, partners, friends and colleagues whose lives are being cut short. </p>
          <p eId="para_593"> The causes are complex. Cancer and cardiovascular disease remain major causes of illness and premature death among men. Men also experience higher levels of a number of important risk factors, including smoking, harmful alcohol use and overweight and obesity. There are also differences in the way men can engage with health services. Men can be less likely to attend their GP, participate in screening or seek support when experiencing mental distress. We, therefore, need to look both at the diseases themselves and at the circumstances that contribute to them. </p>
          <p eId="para_594"> Men’s health is not simply about individual lifestyle choices. Our health is shaped by where we are born and where we live, the work we do, our income and education and our family circumstances. It is also shaped by the communities around us and whether we can access services when we need them. Those factors do not affect every man equally. Men experiencing poverty and socioeconomic disadvantage often experience poorer health outcomes. Traveller men; migrant men; men with disabilities; gay, bisexual and transgender people; men experiencing homelessness; men in prison; and men living in isolated rural communities can face particular barriers. That is why improving average population figures is not enough. We must also reduce inequalities between different groups of men. </p>
          <p eId="para_595"> Ireland has a strong history of recognising these issues. The national men’s health policy 2008-2013 was the first national men’s health policy of its kind internationally. That work was followed by Healthy Ireland - Men 2017-2021 and the current national men’s health action plan 2024-2028. The current action plan provides the basis for our work today. It recognises that improving men’s health requires action on prevention, mental health, chronic disease and how men engage with health services.</p>
          <p eId="para_596">It pays particular attention to men experiencing the greatest disadvantage. It also reflects an important lesson from the past two decades: if we want men to engage with health services and health promotion, we need to think about how and where we can reach them. We cannot always expect men to come to us. Sometimes we need to go to where men already are. </p>
          <p eId="para_597"> Looking at key interventions and community-based approaches, that principle is at the heart of programmes such as Engage, Ireland’s national men’s health training programme. It is also central to On Feirm Ground. On Feirm Ground was developed specifically to respond to the health and well-being challenges farmers face. Farming can involve long and irregular working hours, financial pressure and isolation. Farmers also face unpredictable weather, succession issues and significant demands in their day-to-day work. There can also be a strong culture of self-reliance. That can be a strength but sometimes it can make it more difficult to acknowledge that something is wrong or to seek support. The programme, therefore, works through agricultural advisers and other professionals who already have trusted relationships with farmers. It equips them to recognise signs of distress, begin conversations about health and well-being, and guide farmers towards appropriate support.</p>
          <p eId="para_598"> Importantly, we now have evidence that this approach strengthens the knowledge and confidence of the professionals trained to support farmers. The evaluation of On Feirm Ground found significant improvements in advisers' knowledge of farmers' mental health following training. It also found improvements in their confidence and ability to identify health concerns, and their willingness to direct farmers towards support. Those improvements were largely sustained six months after the training. Perhaps most importantly, advisers reported that they were putting the learning into practice. Many spoke about allowing a few minutes at the end of an ordinary conversation with a farmer to ask how things were going. This may seem like a small intervention but sometimes a conversation with a trusted person is the beginning of someone asking for help.</p>
          <p eId="para_599"> The evaluation demonstrates something important for men’s health more generally. Services can be more effective when they work with the relationships and settings that are already part of men’s lives. That means workplaces, farms, sports clubs, community organisations and men’s sheds can all have a role alongside our formal health services. As we all know, men’s sheds themselves have become an important part of community life throughout Ireland. They provide much more than somewhere to undertake an activity or work on a project. They provide social contact, friendship, a sense of purpose and somewhere to belong. That matters because loneliness and social isolation are public-health issues. They can affect both our physical and mental health, particularly following retirement, bereavement, unemployment or relationship breakdown. The sheds for life programme builds on these existing relationships by bringing health and well-being supports into a trusted community setting. Another programme, men on the move, similarly uses physical activity, peer support and social connection to engage men who may not otherwise participate in structured health or exercise programmes. These initiatives tell us something fundamental about good public health: the service must work for the person, rather than expecting the person to work around the service.</p>
          <p eId="para_600"> Regarding suicide prevention and social connection, mental health is an especially important part of that work. Many men find it difficult to acknowledge mental distress or ask for help. Sometimes distress presents in other ways such as increased alcohol or drug use, gambling, isolation, anger, risk-taking or simply withdrawing from family and friends. We, therefore, need to make it normal for men to talk about mental health before they reach crisis point. It is equally important that when somebody does seek help, the appropriate support is there. Our approach increasingly recognises that good mental health begins long before a person needs specialist support. It is shaped in our homes, schools, workplaces and communities. It is strengthened when people feel connected, have a sense of belonging and purpose, and have the knowledge and support to deal with difficult periods in their lives. That is why mental health promotion, prevention and early intervention are increasingly important parts of our overall approach. There is now a specific commitment to tailor and expand mental health promotion initiatives to meet the needs of men, working with the community and voluntary sector. This will also be continued work through men’s sheds to support resilience, positive coping strategies and peer engagement.</p>
          <p eId="para_601"> Social prescribing also forms part of this wider approach. For someone experiencing loneliness or social isolation, the most appropriate support may not always be clinical. It may mean helping them take part in physical activity, join a community organisation, volunteer, or get involved in arts and culture. These local activities can help people connect with others and improve their well-being. This is why we are continuing to expand social prescribing and improve its reach, particularly for people who are marginalised or vulnerable.</p>
          <p eId="para_602"> Workplaces are another important setting. For many men of working age, the workplace may be one of the most practical places to promote health and well-being. We are, therefore, strengthening the evidence base around workplace mental health promotion, including supports suitable for small and medium-sized businesses. This means acting earlier to prevent mental health difficulties. It is about supporting people to remain well rather than waiting until they become seriously unwell.</p>
          <p eId="para_603"> Regarding budget allocation and investment, budget 2027 supports that wider direction. The total allocation for mental health in 2027 is €1.657 billion, an increase of €108 million, or 7%, on 2026. That investment includes funding for an additional 285 mental-health clinicians across a range of services. It also strengthens crisis services, suicide prevention, community mental health services, youth mental health and counselling supports. Of particular relevance to today’s debate is further investment in free counselling and community therapy supports under budget 2027. This includes additional provision for men, young people and members of the LGBTQ+ community. This builds on the strong demand we have already seen for counselling supports for men.</p>
          <p eId="para_604"> This is important investment but mental health services alone cannot address all of the factors that influence men’s well-being. We also need action across employment, education, housing, transport, community development, sport and social protection. That is why Government believes the next phase of men’s health must involve even stronger cross-government working. We have already seen what this can achieve through our work on farmer health with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. Our work with other Departments and community partners also shows the value of this approach. We need to build on those partnerships.</p>
          <p eId="para_605"> Physical health must be given the same attention. Cardiovascular disease remains one of the most significant causes of illness and premature death, yet many of its main risk factors can be prevented or reduced. These include smoking, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, overweight and obesity, physical inactivity, diabetes and harmful alcohol use. There is now significant momentum at European level to strengthen cardiovascular prevention. The European Commission’s Safe Hearts Plan is the first EU-wide approach to cardiovascular disease. It covers health promotion and prevention, early detection and screening, as well as treatment, care and rehabilitation. It also pays attention to the needs of vulnerable population groups. One of its important messages is that we cannot wait until somebody experiences a heart attack or stroke before addressing cardiovascular risk. We need to identify risks earlier. That includes high blood pressure and other cardiovascular risk factors that can remain undetected for years. The Safe Hearts Plan also encourages member states to develop or strengthen national approaches to cardiovascular health. In line with the EU Safe Hearts Plan, work has commenced in Ireland on the development of a national cardiovascular plan. This will build on the existing cardiac policy and will be informed by the European framework. Prevention, early detection and health equity will be important elements of that work. That has particular relevance for men. We know men can present later to health services, and that smoking, overweight and obesity, alcohol consumption and high blood pressure contribute to cardiovascular risk. The answer is not simply to tell men to live more healthily. We must create the conditions that make healthy choices easier and ensure men at higher risk are identified and supported earlier.</p>
          <p eId="para_606"> Obesity must also form part of that discussion. Overweight and obesity are major risk factors for cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, some cancers and other chronic diseases. Our developing policy approach reflects the need for a stronger focus on prevention and earlier intervention, while recognising obesity as a complex chronic disease rather than a matter of personal failure or individual willpower. For men, this means ensuring that prevention, treatment and support are accessible and designed in ways that encourage engagement. It also means recognising that the foundations for good health are laid much earlier in life. If we want healthier men in the future, we must support healthier boys and young men today.</p>
          <p eId="para_607"> The same principle applies to tobacco and alcohol. Smoking remains one of the most significant preventable causes of illness and premature death. Ireland has made major progress in tobacco control but we cannot become complacent. We must continue supporting people who smoke to quit and prevent a new generation from becoming dependent on nicotine. Similarly, harmful alcohol consumption contributes to cardiovascular disease, liver disease, cancers, accidents and mental-health difficulties.</p>
          <p eId="para_608">These issues are interconnected. A man experiencing stress, isolation or financial difficulty may smoke more, drink more or become less physically active. In turn, those behaviours can increase his risk of chronic disease. That is why prevention must consider the whole person rather than treating individual risk factors in isolation.</p>
          <p eId="para_609"> In terms of cancer screening and survivorship, cancer is another major cause of premature death among men. Earlier presentation, prevention and participation in appropriate screening have important roles to play. Men who are eligible should participate in BowelScreen and men should be encouraged to discuss concerning symptoms with their GP rather than waiting until those symptoms have become severe. We also need to support men living with and beyond cancer. A cancer diagnosis and treatment can affect physical health, mental health, relationships, employment and sexual well-being. Survivorship must therefore be understood more broadly than simply whether treatment has been successful. As we look to the future, prevention will increasingly need to become part of everything we do. Prevention is not an alternative to investing in hospitals or treatment. We will do both but if we can prevent illness, identify disease earlier and help people manage risk before it becomes serious, we improve people’s lives and reduce avoidable pressure on health services.</p>
          <p eId="para_610"> Budget 2027 provides a total of €29.1 billion for health services. This includes an additional €1.76 billion to expand capacity, strengthen community services and progress reform. That is a very significant public investment. Our responsibility is to ensure that investment is matched by improved outcomes for patients and communities. A greater focus on prevention and early intervention is part of achieving that. There is also a strong economic argument. Preventing cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes, mental health difficulties and other chronic conditions means people can remain healthy, active and independent for longer. It means fewer lives cut short. It means less time away from work and family. It means reducing avoidable demand on services that are already under considerable pressure.</p>
          <p eId="para_611"> Looking to the future direction for men’s health, men’s health will remain an important part of our future public health and prevention work. Without pre-empting policy processes that are still under development, Government wants to be clear about the direction in which we believe we need to go. We need a stronger emphasis on prevention across the life course. We need to reduce health inequalities and focus more strongly on the men experiencing the poorest outcomes. We need to make services easier for men to access and use. We need to build on community approaches that have demonstrated their ability to reach men. We need stronger action across government on the factors outside the health service that shape health.</p>
          <p eId="para_612"> Work currently under development is examining how prevention, treatment and support for overweight and obesity can be strengthened. Men and boys must be part of that work. Government wants our policies to recognise that men themselves must be involved in shaping the solutions. We should build on the strengths that already exist within families, workplaces, sporting organisations, farms and communities rather than approaching men’s health only in terms of deficits or problems. That is why the next phase must remain practical. We need to ask what actually helps a man attend a health check. What helps him talk about his mental health? What encourages him to take part in screening? What helps him to become more physically active? What helps him to stop smoking or reduce harmful drinking? What enables him to maintain friendships and social connection as his circumstances change throughout life? The answers will not be identical for every man, but the evidence demonstrates that we can improve engagement when services are designed around real lives and real communities.</p>
          <p eId="para_613"> Ireland has led internationally on men’s health before and we should be proud of that. However, leadership is not something that can simply be claimed on the basis of what we did in the past. It has to be maintained through action. That means implementing the current men’s health action plan, investing in effective programmes, evaluating what works and being prepared to expand successful approaches. It means ensuring that men’s health is considered across our broader work on prevention, cardiovascular health, obesity, mental health, cancer and chronic disease. It means continuing to listen to men themselves.</p>
          <p eId="para_614"> Men’s health has improved considerably in Ireland. That progress should give us confidence. The continuing gaps in life expectancy, premature mortality, suicide and preventable chronic disease show that our work is not finished. The next phase requires us to move further upstream. It means preventing illness where we can. It means identifying risk earlier. It means making services more accessible. It means reaching men through the communities and settings they already trust. It means concentrating our efforts where the need is greatest.</p>
          <p eId="para_615"> We have good foundations on which to build. We have two decades of experience in men’s health policy. We have dedicated national leadership. We have strong community and voluntary partners. We have programmes that have shown that men will engage when we get the approach right. Our task now is to build on that progress. I look forward to hearing the contributions of Deputies today and to continuing this work to improve the health and well-being of men and boys throughout Ireland.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_342">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Mark Wall)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_616">Before I call Deputy Devine, I welcome some groups that were previously here. I think they will come back for the debate. They are: Unmasked: Men's Health Peer Support Group from the Liberties; Drogheda and District Men's Shed; Ballyfermot Men's Shed; and Ashbourne Men's Shed. They are guests of Deputy Devine today.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaireDevine" eId="spk_343">
          <from>Deputy Máire Devine<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_617">There are also the guys from the wee county, Louth, and individual people from all over Leinster.</p>
          <p eId="para_618"> I sit on a lot of community groups, committees in here and whatever. When they deal with social experiences, social ways of doing things, things we need to correct or things we need to improve, they are usually packed with women. The other side of it is that the finance committee is packed with men. I think Mairéad Farrell and I are the only women on the budget oversight committee and there are only two or three women on the finance committee. I have always said, "If you're not at the table, you're on the menu." However, I need to flip that around because it usually would refer to women. I thought: why are men not here? What is stopping them? Where are they?</p>
          <p eId="para_619"> There is increased destabilisation of the world and the increased influences of horrible toxic people on our boys and men whom I deal with on a daily basis in my constituency. When I try to talk to these boys and young men, I can see the malign influences that are happening. I thought this is an opportunity on Lá na bhFear. I am used to saying mná na hÉireann but in this case it is fir na hÉireann. I was delighted to send out an invitation inviting all these groups of men who are grappling with poverty, mental health issues, addiction issues and really pulling up their boots and trying to make sure they, their brothers, their fathers, their uncles and their sons have an opportunity to talk and to have a conversation. It is as simple as that because if they are not at the table chatting, they are left out and they have been left out.</p>
          <p eId="para_620"> I thank an Cathaoirleach Gníomhach for saying hello to them all. We had a wonderful celebration of International Men's Day in the Ceann Comhairle's office. I thank her for giving us that opportunity. We had great songs and stories outlining heartbreak and fun. We ended with Aslan and very working-class communities came in to have a say. They were overawed to actually be in this place because they never thought it was for them. That is an important lesson for all of us to take on board.</p>
          <p eId="para_621"> International Men's Day was established in the 1990s and takes place in 80 countries worldwide. We also have Movember. I have seen a few dodgy moustaches over the last month or so but fair play because it is raising that health issue for men. Since the 1990s it has grown. Let me put it on the record that this is the first time International Men's Day has had statements and-or a celebration in this House and that needs to continue. The idea behind it was to serve as a moment for all of us to recognise and celebrate the men who are part of our lives: our fathers, our brothers, our sons and our spouses.</p>
