<akomaNtoso xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13" xsi:schemaLocation="http://docs.oasis-open.org/legaldocml/ns/akn/3.0/CSD13 ./akomantoso30.xsd">
  <debate name="Official Report">
    <meta>
      <identification source="#debates">
        <FRBRWork>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-17" name="#generation"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#author" href="/ie/oireachtas/house/dail/34"/>
          <FRBRcountry value="ie"/>
          <FRBRname value="debate"/>
        </FRBRWork>
        <FRBRExpression>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate/mul@/main"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate/mul@"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-17" name="#reported"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
          <FRBRlanguage language="eng"/>
        </FRBRExpression>
        <FRBRManifestation>
          <FRBRthis value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate/mul@/main.xml"/>
          <FRBRuri value="/akn/ie/debateRecord/dail/2026-11-17/debate/mul@.akn"/>
          <FRBRdate date="2026-11-17" name="#publication"/>
          <FRBRauthor as="#editor" href="#debates"/>
        </FRBRManifestation>
      </identification>
      <analysis source="#source">
        <parliamentary>
          <voting eId="vote_250" href="#sum_8" refersTo="#sum_7" outcome="#carried">
            <count eId="vote_250-count_1" href="#qty_1" value="79" refersTo="#ta"/>
            <count eId="vote_250-count_2" href="#qty_2" value="62" refersTo="#nil"/>
            <count eId="vote_250-count_3" href="#qty_3" value="0" refersTo="#staon"/>
          </voting>
        </parliamentary>
      </analysis>
      <references source="#debates">
        <TLCConcept eId="#lost" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#DeclaredLost" showAs="Declared Lost"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#carried" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#DeclaredCarried" showAs="Declared Carried"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#staon" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#StaonVote" showAs="Staon Vote"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#nil" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#NílVote" showAs="Níl Vote"/>
        <TLCConcept eId="#ta" href="/ie/oireachtas/ontology#TáVote" showAs="Tá Vote"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AengusOSnodaighSF" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aengus-Ó-Snodaigh.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Aengus Ó Snodaigh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AidanFarrelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aidan-Farrelly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Aidan Farrelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AindriasMoynihan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aindrias-Moynihan.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Aindrias Moynihan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AislingDempsey" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Aisling-Dempsey.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Aisling Dempsey"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AlanDillon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Alan-Dillon.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Alan Dillon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AlanKelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Alan-Kelly.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Alan Kelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AlbertDolan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Albert-Dolan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Albert Dolan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="AnnGraves" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ann-Graves.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Ann Graves"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BrendanSmith" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Brendan-Smith.D.1992-12-14" showAs="Brendan Smith"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BrianBrennan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Brian-Brennan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Brian Brennan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="BrianStanley" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Brian-Stanley.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Brian Stanley"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CathalCrowe" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cathal-Crowe.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Cathal Crowe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CatherineArdagh" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Catherine-Ardagh.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Catherine Ardagh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CatherineCallaghan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Catherine-Callaghan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Catherine Callaghan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CharlieMcConalogue" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Charlie-McConalogue.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Charlie McConalogue"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ChristopherOsullivan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Christopher-O'Sullivan.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Christopher O'Sullivan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CianOCallaghan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cian-O'Callaghan.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Cian O'Callaghan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CiaranAhern" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ciarán-Ahern.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Ciarán Ahern"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ClaireKerrane" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Claire-Kerrane.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Claire Kerrane"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ColmBrophy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Colm-Brophy.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Colm Brophy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ColmBurke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Colm-Burke.S.2011-05-25" showAs="Colm Burke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ConorDMcGuinness" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Conor-D-McGuinness.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Conor D. McGuinness"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="CormacDevlin" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Cormac-Devlin.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Cormac Devlin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DanielEnnis" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Daniel-Ennis.D.2026-05-25" showAs="Daniel Ennis"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DannyHealyRae" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Danny-Healy-Rae.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Danny Healy-Rae"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DaraCalleary" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Dara-Calleary.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Dara Calleary"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DarrenORourke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Darren-O'Rourke.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Darren O'Rourke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DavidCullinane" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/David-Cullinane.S.2011-05-25" showAs="David Cullinane"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DessieEllis" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Dessie-Ellis.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Dessie Ellis"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DonnaMcGettigan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Donna-McGettigan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Donna McGettigan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DonnchadhOLaoghaire" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Donnchadh-Ó-Laoghaire.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="DuncanSmith" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Duncan-Smith.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Duncan Smith"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EamonScanlon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eamon-Scanlon.S.2002-09-12" showAs="Eamon Scanlon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EdwardTimmins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Edward-Timmins.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Edward Timmins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EmerCurrie" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Emer-Currie.S.2020-06-29" showAs="Emer Currie"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EoghanKenny" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eoghan-Kenny.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Eoghan Kenny"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EoinHayes" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eoin-Hayes.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Eoin Hayes"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="EoinOBroin" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Eoin-Ó-Broin.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Eoin Ó Broin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ErinMcGreehan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Erin-McGreehan.S.2020-06-29" showAs="Erin McGreehan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="FionntanOSuilleabhain" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Fionntán-Ó-Súilleabháin.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GaryGannon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Gary-Gannon.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Gary Gannon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GeorgeLawlor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/George-Lawlor.D.2024-11-29" showAs="George Lawlor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GeraldNash" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Gerald-Nash.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Ged Nash"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GillianToole" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Gillian-Toole.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Gillian Toole"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="GraceBoland" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Grace-Boland.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Grace Boland"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="IvanaBacik" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ivana-Bacik.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Ivana Bacik"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JackChambers" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jack-Chambers.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Jack Chambers"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesBrowne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-Browne.D.2016-10-03" showAs="James Browne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesGeogheganFG" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-Geoghegan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="James Geoghegan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesLawless" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-Lawless.D.2016-10-03" showAs="James Lawless"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JamesOConnor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/James-O'Connor.D.2020-02-08" showAs="James O'Connor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenCummins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jen-Cummins.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Jen Cummins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenniferCarrollMacNeill" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jennifer-Carroll-MacNeill.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Jennifer Carroll MacNeill"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JenniferMurnaneOConnor" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jennifer-Murnane-O'Connor.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Jennifer Murnane O'Connor"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JerryButtimer" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jerry-Buttimer.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Jerry Buttimer"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JimOCallaghan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Jim-O'Callaghan.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Jim O'Callaghan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoannaByrne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joanna-Byrne.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Joanna Byrne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeCooney" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-Cooney.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Joe Cooney"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JoeNeville" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Joe-Neville.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Joe Neville"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnBrady" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Brady.D.2016-10-03" showAs="John Brady"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnClendennen" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Clendennen.D.2024-11-29" showAs="John Clendennen"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnConnolly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Connolly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="John Connolly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnLahart" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Lahart.D.2016-10-03" showAs="John Lahart"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnMcGuinness" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-McGuinness.D.1997-06-26" showAs="John McGuinness"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnnyGuirke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Johnny-Guirke.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Johnny Guirke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnnyMythen" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Johnny-Mythen.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Johnny Mythen"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="JohnPaulOShea" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/John-Paul-O'Shea.D.2024-11-29" showAs="John Paul O'Shea"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KeiraKeogh" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Keira-Keogh.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Keira Keogh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KenOFlynn" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ken-O'Flynn.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Ken O'Flynn"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KevinBoxerMoran" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Kevin-Boxer-Moran.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Kevin Boxer Moran"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="KieranODonnell" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Kieran-O'Donnell.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Kieran O'Donnell"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="LiamQuaide" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Liam-Quaide.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Liam Quaide"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="LouiseOReilly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Louise-O'Reilly.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Louise O'Reilly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="LouisOHara" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Louis-O'Hara.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Louis O'Hara"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaeveOConnell" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Maeve-O'Connell.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Maeve O'Connell"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaireDevine" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Máire-Devine.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Máire Devine"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MalcolmByrne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Malcolm-Byrne.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Malcolm Byrne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarianHarkinIND" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Marian-Harkin.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Marian Harkin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarieSherlock" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Marie-Sherlock.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Marie Sherlock"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkWall" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Wall.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Mark Wall"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MarkWard" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mark-Ward.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Mark Ward"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinDaly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Daly.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Martin Daly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinHeydon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Heydon.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Martin Heydon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MartinKenny" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Martin-Kenny.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Martin Kenny"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaryButler" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mary-Butler.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Mary Butler"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MaryLouMcDonald" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Mary-Lou-McDonald.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Mary Lou McDonald"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MattCarthy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Matt-Carthy.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Matt Carthy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MauriceQuinlivan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Maurice-Quinlivan.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Maurice Quinlivan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelCahill" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Cahill.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Michael Cahill"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelCollins2016" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Collins.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Michael Collins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelHealyRae" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Healy-Rae.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Michael Healy-Rae"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelLowry" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Lowry.D.1987-03-10" showAs="Michael Lowry"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMartin" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Micheál-Martin.D.1989-06-29" showAs="Micheál Martin"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMoynihan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Moynihan.D.1997-06-26" showAs="Michael Moynihan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichaelMurphy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Michael-Murphy.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Michael Murphy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="MichealCarrigy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Micheál-Carrigy.S.2020-03-30" showAs="Micheál Carrigy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NaoiseOCearuil" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Naoise-Ó-Cearúil.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Naoise Ó Cearúil"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NaoiseOMuiri" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Naoise-Ó-Muirí.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Naoise Ó Muirí"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NatashaNewsomeDrennan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Natasha-Newsome-Drennan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Natasha Newsome Drennan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NealeRichmond" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Neale-Richmond.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Neale Richmond"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NiallCollins" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Niall-Collins.D.2007-06-14" showAs="Niall Collins"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NoelGrealishPD" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Noel-Grealish.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Noel Grealish"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NoelMcCarthy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Noel-McCarthy.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Noel McCarthy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="NormaFoley" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Norma-Foley.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Norma Foley"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PadraigMacLochlainn" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pádraig-MacLochlainn.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Pádraig Mac Lochlainn"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PadraigOSullivan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pádraig-O'Sullivan.D.2019-11-29" showAs="Pádraig O'Sullivan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PadraigRice" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pádraig-Rice.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Pádraig Rice"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PatTheCopeGallagher" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pat-the-Cope-Gallagher.D.1981-06-30" showAs="Pat the Cope Gallagher"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulDonnelly" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Donnelly.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Paul Donnelly"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulMcAuliffe" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-McAuliffe.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Paul McAuliffe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulMurphy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Murphy.D.2014-10-10" showAs="Paul Murphy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PaulNicholasGogartyGP" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Paul-Nicholas-Gogarty.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Paul Nicholas Gogarty"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PeadarToibin" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Peadar-Tóibín.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Peadar Tóibín"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PearseDoherty" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Pearse-Doherty.S.2007-07-23" showAs="Pearse Doherty"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PeterBurke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Peter-Burke.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Peter Burke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PeterChapCleere" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Peter-'Chap'-Cleere.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Peter 'Chap' Cleere"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="PeterRoche" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Peter-Roche.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Peter Roche"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RichardBoydBarrett" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Richard-Boyd-Barrett.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Richard Boyd Barrett"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobertODonoghue" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robert-O'Donoghue.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Robert O'Donoghue"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RobertTroy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Robert-Troy.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Robert Troy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RodericOGorman" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Roderic-O'Gorman.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Roderic O'Gorman"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RoryHearne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Rory-Hearne.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Rory Hearne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RoseConwayWalsh" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Rose-Conway-Walsh.S.2016-04-25" showAs="Rose Conway-Walsh"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RuairiOmurchu" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ruairí-Ó-Murchú.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Ruairí Ó Murchú"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RuthCoppinger" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ruth-Coppinger.D.2014-05-23" showAs="Ruth Coppinger"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="RyanOMeara" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Ryan-O'Meara.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Ryan O'Meara"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeamusHealy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seamus-Healy.D.2000-06-22" showAs="Seamus Healy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeamusMcGrath" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Séamus-McGrath.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Séamus McGrath"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanCanney" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Canney.D.2016-10-03" showAs="Seán Canney"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanCroweSF" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Crowe.D.2002-06-06" showAs="Seán Crowe"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanFleming" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Fleming.D.1997-06-26" showAs="Sean Fleming"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanKyne" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Kyne.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Seán Kyne"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SeanOFearghaillFF" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Seán-Ó-Fearghaíl.S.2000-06-09" showAs="Seán Ó Fearghaíl"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ShaneMoynihan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Shane-Moynihan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Shane Moynihan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="ShayBrennan" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Shay-Brennan.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Shay Brennan"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SimonHarris" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Simon-Harris.D.2011-03-09" showAs="Simon Harris"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SineadGibney" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Sinéad-Gibney.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Sinéad Gibney"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="SorcaClarke" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Sorca-Clarke.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Sorca Clarke"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="TomBrabazon" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Tom-Brabazon.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Tom Brabazon"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="TonyMcCormack" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Tony-McCormack.D.2024-11-29" showAs="Tony McCormack"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="VeronaMurphy" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Verona-Murphy.D.2020-02-08" showAs="Verona Murphy"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="WilliamAird" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/William-Aird.D.2024-11-29" showAs="William Aird"/>
        <TLCPerson eId="WillieODea" href="/ie/oireachtas/member/id/Willie-O'Dea.D.1982-03-09" showAs="Willie O'Dea"/>
        <TLCRole eId="An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/office/an_cathaoirleach_gníomhach" showAs="An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/health" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Health"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/housing__local_government__heritage" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage"/>
        <TLCRole eId="Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_the_Taoiseach" href="/ie/oireachtas/role/minister_state/taoiseach" showAs="Minister of State at the Department of the Taoiseach"/>
      </references>
    </meta>
    <preface>
      <block name="title_ga">
        <docTitle>DÍOSPÓIREACHTAÍ PARLAIMINTE</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="title_en">
        <docTitle>PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES</docTitle>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_ga">
        <docProponent>DÁIL ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="proponent_en">
        <docProponent>DÁIL ÉIREANN</docProponent>
      </block>
      <block name="status_ga">
        <docStatus>TUAIRISC OIFIGIÚIL</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="status_en">
        <docStatus>(OFFICIAL REPORT)</docStatus>
      </block>
      <block name="date_ga">
        <docDate date="2026-11-17">Dé Máirt, 17 Samhain 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block name="date_en">
        <docDate date="2026-11-17">Tuesday, 17 November 2026</docDate>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_en">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
      <block refersTo="#unrevised" name="version_ga">
        <docStatus/>
      </block>
    </preface>
    <debateBody>
      <debateSection name="prelude" eId="dbsect_1">
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_1">Chuaigh an Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Grace Boland) i gceannas ar 1 p.m.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_2">Paidir agus Machnamh.</summary>
        <summary class="Center" eId="sum_3">Prayer and Reflection.</summary>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="topical" eId="dbsect_2">
        <heading>Ábhair Shaincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Matters<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#GraceBoland" as="#An_Cathaoirleach_Gníomhach" eId="spk_1">
          <from>An Cathaoirleach Gníomhach (Deputy Grace Boland)<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_1">I wish to advise the House of the following matters in respect of which notice has been given under Standing Order 39 and the name of the Member in each case:</p>
          <p eId="para_2"> Deputy Michael Cahill - To discuss the need for improvement works in schools, especially in Kerry.</p>
          <p eId="para_3"> Deputy Albert Dolan - To discuss endometriosis services in Galway.</p>
          <p eId="para_4"> Deputy Malcolm Byrne - To discuss the integration of artificial intelligence into the education system.</p>
          <p eId="para_5"> Deputy Robert O'Donoghue - To discuss the need for an integrated, co-ordinated mental health emergency response.</p>
          <p eId="para_6"> Deputy John Connolly - To discuss the cost associated with the medical report required by people aged 75+ when applying to renew a driving licence.</p>
          <p eId="para_7"> Deputy Joe Cooney - To discuss the need for a systemic review of school transport systems.</p>
          <p eId="para_8"> Deputy Keira Keogh - To discuss provision for another ambulance in Erris, County Mayo.</p>
          <p eId="para_9"> Deputy Fionntán Ó Súilleabháin - To discuss the growing uncertainty facing Dealz workers.</p>
          <p eId="para_10"> Deputy Ryan O'Meara - To discuss financial supports for community cafes.</p>
          <p eId="para_11"> Deputy Roderic O'Gorman - To discuss LGBTI+ rights in Türkiye in light of the "My Family is Safe" operation being undertaken by the Turkish government.</p>
          <p eId="para_12"> Deputy Paul McAuliffe - To discuss HSE-funded counselling services for young people in Finglas.</p>
          <p eId="para_13"> Deputy Michael Murphy - To discuss road safety risks associated with horse-drawn vehicles on public roads.</p>
          <p eId="para_14"> Deputy Maurice Quinlivan - To discuss the issue of wandering horses in urban areas.</p>
          <p eId="para_15"> Deputy Darren O'Rourke - To discuss recent frequent water outages in Ashbourne, County Meath and accountability issues. </p>
          <p eId="para_16"> Deputy Sinéad Gibney - To discuss the progress of essential renovations at St. Brigid's BNS in Foxrock.</p>
          <p eId="para_17"> Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett - To discuss published homelessness figures, and the Government's recently published Aire, the Child and Family Homelessness Action Plan. </p>
          <p eId="para_18"> Deputy Shane Moynihan - To discuss the need to ensure full provision of NEPS in schools across Lucan, Clondalkin, Palmerstown, Rathcoole, Newcastle and Saggart.</p>
          <p eId="para_19"> Deputy Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire - To discuss the need for footpaths from Waterfall village to Bishopstown.</p>
          <p eId="para_20"> Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh - To discuss the planned compulsory purchase order for the 440 acres of commonage on Achill Island.</p>
          <p eId="para_21"> Deputy Louise O'Reilly - To discuss the extension of a cost of disability payment to people over the normal retirement age.</p>
          <p eId="para_22"> Deputy Donna McGettigan - To discuss Government childcare policy to increase the supply of places. </p>
          <p eId="para_23"> Deputy Seán Kyne - To discuss an update on the Claregalway relief road.</p>
          <p eId="para_24"> Deputy Louis O'Hara - To discuss the continued closure of Dunguaire Castle, Kinvara, County Galway.</p>
          <p eId="para_25"> The matters raised by Deputies Paul McAuliffe, Keira Keogh, Richard Boyd Barrett, Louis O'Hara and Sinéad Gibney have been selected for discussion.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="topical" eId="dbsect_3">
        <heading>Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_4">
          <heading>Youth Services<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_2">