          <p eId="para_622">These men significantly and positively impact those around them and we love them for it. "Love " is another word men find difficult to say publicly.</p>
          <p eId="para_623"> The thing for today, or for this year anyhow, is The Future is Everyone. It is an invitation to everyone to recognise and support males and to recognise the contributions of men to families, communities and society. It also seeks to raise awareness about men's health, mental well-being and the challenges they face.</p>
          <p eId="para_624"> My colleague, Councillor John Smyth, who serves in Fingal, is a psychologist. He spoke, as the Minister of State did, about the real need to get those conversations out of the formal settings and the clinical setting and to meet people where they are - on the street, in the cafés, in the men's sheds and in the workplaces where it is much easier for men to open up. They might not even realise that is what they are doing but it is a very healthy way to engage. That is what he is doing on the ground - the street psychologist or whatever you want to call it - and that needs to happen instead of the formal sit-down with the couch, the psychiatrist and all that sort of stuff.</p>
          <p eId="para_625"> Today is a great opportunity to take part in local, national and global conversations about manhood, masculinity and men's issues. The highlighting of the social issues they face is making a difference to boys and men in our community. We must celebrate them in all their diversity. I acknowledge that mental well-being is a major component of what men's sheds do, what psychologists do and what friends do for each other. In regard to the suicide rate among men, while it may have slightly decreased, it is still the case that three out of four suicides are by men. In many rooms, and I am sure in rooms in this establishment, are sons, brothers and fathers who have lost their loved ones. That means a lifetime of unbearable pain and a lifetime of an unsettling that really does not calm down. We keep telling boys to man up and not to cry because boys do not do that.</p>
          <p eId="para_626"> Men die, on average, six years younger than women. They are more prone to social isolation. Boys underperform girls at every stage of education. We need to ask why.</p>
          <p eId="para_627"> We say - and I have probably said it myself in years gone by - that every day is International Men's Day. To some extent, that is true at certain levels of our society but we need to have the conversation when it is not International Men's Day every day. We need the conversation about what manhood means and what masculinity means.</p>
          <p eId="para_628"> Today, we focus on what unites humanity and on the opportunity to work together in terms of men having positive relationships and serving as positive, loving role models for our youth, especially our boys. There are three sets of objectives. Have I got much time?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_344">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Mark Wall)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_629">The Deputy's time is up.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaireDevine" eId="spk_345">
          <from>Deputy Máire Devine<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_630">Okay. I will be quiet for now.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_346">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Mark Wall)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_631">I call Deputy Kenny.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MartinKenny" eId="spk_347">
          <from>Deputy Martin Kenny<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_632">I am glad to be able to speak today on International Men's Day. As Deputy Devine said, we often have to accept that men, in general, hold most of the power in politics and everywhere else in society. From that point of view, every day is a man's day and we need to recognise that. Of course, we also need to recognise the huge positive contribution that men make to society and the generosity, power, strength and will they have to achieve and to do things and make things better for everyone in their lives. We all come across that on so many occasions.</p>
          <p eId="para_633"> Many years ago a young man who I was quite close to died by from suicide. We talked about it afterwards with his peers, who were all teenagers. They were telling stories about him, the things he had done and the craic he was and all of that. I said to them that it was clear they all loved him, not in a romantic way, but that they loved that human. Unfortunately, however, he did not have the capacity to love himself. That is the part that we need to get to - for people to have that sense of being able to look into themselves and see the joy and beauty and the capacity to do good and to have a magnificent life.</p>
          <p eId="para_634"> We have a society that has a lot of difficulties in it. Men are under a lot of pressure and because men, as we said, are the ones who are generally the people in power positions and who have the potential to be in power positions in society, they are bombarded with all this stuff, whether it is pornography or this macho image or ego. Men have a tendency to be addicted to things, whether it is alcohol, drugs or whatever. A lot of men get into that rut but they also become addicted to ego. Ego is as dangerous because it gives them this sense of being all-powerful and of being better than others and of thinking they are so great and that they should dominate and that type of mentality. While that is damaging to everyone around them, it is more damaging than anything to themselves. We need to recognise that and do work around that.</p>
          <p eId="para_635"> I appreciate the Minister of State's opening remarks with regard to the work that has been done with farmers, through men's sheds and through so many areas of our society, including the workplace. We need to get to that part of health, which is about mental health but also about ego and that sense of domination. That is something we need to address in the context of all of this. It is very damaging to anyone who adopts that type of attitude.</p>
          <p eId="para_636"> Men, in general, are very hesitant to say there is anything wrong with them. They say they are all right and that there is nothing wrong with them. If they have a worry or a tendency to find something difficult, they see it as a wrong rather than just a situation that can be resolved. We need to work on that as well. Men, in general, have the capacity to bring so much good to the world and do so in most circumstances. There are also, of course, the times they do not.</p>
          <p eId="para_637"> However, the biggest difficulty we have is the relationship between men and women and the tension and difficulties that are there at times. That is something that men have to address. Deputy Devine said they find it hard to say they love someone but they find it harder to say they love themselves than anyone else. That is where that comes from and that is why we have a lot of work to do in that context.</p>
          <p eId="para_638"> While Government has provided funding and assistance to all of these groups and so on, in every constituency office in the country, we still meet men who have difficulties with their mental health or difficulties with the system and they cannot get through it. They are turned away. They go into a hospital, usually to an accident and emergency department. They are suicidal and maybe have been that way for weeks. A psychologist sits in front of them for ten minutes and tells them they are okay and that they can go home. Their family could have spent weeks trying to get them to that point. There is, therefore, a lot of work to be done to provide adequate services for people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWard" eId="spk_348">
          <from>Deputy Mark Ward<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_639">I welcome this opportunity to speak on International Men's Day. I want to thank my mother, my partner, my daughters and my aunts for all the lovely cards and presents I got this morning. The Minister of State knows I speak in jest. I know the women in the Gallery did the same for the men in their lives today. I am often reminded by the women in my life that every day is men's day and I, for one, am not going to argue with them on that.</p>
          <p eId="para_640"> I was thinking about what I was going to say on this today, so I put my republican hat on and thought about what International Men's Day means. To me, it is not about empty platitudes. It is about recognising the real challenges men face across Ireland and committing to the real political action that we, in this House, have a chance to implement to make it better for them.</p>
          <p eId="para_641"> Right now, there are many men who are carrying a silent crushing weight. We have too many young men who are still living in their childhood bedrooms because of a broken housing system. This takes a toll on their mental health. We have fathers out there who are working full-time and who are finding it really difficult to put food on the table, pay the bills at the end of the week and heat their homes because of the increase in the cost of living. There are loads of men who are in the same situation today, so we need to make sure we have Government policies that are going to deliver affordable homes and decent public services. At the moment, there is a perfect storm out there that is causing harm.</p>
          <p eId="para_642"> We cannot talk about International Men's Day without talking about the crisis in men's mental health. The statistics are stark. In 2022, 79% of all deaths by suicide were by men. Suicide remains one of the leading causes of death among young men on this island. I encourage men to seek support, talk to someone or link in with a service.</p>
          <p eId="para_643">There is also an onus to make sure that when they link to a service there is a service for them to access. I have said before that mental health crises do not just happen between Monday and Friday and the hours of 9 to 5. They can happen at any time. We need 24-7 emergency mental health support for men when they reach out.</p>
          <p eId="para_644"> Building a better future for men goes hand in hand with building a better and more equal society for everybody. True equality means challenging toxic behaviour. It is down to men here to challenge toxic behaviour when we see it. It is about ending gender-based violence and fostering positive male role models for the next generation of boys. It means creating an economy that rewards hard work, builds secure homes and ensures no man and no family is left behind. Today, let us celebrate the good men in our lives, and there are many. Check in on your mates. Reach out to a brother. Reach out to your neighbour. Let us work together to build a fairer and healthier Ireland where every person has a chance to thrive.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_349">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_645">I made the point to the Minister of State and to senior and junior Ministers in the Department of Health about how it uses its time in the Dáil to progress issues. We spend a lot of time on statements on lots of issues and we do not see enough legislation. I would have far preferred the Minister of State to be here today with a Bill on a right to home care. That would benefit men and women across the country. It was promised in 2017, almost a decade ago. We are waiting for legislation. We have to be conscious of that, and we need to progress legislation. We should be using our time well in this House and we should be progressing legislation that benefits everybody.</p>
          <p eId="para_646"> Like others, I think every day of the year is international men's day. Men dominate politics, the boardroom and many parts of Irish culture. They hold more power than women in our society. While we have the opportunity, we will take it to highlight some of the issues facing men, particularly some of the health issues I am conscious of, and some minority groups that face particular issues.</p>
          <p eId="para_647"> This is something I have been working on in my capacity as Chair of the Oireachtas health committee. We put a focus on mental health this month. We had an interesting session earlier with Jigsaw, Shine and Movember. I am one of those people, as Deputy Devine said, who is sporting the dodgy moustache for the month to try to start some conversations. It does work. People raise it jokingly and ask what you are doing it for. You can talk about mental health, how people are keeping, raise a bit of money and have a bit of fun. We had an important session of the health committee where we talked about these issues and about suicide rates, which are really alarming. The CSO figures from 2022 show that 500 people died by suicide that year and four out of five of them were men. There are really alarming figures when it comes to the number of men in this country who die by suicide. We have to address those figures, reduce those rates and ensure we do everything possible to alleviate the distress some men face and that there are services. I am conscious that we tell people to talk and reach out and so on, but there have to be services and supports when somebody reaches out. We have to ensure those services are well funded, well resourced and available in all of the communities across the country, and that we build out community services and supports, so that when people reach out for help and support they can get them. We see people waiting up to two weeks to access even basic GP services. Some of them cannot even get on a GP list. We know from Movember that 97% of GPs had encountered a man who was suicidal every year. There are issues in accessing services.</p>
          <p eId="para_648"> Men often present late for a mixture of emotional, social, behavioural and developmental reasons. There are barriers to accessing services in terms of traditional masculinity. We also see issues online with the manosphere. It is concerning how the online discourse is impacting on men and boys. An interesting paper published by <i>The Lancet </i>last month said the manosphere is a public health issue and we should think about it in that context. The lucrative and misogynistic online industry has direct and indirect health harms, including widespread mental health impacts from body dissatisfaction to distress and depression and dissuading boys and men from seeking help, perpetuating stigma, providing simplistic explanations to the problems they face and blaming women and girls for those problems, which is resulting in a rise in violence against women. We need to take seriously the manosphere and start considering it a public health issue, as recognised by the experts in that paper published in <i>The Lancet</i>. They set out a series of things that can be done to address this. It would be worth the Department engaging with that research and considering how it could be done as part of its ongoing work programme. I might come back to the Minister of State at a future point and get an update on how we can look at that.</p>
          <p eId="para_649"> We also know men face disparities in the area of physical health. Some 40% of Irish men die prematurely and the vast majority of those deaths are preventable. That is an extraordinary number of Irish men dying before their time because of illnesses we know are preventable. More men die from the five leading causes of preventable and manageable diseases than women. It is 148% higher for circulatory diseases, 58% for digestive disorders, 32% for respiratory illness and 17% for cancer. These are preventable deaths. They are things that can be managed and addressed. We know that men are dying much earlier. Some of that is from a reluctance to engage with health services, particularly in respect of some cancers such as testicular or prostate cancer. There can be shame and stigma. People may have symptoms but be shy and unwilling to go to a doctor. If people are worried about their health and have symptoms, I encourage them to reach out to the GP, go to the doctor, talk about it and get the support they need. They should not let things develop for too long. I have talked to too many men who say they have had something bothering them for a while and they leave it and say they will get around to it or come to it. They should make the time and prioritise their health because the earlier they intervene, the better with some of these. Prevention is also really important. There are health disparities men face that need to be addressed.</p>
          <p eId="para_650"> I am also conscious of men from minority and disadvantaged backgrounds who face real health inequalities, such as men in prison and Traveller men. We have a report from the Traveller committee, of which I am a member, setting out the stark health inequalities faced by Travellers, particularly men. I am glad that report will be debated in the Dáil in a couple of weeks’ time. I hope we can get the senior Minister in for that debate and report because it is an important one. It was published in June and the senior Minister has not engaged on it yet, so I would like to see her come to the House and discuss it with us. There are extreme levels of inequality. We know Irish Travellers face symptomatic racism, discrimination and neglect. The life expectancy of Traveller men is 15 years shorter than the average and that should really concern us. They are dying way before their time and the suicide rate is seven to eight times higher for Traveller men.</p>
          <p eId="para_651"> Significant issues are faced by Traveller men and other minorities. We know gay and bi men face higher levels of mental health distress, with 28% reporting symptoms of anxiety and 23% reporting depression because of homophobia, transphobia and the structural discrimination faced by gay and bi men. We have to ensure the health service tackles these issues in a proactive way and reduces these health inequalities, particularly for minority groups, so we can create a society where everybody can thrive.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_350">
          <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_652">On International Men’s Day I thank all the men in this country who do incredible work in our communities and provide a positive role model for what it is to be a man and show men can and do play a central role supporting communities and building better communities. I commend the work of community organisations like STAR in Ballymun, which does incredible outreach with the local community. There are also the Whitehall and Ballymun men's sheds that provide important spaces in our communities.</p>
          <p eId="para_653"> I will also speak briefly about the issue of homelessness. I raised the case of a man in my constituency who is in his 60s. He is working and he is living in his car. It is scandalous that this is what he faces. We know there are many men in homelessness in this country and hundreds over the age of 50 in emergency accommodation or hidden homelessness. For people in homelessness, there is the challenge of getting up every day, the sense of self-esteem and the impact of not having a home. There is a particular way it affects men's sense of themselves and their pride. It affects those who have children. In this case the man has a child. He feels utterly broken every day that he cannot provide a home for his child.</p>
          <p eId="para_654">It is an absolute shame in this country that we have so many men living in homelessness and we fail them by not enabling them to be their best selves.</p>
          <p eId="para_655"> The other issue I want to talk about in the time that is left is that, as the father of two boys, I am deeply worried and concerned about the world in which they are being brought up, and particularly the issue whereby the online world in which they are being shaped is deeply disturbing. Toxic masculinity online, or a toxic version of what it is to be a man, is actually promoted in the online world by the algorithms, the big tech companies and the big social media giants who own these because it is profitable. This Government has not tackled that issue. By not standing up to that and by not getting the algorithms turned off and changed, the Government is facilitating that toxic masculinity that is destroying the lives of our young boys and girls. That needs action on this day.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JoeNeville" eId="spk_351">
          <from>Deputy Joe Neville<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_656">First, I welcome my guests in the Public Gallery: Eimear Whitney, who is a friend of mine, Brian Whitney, Salum al Amin, Fay Hayes and Massie Kate Wasson.</p>