            <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_26">I want to raise with the Minister of State the issue of HSE-funded counselling services for young people in Finglas. To some degree, we are coming to the end of a successful process where earlier this year, like in many communities, <i>ad hoc</i> funding had been used to provide counselling through the two youth services in our area. That was coming to an end and there was a real fear about whether we would be able to continue to provide these counselling services. Like any good community, when the Finglas community heard it was under pressure, they held a fundraiser. They also did what they do best and came together.</p>
            <p eId="para_27">I was delighted to chair a group involving the Finglas Counselling Service, Crosscare, the Finglas Youth Resource Centre and Barnardos which came on board to try to identify how we could mainstream funding for what was called the Hear Me Out service. We are very appreciative that when we reached October, we had put in place funding of almost €100,000 for new adult counselling services in Finglas west through Barnardos. I understand there is also funding, which the Minister of State may outline in her reply from the HSE, for other counselling services in the area through Crosscare. </p>
            <p eId="para_28"> The reason I say all of this is that the HSE social inclusion unit stepped in, saw a need, saw a local solution and provided funding. I am incredibly appreciative of the HSE officers. I will not name them and embarrass them but I thank them for the work they did because it is a great example of what we should be doing right across the country. It is about making sure that when young people ask for help, that help is available and it is available in places where they feel comfortable, not necessarily in a clinical setting but in their local youth service, family resource centre, where the proposed service in Finglas west will be, and in local places they have access to. I commend the work of the local HSE in my area. I thank it for the funding but there is a lesson there on how we apply this right across the country.</p>
            <p eId="para_29"> It is so important because so many of the issues we see in mental health begin in adolescence. That is when some of those concerns arise. We all know being a teenager is a difficult thing but for those people who have complex needs and are living in families where there are multiple issues, counselling can be a really valuable and lifesaving service. When you combine it with other interagency work, like youth services or family intervention through places like the family resource centres, the State is getting value for money too because there are two or three interventions coming together around one person or one family.</p>
            <p eId="para_30"> There are plenty of times when people come in here to ask the Minister of State for money or to make an intervention. To some degree, the system has worked here, with a lot of local co-ordination and I have been happy to play a part in that. We would like to see this as a template for what will happen elsewhere. There are many families in Finglas who have been benefited from the Hear Me Out counselling service and would be relieved to hear we are recruiting that additional adolescent counsellor. They will say to me that if it works well in Finglas, we should do it elsewhere.</p>
            <p eId="para_31"> The Minister of State, Deputy Butler, has a very ambitious programme for expanding mental health services. Much of that is around supporting local groups but I wanted to point out something that has worked well here. My former colleague, Pat Carey, always used to say if something works well in Finglas, we should be trying to do it elsewhere in the country. This is something that has worked well and I would like to see it expand.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health" eId="spk_3">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor)<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:05:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_32">I thank the Deputy for the opportunity to address the House today on the issue which I know is of real and ongoing importance to Finglas and the wider Dublin north-east region. I am taking this Topical Issue on behalf of the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, who is responsible for mental health and has worked very well with the Deputy.</p>
            <p eId="para_33"> There is significant work under way across Government to improve all aspects of child and youth mental health care. The aim of Government is to deliver a modern, responsive service that meets the needs of young people and their families. This is central to our national mental health policy, Sharing the Vision 2020-2030, and our suicide reduction strategy, Connecting for Life: 2026-2035, and the broader ambitions of Sláintecare. Youth mental health supports are made up of a tiered approach. CAMHS is a specialised service available to the small proportion of children and young people who experience moderate to severe mental health difficulties. While approximately 2% of children and adolescents require the specialist care that CAMHS provides, the majority of needs can be met through early intervention, primary care and community supports.</p>
            <p eId="para_34"> In recent years, the Department of Health, in conjunction with the HSE, has expanded investment in these early intervention and downstream services. In the case of Finglas specifically, a number of targeted HSE-supported interventions have been developed locally to improve access to youth counselling, therapeutic support and early intervention services.</p>
            <p eId="para_35">I thank Deputy McAuliffe for his long-standing leadership and advocacy on mental health issues in Finglas. His work in highlighting the needs of young people and families in the community has helped to ensure that youth mental health remains a priority in his locality. I am aware that earlier this year, Deputy McAuliffe brought together Barnardos, Finglas Youth Resource Centre, Finglas Counselling Service and Crosscare in an interagency partnership to explore how local youth counselling provision could be sustained and expanded for the future. This collaborative approach has helped to secure ongoing access to essential supports for young people and their families in Finglas.</p>
            <p eId="para_36"> Building on this work, HSE social inclusion has agreed to provide funding of €100,000 a year to Barnardos Finglas West Family Resource Centre to establish a dedicated youth counselling service in Finglas West. Recruitment will shortly commence for an adolescent counsellor, providing 27.5 hours per week of direct counselling and therapeutic support for young people aged from 12 to 24. This is an important milestone for Finglas West and will strengthen access to early intervention and mental health supports in the local community. More broadly, a number of targeted HSE-supported interventions have been developed locally to improve access to youth counselling, therapeutic support and early intervention services. Total funding of almost €820,000 has been provided in 2026 to support young people in Finglas and surrounding areas, including the Crosscare Hear Me Out project, with two whole-time equivalent counsellor and psychotherapist posts dedicated to the Finglas area; Finglas Youth Resource Centre's Mincéiri project with 1.5 whole-time equivalent youth workers; Barnardos adolescent counselling services; Crosscare teen counselling; and Crosscare drug and alcohol projects. The Hear Me Out project has become a key therapeutic support service specifically for young people in Finglas West and surrounding areas.</p>
            <p eId="para_37"> These services were initially developed to address clear gaps in youth counselling provision and have demonstrated strong outcomes in supporting young people experiencing emotional distress, anxiety, family difficulties and substance-use concerns and other mental health challenges. The successful transition of the Hear Me Out project from Finglas Counselling Service to Crosscare, in collaboration with Finglas Youth Resource Centre, along with increased resourcing, has ensured the continuation and sustainability of this important service model, maintaining local access to therapeutic supports while strengthening governance, organisational infrastructure and long-term service delivery.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#PaulMcAuliffe" eId="spk_4">
            <from>Deputy Paul McAuliffe<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:10:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_38">I thank the Minister of State and I appreciate her kind words about bringing people together. As politicians, we do this all the time. Sometimes it is successful and sometimes it is not but we have learned a lot through this process too.</p>
            <p eId="para_39"> I want to state on the record that earlier this year, we had a service with <i>ad hoc </i>funding which has now been translated into two services. We will have the Crosscare Hear Me Out project, which will now be mainstream funded by the HSE, and Barnardos adolescent counselling as well. This is a huge step forward in terms of the security and provision of mental health services in Finglas. It is exactly what the community needs and deserves.</p>
            <p eId="para_40"> I cannot come to the end of this process without thanking Finglas Counselling Service. It originally carried out this process. It is an adult mental health service that previously secured funding through the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, three years ago. It made the decision not to continue doing it because it was not core to its work. It wanted to stick to what it did well but it also recognised that the service needed to be provided on a mainstream basis by an organisation with dedicated adolescent experience. Audrey in Finglas Counselling Service has been a fantastic mentor to other organisations in helping them to get this funding. I thank her for the work she has done and for the honesty of the service in saying it wanted to focus on what it needed to focus on. It did not just drop the service but worked with other people to ensure it was handed over and it now has mainstream funding.</p>
            <p eId="para_41"> This shows the power of communities coming together. The Minister of State is from Carlow and she knows what communities can do when they come together. Community-based mental health services have had different types of experiences and there are often concerns about governance and clinical standards. This is an example of how we can work with community organisations and partner them with organisations such as Crosscare and Barnardos, which have considerable experience, to ensure a community-led service with good governance from the larger experienced organisations and funding from the HSE. I thank the Minister of State for her work. I invite her and the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, to visit these services in Finglas.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" eId="spk_5" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:15:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_42">We certainly will. I again thank the Deputy.</p>
            <p eId="para_43"> In addition to the service I mentioned previously, the HSE has supported the development of the Mincéirí project through the Finglas Youth Resource Centre to improve engagement with younger members of our Travelling community and other marginalised young people in the Finglas area. That is also really important. The HSE social inclusion and addiction service has a service level agreement with Crosscare for the delivery of a teen counselling service. These are all the services the Deputy mentioned. The level of demand demonstrates the importance of maintaining and continuing investment in community-based counselling and psychotherapy provision for young people in Finglas. These services play a critical role. I will go back to the Minister of State, Deputy Butler. The Deputy will know of her commitment and dedication to mental health. I will also ask, as the Deputy suggested, whether this is an area that could be looked at with a view to rolling out services across the country. When communities come together to provide a service, that really works well. At the end of the day, this is very beneficial to the people who need the service and to their families. I congratulate the Deputy and thank him for his work. The progress outlined today demonstrates what can be done with leadership and working with the HSE and all of the different Departments.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_5">
          <heading>Ambulance Service<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:15:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#KeiraKeogh" eId="spk_6">
            <from>Deputy Keira Keogh<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:15:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_44">I thank the Minister of State for taking this Topical Issue. Today, I will highlight a matter of deep concern to the people of Erris and the north-west Mayo region, namely the lack of adequate ambulance cover. The people of Erris are known for being exceptionally resilient. They are accustomed to overcoming the challenges they have to face because they live in a place that is, while a really beautiful part of the world, really rural and geographically isolated. They are very resourceful people but they deserve timely access to life-saving emergency services. Every second counts in the case of a medical emergency, whether a heart attack, a stroke, a serious road traffic collision or a farming accident. For far too long, communities across Belmullet, Bangor Erris, Ballycroy, Geesala, Pullathomas and so on have been repeatedly raising concerns about ambulance availability and response times. </p>
            <p eId="para_45"> In December 2025, I was contacted by a local retained fireman who was really traumatised by an experience where no ambulance was available for a critically injured young adult. The firefighters and local doctors did their very best to improvise and they themselves called off-duty paramedics they knew to reactivate an off-call ambulance and to come as urgently as they could to transport that man to Mayo University Hospital. They talked about that experience being deeply traumatising as they knew the man was gravely ill but had been told there was no estimated time of arrival for any ambulance. I wrote to the Minister in December to ask for engagement and urgent action.</p>
            <p eId="para_46"> Tragically, in January, this House became aware of the sudden death of Stephen Lavelle from Binghamstown, who fell ill close to his home. Family members had to drive him to Mayo University Hospital because there was no ambulance available. Their experience was also extremely traumatising and ended devastatingly. We wish them very well. I know an investigation is ongoing.</p>
            <p eId="para_47"> Nobody should fear that there will not be an ambulance if they or one of their family members suddenly becomes ill. On 30 January, that fireman and I met with Paul Gallen, head of integrated services. We were informed that an extra ambulance with a daytime crew for the period from 12 noon to 12 midnight was ready to be approved. There was going to be no difficulty in staffing that ambulance. A base was being sought outside of Belmullet but primary notification from the Minister was awaited. We, therefore, wrote to the Minister. On 3 March, the Minister told us that primary notifications are actually an internal HSE process and that the decision did not depend on the Minister's direction. We feel a little bit like we are being pushed between different Departments. I really hope the Minister of State has a really clear update for me today. In June, this firefighter came back to me again because there had been a 75-minute wait in the case of a cardiac arrest. As recently as a fortnight ago, he reached out again. At this point, he was making contact in desperation. He talked about the distress that he and his colleagues faced while they waited over an hour for an ambulance for a critically ill patient alongside a family member. </p>
            <p eId="para_48"> I will give credit where it is due. Last week, the Minister came to visit Belmullet Community Hospital. She is the first Minister for Health in living memory, or possibly ever, to visit that hospital. She met with Mary Noone and her staff, who provide an exceptional service.</p>
            <p eId="para_49">I welcome that the design team has now been appointed and the commencement of the preliminary design for the 50-bed community nursing unit, which will include a ten-bed dementia household and the relocation of the National Ambulance Service. That is so exciting and positive but the reality is that no family should face the fear that distance could determine the outcome of their medical emergency. I hope the Minister of State has a clear update for me.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" eId="spk_7" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_50">I thank the Deputy for raising this very serious issue. I am taking this Topical Issue on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. It gives me the opportunity to speak to the Deputy about the ambulance service in County Mayo, including the Erris region.</p>
            <p eId="para_51"> As the Deputy will be aware, the National Ambulance Service, NAS, serves Mayo on a 24-7 basis from 24 ambulance bases across the HSE's west and north-west region through a highly-skilled workforce of paramedics, advanced paramedics and emergency medical technicians, and a fleet of modern emergency ambulances, intermediate care vehicles and rapid response vehicles. As the Deputy said, the work they do is exceptional and it is important to mention that today.</p>
            <p eId="para_52"> The region is also served by the NAS's alternative care pathways designed to treat patients at the most appropriate level of clinical need while avoiding unnecessary patient conveyances to busy hospital emergency departments where it is not clinically necessary. These pathways include pathfinder "see and treat" services located in Letterkenny and Galway, as well as community paramedic services based in Castlebar, Roscommon and Donegal. Further emergency response capacity is provided in the region through the newly established Government-funded helicopter emergency medical service, HEMS, operating out of Sligo Airport. This service commenced operations on a testing basis in July and is providing enhanced access to care for critically ill patients across the west and north west of the country. </p>
            <p eId="para_53"> Turning to additional ambulance resourcing for north County Mayo, the Deputy's engagement on this matter with the NAS head of integrated services is acknowledged. What I can say to her is that the NAS has advised that an additional ambulance is being actively considered for north County Mayo as part of new service developments for 2027. While nothing can be confirmed at this stage, the NAS has indicated that north County Mayo is one of several possible destinations considered to have the most critical patient need for further resourcing.</p>
            <p eId="para_54"> The Deputy will be aware that this Government has continuously invested in the NAS, with significant increases in investment in recent years. Government investment in 2026 of over €292 million is supporting HSE plans to increase capacity in the NAS with 263 additional posts as part of an investment of €20 million in new service developments.</p>
            <p eId="para_55"> This investment includes provision for six additional paramedic positions to be based in Castlebar as well as for hospital ambulance liaison supervisors to be located at Mayo University Hospital to assist in facilitating timely patient handovers to hospital emergency departments to improve ambulance turnaround times at the emergency department. Recruitment for these positions is in progress. I should add that investment in 2026 has seen significant increases in the NAS capital funding, including €34 million for the renewal and expansion of the NAS fleet of emergency ambulances and other response vehicles. Indeed, overall investment in recent years has seen total NAS staffing rise to 2,550 whole-time equivalents as of the end of September, a rise of 32% or 622 staff since 2020, with over 85% of all NAS staff working in direct patient facing roles.</p>
            <p eId="para_56"> I thank the Deputy for highlighting this issue. I will speak to the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, about this later on.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#KeiraKeogh" eId="spk_8">
            <from>Deputy Keira Keogh<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:20:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_57">I too thank the paramedics, firefighters and GPs, especially those in the Erris region who are providing exceptional service. I welcome the helicopter emergency medical service, HEMS, operating out of Sligo Airport. I know that will benefit the people of Mayo, even though we hoped it would be located in Erris. However, I have to say that I am really frustrated to read the paragraph that states that the NAS has advised that an additional ambulance is being actively considered for north County Mayo.</p>
            <p eId="para_58">In January 2026, I was told by that person that they thought we would have that extra ambulance by the summer, but now it sounds like it is just being considered. We were told there was one for 12 a.m. to 12 p.m. being approved and was just waiting on a primary notification, but now it seems we have gone backwards where it is being said it is being considered. I am seeking more clarification on what is happening there and whether we have gone backwards. Realistically, the people of Erris are not looking for any special treatment; they are looking for fair treatment. They are seeking the assurance that if a loved one suffers a cardiac arrest, if a child is seriously injured or if an elderly neighbour becomes critically ill, help will arrive as quickly as possible. </p>
            <p eId="para_59"> I have tried not to come in here to talk about this issue and instead deal with it in direct contact with those in the Department and the HSE so as not to scaremonger or make people fearful when they call 999 or 112, so that they have that confidence that an ambulance is going to arrive. It is not good enough and it is not a new problem. This existed long before I became a TD and it is one the firefighters, GPs and paramedics have consistently warned us about in the area. As a public representative, I have a duty to ensure rural Ireland is not left behind. Investment in an ambulance service in Erris that is fit for purpose, timely and serves the needs of the people is absolutely paramount.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor" eId="spk_9" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Health">
            <from>Deputy Jennifer Murnane O'Connor<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:25:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_60">I thank the Deputy for raising this matter. She is advocating on behalf of her own constituency for the provision of an ambulance service in Erris and Mayo. Again, the line is there. I assure the Deputy that the request for additional ambulance resourcing for Erris remains under active consideration, but I will also speak to the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, on this. I also assure the Deputy that this Government remains committed to investing in increasing capacity in our national ambulance services for patients across the country. As the Deputy said, there is a fear of not getting an ambulance on time. Nobody ever wants to be in that situation. I totally understand that. </p>
            <p eId="para_61"> I thank the Deputy for highlighting this. It is important we go back and get clarification for her, particularly for those who need to know what is happening within the HSE, which is working with the Department. I will get the Minister to come back to the Deputy. I thank her again for raising this very serious issue.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_6">
          <heading>Homeless Persons Supports<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:25:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#RichardBoydBarrett" eId="spk_10">
            <from>Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:25:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_62">The latest homelessness figures are an absolute disgrace, shame and scandal for a wealthy country such as ours. There are 18,000 people in emergency accommodation including almost 6,000 children. While we have a report that has some good aspirations in it, it is very difficult to stomach the situation we are in particularly because the Government was warned that its reliance on private developers to deliver even social housing was going to cause a problem. For at least three or four years, we said private developers were not interested in building three- and four-bedroom homes because if they build one- and two-bedroom homes, they can get more units. The Government did not listen. Even when output goes up, child and family homelessness continues to increase because they are not building three- and four-bedroom homes. We finally got an acknowledgement from the Government but is the reliance on the private developers, who do not give a damn about the homeless figures and are only interested in how much money they can make from a site, going to have any impact when Government continues to rely on them for housing? </p>
            <p eId="para_63"> I might say as an incidental that about two years ago, I reported an apartment block in my area, Domville in Cherrywood, where there were 30 empty apartments built by a private developer for an approved housing body, AHB. I got a message from that AHB to say they are still empty two years on because of some row with the developer. This is the sort of stuff that goes on. While we get aspirations from Government that it is going to do something, the underlying policy of relying on private developers who are profit driven is not capable of dealing with the problem. </p>
            <p eId="para_64"> The human cost of this is terrible. I will give some examples in my area that I am dealing with. Amy is a mother of two and one of her children has Down's syndrome. She is currently couch surfing.</p>
            <p eId="para_65">She has to pick up her kids from school each day and then wander the streets because she has nowhere to go. She has been offered a housing assistance payment, HAP, homeless rate of €1,900 but she needs a three-bedroom home. There is no such thing as a three-bedroom home for €1,900 to rent. The only emergency accommodation she has been offered is in Kildare. She lives in Dún Laoghaire and her child needs therapies in Dún Laoghaire so that is an absolute non-starter for her but there is no emergency accommodation in Dún Laoghaire at all. In fact, I was told yesterday that 5% of the homelessness in Dublin, or possibly in the country, is in Dún Laoghaire but Dún Laoghaire has only 2% of the homeless accommodation. These days, a homeless family with children is just told to go to Kildare because that is the nearest. It is unbelievable. </p>
            <p eId="para_66"> Given the aspiration expressed in this that children should not be put into these situations, what is the Minister actually going to do for people like Amy or Saoirse, who has spent two years in homeless service and has a three-year-old and a four-year-old, one of whom has additional needs? She has a three-bedroom need and is going from one emergency hub to another. Charlotte, who has a four-month-old, has to separate from her child three nights a week so her child can stay with her sister. The only place she has been offered is Kildare when she lives in Dún Laoghaire. Again, with the €1,900 HAP limit, it is impossible to find the accommodation she is looking for. Let us not forget older people, although they are not affected by the report. Christine is a senior citizen with cancer and COPD, has had a heart attack and is sleeping on a couch in a mobile home with her family. She has been homeless for three and a half years and despite weeks of representations to the council, all she is being offered is emergency accommodation in a family hub. That is just a small glimpse of the suffering that people are going through. What is going to change?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage" eId="spk_11">
            <from>Minister of State at the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage (Deputy Alan Dillon)<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:30:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_67">I thank the Deputy for raising this important issue today, which I am taking on behalf of the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Deputy James Browne. Behind every statistic is a person, a child and a family facing uncertainty and stress, as Deputy Boyd Barrett outlined. As a TD, a Member of this House and a member of Government, I certainly recognise that. We understand the anxiety that is being felt by parents trying to provide stability for children and families worried about where they will live. The latest homelessness figures are deeply concerning. The most recent report shows that over 18,000 people accessed emergency accommodation, including 2,821 families and 5,897 children. Any increase is really disappointing and neither the Minister nor anyone else in Government is satisfied with those figures. </p>
            <p eId="para_68"> However, while we must be honest about the scale of the challenge, we must also be honest about what is being done and what progress is being made. The most effective response to homelessness is to prevent people from entering it in the first place and to support those in emergency accommodation to move on into secure permanent homes as quickly as possible. In the second quarter of this year alone, 748 households, including 405 families and 644 children, were prevented from entering emergency accommodation. During the same period, 613 households, including 276 families and 539 children, exited emergency accommodation into secure tenancies. Overall, over 1,360 households and almost 2,900 individuals either avoided homelessness or successfully exited emergency accommodation into secure housing during that quarter. These figures matter because they represent real families securing stability, real children returning to routine and real people getting the chance to rebuild their lives.</p>
            <p eId="para_69"> Addressing family homelessness is an absolute priority for the Government and that is why under the new housing plan, we committed to developing a dedicated child and family homelessness action strategy. Last week, the Government published the Aire children and family homelessness action plan that was developed following considerable engagement across Government, stakeholders and, importantly, children with lived experience of homelessness. The plan contains 43 actions backed by an additional €20 million of investment. The plan is structured around three clear priorities, the first of which is prevention - stopping families entering homelessness in the first place. The second is protection, which involves supporting children's well-being while families remain in temporary accommodation.</p>
            <p eId="para_70">The third is progression and helping families move quicker into secure, long-term housing. This is not simply another housing response. It brings together housing, health, education, childcare, youth services and family support in order to provide a more co-ordinated response to family homelessness. The Government remains committed to increasing housing supply because the long-term answer to homelessness is more homes. That is why we are targeting over 72,000 social homes and over 90,000 affordable housing supports. In budget 2027, we provided over €7.7 billion for housing, a figure which rises to €9.1 billion when investments in the Land Development Agency, LDA, and the Housing Finance Agency, HFA, are included.</p>
            <p eId="para_71"> We do not pretend there is a quick fix to this challenge. We need to continue to build housing supply over the years ahead. Equally, we need to continue to support those families who can be prevented from entering homelessness in the first place.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#RichardBoydBarrett" eId="spk_12">
            <from>Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:35:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_72">I will go slightly off topic and mention the tragedy that happened in Monkstown Farm. There is a housing implication in this regard. Terrible injuries were inflicted on a number of young children. I have been contacted by a number of the affected families. As a result of severe, life-changing injuries, many of them are going to need transfers and adapted accommodation, even to be able to exit hospitals. I ask the Minister of State to contact Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council and encourage it to provide assistance to the affected families.</p>
            <p eId="para_73"> On the topic itself, I do not understand how the Minister of State can talk about prevention when the Government has refused to impose a no-fault eviction ban, which is one of the major reasons people end up homeless. I do not understand how he can talk about prevention when we have a report stating that rents have increased by 7% in the past year. The Government allowed this to happen because it refused to impose a rent freeze, which is what we want, in order to stop an increase in rents and, indeed, to reduce rents.</p>
            <p eId="para_74"> The average rent in this country is now €2,300 per month. In my area, it is more like €3,000 per month. It is completely impossible. When it comes to the housing assistance payment, HAP, rates, as I said, an individual with two children, one of whom has Down’s syndrome, is looking for a three-bedroom house at €1,900 per month. That is like finding a needle in a haystack. It is despair and desperation stuff. She and her children are being traumatised, as are others in homeless accommodation. Saoirse has spent two years with her children in homeless accommodation. Charlotte has been separated from her four-month-old child because there is nothing for them. The HAP rates have not increased, nor have the social housing income thresholds. The Government continues to rely on private developers rather than upscaling the amount of social and affordable housing to a level that will meet demand and the target of ending housing waiting lists rather than the decade or so that people are currently waiting.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" eId="spk_13" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy Alan Dillon<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:35:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_75">I also wish to convey my best wishes to those impacted by the Monkstown incident. I will relay the Deputy’s concerns and the need for follow-up support to the Minister, Deputy Browne.</p>