          <p eId="para_657"> What we are discussing today is very topical. Deputy Hearne spoke to the difficulties and the challenges of being a young male, but first I want to speak briefly to how lucky I was growing up and the positive role models I had here. We can talk about the negative role models but we also have to talk about the positive role models, such as my dad, Tom Neville, who got up every day, worked hard and looked after his family. He was my primary role model and continues to be a role model for me. My uncle Dan, who served here, and my uncle Micheál, who had the farm, were also very positive role models. On the other side, there was my uncle John B., who is my godfather, his brother T.P., who looked after us as well, and even my uncle Cyril, who had to go to London and work on the buildings and raise his family. All around me I had positive role models, including my brothers, Tom, Mick and Donie. I have been lucky but I am also conscious that not everybody is as lucky as I am. People do not necessarily have those positive male role models in their lives and it can make it difficult. In many ways, I had it easy in that respect. In fairness, a lot of those role models have led me to be in the position that I am in here today. I am conscious of that and aware of the impact that those men had on my life. Obviously, women had a primary role, and particularly my mother, but we are making statements in here today on men and that is why I specifically referenced those people.</p>
          <p eId="para_658"> As Deputy Hearne said, we need to talk about who those role models are for a lot of younger people, such as people on TikTok. As the students in the Gallery scroll through, they see role models flashing their muscles, flashing their cars - whatever it may be - and showing a different element. We should not look to that as a positive role model, where a post shows something flash or something to potentially strive for that they really should not strive for, or shows women in a negative light, in a light that they should not be shown in. Ultimately, men and women working together is the best way possible for us to achieve a positive society, and that is really important.</p>
          <p eId="para_659"> Transferring that to a local level, I look at the work that the team in the Leixlip Youth Project does. They do a huge amount, especially with younger boys in Leixlip. I see how they deal with them and chat to them. I see what Mars and her team do. They engage with them and they bring them through because, as I said, not all of them are necessarily as lucky as I was to have such positive role models. We need more of those sorts of projects. We need more of that investment in north Kildare. The Cathaoirleach Gníomhach, Deputy Wall, is based in south Kildare, where there are similar outlets in Athy and Newbridge. We need to have more of those in, for example, Celbridge, Maynooth and Kilcock, where we can show more engagement with those young people and ensure they see positive role models, as I said, rather than those negative ones they can see on their phones.</p>
          <p eId="para_660"> Finally, I want to speak to a different genre of male and a really positive transformation we have seen in the last ten or 15 years, namely, the growth of men's and women's sheds, albeit obviously the former in the context of this debate. We have seen our communities come together. In the past, it was around the pub table. In fairness, if you did not go to the pub, you did not see anyone, but where I have really seen positive engagement in our communities is through the older aged and men getting together. They might be retired, but they are able to come together. I saw the announcement today by the Government. I know the Minister of State here is fully in support of it. The Minister of State, Deputy Buttimer, who made the announcement, said we should continue to support men's sheds.</p>
          <p eId="para_661"> Like the Cathaoirleach Gníomhach, I will continue to work in the same vein for all the men of Kildare.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_352">
          <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_662">I wish Deputy Neville a happy men's day and thank him for leaving me some time to speak. It is interesting what he said.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#KieranODonnell" eId="spk_353" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
          <from>Deputy Kieran O'Donnell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_663">It is quality you want.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_354">
          <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_664">International Men's Day provides a great opportunity to remember the people who inspired us in our lives and who taught us lessons. Sometimes, particularly with men, it is not necessarily what is said but what is done. I am thinking of my own grandfather, George Lawlor. He was Noël Browne's director of elections and inspired me to get involved in politics. My other grandfather, Dan McAuliffe, taught me and my father that hard work is important. My father certainly carried that on. Unfortunately, men do not talk about those things with each other.</p>
          <p eId="para_665"> This week, I could have spent no time at all here in the Chamber given the number of events being held for International Men's Day. I was at an amazing event yesterday in Whitehall Colmcille, a great GAA club - not as good as my own Ballymun Kickhams but a great GAA club.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#KieranODonnell" eId="spk_355" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
          <from>Deputy Kieran O'Donnell<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_666">Good recovery there.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_356">
          <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_667">The place was jammers. It had the Whilehall men's shed, the Skelly's Lane men's shed and other men's sheds from right across the city, all celebrating International Men's Day together and exchanging those few words with somebody to be able to talk to. I also want to give a shoutout for the Retired Active Men's Social, RAMS, from Newcastle - brilliant singers, amazing entertainment.</p>
          <p eId="para_668"> There are so many other men's sheds. I welcome the funding announced this afternoon, at almost €1.1 million for men's sheds. There are a lot of men's sheds in my area, including in Ballymun and Finglas, but a lot of them are not registered. A lot of them do not want to go to the bother of registering. I would encourage groups to get involved. Being linked in, even just with the local authority, gives them those extra supports. Perhaps the local authority can help them apply.</p>
          <p eId="para_669"> I acknowledge the huge amount of work. We have done a lot in terms of life expectancy for men, particularly given that it is now 80 years of age. It has increased by three and a half years since 2007. We will all take those extra three and a half years when we need them. While that gap has narrowed between men and women, however, we still have a long way to go.</p>
          <p eId="para_670"> I often have people in my clinic, particularly men after they retire, who have spent their entire life working hard and when they retire, they find a gap. There are so many outlets, whether in local community organisations or the library service. There are so many great things and I would encourage people to reach out and maybe where they did not have the time to be involved in their community, now when they retire is the perfect time to do that because having that interaction and engagement all feeds into a healthy, positive retirement and into expanding your life overall.</p>
          <p eId="para_671"> I wish everybody a happy International Men's Day, particularly Deputy Ó Cearúil, whom I will pass over to in good time.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#NaoiseOCearuil" eId="spk_357">
          <from>Deputy Naoise Ó Cearúil<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_672">A lot of people have spoken here today about the number of events happening, not only today but throughout the week, for International Men's Day. It is great to see how far that has developed, such that men can now talk about their health, including their mental health.</p>
          <p eId="para_673"> It is critical that we now have third spaces. We have the men's sheds, which are such an amazing resource, particularly for older men. Generally speaking, it is retired men, but younger men are involved as well. In Kildare, I want to acknowledge Celbridge, Leixlip, Maynooth, Confey, Johnstown Bridge and Clane men's sheds, which do an amazing amount of work in Kildare North. There are a lot of amazing men's shed groups in Kildare South as well.</p>
          <p eId="para_674"> I also want to acknowledge Celbridge Boys' Club, which is a group that has come together. Younger men go out for walks. They are not actually boys now. They are in their 20s, 30s, 40s and 50s. They go out hiking and they talk about their mental health. It is another example of a third space for men, which is so positive and is such a good development.</p>
          <p eId="para_675"> Yesterday I held an event in Leinster House on preventing gender-based violence against women.</p>
          <p eId="para_676">We had some amazing speakers, including Seán Cooke, CEO of the Men’s Development Network, Ellen O'Malley-Dunlop, who was CEO of the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, Professor Debbie Ging from DCU, and Claire Lott, the mother of Nadine Lott who was horrendously murdered in 2019 by her partner. That event was quite interesting, eye-opening and, in ways, emotional. What we have to try to do is change men's mindsets from a younger age. From secondary school in particular, the focus has to be on how they view women. We speak about hardcore pornography, the manosphere and what we see online but we have to ensure the White Ribbon campaign, run by the Men’s Development Network, is expanded to as many schools as possible to ensure men see women in the same positive light and equal light rather than from a chauvinistic perspective.</p>
          <p eId="para_677"> I pay particular tribute to Claire Lott who spoke powerfully yesterday about what a healthy relationship is. We need to listen to victims and victims' families when it comes to gender-based violence and make an impact on people at a younger age in particular.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#FionntanOSuilleabhain" eId="spk_358">
          <from>Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_678">Today we celebrate International Men's Day and the hugely positive contributions men and boys make to our communities. We constantly hear the refrain that every day is men’s day, it is a man’s world, etc., but we should remind ourselves of a few of the startling statistics of this men's world. They are quite stark and shocking and they demand action.</p>
          <p eId="para_679"> Men account for 95% of all workplace deaths and 78% of all road fatalities in this State. Men in Ireland still die 3.6 years younger than women on average while globally it is 5.2 years younger than women. Men are 56% more likely to die prematurely than women, with cancer accounting for almost one in three male deaths. Men are 34% more likely to die from cancer than women. Some 77% of people treated for major heart attacks are men. Men are up to four times more likely to die by suicide than women. That is something that is well-documented but we have not seen action on it. More than six in ten men are overweight or obese, placing them at greater risk of chronic illness. Men are three times more likely than women to experience addiction, and account for 71% of alcohol-induced deaths. My own background is in primary school teaching and internationally boys are underperforming girls academically throughout the world.</p>
          <p eId="para_680"> When we hear these sweeping generalisations and sometimes disparaging comments about men, even in advertising, let us remember that behind each of these statistics is your father, son, brother, nephew, uncle, husband, partner and friend. There is a deep inequality at the heart of this issue.</p>
          <p eId="para_681"> A man living in one of Ireland’s most disadvantaged communities – working-class men - can expect to live five years less than a man living in one of the most affluent areas. Similarly, rural and farming men can get left behind and isolated. Too often men are encouraged to stay silent, ignore symptoms and put off seeking help. Too often support only arrives when a crisis has developed. Men's sheds are crucial and need to be supported. They bring incredible value to the community. I thank Deputy Devine for bringing in members of a men's shed today. I was delighted to meet them. We need greater investment in men’s sheds and mental health services as well as in stronger cancer, prostate, and cardiovascular screening programmes, better workplace health initiatives, and targeted supports for men. If we are serious about improving public health, we must be serious about improving men's health. It is not just about statistics.</p>
          <p eId="para_682"> I urge the Minister of State to take note of the conversations we are having today. It is great that we are having them. As we approach the Christmas period, I acknowledge the number of men who will be having Christmas dinner alone or maybe meeting their children in McDonald's in the afternoon for one hour due to the ongoing failings in multiple systems, including our dysfunctional family law system. We need positive role models for boys and to strive towards equality for all because many boys are being targeted by corporate groups. What they did to girls in targeting them for many years in terms of their self-image they are now doing to boys. They are doubling their marketplace and shareholding and we need to keep an eye on that. I hope the Minister of State takes these discussions on board. I wish the men in our lives a happy International Men’s Day.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CiaranAhern" eId="spk_359">
          <from>Deputy Ciarán Ahern<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_683">As the Cathaoirleach Gníomhach can see, I have given over my own face to the cause of men’s health this month, much to the chagrin of my wife. However, assuming our marriage survives this, I wish to give a shoutout to Movember and thank it for all the important work it is doing. It has become one of the strongest voices internationally for men’s health, and mental health in particular. The money raised every November from Movember funds mental health services, suicide prevention, and research into prostate and testicular cancer. Movember has done a lot to reduce the apprehension many men feel about asking for help when they are struggling, and has helped to encourage men to proactively contact friends they know may be struggling on some level and ask if they are all right.</p>
          <p eId="para_684"> We know men in this country die younger than women and make up the large majority of suicide deaths. Too many of us go years without speaking to anyone about how we are really feeling and too many of us are reluctant to see a doctor until a problem has become a crisis. That is slowly changing, thankfully. We are beginning to see that talking is a sign of strength rather than weakness and that is thanks in no small part to the work of organisations like Movember and others, including our sports clubs, local community groups like men’s sheds, and individual campaigners, as well as the men who have been brave enough to talk about their struggles openly and honestly in public forums.</p>
          <p eId="para_685"> These can be struggles related to work, relationships, alcohol, drugs, gambling, you name it. When it comes to problem gambling, I commend the work of the Gameplan, founded by Sarah Healy, which works with sports clubs and uses the language of sport to tackle the issue of problem gambling. It gives coaches and players the playbook they need to spot the signs of problem gambling and raise it with people they think may be showing these signs and lead their peers towards help. It is a really important service.</p>
          <p eId="para_686"> To go back to Movember and something that is a personal issue to me, in the Real Face of Men's Health Report from 2025, Movember found that 61% of dads believe society does not do enough to support them and called for action on paternity leave. More recently, the Movember report, Extra time with Dad, made the case that paternity leave is not just a nice thing to have but it is a public health matter. Ireland provides a few weeks of statutory paternity leave, the minimum required under EU law, and ranks fifth from the bottom among EU member states for paid leave for new dads. The payment is €309 a week, less than 40% of the median weekly income in Ireland. It is no surprise, therefore, that one in two dads here does not take any paternity leave at all. Some 67% experience financial strain as a result of taking leave and half feel that taking more leave would put their career at risk. We need to do better on this front. Men are being told, in effect, that they have a right to be at home at the most important moment of their lives but they will have to pay for it, and perhaps pay with their careers as well.</p>
          <p eId="para_687"> Dads who take paternity leave report better mental health, stronger bonds with their child, and a greater ability to support their partner. That last point is crucial. By providing such little paternity leave for dads, there is a tacit expectation that the majority of caring responsibilities in the first few weeks of a child's life will fall on the mother. That responsibility should be shared equally. I have spoken about taking paternity leave as a TD following the birth of my second son last year. I was lucky enough to be able to afford to do so but others are not so lucky. Being there for your family as a new dad should not depend on your employer’s goodwill or ability to top up your statutory paternity pay.</p>
          <p eId="para_688"> The Labour Party proudly introduced paternity pay ten years ago when we were in government. I do not think we anticipated that more than a decade later, Ireland would still be at the bottom of the European table. We would like to work with the Minister to improve that. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EoghanKenny" eId="spk_360">
          <from>Deputy Eoghan Kenny<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_689">As the youngest Member of this House, I want to use my time on International Men’s Day to speak in particular about the challenges facing young men in Ireland. We need to have a much more honest conversation about what it means to be a young man in society. There is enormous pressure on young men to be successful, financially secure, look a certain way and, above all, appear as though they have everything under control. The reality is many do not. Social media has definitely intensified those pressures. Young men are constantly and consistently comparing themselves to others and are increasingly exposed to sordid ideas of masculinity.</p>
          <p eId="para_690"> As a young gay man, I am particularly conscious of the expectation society places on young men about how they should behave and who they should be.</p>
          <p eId="para_691">No young man should ever feel he has to change who he is in order to be accepted. There is no single way to be a man. As a former secondary school teacher, I recognise the important role our schools, sporting organisations and communities play in shaping young men.</p>
          <p eId="para_692"> We must create environments where boys feel comfortable expressing themselves without fear of ridicule or judgment. In 2024, 387 men died by suicide in Ireland, accounting for more than 80% of all deaths by suicide. Behind every one of those figures are a devastated family and a life that really mattered. We constantly encourage men to speak up, to reach out and to ask for help, but we must ask ourselves what happens when they do that. What happens when they are placed on a waiting list for mental health services or cannot afford private counselling? We cannot spend today, all of us in this House, encouraging men to break their silence if the State is not prepared to listen when they do.</p>
          <p eId="para_693"> Men's health is also an issue of social inequality. Men living in our most deprived communities have a life expectancy five years shorter than those living in our most affluent ones. That is a profound injustice. We need properly funded mental health services, accessible addiction treatment, affordable GP care and greater investment in preventative healthcare.</p>
          <p eId="para_694"> Today is also an opportunity to celebrate the most positive contribution men make to our society and recognise our fathers, brothers, teachers, coaches and friends who are positive role models in our lives. Supporting men and boys should never be seen as being at odds with advancing equality for women and for girls. We can and must do both.</p>
          <p eId="para_695"> Finally, to young men across Ireland, it is okay not to have your life figured out at 18 or 21 or 26. It is absolutely okay to struggle. It is okay to ask for help, and there is absolutely no shame in admitting that you are definitely not okay. Being a man should never mean suffering in silence, and I wish every man across the country a happy International Men's Day. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" eId="spk_361" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach">
          <from>Deputy Mark Wall<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_696">Like the Acting Chair, I have given over my face, as Deputy Devine would say, to dodgy facial hair. It has been very worthwhile, however, because like the Acting Chair and other contributors today, it has started a conversation with many of my friends and a lot of people I meet are asking my why I have suddenly taken on this new feature. As the Acting Chair said, it is thanks to Movember and it does start that conversation. I think it is very important that we do that. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaireDevine" eId="spk_362">