            <p eId="para_76"> In respect of the figures published last Friday, I fully understand why people are frustrated and why the Deputy has come into the House in the manner he has. I share that frustration. The question is not whether the figures are too high - they are – but, rather, what actions we are taking to turn the situation around. As I said earlier, we have implemented a number of prevention measures. The figures demonstrate that over 748 households were prevented from entering homelessness. Indeed, 613 houses exited emergency accommodation into permanent tenancies. These families matter too. </p>
            <p eId="para_77"> We are not ignoring the problem. We are tackling it on multiple fronts, ranging from prevention measures, exits, housing first, social housing delivery and the new child and family homelessness action plan. Homelessness will only be reduced sustainably when we have more supply in the system. That is why we need a combination of private housing, social housing, approved housing bodies and the Land Development Agency. We need an array, focused on delivery.</p>
            <p eId="para_78">Only delivery will combat the challenges being faced by many of those in insecure tenures. We want to continue to invest as a Government. That is why we put record levels of investment into housing. As I said, there is over €9.1 billion for housing in 2027. The commitment is here on this side. We have to work, not only with local authorities but with all housing operators across the system to deliver. That is the focus now.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_7">
          <heading>Heritage Sites<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:40:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#LouisOHara" eId="spk_14">
            <from>Deputy Louis O'Hara<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_79">Dunguaire Castle has been closed for the past three years. There has been a long-running saga whereby Galway County Council was expected to take ownership of the castle from the Shannon Group but that did not materialise as the Government has not provided it with the funding to acquire the building and carry out the necessary repairs. All the while, the castle has lain idle and closed to the public. It has not been properly maintained. We are told that a significant amount of work and investment is needed to bring it up to a safe standard for reopening to the public. This is a real shame because Dunguaire is an iconic landmark on the Wild Atlantic Way. It is one of our region’s greatest tourism and heritage assets. It is such a missed opportunity for Kinvara and the wider region that it has remained closed for so long. Kinvara is a small picturesque village on the Wild Atlantic Way. A huge number of people visit and pass by, particularly during the summer months. Many visit to see Dunguaire Castle but when they arrive they find the gates locked. This has been a source of great frustration for the local community who cannot understand why this situation has been allowed to persist. They cannot understand why former Shannon Group assets like Bunratty in County Clare have been taken into public ownership at a cost of millions of euro while Dunguaire is left in limbo. This needs to be sorted finally. There should be an aim of having Dunguaire open again for the next summer season.</p>
            <p eId="para_80"> I received an update that officials in the Department of housing and the OPW have been in discussions around the site. I understand they have inspected the site and have identified significant repairs and upgrading which are required, including to the castle roof, fire and security systems, electrical installations and conservation repairs. I understand that if the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage acquires the site, the OPW will be responsible for its conservation and care and would require additional resources to address the complexity and range of works required on the castle. That would be very welcome. The OPW has a number of similar sites in County Galway, including Athenry Castle and Portumna Castle, and it does a fantastic job of running those sites. I have a lot of confidence and faith in the OPW’s ability to make a success out of Dunguaire Castle as well but the longer the Government continues to delay and allow it to drag on, the more the castle will deteriorate. That is the fear. The local community, which is following this closely, is not particularly concerned with which State body takes it on; they just want it brought back into public ownership for necessary repair works to be carried out, to be maintained properly into the future and to be in a position where it can open its doors again.</p>
            <p eId="para_81"> Is the Department of housing and heritage going to take ownership of this castle? Can the Minister of State give that commitment here today? Can he, at the very least, give the community an indication as to when they can finally expect a decision to be made and for there to be clarity around the future of this castle?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" eId="spk_15" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy Alan Dillon<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:40:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_82">I thank Deputy O’Hara for raising this important issue which I am taking on behalf of the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage, Deputy James Browne. As the Deputy outlined, Dunguaire Castle is one of Ireland’s most recognisable heritage landmarks. It is situated on Galway Bay close to Kinvara. It has enormous historical, cultural and tourism significance, both locally and internationally. For generations it has been a real source of pride for the local community and an important attraction for visitors in the region. I fully accept the concerns that were raised by Deputy O’Hara regarding its continued closure and I understand the frustration felt by local residents, businesses, tour operators and elected representatives who want to see the castle reopened and to welcome visitors once again.</p>
            <p eId="para_83"> It is important to understand, however, how the situation arose. Back in 2020 the Shannon Airport Group advised the Government that significant restructuring work was required to secure the long-term future of its heritage operations and employees.</p>
            <p eId="para_84">The organisation faced considerable challenges, including the specialist expertise and investment required to maintain heritage sites, together with the severe impact of Covid-19 on visitor revenue. As a result, the Government decided in 2021 that the group could explore transferring heritage sites to local authorities as the most sustainable way of protecting those important assets into the future. This approach led to a number of successful transfers. King John's Castle in Limerick was transferred to Limerick City and County Council, while four heritage sites were transferred to Clare County Council. However, Dunguaire Castle proved more challenging. It is now the only remaining site that has not transferred from the Shannon Heritage portfolio, and Galway County Council confirmed it was not in a position to take ownership of the castle, meaning an alternative long-term solution had to be found.</p>
            <p eId="para_85"> Rather than allowing uncertainty to continue, the Minister has stepped in. For that reason, the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, working alongside the Office of Public Works, OPW, is progressing the acquisition of Dunguaire Castle because of its exceptional heritage value and national importance. While the legal conveyancing process remains ongoing, it would be inappropriate to speculate on any completion date, as the Deputy is looking for, but there is a clear direction of travel now and a long-term plan for the future of the site. Once the acquisition is completed, the OPW will assume responsibility for conservation and maintenance, bringing Dunguaire Castle into the national heritage estate while ensuring its long-term protection, preservation and management as a national monument.</p>
            <p eId="para_86"> This is not simply about ownership; it is also about safeguarding this iconic part of our national heritage for future generations. It is about creating the conditions that can facilitate renewed access for local communities and visitors when it is practically safe to do so.</p>
            <p eId="para_87"> The Government recognises the importance of Dunguaire Castle to Kinvara, Galway, the west of Ireland and, indeed, Ireland's tourism and heritage offering. The acquisition process is now in train to protect the historic asset and put the foundations in place to allow the castle to have a sustainable future for generations to come.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#LouisOHara" eId="spk_16">
            <from>Deputy Louis O'Hara<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:45:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_88">I thank the Minister of State for the response. I cannot stress enough the frustration in the local community that Dunguaire Castle has been left closed for so long. I have received over 3,000 emails in the past six months alone from people right across the world who cannot understand why such an incredible castle and one of our region's greatest tourism and heritage assets has been left closed indefinitely. The local community expects this to be resolved and expects it to be resolved quickly. The castle has been left closed for three years now. That has resulted in a huge loss of employment, a loss of visitors to the area and, of course, a loss to our history and heritage. Therefore, we cannot allow this historic building to remain closed and deteriorate any further. We need to see those remedial works carried out to bring it up to a safe standard to ensure it can be opened once again to the public.</p>
            <p eId="para_89"> I appreciate the update the Minister of State has given today in terms of the Department of housing working together with the OPW to acquire the castle and bring it back into use. That is all very welcome. We have had three years of false promises and commitments in relation to the castle, so the community wants a real assurance that this matter is going to be resolved and that the castle will be opened again in the near future for the next tourist season.</p>
            <p eId="para_90"> I welcome the comment that there is a clear direction of travel, but we need to see urgency. We also need to see a timeline from the Department and the OPW as to when they are going to acquire the castle, begin the remedial works that are so badly needed to protect the integrity of the castle and ensure it can be reopened to the general public as quickly as possible.</p>
            <p eId="para_91"> I appreciate the update given today, but I urge the Government to treat this with urgency. The castle has been closed for three years and the local community wants to see movement on this. I want to see the castle reopened again.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" eId="spk_17" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy Alan Dillon<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:45:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_92">I thank the Deputy for raising this important issue. I understand the frustration.</p>
            <p eId="para_93">People have seen the castle closed for far too long. Indeed, I spoke to Senator P. J. Murphy with regard to this. I know he has engaged with the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, on the tourism aspects of this project. However, before reopening can be considered, it is critically important that the ownership and the legal matters are resolved. That is happening at the minute with the conveyance. The Department of housing and the OPW are working as we speak through the acquisition process, which will finally provide a long-term future for Dunguaire Castle rather than just a temporary fix. The Government has been working through the complex transition following the restructuring of Shannon Heritage. As the Deputy knows, this was part of its portfolio. That Galway County Council was unable to take ownership of it was challenging. The Minister has intervened. He is working through it, considering the exceptional national significance of this historic site, its importance to Galway, to the west of Ireland, and to Ireland, and we look forward to a speedy resolution.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
        <debateSection name="debate" eId="dbsect_8">
          <heading>Schools Refurbishment<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:50:00+00:00"/></heading>
          <speech by="#SineadGibney" eId="spk_18">
            <from>Deputy Sinéad Gibney<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:50:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_94">St. Brigid's national school sits on a small site in the community of Foxrock, where approximately 400 children go to school every day. The original schoolhouse is over 112 years old. It is a protected structure and is in need of major restorative works. As it stands, it is not fit for purpose. There are also two dilapidated prefabs where further classrooms are located. As many people who went to national schools will know, prefabs were installed as temporary measures. They have an expected lifespan of about ten years. One of the prefabs at St. Brigid's is now about 40 years old. The building is rotten. There are holes in classroom floors that staff have had to patch themselves so that students and staff do not fall through. There is mould in the principal's office and it is spreading uncontrollably over files stashed in what limited space there is. Mr. Flood has to work with the window open to protect his health, so of course his office is freezing. The skylight in the secretary's office is so old and bowed inwards that birds bathe in it after it rains. Most classrooms have buckets to catch the rainwater when it starts dripping through the ceiling.</p>
            <p eId="para_95"> In one prefab, 15 female teachers, hard-working professional adults, must share one toilet between them at break time but it barely flushes. All the toilets in these antiquated prefabs take about ten minutes to refill after a flush. Ms Ramirez showed my team the basins that staff and students have to use to ensure the toilet is properly flushed after them. The bathroom facilities are, to put it succinctly, grim. Add to this the indignity of having to use a toilet that is literally within the classroom, separated by thin partition walls. The toilets in the old building are cold and smelly. Students do not like using them, so they often hold it in all day. There are large cracks in the walls of the old building, the plaster is falling off and the wind is coming through. The staff room is never quiet or private because it is a throughway for students to get from one part of the school to the other. The roof on one prefab received an emergency patch job in 2023 because it was leaking. Money was spent on maintaining a crumbling building that was no longer fit for purpose. This is in Foxrock in 2026. It is one of the most affluent areas in this country. The school is losing pupils, and who would send their child there after visiting for an open day?</p>
            <p eId="para_96"> Conversations with the Department of education regarding building upgrades have been ongoing since 1996 to coincide with the supposed retirement of the prefabs that turned ten years old that year. Thirty years later, nothing has been done. In 2018, St. Brigid's board of management received positive updates from the Department and was asked to fill out application forms for upgrades, and nothing happened. In 2023, the Department confirmed that the school's building project would go ahead under the accelerated delivery of architectural planning and tendering, ADAPT, programme, with a construction date planned for spring 2026 to be completed by autumn 2027. Three years after the school applied to the ADAPT programme and with almost €500,000 spent by the school on planning and architectural plans in preparation for this long overdue renovation, the project stalled without communication from the Department. There was radio silence. The school then received unofficial word that it will be 2031 before the renovations could start.</p>
            <p eId="para_97"> I point out that there was a delay in the progress of the project because the Department wanted the plans to be changed. It wanted a third special educational needs class, so the architects amended the plans and resubmitted them.</p>
            <p eId="para_98">Approval for the new design is supposed to take one month. Nine months after submitting the new plans that the Department strongly recommended, the school has heard nothing. Nobody will answer their questions. Will the Minister of State ensure the plans submitted to the Department approximately nine months ago are approved? If there are any outstanding issues with the plans, will he communicate clearly with the school and project management team so the project can move to the next stage? Will he commit to an estimated timeline for this? Will he confirm what the plan is for decanting St. Brigid's while construction is under way? I have plenty more detail to provide to him.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" eId="spk_19" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy Alan Dillon<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:55:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_99">I thank Deputy Gibney for raising this important matter. I am taking it on behalf of the Minister for education, Deputy Naughton. I recognise the importance of the project, not just for the pupils but for students, staff and the wider school community. The proposed project represents significant investment in education infrastructure and will deliver a 17-classroom primary school, together with three special educational needs classrooms. That will ensure the school can continue to meet the needs of current and future pupils.</p>