          <from>Deputy Máire Devine<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_697">Is it going? </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" eId="spk_363" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach">
          <from>Deputy Mark Wall<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_698">It is very important that we continue to do that because conversations, as has been said by so many contributors, are so important to men's health.</p>
          <p eId="para_699"> I want to concentrate on two areas of men's health, the first ofd which is prostate cancer. We recently met people behind Movember and they told us that men were waiting over 180 days in the public system for rapid access clinics for a biopsy for prostate cancer or potential prostate cancer compared with 57 days for those going private. A number of men I have met in my clinics over the past days have asked me to raise this because some of them have been those soldiers, as we might say, who have come up against those time delays, and it needs to improve. There have been calls for a national conversation and a national screening service, and I have raised this with the Minister for Health. It happens in the UK, and it needs to start happening here. We have a brilliant breast check service here and prostate cancer, as we all know, is so detrimental to men's health. Given how many men suffer from it, we need to take it seriously. The home tests we have for prostate screening need to happen more regularly because too many of our men are suffering from that disease.</p>
          <p eId="para_700"> I also want to concentrate on mental health, which been raised by almost every contributor today. Yesterday in the Dáil I raised the case of two young men who had been brought by their parents to accident and emergency departments in two different hospitals. Both were told they would get no help at the accident and emergency departments. That is simply not good enough. We all recognise the importance of mental health, and we all recognise the great job that all those working in the mental health service do for us day in, day out. However, when we hear from the Psychiatric Nurses Association of Ireland that there are 700 vacancies, that is simply not good enough, and it has to be having a knock-on effect on mental health. It is important that we call that out, particularly on men's mental health because we know, unfortunately, that nearly five times more men than women die from suicide. From my party colleague Deputy Lawlor, I know that the rate for Traveller men is seven times higher. Mental health is a serious issue in this country. I know the Minister of State has a particular interest in it and has done some great work in the area. We need to work with unions, and we need to see more people involved in helping men on this important day. I join with my colleagues in wishing all men a very happy International Men's Day. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JamesGeogheganFG" eId="spk_364">
          <from>Deputy James Geoghegan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_701">I do not think I have ever heard as many men talk about men in this Chamber. I want to compliment my former colleague on Dublin City Council Deputy Máire Devine for adding a female voice to this discussion.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#NaoiseOMuiri" eId="spk_365">
          <from>Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_702">Hear, hear. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JamesGeogheganFG" eId="spk_366">
          <from>Deputy James Geoghegan<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_703">There is a certain awkwardness about celebrating International Men's Day. We know that women continue to face enormous inequalities in our society. They face threats to their personal safety that most men will never have to contemplate, and we have much more work to do to achieve genuine equality. I am the father of two boys and a little girl who, it is fair to say, rules the roost. Like any parent, I spend a lot of time thinking about the world my children are growing up in, the challenges they will face and the kind of people I hope they will become. Recognising the particular challenges facing men and boys does not take away from any of that. Indeed, raising happier, healthier and more emotionally secure boys benefits all of society. I want my sons to grow up to be confident but kind, strong, compassionate and ambitious yet respectful, and I want them to understand that there is nothing remotely unmanly about expressing affection, showing emotion or asking for help. Yet, there are people online making enormous amounts of money telling young boys what it means to be a man. Too often the version of masculinity they are selling equates strength with aggression, success with wealth, vulnerability with weakness, and we cannot leave it to social media algorithms to teach our boys what it means to be a man. We need positive male role models in our homes, schools, sports clubs and communities, and we should celebrate the many men who quietly provide that example every single day, fathers, teachers, coaches, volunteers.</p>
          <p eId="para_704"> According to figures published by the CSO just three weeks ago, 481 people died by suicide in Ireland in 2024, and of those, 387 were male. That is eight out of every ten people. We know that behind every statistic, as the Deputy said earlier, are brothers, fathers, sons. There is still a generation of men who grew up believing that the appropriate response to life's difficulties is simply to get on with things, and we must continue to invest in mental health services, dedicated training initiatives and suicide prevention. Supporting men, however, is about far more than intervening at a crisis moment. Sometimes the most effective thing we can do is give somebody somewhere to go. We have heard an awful lot about men's sheds here today, and I want to acknowledge the extraordinary work of the men's shed movement. Equally, I acknowledge the work of the Minister, Deputy Calleary, and the Minister of State, Deputy Buttimer, in securing the long-term future of that movement. In my own constituency, I want to particularly acknowledge Rathmines men's shed, Orwell men's shed, Terenure men's shed and Raytown men's shed, to name but a few, and to acknowledge the funding that has been allocated to men's sheds over the last number of years. We all know in our communities as constituency TDs the value they bring and how it is much more than just a building. For any man who has retired, lost a partner, lost his job or lives alone, the small things like a cup of tea and a conversation can make an enormous difference. I want to pay tribute to everyone who keeps these organisation going and I encourage the Government to continue to work with the Men's Shed Association in securing its long-term future.</p>
          <p eId="para_705"> International Men's Day should not be about a competition between men and women in society. It should be about the kind of society we want to build and the kind of men we want our boys to become. As the father of two boys and a girl, I want all three of my children to grow up in a society in which they are brought up equally. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JohnLahart" eId="spk_367">
          <from>Deputy John Lahart<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T15:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_706">In the short time I have, I want to pick up on two themes rather than trying to fire through as many as possible. The first is born out of professional and personal experience of having had a health challenge a few years ago. It is a message to all men who might be listening or watching, or watching at some stage during the week if they catch up on this debate. It is a simple line that I have distilled from all the different things I have learned. Like many other men, I would have been that stereotype who avoided getting the health check-ups and things like that until there came a point when I just had to get one. The doctor, or other health professional, is your friend. All of the things I have learned over the last number of years can be distilled into that sentence.</p>
          <p eId="para_707">For men and women, clearly, the doctor is your friend. Somewhere along the way, men learned to avoid. Colleagues in this House have talked to me about a health concern they have. When I mention going to the doctor, they will grimace. Certainly, a look of fear or anxiety will come over their face. What I want to say to people is the doctor is your friend. The worst thing that can happen is you find out there is something wrong with you. In most cases, it tends not to be as big as you think it might be. If it is, with the advances in modern medicine and care, there is always a good chance that interventions can be made and assistance provided. The doctor is your friend.</p>
          <p eId="para_708"> The second thing is a theme raised by other speakers. It is about valuing men and women equally. There is a tendency to pit men and women against each other in terms of these issues. One of the previous speakers talked about advertising. One of the things I have noticed, and we are talking about it because it is International Men's Day, is that men can come off quite badly in modern advertisements. I find that, watching as a man. I am sure that is exactly how women felt for generations. There was a time when girls were way behind in STEM subject results and the State put in a huge amount of resources to ensure that they caught up. They have not just caught up. They have passed boys by, but nobody expresses any concern now that boys are falling behind. One of my favourite things every year is to go to the Young Scientist and Technology Exhibition. The organisers get quite excited now that for the third year running, there are more projects from girls and girls' schools than there are from boys or boys' schools. That is to be celebrated but, equally, we should be asking why there are not as many projects from boys' schools and why boys are falling behind. It is about valuing both sexes equally. Today, we get to mark that.</p>
          <p eId="para_709"> I raised two themes. The first is valuing our boys and our girls equally, particularly in terms of the resources we allocate to their education and health and second, for men, the doctor is your friend.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#NaoiseOMuiri" eId="spk_368">
          <from>Deputy Naoise Ó Muirí<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_710">A lot of the discussion today is rightly around issues such as mental health, addiction and homelessness, but I want to talk about fatherhood and ensuring fathers have a genuine opportunity to be present during the earliest days of their children's lives. When a child arrives, it is one of the most significant moments any family will ever experience. It is hugely exciting but can also be very stressful and challenging. For young families, life literally changes overnight and they do not get a manual as to how to handle this. Those first few months are particularly important as new parents begin to find their feet. That is when the new bonds form, when parents learn together how to navigate family life and when children benefit from the stability that comes from having both parents actively involved in their health and care.</p>
          <p eId="para_711"> Research consistently shows that children do better when fathers are engaged from the early stages of life. Mothers also benefit from having a partner who can share caring responsibilities, during what can be an exhausting and demanding period for the mother in particular. However, for first-time fathers, the reality is that work commitments and financial pressures can cut short this crucial time with their newborn. Fathers feel obliged at times to return to work, as do mothers, before they have had a meaningful opportunity to settle into family life and properly support their partner. Under current legislation, the Paternity Leave and Benefit Act 2016 provides fathers with two weeks of paid paternity leave. I think we should do better. Ireland is the fastest growing economy in the euro area and we have the capacity to support young Irish families. Let us extend paternity leave. It would be a welcome move from the Government to better recognise the role of fatherhood. Becoming a dad changes every aspect of your life. I do not believe that two weeks is enough to fully appreciate the magnitude of the change that occurs. Extended paternity leave will be good for dads' health, good for babies' health and good for families' health. On International Men's Day, let us recognise the importance of giving fathers a little bit more time with their newborns. Every child deserves a chance to build those early bonds with both parents and every father deserves the opportunity to be there from the very beginning.</p>
          <p eId="para_712"> I acknowledge the work of Theresa Kelly and the It's OK not to be OK campaign. Theresa is one of these unstoppable people in Dublin Bay North. Every constituency has them and needs more of them. It is a ground-up campaign. It is about people accepting and saying that it is okay not to be okay and facing up to the reality of that. I commend them on that campaign and look forward to supporting them in the years ahead.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulDonnelly" eId="spk_369">
          <from>Deputy Paul Donnelly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_713">International Men's Day is an opportunity to talk about the challenges facing men and boys but also about the practical things we can do to improve their lives. I want to speak about the men I meet in Dublin West all the time. They are fathers, grandfathers, sons and brothers. They are the men we meet at the school gate, at work, in the local pub, or at the football club standing on the sidelines on a wet weekend morning. Very often, they are better at asking how somebody else is than admitting themselves when they are struggling. I will do a call-out to highlight an event coming up this Sunday. It is called Shoulder to Shoulder, for International Men's Day, run by a Dublin West lad called John Boland. It will be on at 10 o'clock in Glencullen nature park. It is about men standing shoulder to shoulder and supporting each other.</p>
          <p eId="para_714"> Two in five Irish men die prematurely before the age of 75. Men are 56% more likely to die prematurely. Cancer and cardiovascular disease remain major causes of death. I am reminded of a report done by the Irish Cancer Society in 2014 in my constituency of Dublin West that highlighted that people in one part of Dublin West are two times more likely to die of cancer and three times more likely to die of any other disease. What is shocking in the context of that report is that working class men are at an even higher risk.</p>
          <p eId="para_715"> Mental health must also be central to this discussion. Men account for the overwhelming majority of deaths by suicide. Too many men still believe they are expected to cope alone and not ask for help. We need the services. We had it at an event today, where a chap called Luke talked about his mental health issues and how he had to really struggle to try to access mental health services. Time and again, it was not there when he needed it. We hear that constantly when people present to the emergency departments in hospitals. The supports are just not there. They are completely overwhelmed. We need services that do not simply wait for men to come through the door. We need to reach men where they are through their communities' workplaces, sports clubs and local organisations.</p>
          <p eId="para_716"> Men living in the most deprived communities can expect to live five years less than men in most affluent areas. Traveller men in particular present stark health inequalities, where the suicide rate is seven times higher than in the settled community. Where you are born, where you live and how much money you have should not determine how long you live. It should be prompt action. We need earlier intervention. We need the supports there when people, both men and women, need those supports. I encourage men to look after their physical and mental health, to talk to somebody when they are struggling and to know that asking for help is a strength and not a weakness.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#BarryWard" eId="spk_370">
          <from>Deputy Barry Ward<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_717">I have been listening to the debate today. It is very easy to highlight where men's health in particular lags behind the general population. There are complex reasons for that but the statistics bear it out as a factor. We know that men will live on average three years less than women, for example, and that men are more likely to be the victims of suicide. In fact, four out of five suicides in Ireland will be men. We are more susceptible to certain cancers. We are more likely to die from preventable diseases earlier in life. In fact, two in five of us will die from a preventable disease before the age of 75. Prostate cancer is a major issue. One in six men are likely to experience prostate cancer at some time in their lives. We can identify statistically that an issue needs to be addressed. The issue ranges, healthwise, from more minor matters to serious issues and to mental health issues. All of these have an impact on men in our community.</p>
          <p eId="para_718"> When I say men, I am talking generally. If we look specifically at Traveller men, the figures are even more stark. There is an issue there. I recognise that Healthy Ireland's national men's health action plan is in place and dealing with them but I also think that, as much as we can do, men need to play a serious role in what they do to safeguard their own health. Men need to go to their doctor. They are much less likely to go to the doctor than women are. Men need to take screening. Men need to take a proactive approach to their own health. So often it is the case, and I do not exempt myself from criticism in this regard, that we are too busy, it does not suit or there is so much more on.</p>
          <p eId="para_719">It is our responsibility, particularly those of us who have responsibility for other people. I have a little girl who is three years old. I want to be there when she is an adult to experience all the things she experiences as an adult and to contribute to them. If I do not look after my health, I will not be there to do that. All of us men need to take responsibility for looking after our health. That means being proactive, going to the doctor, getting screening when it is made available and getting check-ups to ensure we do not become part of the negative statistics that show there is a significant problem in respect of men's health.</p>
          <p eId="para_720"> The other thing that is part of this, in terms of issues around men, is the idea that we somehow should not share or talk about our problems. It is a bit of a trope, but the reality is that men do not share difficulties, certainly not in the way statistics indicate women do. I worry that sometimes people feel there is some kind of shame in being emotional, or sharing emotions or difficulties. The old adage that a problem shared is a problem halved may not be scientifically correct but it is certainly emotionally valuable. The more we realise that we can share, the better. I think most guys would say that when something is shared with them, they do not think less of the person who shared it or think they are weak or anything like that. I do not think serious, sensible people think those things. When we have a problem we want to share, we should not expect for a moment that sharing it with other people would cause them to think of us that way. Let us be a bit grown up about this. Let us be cognisant of the statistical fact we have work to do as men to deal with our mental health and physical health.</p>
          <p eId="para_721"> The State puts in place treatments and screening and there are ways in which we can visit our doctors and so on, but let us avail of them. Many men - I am guilty of this, as are friends of mine - decide there are more important things on the table at that moment than our health or the niggling thing we have, whether it is a pain or a sickness. If people have that, they should go to the doctor, speak to their GP or someone else who can help with it. If something is making them feel down, they should speak to a friend and share the problem with a colleague or friend because that can make all the difference. The statistical difference between men and women is evidence of that relatively small difference. Some are bigger than others. However, with a little work, a lot of ground can be made up by men to deal with the statistics that specifically apply to us and to the deficit in men's health.</p>
          <p eId="para_722"> Today is about more than health, but I wanted to focus on men's health because it is something we can take responsibility for. We can change the statistics and change the way our futures will pan out, if we just take a little more responsibility.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EdwardTimmins" eId="spk_371">
          <from>Deputy Edward Timmins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_723">I am pleased to speak about this important topic and thank the Dáil for giving time to this discussion. All people's health is equally important. It is not just that of men, but equally that of women and children. However, men's health has unique characteristics and is sometimes not discussed as openly as it should be. I will cite an extreme example of men's lives not being valued by our society as much as they should be. I am referring to the Russia-Ukraine war in which more than 500,000 young men have died on the battlefields. This is happening on our continent in Europe, yet this extraordinary loss of life has never got the attention it deserves. Is it because they are men? These young men are victims, like all victims throughout the world, but it barely gets reported.</p>
          <p eId="para_724"> In our country, the figures are stark. As Deputy Ward mentioned, approximately 40% of men die prematurely before the age of 75, with the vast majority of these deaths considered preventable. Cancer and cardiovascular disease remain the dominant cause of premature male death, while suicide continues to affect men disproportionately. Accidents are also a cause of death, with men working in the most dangerous occupations. We need to do more about work-related accidents. This is especially true in farming.</p>
          <p eId="para_725"> Men's health needs to be discussed more. We are making progress and today is another step in the right direction. Many men feel huge pressure to continue to work, even though their health is suffering. Some 50% of fathers who took paternity leave believe taking more time would have put their career progression at risk. Men need to realise that their health is not only important to themselves, but that it is important they are there to support those around them. That should be a great motivator for men to remain healthy.</p>
          <p eId="para_726"> All people, men and women, often set goals in the areas of money, career, houses and holidays, but people seldom set goals for exactly how long they want to live and what standard of health they want to enjoy throughout their lives. They take the issue of health and longevity for granted. The starting point of health, energy, fitness and a long life is for people to sit down and write a clear goal that they want to live until they are 80, 90 or more years old. Then people should list all the things they need to do and all the things they need not do to get them there. They will then develop the habits to help them to get there. There is no certainty in life, but there are things people can do to increase the chances of a healthy life.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PaulLawless" eId="spk_372">
          <from>Deputy Paul Lawless<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_727">I begin by speaking about the tragedy that is suicide. It is extraordinarily sad. It is happening in every community. It is hugely concerning and it disproportionately affects men. In 2022, 500 people died by suicide and 389 of them were men. That is almost one in four and it is young men in particular. One in three deaths among those suicides were of people aged between 20 and 24. There is also a big spike as men age above 70. It is a major issue. I know many families and communities that have been affected and many families will never be the same again.</p>
          <p eId="para_728"> There are major issues with the reporting of suicide. There is a significant lag. That is understandable because of coroners' reports and so forth. However, we need to look at it. The HSE's analysis suggests the reporting, although it is quite late, is about 30% higher than what is being counted. We need to review that, look at the numbers and study them because some of these tragedies can be prevented.</p>
          <p eId="para_729"> I commend the organisations, such as men's sheds and women's sheds, which do great work. I have attended many in my constituency and they are doing great work. It is a great outlet for men, particularly men who have retired and so on. I encourage men to consider joining a men's shed. It is a fantastic organisation. It is a great outlet for people and I encourage everyone, every man and indeed every woman now there are women's sheds, to join their local men's shed.</p>
          <p eId="para_730"> I will also speak about children, young people and bullying in schools and society. When I was young, people may have been bullied in the schoolyard and that was hard to take, but when they went home, they closed the door and they were safe. Nowadays, they are not safe because of mobile phones. Phones and social media mean that bullying is happening 24 hours per day, 365 days per year and it is having an enormous impact on young people. Schools are doing great work in many cases but they cannot police the internet and children - young boys and girls - are being bullied online. We, as a State, are doing little to protect them. These young people are the guinea pigs of this experiment. I have highlighted this previously with the Government. We need to look at a ban.</p>
          <p eId="para_731">We need to introduce a smartphone and social media ban for young people. I have called for this and raised it with the Taoiseach. The response was we cannot police it. It is hard to police the sale of alcohol to young people but we do it. Of course, there are instances where it happens but it is illegal, we stand over it and we come down heavily on those premises that illegally sell alcohol to children. We have bans on the sale of cigarettes so we can and should ban smartphones and social media for young people. Just because it is hard does not mean we should sacrifice our children. In the absence of government regulation and guidelines children are becoming victims of bullying. That is happening and nobody sees it but the child themselves. It is happening in such an insidious way and it is unacceptable.</p>
          <p eId="para_732"> Great work is being done by community groups and parents. I commend the Achill smartphone-free childhood imitative. A group of parents got together on Achill. They did a survey of all the schools on the island and 93% of parents of primary school-age children said they would rather delay smartphone use. As a result, they came together and formed a consensus they would delay the use of smartphones. I commend those people and the proactive families that have engaged in that initiative. The vast majority of families with young children want to see this. When it is suggested to parents that they just do not provide a phone to their children, they point out there is a knock-on impact when one child gets a phone. Before you know it, 80% of the class has a phone and the last remaining parents cannot hold out because they feel they cannot leave their child vulnerable and isolated. “Isolated” is the word I hear. Parents ask how they can delay their child receiving a smartphone if every other child in the class has one. They fear their child will be isolated in the Snapchat and WhatsApp groups and so on.</p>
          <p eId="para_733"> There is a role for the Government and the Minister for children to come in here, say this is our policy and enforce it right across the schools in the State. Will it be difficult? I think it will. Will it be policed right across the State? I do not think so. It would be a great challenge but it would set such an important precedent if the Government were to take the lead here. It should not be down to parents on Achill Island or other areas to take the lead. It would be an important step in the right direction to issue guidance to schools across the State and introduce a ban on smartphone use. It is having such a negative impact on our young people. I ask the Minister of State to really consider this.</p>
          <p eId="para_734"> I also want to raise GP access. For so many men and women who struggle with their mental health, the first place they may go is their GP but there is a crisis in GP access in this State, especially in Mayo. Recently a GP could not find a location in which to practise and was forced into early retirement. As a result, no additional GP in Westport could be found and the existing GMS patients were essentially merged into an existing GP practice. That is going to have such an impact. It will mean a reduction in access for people across the Westport area to a GP. A reduction in GP access in a primary care setting will have a knock-on impact in the form of greater pressure on the emergency departments in our hospitals. Data on this is not collected even though it should be, but hundreds of people end up taking their own lives following involvement in the HSE service. We should look at that. A person experiencing suicidal tendencies who presents at an ED that is overcrowded with people in the waiting room who have physical illnesses means it is not an appropriate place. I am very concerned about the lack of GP availability across the State.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" eId="spk_373">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_735">It is very important that we have these statements on International Men's Day. I take this opportunity to thank all the Deputies for their contributions to the debate. Ireland has seen many improvements in the health and lifespan of our men. However, we have many challenges and we must tackle them.</p>
          <p eId="para_736"> As has been highlighted, men’s health remains an area that requires focused attention and sustained policy action. There are persistent gaps in life expectancy and premature mortality between men and women that is largely preventable. We need to ensure it is prevented. To reduce these gaps we must accelerate prevention efforts like tackling smoking and harmful drinking as well as promoting healthy diets, physical activity and encouraging greater participation in screening and health checks. These are all areas we as a Government are committed to looking at.</p>
          <p eId="para_737"> Ireland’s recognition of men's health is a policy that has developed significantly over the last two decades. Ireland was the first country in the world to publish a men’s health policy in 2009. This was followed by two HSE action plans. At Government level we are working in partnership with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the Department of Social Protection to support men’s health initiatives. This needs to be extended to other Departments. My Department, the HSE and many community and voluntary organisations have been working in close partnership over the past 20 years in an effort to improve the health and well-being of boys and men in Ireland. We also have leadership in the HSE on these issues with the appointment of the national men’s health lead in 2025 to drive the implementation of the men’s health action plan. We are world leaders in research on men’s health. The men’s health research centre in SETU in Carlow – I had to mention Carlow as it is my hometown – makes a significant contribution to the evidence base for promoting health among men and boys and they are doing great work down there.</p>
          <p eId="para_738"> Men’s health is not just a matter of an individual lifestyle. It is shaped by the social, economic and environmental factors in which we live, work and grow. I am pleased to confirm development of the new men’s health policy for Ireland is an action for consideration within the new Healthy Ireland framework. The good news is the Healthy Ireland framework is currently being redrafted for the first time since it was launched in 2013 and I look forward to sharing this with colleagues in the coming months. We are hoping to get this done as soon as possible. It is a priority for us and it is important to get it done as soon as we can.</p>
          <p eId="para_739"> Any effective men’s health policy must target those groups of men who are most at risk and most underserved by existing services. This will be a priority for the next policy. We need to make health services more accessible and appealing to men and expand other models that encourage them to seek help and improve mental health - mental health literacy among men was mentioned - as part of this action plan. We must work to ensure men’s health is not treated in isolation but integrated and is also part of our health policies. It is critical we maintain momentum and funding for men’s health initiatives. Government supports for men’s health remain strong. Recent funding for male counselling supports announced by my colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, further demonstrates this commitment. She told me there have been 10,000 hours of free counselling for men, which is a total of 31,000 sessions altogether. That is really important.</p>
          <p eId="para_740"> Ireland has shown strong leadership in men’s health. We have built a foundation through policy and practice. Going forward, our focus will be on developing the men’s health policy and supporting those men most in need as well as engaging men with us in our health journey. I am committed to supporting men’s health. With my ministerial colleagues I will be exploring the opportunities with Healthy Ireland for further cross-government work.</p>
          <p eId="para_741"> I want to acknowledge the work of some of the organisations that receive funding from my remit for the work they do to improve health and well-being among men. The Irish men’s shed movement plays a vital role in supporting the health, well-being and social connection of men across Ireland and I pay tribute to it. It was important that nearly every speaker brought up men’s sheds. It shows the benefit of men’s sheds when they all come together to connect, work together and socialise. It is a totally different outlet for them.</p>
          <p eId="para_742">This is what we need to grow. It is a priority. The Irish men's sheds movement plays a vital role in terms of health and well-being through providing welcoming spaces for friendship, activities, supporting them in tackling social isolation and promoting positive mental health. That is the part I work with - health and well-being and social connection. Again, the topic of mental health came up a lot today. That is another priority the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, is very much focused on. The Department of Health is focused on health and well-being because we need to make sure men have that. Another one aspect is physical health and how we can promote that more. Programmes, such as the Sheds for Life programme, have further strengthened this impact by connecting shed members with practical health initiatives, health checks and well-being supports that empower men to lead healthier lives. Health checks are very important because it is important to make sure our men go for their health checkups and go to see their doctors. That is something we are prioritising.</p>
          <p eId="para_743"> Alongside the Department of agriculture, Healthy Ireland has also supported On Feirm Ground. I recently attended the launch of that evaluation report. That is having an impact on men in rural areas, who could otherwise be hard to reach or may not know who to ask for help, and that is what we are doing. If a person wants help, there is help out there. It is working well. As a Minister of State, I will support programmes like this because supporting men's health is about so much more than just what is happening in hospitals or surgeries. It is about ensuring that we promote health and well-being in the community with opportunities for physical activity, creative arts and connecting with people with shared interests. This is so important.</p>
          <p eId="para_744"> Again, I thank everybody. I really feel we are all on the same page. We have challenges. However, it is great that people are living longer. Men are living longer but we want to make sure we give them the best quality of life that we can.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MarkWall" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_374">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Mark Wall)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_745">I thank the Minister of State. We are going to suspend the House as we prepare for the next item of business.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_16">
          <i> Cuireadh an Dáil ar fionraí ar 4.31 p.m. agus cuireadh tús leis arís ar 4.37 p.m.</i>
        </summary>
        <summary eId="sum_17">
          <i> Sitting suspended at 4.31 p.m. and resumed at 4.37 p.m.</i>
        </summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_44">
        <heading>Gnó na Dála - Business of Dáil<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#KeiraKeogh" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_375">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Keira Keogh)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_746">Before I move to the next business, I wish the men of Ireland, especially our male Deputies, a happy International Men's Day. I thank them all for what they do in supporting us.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="debate" refersTo="#bill.2026.66.dail.2" eId="dbsect_45">
        <heading>School Meals Nutritional Standards Bill 2026: Second Stage [Private Members]<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#JenCummins" eId="spk_376">
          <from>Deputy Jen Cummins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_747">I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."</p>
          <p eId="para_748"> I am delighted to be here on Second Stage of this Bill, which I have been working on for a very long time. I thank my two staff members who are in Gallery. As everybody who works in this environment knows our staff members are so important. I thank, particularly Katie, who has commuted all the way from Türkiye today to be here because she has worked so hard on this Bill. I thank them both very much for all the work they have done on this Bill and making sure the office keeps ticking over while we are contemplating how we can make the hot school meals a better programme for all the children in this country.</p>
          <p eId="para_749"> The hot school meals programme started a number of years ago because children were coming into the classrooms of our primary schools and they were hungry. Everybody knows that when you are hungry, all you can think about is being hungry. If you have been hungry for a prolonged period, that hunger takes over every other part of your body. It is very difficult to concentrate on anything else. Children are expected to sit in classes and learn and participate but if they have not had breakfast and maybe if they have not had dinner the night before, that is a very difficult situation. It was recognised by schools around the country that this was an issue. They were trying to do things, for example, having breakfast clubs or different things to help children. That often involved taking a child aside and telling them that they had something for them to eat. However, we do not want to stigmatise a child. The beauty of the hot school meals is that it does not do that. It makes sure that every child in this country gets that meal regardless of whether they have had a dinner or breakfast. Nobody knows who is hungry and nobody knows who is not.</p>
          <p eId="para_750"> There are a number of things as to what the difficulty is with that programme. I will come to them throughout the time I am going to speak. To reflect, at the beginning, the rollout of that programme was very quick because it was an answer to an acute situation of hunger. It has been acknowledged by the Government side and everybody involved that with the rollout being so quick, because we wanted to make sure no one was hungry, what happened was that there were maybe a few steps that should have taken place at the beginning that did not take place. This Bill is a recognition to make sure that those steps are put in.</p>
          <p eId="para_751">When people started sending me information about hot school meals they told me they were gross, disgusting or other negative words. They sent me photographs and I thought the problem was chronic. As we looked into it more, more photographs came in. It got a bit of traction and people started talking about it nationwide. Over a period of time, Deputies and Senators from all parties and councillors from around the country contacted me to tell me parents were complaining about the hot school meals and said it was not what taxpayers, who pay almost €300 million for the programme, should be served. Things are not universally woeful. Obviously, some provision is excellent and I need to acknowledge that.</p>
          <p eId="para_752"> It is important that we identify the reasons the scheme is in place. It is in place because in this country there are 239,000 children living in poverty. I worked on a school completion programme when I worked in youth work. I have worked in some of the poorest parts of this city. When you go to a home where there is no food in modern times, not Dickensian times, it is an experience that will never leave you as a worker. You realise that when you leave, you will go home and have dinner or lunch or whatever, depending on what time of the day it is. You know the child, mum and dad do not have anything. It would break your heart.</p>
          <p eId="para_753"> I have delivered food packages to families in Dublin. This happens throughout the country. Many organisations are involved in delivering food packages. We have food banks and other things because there are people who are not able to afford food. When a child is hungry that never leaves you. I want to highlight during the course of the debate that this programme is a way of preventing that. Of course there is holiday hunger and other such things which I will not get to today, but the reality of why the programme is in place is important because of the young people it affects.</p>