            <p eId="para_100"> The project is at stage 2a, developed design, a critical phase during which the design is further developed, costed and refined, and preparation is made of the statutory approvals. The stage 2a report was submitted to the Department in February of this year and is undergoing the necessary due diligence review. On completion of the process, engagement will take place with the project manager and the school regarding the next stakeholder meeting. While I appreciate school communities naturally want projects to move on as quickly as possible, it is important all major school building projects progress through each stage in accordance with the Government's infrastructure guidelines and capital works management framework. Government remains committed to investing significantly in school infrastructure nationwide. A total capital allocation of over €7.55 billion has been confirmed by the Department of education under the national development plan for the period out to 2030. Emphasis will be placed on the provision of accommodation for children with special educational needs and ensuring school place requirements can continue to be met across the country.</p>
            <p eId="para_101"> Across the school building programme, approximately 1,000 projects of varying scale will be on-site during 2026. This represents one of the most significant periods of investment ever undertaken in the education sphere. Since 2020, over €2.1 billion in capital funding has been invested in Dublin schools, with hundreds of projects delivered through new school building programmes, expansions, modular accommodation and other improvement works. The Government remains committed to delivering modern education facilities, including at St. Brigid's, expanding SEN provision and ensuring investment is targeted where it can have the greatest impact on students, families and school communities.</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#SineadGibney" eId="spk_20">
            <from>Deputy Sinéad Gibney<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T13:55:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_102">I want to give a shout-out to the teaching staff and entire school community. I will never cease to be amazed by the ingenuity and resourcefulness of teachers in the Irish public education system. Unfortunately, they have to show those qualities when dealing with stagnant funding and increasing complexities in childhood education. I share my most heartfelt respect for the dedicated staff of St. Brigid's. They have squeezed sensory areas into every corner they can find to provide calming areas for children with complex sensory needs.</p>
            <p eId="para_103"> Despite all the grim circumstances I have described in St. Brigid's school and the grim predictions, the community of staff, students and families is warm, united and dedicated. They adore their school community. It is a multigenerational community. Parents who went there now send their children there. The principal's young son is a student. Ms Ramirez was a pupil there and is now a senior teacher. She teaches in the same prefab she attended as a child. The senior staff and board of management decided to keep the project secret so as not to get everyone's hopes up. The lack of clarity from the Department has prevented the school moving forward with other big projects and management decisions but they have now decided to share this with me and their other TDs because they cannot wait any longer. They have informed the entire school. The children and staff cheered with delight upon hearing it. The parents are chatting excitedly at the gates.</p>
            <p eId="para_104"> After three decades of promised renovations for these incredibly difficult circumstances in which people are trying to teach and learn and a predicted five-year delay until 2031 before it can start, will this Government and the Minister of State please commit to doing this immediately?</p>
          </speech>
          <speech by="#AlanDillon" eId="spk_21" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_Housing,_Local_Government_and_Heritage">
            <from>Deputy Alan Dillon<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
            <p eId="para_105">I again thank the Deputy for raising this important matter. I completely understand the frustration from the parents, staff and wider school community, who want to see visible progress and understandably want certainty regarding the timeline. The important point is that this project is active and progressing. The stage 2a report on the proposed development was delivered in February of this year and it is an enormous project, with 17 classrooms and three SEN classrooms, which is a substantial investment in the future of the St. Brigid's school. I do not want to mislead the House by giving dates that cannot yet be guaranteed. I know the Minster, Deputy Naughton, is working on future capital programmes. The Department is very much committed to progressing projects as quickly as possible and ensuring the appropriate oversight is in place where there is value for money and compliance with all the requirements. Schools are being delivered right across the country. There is record investment in the schools capital programme. The focus of the Minister and the Department will ensure St. Brigid's Boys' National School advances successfully to the next stage at the earliest possible opportunity so that this important investment can ultimately be delivered for the pupils, parents and wider school community.</p>
          </speech>
        </debateSection>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="questions" eId="dbsect_9">
        <heading>Ceisteanna ó Cheannairí - Leaders' Questions<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:00:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_22">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_106">I welcome everyone in the Gallery but mention in particular the college students from Ballymote, County Sligo, who attend a former college of Deputy Eamon Scanlon, of whom they are guests. They are most welcome.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_23">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_107">Sa bhliain 2002, dúirt Brian Cowen, a bhí mar Aire ag an am, nach mbeadh aon athrú ar an nglas triarach gan reifreann a chur ar na daoine. Cén fáth go bhfuil an Taoiseach ag briseadh an ghealltanais seo anois?</p>
          <p eId="para_108"> In 2013, the Taoiseach told this House the triple lock was "at the core of our neutrality". He said the push to weaken it was part of a wider effort by "a wing of Fine Gael to erode neutrality" and he was unequivocal at that time. He said, "My party and I completely reject this." Now he is doing the very thing he once condemned. </p>
          <p eId="para_109"> During the Lisbon treaty referendum, the Irish people were given legally binding assurances that the treaty would not affect Ireland's military neutrality. As Minister for Foreign Affairs, he helped to secure those assurances. The declaration accompanying Ireland's ratification reaffirmed the triple lock. Overseas deployment required UN authorisation, Government agreement and Dáil approval. </p>
          <p eId="para_110"> Of course, he was not the first Fianna Fáil Minister for Foreign Affairs to make such a commitment. In 2002, ahead of the second Nice referendum, the then Minister for Foreign Affairs, Brian Cowen, assured this House that "there will be no change to [the triple lock] unless the people first give their assent in a referendum." Now, as Taoiseach, Deputy Martin is walking away from these solemn commitments. He cannot ask people to trust assurances on neutrality and then discard the safeguards that gave them practical force. He cannot tear out that safeguard and insult the intelligence of the Irish people by claiming that nothing is changing. </p>
          <p eId="para_111"> This is a fundamental breach of trust and reports suggest it is not even a settled position within the Taoiseach's own party. His own colleagues, members of his parliamentary party, have described what he is doing as "a fundamental change in Fianna Fáil policy". If they are advising the Taoiseach to stop this, it is because they are listening to the Irish people in a way he simply is not.</p>
          <p eId="para_112"> Do not take the Irish people for fools. The proposed EU mission in Lebanon shows exactly what is at stake. It is not a peacekeeping mission. On RTÉ's "This Week" on 25 October the Minister, Deputy McEntee, said Irish troops should join an EU mission in Lebanon, that the role was likely to involve peace enforcement and, crucially, that Ireland could not take part in this mission unless the triple lock was changed - in other words, an EU mission without UN authorisation.</p>
          <p eId="para_113">In other words, it would not be a peacekeeping mission at all but something very different.</p>
          <p eId="para_114"> What the Taoiseach is proposing is no mere technical adjustment. It is a fundamental change to Ireland's foreign and defence policy. The Government wants to remove the triple lock so it can deploy Irish troops on missions without a UN mandate. The Government cannot break its word, remove the triple lock and fundamentally undermine Irish neutrality without at least first asking the Irish people. If the Taoiseach is sure that he is right and that the Irish people would support this course of action, he should put it to them and let them decide. We need a referendum on this question.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_24">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_115">Fundamentally, ní aontaím in aon chor leis an méid atá ráite ag an Teachta maidir le neodracht na tíre. Níl aon amhras ach go bhfuil an Rialtas taobh thiar den pholasaí a bhaineann le neodracht na tíre. Nílimid chun é sin a athrú in aon chor. Tá a fhios ag an Teachta é sin. Gach aon bhliain agus i rith na mblianta, tá Sinn Féin ag rá go bhfuil deireadh le polasaí na neodrachta ach níor tharla aon deireadh leis an bpolasaí sin. Bhí Sinn Féin áiféalach 50 bliain ó shin agus tá sé áiféalach i bliana.</p>
          <p eId="para_116"> Over 50-odd years, the Deputy's party and movement have declared that Irish neutrality was at an end. In 1972, they said the same. It was quite extraordinary commentary at that time. They said that if we joined the European Union, it would be the end of Irish neutrality. Every single EU treaty was to be the end of Irish neutrality. There was going to be conscription, just like the Deputy is saying now.</p>
          <p eId="para_117"> It was all false and all proven to be false subsequently. No Irish soldier ever joined a European army. After all the treaties and after joining the European Union, we never joined NATO. That did not stop the Deputy's party saying it, though, during every single referendum on a European Union treaty. Sinn Féin opposed every one of them because it is fundamentally anti-European Union. Then it accuses the European Union of being militarist, when it is not. It is the biggest peacekeeping project in the history of the 20th and 21st centuries. That is why the European Union came together, but the Deputy's party opposed it and continues to oppose it.</p>
          <p eId="para_118"> I take issue with some of what the Deputy has said, some of what she said last week and some of what she has said on social media, where she blatantly told a false narrative and an untruth when she was saying that Irish soldiers will end up on the side of Israel. That is endangering Irish troops who are currently on a United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon, UNIFIL, peacekeeping mission.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_4">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_25">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_119">Deputies, please allow the Taoiseach to finish. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#SimonHarris" eId="spk_26">
          <from> The Tánaiste<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_120">The Deputy should not do that. It is a very tense situation in Lebanon. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_27">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_121">Did the Taoiseach tell Kaja Kallas that?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_28">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_122">Deputies, it applies to both sides. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_29">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_123">We have been down the middle as peacekeepers and Irish soldiers have lost their lives. Unnecessarily creating false narratives of that kind endangers soldiers who are currently on a UNIFIL peacekeeping mission-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_30">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_124">Did the Taoiseach say that to Kaja Kallas? </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_31">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_125">Deputy, please.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_32">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_126">-----and Deputy McDonald should desist from doing that.</p>
          <p eId="para_127"> What happened in 2002? We had a referendum to amend the Constitution and inserted Article 29.4.9°, which reads:</p>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_128">The State shall not adopt a decision taken by the European Council to establish a common defence pursuant to Article 1.2 of the Treaty referred to in subsection 7° of this section where that common defence would include the State.</p>
          <p eId="para_129"> So we cannot join any European army. We cannot be part of any European defence pact because the Constitution prohibits it. The only way we could be part of that would be to seek the deletion or amendment of that Article 29.4.9°. Sinn Féin has ignored that for the entirety of this debate.</p>
          <p eId="para_130"> The world has changed very significantly for the worst because of the rogue behaviour of members of the UN Security Council that Sinn Féin wants us to defer to. In essence, it is saying Russia, which has violated every principle of the UN Charter, should be the decision-makers in respect of where Irish peacekeepers go in future. That is the de facto reality right now. There is no point in the Deputy nodding her head-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_33">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_131">I was shaking my head. This is nodding and this is shaking.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_34">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:05:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_132">-----because the UN Security Council has Russia as a member. UNIFIL is ending. Why? Because the United States, under pressure from Israel, wanted it to cease. We have been peacekeepers in Lebanon since the 1970s. </p>
          <p eId="para_133">That has come to an end because of another member of the UN Security Council.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_35">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_134">Thank you, Taoiseach. Deputy McDonald is on her feet.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_36">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_135">We should not have to be dictated to-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_37">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_136">Thank you, Taoiseach. Your time is up.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_38">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_137">-----and Russia, the US or the United Kingdom should not have a veto-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_39">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_138">Deputy McDonald is on her feet and your time is up, Taoiseach.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_40">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_139">----over where Irish troops go for peacekeeping.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_41">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_140">Deputy McDonald.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_42">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_141">The only decision-makers on this question, a question as fundamental as this, are the Irish people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_43">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_142">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_44">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_143">That is why the Government should go to a referendum. In 2002, the Taoiseach's predecessor Brian Cowen acknowledged this. Let me repeat, "there will be no change to [the triple lock] unless the people first give their assent in a referendum." That is the correct and democratic position. That is the position that recognises the importance of this issue to Irish people. The triple lock is fundamental to our foreign and defence policy. The Taoiseach knows this. That is why it was introduced in the first instance. He knows that removing the need for a UN mandate transforms entirely the nature of the deployments of our soldiers and of Irish neutrality itself. If anybody is proposing a course of action that will put Irish lives at risk and Irish soldiers in danger, it is the Taoiseach and not I.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_45">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_144">Hear, hear.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_46">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_145">Let me repeat again-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_47">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_146">Thank you, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_48">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_147">On this issue-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_49">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_148">Please.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_50">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_149">Let us have the debate where it needs to happen-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_51">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_150">Time is up, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_52">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_151">----among the Irish people. Have a referendum and allow them to make the democratic call.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_53">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_152">We have never had a referendum that does not involve either adding to, deleting from or amending the Irish Constitution. That is when we have referendums - to amend, delete from or add to the Irish Constitution. We then have, under our Constitution, a parliamentary democracy. That is the basic, fundamental tenet of how we operate our democracy. We are not Switzerland; we do not have referendums on issues <i>per se</i> where we are not adding to, removing from or amending the Constitution. That is a clear point.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_54">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_153">That was not Brian Cowen's view.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_55">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_154">Deputy, your time is up.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_56">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_155">That was not the Taoiseach's predecessor's view.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_57">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_156">We have been proud peacekeepers.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_58">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_157">Yes, no one is disputing that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_59">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_158">That is our defining contribution to the world, through peacekeeping.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_60">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_159">Nobody is disputing that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_61">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_160">That is what we will continue to do-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_62">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_161">No, not without a UN mandate.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_63">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_162">-----but I really take issue with the idea-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#ConorDMcGuinness" eId="spk_64">
          <from>Deputy Conor D. McGuinness<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_163">Brian Cowen said otherwise.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_65">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_164">The Security Council will not sanction any significant new measures and has in our peacekeeping missions. Look at Russia-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_66">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_165">There are substantial peacekeeping mandates still in place. That is rubbish.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_67">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_166">-----with the Sahel in Africa, where the Wagner Group has been deployed by Russia to exploit for the benefit of Russia.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_68">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_167">Was Brian Cowen wrong?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_69">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_168">Time is up, Taoiseach, thank you.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_70">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_169">And you want us to be dictated by that kind of geopolitics?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_71">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_170">No, I want you to keep your word.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_72">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_171">Deputy Cian O'Callaghan.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_73">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_172">I want you to keep your word.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_74">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_173">It is incoherent and ill informed.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_75">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_174">Time is up.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_5">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_76">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_175">Deputy Cian O'Callaghan. If you are not on your feet I will move on, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_6">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#CianOCallaghan" eId="spk_77">
          <from>Deputy Cian O'Callaghan<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_176">I spoke to Yvonne Nolan yesterday. Yvonne and her three children are due to be evicted from their home today by a vulture fund. She is trying to put on a brave face for her children but she is struggling. Her 16-year-old twin boys are autistic and non-verbal and have severe and complex needs. They have no idea they are going to lose their home and Yvonne has no way to explain it. Their home has been specially adapted to keep the boys safe and yet the initial response from the State was a one-bed apartment in Dublin city centre - a one-bed for a mother, her teenage daughter and her two autistic teenage sons. It is absolutely scandalous.</p>
          <p eId="para_177"> Yvonne has been begging for help for months. She repeatedly asked for a permanent residential placement for her boys but was told nothing was available. It was only after she went to the media that an emergency placement was eventually found. She was told yesterday that her boys would be placed in temporary respite accommodation, but this means her sons being transferred between two separate places during the week. This arrangement is only on a week-to-week basis. She has no guarantee of what will happen next week or the week after. There is no clarity about what comes next and what will happen to her children.</p>
          <p eId="para_178"> There are now a record 18,065 people living in emergency accommodation. This includes more than 5,800 children, so Yvonne and her family are not alone in this pain. What is happening is inhumane; there is no other word for it. Yvonne told me that the very last thing she wanted was to go to the media but that she was left with absolutely no choice because her boys were being put at real risk, with no permanent residential place to live and no idea when one will be available. This is a catastrophic failure of not just planning but care. Exactly as the Before We Die campaign has been trying to tell the Government, the State is knowingly failing these boys and thousands of other disabled people across the country.</p>
          <p eId="para_179"> Yvonne and her family need the Taoiseach's help. The eviction needs to be halted at least until the end of the school year. The HSE needs to provide a permanent home for her two sons. Yvonne and her family need enough time to plan for this transition. Will the Taoiseach call on the vulture fund to halt this eviction?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_78">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_180">First of all, I am always reluctant to go into the specifics of any individual case in the House and in public because invariably there can be complexities behind every individual case that may not always be apparent. One always has to be careful and cautious about doing that and extrapolating from any individual case. That said, I do not believe any eviction should take place in this case. I do not know the full circumstances behind the decision to seek an eviction but that would be the first point in terms of prevention of the eviction. I think there is perhaps complexity in this case that may not be immediately apparent, so I am not going to comment any further on it because we are often restricted.</p>
          <p eId="para_181"> On the broader point about housing and residential, I have met the Before We Die campaign. The Ministers for housing and disability have taken steps to ensure all future housing allocation will have a ring-fenced quota from local authorities in respect of social housing allocation for people with disabilities. More work has to be done in fleshing that out but it has already been communicated to local authorities.</p>
          <p eId="para_182"> This year, we will go close to 10,000 social houses. In the decade from 2020 to 2030, we will have well over 80,000 social houses built if not more. There has been extraordinary growth in the delivery of social housing since 2020, which no one wants to acknowledge but it has been hugely substantial. Within that, there has to be room for people with disabilities, just as we have ring-fenced housing for elderly people and people who need housing. The same should apply to disabilities. That is the direction of travel the Government has taken and a recent Cabinet subcommittee meeting reinforced that position.</p>
          <p eId="para_183"> On social housing, about 61,569 homes were added to the social housing stock between 2020 and 2026. That compares with 34,800 social homes provided by local authorities and the capital assistance programme between 2015 and 2020. We are now doing nearly 62,000 compared with 35,000 in a previous five-year period. That is huge progress on the social housing front. We are going to keep that momentum going because there are another 40,000-odd in the pipeline already over the next two years at different stages of construction, and within that we will provide for people with disabilities. There is work to be done in tying up local authorities with approved housing bodies and then the health services will have to provide wraparound services-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_79">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_184">Thank you, Taoiseach. Deputy O'Callaghan</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_80">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_185">-----but we are not going to wait for that. We are going to get houses built for people with disabilities.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CianOCallaghan" eId="spk_81">
          <from>Deputy Cian O'Callaghan<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_186">The Before We Die campaign has been warning the Taoiseach again and again that there need to be plans in place to meet the residential needs of people with disabilities. Does he think it is in any way acceptable that this family was offered a one-bed apartment for a mother, her teenage daughter and her two autistic sons? Does he think it is in any way acceptable that what is now being provided are temporary respite placements where her two teenage sons will have to move every week from place to place? They do not even know how long that respite place will be there for. They are told it will be there for a week and that they might get another week, or another week after that. That is no way for people to be treated. When will the Taoiseach and the Government get their act together and provide the housing needed for people with disabilities and their families so they are not thrown into a crisis and an emergency? Plans need to be in place so they can make transitions together as a family in the time they need.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_82">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:10:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_187">My understanding is the family has been told respite will be continuous until the complex family situation is dealt with and addressed in terms of accommodation.</p>
          <p eId="para_188">As I said to the Deputy before, the situation is quite complex but our priority is the family and the children in that case. I have met with Before We Die. The Tánaiste and I, along with key Ministers, met with Before We Die. It was a very positive and engaging meeting. We will continue regular meetings and we are solution-driven in respect of the issues raised by the Before We Die campaign, which I would not conflate with this case. It is not the same.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_83">
          <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_189">They are absolutely connected.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_84">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_190">The Before We Die campaign is a broader issue in terms of parents getting older and wanting to have certainty and security about where their adult children will reside in case either parent or both parents pass. That is the core issue, along with others, the Before We Die campaign put before us in respect of housing.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_85">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_191">This was supposed to be a landmark year for the reform of our health service. The Minister for Health had promised rigorous oversight, transparent reporting, population-based funding, savings of €181 million and no supplementary health budgets. It turns out those so-called promises were the stuff of fantasy. In reality, hospitals are in chaos and the HSE is plunging into a deficit of more than €1 billion, which is potentially the second largest in its history. The Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, claimed the HSE broke even last year but it actually recorded a massive deficit then, even with a supplementary budget, too. Now, we know that next year's health budget will be swallowed up before it can deliver any of the improvements patients need.</p>
          <p eId="para_192"> Those improvements are needed badly. Professor Matthew Sadlier of the IMO gave a startling interview on "Morning Ireland" yesterday. He warned of sharp rises in pressure in our hospitals. Almost 1 million people are already languishing on waiting list and the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation has warned that accident and emergency departments face a dire situation this winter, with admissions already up on last year. Shockingly, 2,900 nursing and midwifery posts are currently vacant and yet the Government tells us the health service is overstaffed. This is Orwellian doublespeak, especially for the many patients languishing on trolleys and for any of us with a family member in hospital. We know those patients receiving care on trolleys face a higher mortality risk than those who are treated in hospital beds. In a month's time, we all fear that chairs could sit empty at Christmas dinners around the country because of terrible failings in health and short staffing.</p>
          <p eId="para_193"> My thoughts are with hospital patients but also with healthcare workers. Because of the Government's recruitment freeze and spending restrictions, they are forced to work in impossible circumstances and they know they are working under unsafe conditions. They know their patients might get sicker because of staffing pressures. To add insult to injury, it seems they are being gaslit by the Government. At Cork University Hospital, we saw the double counting of staff who moved from agency contracts to HSE contracts. The same people were carrying out the same work at the same hospital but were counted twice for the purpose of fictional staffing figures.</p>
          <p eId="para_194"> It is time for honestly in healthcare. Tomorrow morning, the Labour Party will bring a motion to the Dáil calling on the Taoiseach to tell the truth on health spending and health staffing. We are demanding an honest, multi-annual funding plan, based on the actual needs of patients and the health service. We are calling for a supplementary estimate to meet the actual cost of health services this year. Why is the Taoiseach systematically under-resourcing our hospitals and will he support our Labour Party motion tomorrow?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_86">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_195">We have no issue with telling the truth about the exponential growth in public funding in the health service over the past five to six years. The spend has broken all records. We need a debate, not just on spend, spend and spend. We need to make sure we prioritise and get good outcomes from the spending. Equally, that is an important debate to have. The Government passed a supplementary budget for health today.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#GeraldNash" eId="spk_87">