          <p eId="para_754"> The quality of the food is not on a par with other food. The children I have described do not have a meal anywhere else in their day or quality food, and therefore the hot meal they get in school has to be the best meal they can possibly be provided with because these are children who are developing. It is an important time because young children develop at such a fast rate. Their bodies and brains are developing. They are learning. They grow like sunflowers and we need to nourish them. When I realised that not all of the meals are the best, I realised that something needed to be done about this and we needed to put this on a statutory footing. The steps that did not happen in the first place need to be put in place.</p>
          <p eId="para_755"> I asked the Office of Parliamentary Legal Advisers how it would work because I did not know, as a first-time legislator. It was absolutely brilliant in helping me to draft the Bill. I went back and forth over a long period. I want to put on the record what exactly it is seeks to do. The Minister for Health will be involved because this is about healthy school meals, but a number of other Ministers would also be involved. Section 2 states: </p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_756">(1) The Minister shall, within the period of 12 months from the coming into operation of this Act, by regulations provide for nutritional standards and related requirements for school meals.</p>
          <p eId="para_757"> Section 2(2)(a) refers to age-appropriate portion sizes, which are not currently provided. A six-year-old and a 12-year old do not eat the same amount. We need to make sure there are age-appropriate portion sizes. Section 2(2)(b) refers to the food groups to be contained in each meal. That seems like a simple provision, but in the pictures sent to me some meals only had one type of food, which was carbs or a bit of protein that was not great. We are supposed to be eating a rainbow, and that is what school meals should be. Section 2(2)(c) refers to the quantities, portions or servings of each food group to be contained in each meal, which is self-explanatory. Section 2(2)(d) refers to the food preparation and cooking methods requirement, which is important. Food preparation was an issue that was raised constantly, in terms of where and how the food is prepared. That needs to be regulated. Section 2(2)(e) refers to the frequency of the provision of certain types of foods and meals offered to ensure there is a rotation of food. That is important. We cannot serve the same thing every day children are in school. Section 2(2)(f) refers to the prohibition of certain foods. This includes highly processed food which we all know is not acceptable and we should keep that to a minimum. Such food should be gotten rid of. Section 2(2)(g) refers to the types of drinks to be served at meals, which is self-explanatory. Section 2(2)(h) refers to vegetarian alternatives. The education committee went to Finland and saw how well it system works. A school had a meat and vegetarian curry, which is a simple option.</p>
          <p eId="para_758"> Section 2 goes on to state:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_759">(3) Before the Minister makes regulations under subsection (1), he or she shall consult with—</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_760">(a) the Minister for Social Protection,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_761">(b) the Minister for Children, Disability and Equality,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_762">(c) the Minister for Education and Youth, and</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_763">(d) the Food Safety Authority of Ireland.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_764">(4) In making regulations under subsection (1), the Minister shall have regard to—</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_765">(a) national food-based dietary guidance,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_766">(b) the constitutional rights of children,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_767">(c) the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989), and</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_768">(d) promoting a healthy food environment, including the underlying determinants of health such as safe food, nutritious food and adequate nutrition.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_769">(5) Regulations made under this section shall be deemed to be food legislation for the purposes of the Food Safety Authority of Ireland Act 1998 and shall be enforceable—</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_770">(a) by the Food Safety Authority of Ireland,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_771">(b) by an official agency within the meaning of that Act acting pursuant to a service contract with the Authority, or</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_772">(c) by both the Authority and such an agency,</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_773">and the enforcement provisions provided for by that Act in respect of food legislation shall apply for the purposes of ensuring compliance with the requirements of any regulations so made.</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_774">The last section amends the Education Act, which is important. As this programme operates in schools, we need to amend one section of the Education Act. The section states: </p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_775">Section 9 of the Education Act 1998 is amended by inserting the following paragraph after paragraph (d)</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_776">“(da) promote a healthy life and healthy food environment for students,”. </p>
          <p eId="para_777"> It is important that happens. </p>
          <p eId="para_778"> They are the technicalities of the Bill. The Bill ensure that the hot school meals programme deals with all providers. The hot school meals programme comprises a variety of providers throughout the country. That is due to its quick roll-out and the fact that not every school has a kitchen. The gold standard for us as a country would be that any new school build would have a school kitchen because of the importance of being able to provide meals on site. That is the gold standard. Lots of different things are happening at the moment, but I want to make sure that the Bill covers for-profit local providers and on-site providers in schools. They need to adhere to the standards of nutrition, food and production safety.</p>
          <p eId="para_779"> It has been widely reported that some of the meals being provided are not great, as we have discussed. Food safety is also an issue. The reason the Food Safety Authority of Ireland is involved in the Bill is because the standards for providing food anywhere, be it a restaurant, café, youth club or hospital, have to be met, and it has to be the same for the school meal system. We have seen recent reports where standards have not been reached and there have been breaches, and the Food Safety Authority of Ireland has been able to do something about that. I want to make sure that is part of any discussion of the hot school meals system.</p>
          <p eId="para_780"> This is a €300 million taxpayer-funded scheme. That is a lot of money. Therefore, we need to make sure there is value for money. That is one element. The most important element for me is that the Bill recognises that every child deserves access to nutritious food that supports their health, development and ability to learn. We know that children learn better when they are not hungry. We know they learn better when they are nourished. We know they learn better when they are share a meal together because interaction is important. Eating healthily is a lifelong skill that needs to be learned.</p>
          <p eId="para_781"> I note the Government has put forward a timed amendment to the Bill. I am disappointed, as I said to the Minister, Deputy Calleary, last night when he told me.</p>
          <p eId="para_782">I understand that the Government wants a timed amendment. I think 18 months is too long, and I would ask the Government to reduce it as much as possible. In fact, I would love to ask the Government to just take it away and that we go with the Bill. However, I know this is how it is, and that timed amendments are how they are.</p>
          <p eId="para_783"> The reality is that the Government is doing work on these issues. I know that Ipsos B and A and the Department of Social Protection did the research, and that there is an interdepartmental group. This Bill is not a sidebar to that. It would help to lead the way in which that work is happening and put it on a statutory footing. Sometimes, in this country, we kind of take the “Sure it will be grand” route. This programme is too important for the “Sure it will be grand” route. It has to be statutory. I really would ask if there is any negotiation that can be done on the floor of the Dáil to reduce that time. It is a lot of money and it has to do with children.</p>
          <p eId="para_784"> There is one point I did not make. This Bill also takes into consideration the food served to children with additional needs. This comes into the part concerning the rights of the child. The food served also needs to be acceptable to children from medical and sensory perspectives. This is very important because when we have that on a statutory footing, it means that children are nourished, but it is also inclusive. It means they are not othered, and they are not eating something different that they have to bring from home. If we go back to the issues of stigmatisation, we do not want that in this Bill. I should have mentioned that earlier. It is very important. That is why this Bill is so thorough in its way of looking at how the hot school meals scheme will be the best it can be for every single child in the country. I really would ask the Government not to put the timed amendment.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" eId="spk_377">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T16:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_785">I move amendment No 1:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_786">To delete all words after "That" and substitute the following:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_787">"Dáil Éireann resolves that the School Meals Nutritional Standards Bill 2026 be deemed to be read a second time this day 18 months.".</p>
          <p eId="para_788"> I welcome the opportunity to address the School Meals Nutritional Standards Bill 2026. I acknowledge Deputy Cummins for bringing forward a Bill that is very focused, as the Deputy is focused, on an issue of real importance to children and families. The hot school meals programme, administered by the Department of Social Protection, has expanded from a pilot in just 30 schools to a nationwide programme, with 3,200 primary schools now eligible to participate and approximately 550,000 children able to access a hot school meal every day. The programme now supports up to 3.4 million school meals per week, helping to reduce family food costs and enhance participation in education.</p>
          <p eId="para_789"> The quality of the food provided through the school meals scheme is of huge importance. The Government shares the central aim behind this Bill. Every child should have access to food that is safe, nutritious, balanced and appropriate to their needs. For many children, the meal provided at school is an important part of their daily nutrition. It can support concentration and well-being, as well as reduce inequalities and ensure that children are supported to learn, regardless of their household circumstances.</p>
          <p eId="para_790"> As I mentioned, the hot school meals programme is led by the Department of Social Protection. The Department of Health contributes to the Healthy Ireland nutrition and obesity policy, food safety policy and active participation in the interdepartmental structures supporting the programme. The Department of Education and Youth, the Food Safety Authority of Ireland and the HSE are also very important in providing their expertise, which is part of this.</p>
          <p eId="para_791"> This work is grounded in Healthy Ireland’s whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach. Good nutrition in childhood is fundamental to healthy growth and development. It also supports the broader aim of giving children the best start in life and reducing health inequalities in their own lifetime. Important progress has already been made. Updated nutrition standards for school meals were published in 2026, as the Deputy noted. These standards were developed collaboratively for the Department of Social Protection by the Department of Health, the FSAI, the Irish Nutrition and Dietetic Institute, Safe Food and the HSE. They provided practical guidance on balanced meals, food groups, portion sizes and drinks, and they also highlighted food that should not be offered, such as high fat, salt and sugar, HFSS, foods.</p>
          <p eId="para_792"> A comprehensive nutrition review of the hot meals scheme was completed in July 2026. This review provides the strongest evidence base available to date on the nutritional quality of meals under the scheme. It examined 360 meals from 15 suppliers, and included school visits covering 322 meals across 151 classes. I can see the Deputy’s passion and I am sure she knows all the facts. A lot of the findings are positive. Participation in the scheme is high and schools reported strong levels of satisfaction in areas such as choice, dietary requirements, quality and nutritional value. Many nutritious and balanced options are available.</p>
          <p eId="para_793"> The programme has become a major national intervention, reaching schools in communities throughout the country. The review also identified areas where improvement is needed. Only a small proportion of the meals met all five of the core standards used in the review. Fruit and vegetable content needs to improve. Vegetarian and vegan choices often require stronger protein provision. Age-appropriate portion sizes are not consistently available, and I thank the Deputy for highlighting the importance of portion sizes. Menu planning, supplier assurance, monitoring and the management of food waste also need sustained attention. These findings are not an argument against the programme; they are a practical roadmap for strengthening it. The review recommended a standardised three-week menu cycle, clear age-related portions and improved menus. It also recommends stronger compliance audits, effective procedures for managing persistent non-compliance and greater use of procurement and tender evaluation to reward quality.</p>
          <p eId="para_794"> The Bill before the House seeks to reinforce the nutritional quality of State-funded school meals through the law. It would require the Minister for Health to make regulations covering matters such as portion size, food groups, quantities, cooking methods, the frequency of specific food, drinks and vegetarian alternatives. It would also deem these regulations to be food legislation for the purposes of the Food Safety Authority of Ireland Act 1998. The Government must examine that proposed model carefully. There is an important distinction between setting nutritional standards and creating statutory obligations and an enforcement regime.</p>
          <p eId="para_795"> Traditionally, food safety controls focus on protecting consumers from risks and ensuring compliance with food law. Nutritional compliance can require a different form of assessment involving menus, recipes, ingredients, portion weight and meal cycles, preparation methods and procurement. That assessment may require specialist nutritional and dietetic experts alongside regulatory skills. At present, there is no dedicated national workforce of nutritional inspectors operating under the FSAI’s official agency framework for this purpose. I know the Deputy also spoke about that. A statutory regime could, therefore, require training, specialist support, a data system and additional staffing.</p>
          <p eId="para_796"> There are also legal questions. Simply stating that nutritional regulations are food legislation does not establish that the existing food safety legal framework is suitable. Detailed advice would be required on the functions and powers of the FSAI and official agencies, the nature of the offence and the sanctions appeal arrangements, proportionality and the relationship with existing Irish and European food law.</p>
          <p eId="para_797"> The allocation of responsibility also needs to be clear. A school meal may involve the State as the funder, the school or board of management as the contract holder, a caterer or supplier as the food business operator and several bodies involved in programme administration and oversight. If a meal does not meet a statutory nutrition requirement, the legislation must clearly identify who is responsible and what corrective action is appropriate. Governance is, therefore, central. The programme is funded and overseen by the Department of Social Protection. The Bill would place regulation-making responsibility on the Minister for Health and enforcement responsibility on the FSAI or an official agency. Before such a model is enacted, the Government would need to agree the framework, policy ownership, monitoring, inspection, enforcement and, of course, accountability.</p>
          <p eId="para_798"> The resource implication must also be assessed. Costs would arise for regulators, the HSE specialist nutrition services, schools, suppliers and the programme administration.</p>
          <p eId="para_799">Schools and suppliers may face additional procurement, record-keeping and contract-monitoring requirements. Smaller suppliers and schools in remote areas may face particular pressures. That is another concern in rural Ireland and smaller areas. These impacts should be quantified through a regulatory impact analysis and a costed implementation plan. </p>
          <p eId="para_800"> The Bill also proposes to amend section 9 of the Education Act 1998 by requiring schools to promote a healthy life and a healthy food environment. The objective is understandable but the phrase “healthy life” is very broad. It may extend well beyond school meals into a wide range of physical and mental health matters. Any new statutory duty on schools must be clear, proportionate and capable of implementation. The provision should, therefore, be narrowed or reconsidered in consultation with the Department of Education and Youth.</p>
          <p eId="para_801"> The Government’s position is constructive. We support the policy intention. We want higher and more consistent nutritional standards, stronger accountability and better outcomes for children. At the same time, we cannot assume that the particular legal and enforcement mechanism proposed is the only or the most effective route. A significant body of work is already under way. The revised standards and the nutrition review recommendations can be embedded in funding conditions, procurement contracts, menu specifications, supplier assurance, monitoring and targeted audits. Accordingly, subject to the Government decision and the advice of the lead Department, the Government does not propose to reject the positive aim at the heart of the Bill. It is a really good Bill. I can see the concerns the Deputy has.</p>
          <p eId="para_802"> However, progression beyond Second Stage would require substantial further work and changes. This must include cross-government legal analysis, a settled governance model, a proportionate compliance and enforcement framework, a workforce and training plan and a full assessment of costs. We are committed to working with Deputy Cummins, the relevant Departments, the FSAI, the HSE, Safefood, schools and suppliers to strengthen the nutritional quality of school meals. Our focus must remain on a practical system that delivers healthier meals consistently, supports schools and suppliers and uses legislation where it is clear, fair and effective. As the Bill also covers matters outside the Department of Health’s remit, the Department of Social Protection as the lead Department with my Department's support will need to co-ordinate a cross-government response and agree a realistic timeframe - the Deputy spoke about 18 months - to revert on the Bill. I thank the Deputy for highlighting this issue, which parents have brought to my attention. I know the Department is very committed to it. It falls across a lot of Departments and involves them working together.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#DarrenORourke" eId="spk_378">
          <from>Deputy Darren O'Rourke<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_803">I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate and commend Deputy Cummins and her staff on their work in bringing it to this Stage. I begin by acknowledging the importance of the school meals programme and the positive difference it makes to families right across the country. For many children, a nutritious meal in school is not simply a welcome addition to their day. It is an essential part of their well-being, their development and their ability to concentrate and learn. For parents struggling with the cost of living, the programme also provides important financial support. Its expansion has been a welcome investment by the State and Sinn Féin wants to see that programme protected and expanded but we need to be honest about the problems that have emerged. Providing a meal in and of itself is not enough. We have a responsibility to ensure the food being served is nutritious, is appropriate for children's needs and is of a consistent standard, regardless of which school they attend or which supplier delivers their meals. That is why Sinn Féin supports the objectives of this Bill and the introduction of statutory nutritional standards.</p>
          <p eId="para_804"> The Government's own independent review published in September identified significant shortcomings. Almost one in five meals served is going uneaten. Even after accounting for pupil absences, the figure remains at over 11%. That equates to approximately 100,000 meals thrown away every single day. We need to ask why. Are the menus appealing to children? Are the portions appropriate? Are we providing enough choice? Are we actually listening to the children who are supposed to benefit from this programme? There is little value in spending hundreds of millions of euro on a scheme if a significant proportion of the food ends up in the bin. The review also identified shortcomings in the provision of fruit, vegetables, salads and wholegrains. It highlighted the need for better menu choices, greater consistency and more appropriate portion sizes. One striking finding was that a four-year-old child can receive exactly the same portion as a 12-year-old. That makes absolutely no sense. Children have different nutritional requirements at different stages of their development. A one-size-fits-all approach is neither sensible nor acceptable. We must also recognise that a meal being safe to eat does not automatically mean it is nutritionally adequate. The standards introduced under this legislation must be meaningful. They must address nutritional composition, portion sizes, food groups, drinks and the needs of children with dietary requirements.</p>
          <p eId="para_805"> I also want to make the wider point that we cannot separate the quality of the food and the enormous levels of waste from the business model through which this programme is delivered. The State is spending approximately €300 million annually on school meals at a rate of €3.20 per meal. That is a substantial public investment and taxpayers and parents are entitled to ask a very straightforward question, namely, how much of that €3.20 is actually being spent on the food that reaches a child's plate? How much is absorbed by intermediaries, administration overheads and profit margins. Sinn Féin believes that the dominance of for-profit providers in this programme needs to be challenged. When a system is designed around volume, logistics and protecting profit margins, there is an obvious risk that food quality, variety and suitability become secondary considerations. We should not accept a situation where the nutritional quality of a child's lunch is determined by the commercial interests of a private provider. We should not accept a system where economies of scale take precedence over the individual needs of children and we certainly should not accept a situation where approximately 100,000 meals are going uneaten every day while significant amounts of public moneys are being spent on their provision.</p>
          <p eId="para_806"> There is a better way of doing this. Sinn Féin is calling for the piloting of a not-for-profit community-led model of school meal provision. We want to see greater use of fresh ingredients, local producers and shorter supply chains. We want to see more food prepared and cooked on site with schools and communities having a meaningful role in shaping what children eat. This is not simply an aspiration. It is an approach supported by the recommendations of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Education and Youth and the legislation debated today would be a significant help. The committee's report published in March recommended that on-site preparation and cooking from scratch be the preferred delivery model as the programme expands. It also called for support for local producers, sustainable supply chains, a national value-for-money audit and proper investment in school kitchens and dining facilities. These are sensible recommendations and the Government should act on them.</p>
          <p eId="para_807"> There is also a need to make the programme genuinely universal. No child should go hungry during the school day and access to nutritious meals should not depend on a family's income or circumstances. We must also prioritise extending the programme to all post-primary schools. Of course, none of this can happen without proper investment. Schools need suitable kitchens, dining facilities and the resources to deliver a high-quality service. We cannot expect schools to deliver better outcomes without giving them the means to do so.</p>
          <p eId="para_808"> Finally, we need transparency and accountability. Nutritional standards must be independently monitored and properly enforced. Enacting Deputy Cummins's Bill is very important in this regard. Parents and schools must have confidence in the food being provided and in the value being delivered for public money. Sinn Féin fully supports this Bill. We need a school meals programme that puts children's health and well-being first rather than the commercial interests of those delivering it. Every euro of public money should deliver the best possible meal for every child. That means nutritious food, appropriate portions, genuine choice, less waste and a delivery model rooted in our schools and communities.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_379">
          <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_809">I thank my colleague, Deputy Jen Cummins, for bringing forward this very important Bill. Along with the air they breathe and, of course, the love and care they receive from their caregivers and having a roof over their head, food is the most important thing for children so that they can be supported in their development.</p>
          <p eId="para_810"> Unfortunately, too many children are living in food poverty in this country. I want to talk about the importance of school meals in addressing child food poverty but also in addressing the lack of access to food among some of our most vulnerable families and children in this country. The context of why it is so important is the nutritional quality and nutritional value of that food. Too many children in this country are going hungry. It is a shocking state of affairs that we have tens of thousands of children growing up right now in this country who do not receive nutritious food every day. That has a developmental impact on their mental health and their physical development. There is a responsibility at the core of this State and this Republic. The foundational document, the Proclamation of this Republic, sets out to cherish all children equally but not all children in this country are growing up and cherished equally. The fundamental responsibility of this State is to ensure they do and that they can have the basics such as food, shelter, health and education. However, food is fundamental.</p>
          <p eId="para_811"> In schools we have the opportunity to ensure that children, through the five days they attend, and ideally over time it being extended through the summer and holidays, have access to a nutritional meal once a day that will enable them to thrive and to be the best they can be. We know it has massive impacts in terms of concentration in school and developmentally.</p>
          <p eId="para_812"> The scale of food poverty is actually really shocking. The Barnardos report, Cost of Living: The Impact on Children 2026 showed that 20% of parents said that they or their children had to go without or cut back on food. Some 44% skipped meals, which was up from 40% in 2025, and 30% - almost one third of parents - felt that at some point they did not have enough food to feed their children. These are shocking statistics. What the representative survey Barnardos undertakes of families with children under 18 reveals is this hidden food poverty crisis that is not captured in the SILC data. We are getting it because it is focused specifically on families. These figures are absolutely shameful and stark given that 30% of families felt at some point they did not have enough food to feel their children and 16% of families reported using a food bank - a figure up from 12% last year.</p>
          <p eId="para_813"> In my own constituency, one local food bank, Feed our Homeless in Finglas, which I have visited on a number of occasions, supported 1,000 families in north Dublin in 2025. It said that 30% of those it supports were of primary school age. It supports them with food and linking families in with support services. What it told me is that it is seeing families with children going without electricity and without food. What this shows is the fundamental challenge and disaster of this cost-of-living crisis and how it is impacting on children. As we know, children only have one childhood. They only have one opportunity within which they can be supported to develop physically and mentally. If that childhood is damaged or lost, as it is as a result of food poverty, they can never get that back.</p>
          <p eId="para_814"> The other area I want to talk about, in relation to the importance of nutritional standards in our school meals and why they are so important, is about those families in homelessness. The research shows, and we have seen a number of reports from hospitals like Temple Street, that children who are in emergency accommodation are presenting with malnutrition. There are malnourished children in Ireland when we have never been wealthier. It is absolutely scandalous. Children are living in emergency accommodation, bed and breakfast accommodation and family hubs. We have over 5,800 children living in emergency accommodation, sharing a room with their entire family without adequate cooking facilities. They cannot prepare a nutritious meal.</p>
          <p eId="para_815"> This brings us back to the importance of this Bill and I thank my colleague, Deputy Cummins, for bringing it forward. It is fundamental, particularly for those vulnerable children, that they have access to a nutritional meal, not the takeaways their parents have no alternative to getting when they are in emergency accommodation but real nutritious food. It is an opportunity for the Irish State, for the Government, to make a real intervention in supporting families and children. I recommend and call on the Government not to press the timed amendment but to support the immediate progress of the Bill. Again, I thank my colleague for doing the work and bringing this forward.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#LouiseOReilly" eId="spk_380">
          <from>Deputy Louise O'Reilly<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_816">I thank the Deputy for bringing forward this legislation and for giving us the chance to have a discussion on the hot school meals programme. It is an incredibly important intervention for an awful lot of students. For many children - and this is a pretty shameful indictment of the Government - it represents a substantial portion of the nutrition they will receive in a day, without which they would not get that vital intervention. That children are going to school hungry, that children are living in poverty, and that child poverty is increasing is on the Government. I do not like the practice of a timed amendment. If it is good legislation, it is good legislation. If it needs a bit of work, I am sure the proposer would be more than happy to work with the Government. Nobody is saying it is not a good idea that there should be nutritional standards enshrined in legislation. It might take a while to figure out the modalities of that but that does not mean it is not worth doing or that it should be delayed.</p>
          <p eId="para_817"> Everybody who has spoken has spoken about the merits of the programme. The legislation is designed to strengthen the programme. If we all want the programme to be as good as it can be and if we all want to ensure kids have access to decent quality food in school, then, rather than imposing a timed amendment on the Bill, what we should be doing is having that discussion now. That is what Committee Stage is for. That is what pre-legislative scrutiny is for. That is where we get a chance to hear from experts and to do all of that work that is so important. I do not think that saying not now but in 18 months, when the Government does not seem to have a plan to do anything different, is very fair. That is what the Government is doing. At this stage, because we will not be voting on it until next week, I encourage the Minister of State to perhaps talk to the senior Ministers in the Departments of Social Protection and education to see if accommodation can be found to work with the proposer to ensure we get this through. I do not believe anybody thinks that it is a bad idea. As they say, it is never the wrong time to do the right thing, so perhaps that could be done now.</p>
          <p eId="para_818"> The Minister of State in her opening statement said that the Government wanted to see greater use of procurement to enforce quality. That is not happening. What procurement is doing is enforcing something that may look like value for money on paper but does not necessarily represent quality. As my colleague, an Teachta O'Rourke, pointed out, 10% of meals go uneaten, and that is after you exclude those children who are not in school. That is an issue. If you are going to use procurement as a way to drive quality, then that should be the overarching aim of procurement, and we all know that it is not. We can see what happened when the home help service went into that very aggressive procurement procedure. Effectively, what happened was that the quality was driven down. The quality of the people delivering the care did not go down but the wages and the time spent with the client went down.</p>
          <p eId="para_819">Of course, the profits of the big multinational corporations went up. When you are chasing a profit, you are not chasing high nutritional standards. That is just a fact. What Sinn Féin has been long on the record as proposing and what we believe will deliver in the interests of children and the whole school community is a community-based not-for-profit model.</p>
          <p eId="para_820"> There is a pilot down in Cork whereby the meals are delivered by meals on wheels. That is an organisation that already exists. I have spoken to its representatives at the social protection committee. With sufficient resources, this is work that organisation could be able to do. Every shilling that goes into that gets spent on delivering the food, because they do not have to take a slice off the top for their shareholders. They do not have to drive either the cost of the food or the standards down in order to satisfy their shareholders' need to make a profit. If the need to make a profit is removed, it becomes all about the nutritional standards and ensuring that money is spent making sure that kids actually have a decent and nutritious meal.</p>
          <p eId="para_821"> With the community-led not-for-profit model as proposed by Sinn Féin, we also get the benefit of local delivery. The food no longer has to be prepared in such a way that it can be transported across two or three counties. We have all had food on aeroplanes. We would not want to eat it every day, but it is designed to be transported and to be easy to handle. We would not want that every day. If we would not want it every day, we certainly would not want our kids eating it every day. The Government is missing a trick here in that it is spending the same amount of money but not making certain that, while they may be keeping their shareholders happy, the outsourced private for-profit people may not be ensuring the highest standards. They have another metric by which they judge their success, which is profit as opposed to not nutritional standards.</p>
          <p eId="para_822"> As has been mentioned, 6,000 children are living in emergency accommodation. Their parents do not have any means by which to cook meals. As a parent, I know that every child loves a takeaway every once in a while. They do not want it to be their dinner every night, though. Nobody wants chips for dinner every night. Nobody wants McDonald's or any other fast food for their dinner every night. Even children get sick of that. They want a hot, decent, nutritious meal. However, many people do not have access to cooking facilities for all sorts of reasons - which leads us back to Government policy - and are living in emergency accommodation. For the 6,000 kids trapped in emergency accommodation, that moves the hot school meals programme into a very elevated position in terms of the nutrition they get for the day. I am sure their parents would like to be in a position to know for a fact that the highest nutritional standards are being followed because the person delivering it is not chasing a profit but is, in fact, just chasing quality.</p>
          <p eId="para_823"> When the Minister of State said that the Government is proposing greater use of procurement to enforce policy - I know she is not here to answer - she did not follow that up with anything that would give any indication or any hope that that is, in fact, what will happen. I encourage the Minister of State, Deputy Troy, to ask the relevant senior Ministers, namely the Minister for education and the Minister for Social Protection, to have a discussion with the proposer of the legislation, even if there is a difficulty with it. Those of us in opposition do our best, but the legislation might need a bit of a tweak, and that is grand. That is what pre-legislative scrutiny and Committee Stage are for. That is what all of those discussions that we have the facility to have are designed to achieve. I encourage the Minister of State to withdraw the amendment and to work to ensure that high-quality nutritional standards are delivered but delivered in a not-for-profit environment.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#EoghanKenny" eId="spk_381">
          <from>Deputy Eoghan Kenny<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_824">I commend Deputy Jen Cummins on bringing forward this legislation and on her continued advocacy in respect of this significantly important issue. The Labour Party fully supports Deputy Cummins's legislation. We fundamentally believe that no child, irrespective of their families' financial circumstances, should sit in a classroom hungry. As a former teacher, I understand the importance of ensuring that children are properly fed before we can expect them to fully engage in their education. We talk regularly in this Chamber about educational disadvantage, attendance, academic performance and educational outcomes. However, we sometimes overlook the most basic needs of the child.</p>
          <p eId="para_825"> If a child is hungry - I heard Deputy Cummins say this - how can we recently expect him or her to concentrate, participate in class or reach their full potential? That is why the school meals programme is so important. It is an educational measure, a public health measure and, crucially, an anti-poverty measure. For some children in this country, the meal they receive school may be their only substantial meal that day. That is a difficult reality to accept in a country as wealthy as ours, but it is the reality nonetheless. That is precisely why we have responsibility to get this programme right.</p>
          <p eId="para_826"> Providing a hot meal and a nutritious meal are not necessarily the same thing. The findings of the review published in September should concern every Member of this House. Approximately 100,000 school meals go uneaten every day, including meals ordered for children who are absent. Children in junior infants and children sixth class receive the same portion sizes, despite having substantially different nutritional needs.</p>
          <p eId="para_827"> Concerns have also been expressed about children choosing meals high in fat, salt and sugar over healthier alternatives. Surely the State can do better than that. Through this programme, we have an opportunity to establish healthy eating habits that children carry with them throughout their lives but that requires more than simply delivering a meal to a school gate and considering that the job is done. We need to ensure that the food provided is nutritious, appealing, age appropriate and of a consistently high standard. That is why placing nutritional standards on a statutory footing, as Deputy Cummins is trying to do here, is so important.</p>
          <p eId="para_828"> As a member of the public accounts committee, I was particularly interested in the recent findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General regarding the procurement of school meals. An estimated €176 million in school meals funding for the 2025-26 academic year was associated with just five suppliers. That represents approximately 69% of the funding issued and yet the Department does not maintain a central record of the actual amounts paid to individual suppliers. With that level of public expenditure must come an appropriate level of public accountability.</p>
          <p eId="para_829"> I also fundamentally disagree with the extent to which responsibility for addressing concerns about food quality has been placed on individual boards of management. School principals are educators. They are not nutritionists. They are not procurement specialists. They are not food inspectors. We cannot continually place additional responsibilities on school management teams across the country without providing the necessary resources or expertise. There must be independent oversight, accountability and enforcement of nutritional standards.</p>
          <p eId="para_830"> I also believe we need a fundamental cultural shift in how we view school meals in this country. Despite the roll-out of this programme, many parents are still preparing packed lunches for their children every morning. We need to ask ourselves why that is. Is it a concern about the quantity of the food? Is it a lack of choice? Is it a lack of confidence in the nutritional value of the meals or is it simply because, as a society, we have become accustomed to children bringing their own lunches to school? I am not suggesting a moment that parents should not have that choice but surely our ambition should be to make school meals the norm rather than the exception.</p>
          <p eId="para_831"> In countries such as Finland, school meals are an established part of school day. Children sit together, eat together and develop healthy eating habits together. That is the direction in which Ireland should be moving. We need to build a strong school meals programme in which parents have such confidence that they feel comfortable sending their children to school without having to prepare a separate lunch. That would represent a significant step forward in tackling child poverty, delivering genuinely free education and reducing the daily pressures on working families. A nutritious school meal should be as much a part of the school day as the lessons taught in the classroom. When we are designing new school buildings, why are we not giving greater consideration to the provision of kitchens and dining facilities? We need a long-term vision for school meals in this country.</p>
          <p eId="para_832"> Coming from north Cork, I also know the quality of food that is produced on our doorstep. We have fantastic farmers, food producers and small businesses throughout this country. Surely there is an opportunity to better connect those businesses with our schools. We could be supporting local employment strengthening rural economies and providing children with fresh nutritious food.</p>
          <p eId="para_833"> We must also ensure that children with additional needs, sensory difficulties, allergies and other dietary requirements are properly accommodated.</p>
          <p eId="para_834"> A universal programme can only be considered truly universal if every child can participate in it. We cannot have a debate about school meals without addressing their expansion to secondary schools. A child's nutritional needs do not suddenly disappear when they leave sixth class. Neither does child poverty. As somebody who taught at post-primary level, I know the importance of teenagers having access to nutritious food throughout the school day. The Government is committed to expanding the programme to secondary schools but we have no clear timetable for that delivery. When can parents and students expect to see that commitment fulfilled?</p>
          <p eId="para_835"> The Labour Party has consistently advocated for the expansion of school meals to all schools. We have allocated funding for that expansion in our alternative budgets. We believe that school meals should be a universal public service. There should also be no stigma attached to receiving a meal in a school. There should be no distinction between the children whose parents are struggling financially and the child whose parents are financially comfortable. Every child should have the same opportunity to sit down and enjoy a nutritious meal alongside his or her classmates. That is what equality looks like in practise.</p>
          <p eId="para_836"> Ultimately, the success of the school meals programme cannot simply be measured by the number of meals delivered, the number of schools participating or the amount of money spent. It must be measured by a number of children who are properly fed. We have a programme with enormous potential.</p>
          <p eId="para_837"> I commend previous governments on bringing forward the hot school meals programme. I absolutely welcome it; I am sure we all do. It has potential but we must ensure the quality of the programme matches the scale of our investment. We owe that to the children who deeply depend on it, the parents who trust it and the taxpayers who fund it. Every child deserves a decent education, every child deserves the opportunity to reach his or her full potential and every child deserves a nutritious meal. For those reasons, I welcome Deputy Cummins's legislation.</p>
          <p eId="para_838"> I urge the Government to withdraw its timed amendment. All of us in this House have a role to play in ensuring this programme and in ensuring its potential. We can all assist in that. I do not think any of us in this House is playing politics in any way with this programme. Legislation like this is essential to ensuring that a nutritious meal is provided to every single child across the education system every single day of their school lives.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#FionntanOSuilleabhain" eId="spk_382">
          <from>Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_839">I would like to support this Bill. As a primary school teacher for 34 years, I believe the hot school meal is a great idea and especially important for children from disadvantaged backgrounds. However, the quality leaves a lot to be desired. I have been in schools and in classrooms and have seen far too much end up in the bin. Speaking to principals, there is a general unhappiness with the present model. One principal even told me that the funding that is given to the company for the school meals is practically the same as all their grant funding for running the rest of the school. This is certainly an anomaly.</p>
          <p eId="para_840"> Darina Allen appeared before the committee some months ago. It is worth listening back to that discussion. There were some very good ideas. The Japanese model is very good. They very much have a focus in primary schools on local healthy produce that is very nutritious. The children are part of the food-growing, they are part of the food preparation and they are part of all the cleaning up and other things as well. In all stages, basically, from farm to fork, the children are involved.</p>
          <p eId="para_841"> Finally, it is essential that we hold on to the hot school meals programme but we definitely need to improve it. I know that from speaking to many principals about this over the past ten years. We need to reassess the scheme and improve the funding provided to it, the quality and the model. It would be very good idea, where practical, to have an allotment attached to a school where they could grow the food and the pupils could watch and take part in the entire process and that provision would be made in any new schools, or even in older schools, to develop a proper kitchen. That is essential as well as the staff to work in it. That is essential also because often what is happening is that a lot of principals are getting left with a lot of extra work and they are already overloaded. Ireland could learn an awful lot from the Japanese model. They are doing a lot of things quite well. It is worth listening back to the discussion with Darina Allen as well.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#KeiraKeogh" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_383">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Keira Keogh)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_842">I call the Minister of State, Deputy Troy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RobertTroy" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Finance" eId="spk_384">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Deputy Robert Troy)<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_843">I thank all the Deputies for their contributions to the debate this evening, in particular Deputy Cummins for bringing forward this Bill. While it is not under my area of responsibility in government, I am glad that I am on Front Bench duty today and got the opportunity to listen to the debate. It is fair to say there was a lot of agreement in the contributions. </p>
          <p eId="para_844"> At the very outset, we need to look at where we have come from. We have a scheme in place, which is delivering hot school meals to 550,000 children across 3,200 schools. All schools must follow strict HSE safe food nutritional guidelines, eliminating foods high in fat, salt and sugar. There is a very good basis on which we can build. Deputy Kenny alluded to the fact that, as a former of educationalist, he sees the benefit of it. However, it is only right and proper that for any scheme introduced by Government, we continue to review and monitor it and, where improvements can be made, that they are made.</p>
          <p eId="para_845"> The debate also identified the need to distinguish between a strong policy objective and detailed legislative mechanisms required to deliver it. That is perhaps where there is a difference between Government and Opposition. The Bill would enable the introduction of nutrition regulations, classify them as food legislation and place them within the Food Safety Authority of Ireland, FSAI, Act enforcement framework. That is a significant regulatory change. Before such a system can operate, Government must settle who owns the policy, who monitors routine compliance, who inspects, who takes enforcement action and who is legally responsible when a meal does not comply. It would also ensure that inspectors have the necessary competencies and access to special dietary and nutritional expertise. The cost for regulators, school suppliers and programme administration must also be identified because with any new proposal like this, there are costs associated with it. The consequences of minor isolated or temporary non-compliance must also be proportionate.</p>
          <p eId="para_846"> The proposed duty on schools to promote a healthy lifestyle must also be clarified so that it does not create an uncertain and open-ended statutory declaration. Some of the contributors talked today about the existing scheme putting undue pressures on principals. I disagree with Deputy Kenny somewhat. Principals are not merely educators. They are leaders. They have HR expertise and they are administrators. That is the reason they have gone for a position of authority or responsibility within the school. They are not simply just teaching anymore. I do not mean that in any derogatory way to teachers but they have taken the next step up. Sometimes they are the ones who are best placed to identify what is needed for their own school or whether there is a service.</p>
          <p eId="para_847"> Deputy O’Reilly mentioned the Meals on Wheel service that is used in a particular area. Perhaps it was the principal who identified it in that area. It is not always putting an additional burden on schools. Sometimes the schools relish that and relish the opportunity to have autonomy over decisions. I know Deputy Kenny probably appreciates that far more than me given his professional background.</p>
          <p eId="para_848"> It fair to say the Government is not starting from a blank page. We did publish updated nutritional standards for school meals in 2026 and a detailed nutritional review has identified practical priorities, better menu planning, improved fruit and vegetable provision, age-appropriate portions, stronger vegetarian and vegan options, halal options and also supplier controls, procurement measures and robust auditing. The immediate task now is to implement those recommendations, evaluate their effect and identify any further areas for improvement.</p>
          <p eId="para_849"> As was mentioned earlier, procurement, funding conditions, supplier assurance and targeted audits all can deliver improvements. That is maybe where I differ from the Deputies on the Opposition benches. Procurement and private enterprise are part of delivering these areas once it is done right and once the nutritional value is there. I can give the example of Wholesome Kitchen in Mullingar, which has won national awards for its nutritional food and value for money and also in terms of what it does in meeting its carbon emissions and providing good quality.</p>
          <p eId="para_850">There are private companies which mark themselves and it is their unique selling point because they recognise the importance of good quality food and meeting their carbon emissions and all of those good objectives we set ourselves. While we support the objective of the Bill, there is a timed amendment. Members are sometimes critical of that. That should not stop us from continuing to work together constructively. We are on the one page in this area. We want to achieve the best outcomes for what everyone acknowledges is a good initiative that this Government and the previous Government, of which members of this were part, introduced because we saw the need to do so.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#JenCummins" eId="spk_385">
          <from>Deputy Jen Cummins<recordedTime time="2026-11-19T17:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_851">I thank the Deputies who took the time to come in to discuss the Bill. I know it is Thursday and often the Dáil is quite empty at this time of the week. I appreciate it, especially the Members who have to travel to different places.</p>
          <p eId="para_852"> This Bill clearly states in section 2 that, "The Minister shall, within the period of 12 months from the coming into operation of this Act, by regulations provide". It is 12 months after the enactment of this Bill that all of those things can be ironed out. The Minister of State said we are all of the same page. The mechanism to be on the same page is going to Committee Stage. That is how it goes. Deputy O'Reilly has clearly set out how that goes. We are on Second Stage. It will go to Committee Stage, and we can iron all the issues out then. The Departments can all work on those issues the way they need to, to set them out as we go along. A timed amendment will mean that this pauses and brings us closer to a general election. When the general election is called, what will happen to the Bill then? There are children getting these school meals now, which are not up to scratch. Putting these under a statutory framework will be important for those children who will benefit from what all of us on all sides of the House agree. Hot school meals is a brilliant programme. This is just trying to make it even better.</p>
          <p eId="para_853"> Many issues were mentioned and I would like to bring some of those discussions to a close. Members raised the quality of food and when that has come into question, it is available to every school in the country. It is available to every child. I mentioned at the beginning that some schools do not take it up and some parents do not allow their children to have the hot school meals for various reasons. Let me spell out those various reasons. If parents do not think the standard of that school meal is acceptable, they will not sign the child up to it. If children are not able to eat the food because of sensory or medical issues, they cannot eat the food. Perhaps the food being served is not vegetarian or vegan so they will not be able to eat it either. The food may also not be suitable for religious reasons. There are lots of reasons families are not signing their children up to it.</p>
          <p eId="para_854"> I have noticed in the past the private providers going into the schools. I agree that we need to reduce the private provision and for-profit model of school meals. This is a public service. It should be provided publicly in our schools. The gold standard is for that to be delivered by staff employed in the school to cook and serve that food and do the clean up afterwards. As one of the Deputies said, the Japanese model is excellent. I witnessed it when I was there over a quarter of a century ago. I saw how children served food to one another in their schools and how they were involved. The point is that the gold standard is on-site. We need to be able to retrofit schools and to forward plan any school being built to ensure that standard. However, the private for-profit providers have an option. When parents choose for their child to have X, Y and Z, they are also able to have additional options, which cost extra. It could be rice cakes, pancakes or popcorn and 65 cent here and there. That is not acceptable because it leads to us going back on the universal nature of the hot school meals. That cannot be allowed to continue. I raised this with the interdepartmental group and the relevant Ministers to say that needs to be cut out. We cannot do that because it means the programme is not universal. I could be sitting eating the standard meal and somebody sitting beside me will have all the extras. That is not on. This is where we need to decide what we want this for. It is important to make sure that it goes back to the core reason that no child is hungry, the food given is nutritious and everybody is treated equally.</p>
          <p eId="para_855"> It is then about looking at what those standards will be. As I outlined earlier, the Bill states clearly what those standards should be. There is no reason to delay it because the Government is going to do it anyway. The Minister of State has agreed that it is going to be done, it is important to do it, and he wants to find the mechanism to do it. I ask him not to press the timed amendment because it is just kicking the can down the road. There is no reason for that. Committee Stage is the Stage to discuss that. It is unfortunate that this is becoming more prevalent in this Thirty-fourth Dáil. Bills are subject to timed amendments. If we agree a Bill is good and that things can be done, we should not delay. This Bill is retrospectively fitting things out that should have been done when the roll-out happened in the first place. We all agreed it needed to roll out but now we need to iron out the things that should have been ironed out at the beginning.</p>
          <p eId="para_856"> Somebody said earlier that this was to do with management in school and that all of the things would cause an extra burden. What happened when the HACCP standards came in for hot school meals? That should have happened in the first instance. No school meals should have been served in the first place without HACCP and how it is managed. I was HACCP trained in my previous job. I have been around the food industry for a while because of family members, my husband and my father. In my previous job I was responsible for HACCP in my project and to make sure the food we served was appropriate and had proper Food Safety Authority of Ireland issues. When we retrospectively do that it of course adds a burden, but it should have been done in the first place. All of these things being set out need to be done to make sure it is the best possible standard. I did not accept the Minister of State talking about all of the things that might add burdens. That is scaremongering. We do not need to do that. It is not effective. Every principal who works in this country knows the quality of things that need to happen in their schools. They are responsible for those standards and are well capable of following the standards and making sure they are put in properly. Of course, the important thing is that the resources need to come to the schools to make sure they are, in fact, able to do that. That is not provided for in this legislation but the Government is going to examine how it can fully resource schools to ensure that this is put in properly.</p>
          <p eId="para_857"> Before I conclude, I again appeal to the Minister of State. This is not a timed amendment. It is about the young people at the end of the day. The longer we leave this and do not put those regulations in place, the longer it means that poor practice will continue. I highlighted that poor practice has happened in recent months. We need not to have that for taxpayers who are paying millions of euro for this important programme. I am happy to have brought this Bill forward. It is important. I am thankful to everybody for the debate we have had today. I look forward to it progressing. As a legislator, I would love that it would go through Committee Stage and all the rest. However, it is most important that the measures in the Bill happen to ensure that the health and well-being of children is of utmost importance, and in my eyes they always will be, as somebody who has worked with children for a long time.</p>
          <p eId="para_858"> On the well-being element under section 9 in the Education Act, the Minister of State is being a little pedantic. I do not accept that. That is a broad sentence that can be incorporated into circulars and curricula that are already in place. There are well-being programmes in schools, such as Stay Safe, relationships and sexuality and SPHE. That statement allows it to permeate throughout all the curricula and the circulars that will come to schools. That is a little pedantic. If that is a thing that would make the Bill, that is why it is important on Committee Stage to discuss that.</p>
          <p eId="para_859"> I thank all the Members. I appreciate it.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_18"> Amendment put.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_19"><b>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Keira Keogh)</b>: In accordance with Standing Order 85(2), the division is postponed until the next weekly division time.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_20"> Cuireadh an Dáil ar athló ar 5.50 p.m. go dtí 1 p.m., Dé Máirt, an 24 Samhain 2026.</summary>
        <summary eId="sum_21"> The Dáil adjourned at 5.50 p.m. until 1 p.m. on Tuesday, 24 November 2026.</summary>
      </debateSection>
    </debateBody>
  </debate>
</akomaNtoso>