          <from>Deputy Ged Nash<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_196">About time.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_88">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_197">It was a very substantial one, over and above what was provided. Health funding will have risen by about €13.7 billion, or 88%, between 2019 and 2027. The overall 2027 health allocation is €29.1 billion, comprising €27.4 billion current spend and €1.7 billion capital. The workforce has grown by 31%, or 31,544 whole-time equivalents, to over 133,000, currently. Those are the facts.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_89">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_198">What do we have to show for it?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_90">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_199">By any yardstick, that is a very significant expansion of our health service. The population has grown. Demand has increased. Pressures on the hospitals have increased, particularly as our population is ageing and growing on an ongoing basis. We have recruited about 11,125 additional nurses and about 5,000 additional health and social care professionals. In our hospitals, spending has gone up by about 52% and staffing by 33% since the start of 2020. There is no argument that there has not been a very significant increase in spending.</p>
          <p eId="para_200"> As I have said, we have had significant population growth. We have increased acuity and complexity among presenting patients and there has been a sustained rise in demand for urgent and emergency care. Emergency department attendances by the end of August this year have gone up 7.2%. It went up 9.8% for those aged over-75. We fully accept that but that, in itself, does not explain what was the HSE overspend.</p>
          <p eId="para_201"> To be fair, for any deficit in any year, some of that is because of demand-led schemes. Some of that is down to structural pressures, such as drugs, pensions, State claims and demand across community health schemes, which have to be met. That always leads to the necessity for a supplementary budget. There are other areas, from pay to agency overtime and so on, which are outside of that. Basically, no one could disagree that we have to have some framework in terms of public expenditure and spending within the health service. The Deputy says there has been a freeze. There has been no freeze. A total of 400 whole-time equivalents have been recruited in September of this year alone.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_91">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_202">We absolutely agree with the Taoiseach that we need an honest framework for health spending. The problem is his framework is not honest. It is fictional. What he says happens every year is overspending. The Taoiseach says the health service is overspending. What we say and what patients and healthcare workers say, and what they see, is underfunding. The Government is under-resourcing the health service and then accusing hospital managers of overspending. It is not adding up, either way. These budgets that the Taoiseach presents us with are fictional because you need supplementary budgets every year to meet what he has acknowledged are the increased pressures on hospitals. The increased pressures are being felt everywhere and being felt most of all by patients who are not receiving the care they need. Just this morning, I heard from a distressed woman whose 87-year-old sister was admitted to St. Vincent's hospital in my constituency on Saturday night. By yesterday evening, she still had not heard from her. The previous time she was admitted to hospital, the same patient spent months in turmoil because they could not discharge her. For two thirds of this year, more than 500 patients who were medically fit to leave hospitals had nowhere to go. Delayed discharging is costing more than €20 million a month and yet the Taoiseach persists in saying that hospitals are overspending. They are patently being underfunded and we need to fix this.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_92">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_203">That is not the case, actually.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_93">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_204">It is the case.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_94">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_205">The Deputy talked about limits and so on. Staffing in the HSE increased by almost 400 whole-time equivalents in September of this year, bringing the net increase in staff for the first nine months of the year to 4,000 whole-time equivalents. That is the net figure after departures. It is not simply the number of people recruited. There has been a net increase of 4,000 in the first nine months of the year. Recruitment has not stopped. At the end of September, we were at 133,000 plus whole-time equivalents. The number of nurses and midwives increased by 992 in the first nine months of 2026. Those are the facts.</p>
          <p eId="para_206"> As I said earlier, you get supplementary budgets and it is a substantial supplementary budget this year. A lot of it is demand-led schemes, although not all of it, and about 65% is spent on structural demands that are ongoing within the public health service. When I came back in in 2020 during the pandemic, we dramatically increased the base of health spend. We actually dealt with all of the supplementaries. We were told to gave another €1 billion. Does the Deputy remember that? We did.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_95">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_207">The vacant posts-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_96">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_208">The Deputy needs to be a bit more honest herself. In Opposition, I understand the rigours of trying to control budgets is not an appetising prospect but the Government has to have some framework.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_97">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:20:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_209">We are now in the 13th year of the housing crisis and the Taoiseach's Government is a record breaking Government for all of the wrong reasons. That latest figures in terms of homelessness are record figures.</p>
          <p eId="para_210">There are 18,000 people homeless in this State. It is absolutely astounding. It is the equivalent of every man, woman and child in a town the size of Maynooth homeless. This does not include those who are the hidden homeless. Nearly 6,000 children will wake up on Christmas morning without a home of their own. Think about that. It is equivalent to 272 classrooms of children who are growing up with the massive challenges that come with not having a home. All of this is because of the Government's housing policy. According to the Deloitte crane survey, the Government's housing delivery will miss its target by 120,000 by 2030. Either the target is disastrously out or the delivery of homes is a disaster. The Taoiseach will counter by saying the numbers are up this year but that is partially because the suspension of the development levy has front-loaded completions before the end of the year. Shockingly, planning applications last year were well below target, meaning this construction will not be sustained.</p>
          <p eId="para_211"> I talked to a builder in Meath recently who is under massive pressure to avail of the development levy measure before the end of the year because the ESB will not connect him in time. I spoke to another builder in Meath who is thousands of euro out every week because he is waiting for Uisce Éireann to connect his new estate. Uisce Éireann and the ESB are semi-State bodies. They operate on the basis of Government policy and their inaction is physically blocking the building of thousands of homes across the country at the moment.</p>
          <p eId="para_212"> Despite this being the 13th year of the housing crisis, the Government presides over the slowest planning, permitting, licensing, tendering, procurement and judicial review systems in the whole of the European Union. It takes twice as long to build a home in this country now as it did ten years ago. The viability issue remains. Right now, there are hundreds of builders across the country who are not building homes during this crisis. The development levy is a tax on building homes. The Government recognised this when it introduced the waiver. Yet, in the middle of this housing crisis, the Government's aim is to return to the development levy.</p>
          <p eId="para_213"> VAT is also a tax on building homes. Other jurisdictions recognise this. There is no VAT on the building of homes in the North of Ireland. The Taoiseach recognises it too because the Government reduced VAT on the building of apartments but it will not reduce VAT on the building of homes. Will the Government keep the development levy waiver for another three years and reduce VAT on the building of homes in this country?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_98">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_214">I do not accept Deputy Tóibín's presentation at all. The Deputy mentioned the European Union and referenced Ireland in that context. The facts are that Ireland ranks fastest in Europe on completions <i>per capita</i>. We are building houses faster than anybody in Europe by a long shot, with 7.2 units per 1,000 population. This is according to EUROCONSTRUCT and it covers 19 countries. It was published in August this year. That is more than double the European average of 3.0 and triple the United Kingdom's 2.4 per 1,000. We are way ahead of anybody else in terms of house construction and we need to do more.</p>
          <p eId="para_215"> Completions rose by 40% between 2022 and 2026. I have been in Government since 2020. We had Covid for the first two years, which did knock us back a bit. We are one of only five European countries where output grew while the Continent overall declined. We will have delivered over 180,000 houses since 2020. Commencements between January and September this year were up by 156% on comparable 2025 data. Residential construction employment, meaning those working in housebuilding, is up by 14%. The volume of first-time buyer mortgage drawdowns rose by 6.6% year on year. We had the highest quarter 1 volume since 2007. Ireland is one of the few European Union countries where home ownership rates have increased since 2021. Our home ownership is going up because of the schemes we introduced, including help to buy and the first home scheme, and the grant schemes for dereliction and vacant houses.</p>
          <p eId="para_216"> On the social housing front, as I said earlier, we have added about 61,569 social houses to the social housing stock during that five-year period, compared with 34,000 in the previous five years. We are up by 50% in the first six months of 2026 in terms of completed social houses. It is the highest ever first-half delivery of new-build social homes recorded and there are a further 22,000 additional social homes in the pipeline. Over 22,800 starter-home supports were delivered from 2021 to the end of quarter 2 of 2026.</p>
          <p eId="para_217"> In relation to homelessness, we have a strategic plan and an allocation of resources. Fundamentally, it is a population growth issue and it is also a migration issue, quite frankly. This is clear from the figures in terms of those in emergency accommodation, particularly in Dublin but also across the country. We have to continue to build more and more homes to get people out of emergency accommodation as quickly as we possibly can. The Minister has a child and family homelessness strategy with resources behind it. We need buy-in, particularly in terms of the location of large families across the community, which has proven to be somewhat challenging in recent times.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_99">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_218">Output is growing because it is starting from a collapsed base. Imagine, in 2013, 8,000 homes were built in the whole country. The Taoiseach is talking about figures that are coming from a disastrously low base. We have raised the immigration issue for the past five years and have been poo-pooed by the Government for doing so. The Taoiseach is making an achievement out of failure on this. The Government's target is 50,000 and its output is 20% lower than the target. No end of spin can change that.</p>
          <p eId="para_219"> Today, we have the shocking information that rents are now, on average, €2,239 per month. This is 43% higher than five years ago. If we look at it, it is equivalent to an annual gross salary of €30,000. This is the full gross salary of somebody on the minimum wage in this country. The Taoiseach said the removal of rent caps would increase availability but availability of rental properties is down by 7% since 2024. This is Leaders' Questions where we pose a question to the Taoiseach and he answers it. My question is whether the Government will keep the development levy waiver for another three years.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_100">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_220">We will not be doing that for another three years because we have undertaken quite substantial reforms over the last two years which will further enhance the pipeline. The big issue is that approximately 80% of all houses are State backed. The Government is funding or subsidising the vast majority of housing one way or another, building social houses and through a variety of schemes we are putting in huge supports.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_101">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_221">I am talking about viability</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_102">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_222">I did not interrupt Deputy Tóibín. We have taken a range of measures, which the Opposition opposed for different reasons, that will help the supply side in terms of housing and apartments.</p>
          <p eId="para_223"> Regarding infrastructure, the housing activation office has been particularly effective in enabling sites to become shovel-ready for housing construction. That relates to infrastructure to do with water, the grid, roads or whatever the particular issue is on a given site. The housing activation office and the head person there are having a very impactful role in getting more housing done faster.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_103">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_224">We have a very busy Gallery today. I welcome Brian and Jerry McSweeney and Nellie Crane from Bandon who are here today with Deputy Michael Collins and also Ballynog national school in County Cork who are in the Public Gallery at the behest of Deputy Noel McCarthy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_104">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_225">I think that should be Ballynoe National School.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_105">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_226">It is his handwriting, I am afraid, is the issue.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_106">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_227">His handwriting is notorious; he should go back to school.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_107">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_228">Sorry about that.</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
      <debateSection name="orderofBusiness" eId="dbsect_10">
        <heading>An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></heading>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_108">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_229">In accordance with Standing Order 35, I call on the Chief Whip, Deputy Mary Butler, to move the arrangements for this week's business.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryButler" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_the_Taoiseach" eId="spk_109">
          <from>Minister of State at the Department of the Taoiseach (Deputy Mary Butler)<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_230">I move:</p>
          <p eId="para_231"> Tuesday's business shall be: </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_232">- Motion re Report of the Committee on Standing Orders and Dáil Reform entitled "Post-enactment Reports" (without debate and any division claimed to be taken immediately) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_233">- Motion re Leave to Introduce Supplementary Estimates [Votes 6, 9, 12, 14, 18, 20, 21, 24, 26 to 28, 30 to 34, 36 to 38, 42 and 44] (without debate and any division claimed to be taken immediately) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_234">- Finance (International Financial Institutions) Bill 2026 (Second Stage) (to conclude at the end of the first speaking round; not to exceed 3 hours and 34 minutes) </p>
          <p eId="para_235"> Tuesday's private members' business shall be the Motion re Defending Irish Neutrality, selected by Sinn Féin.</p>
          <p eId="para_236"> Wednesday's business shall be:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_237">- Statements on Childcare (not to exceed 3 hours and 32 minutes) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_238">- Media Regulation Bill 2026 (Amendments from the Seanad) (to conclude within 1 hour) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_239">- Motion re Proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026 (to conclude within 1 hour and any division claimed to be taken immediately) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_240">- Motion re Proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of a Regulation on the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation (Eurojust) and repealing Regulation (EU) 2018/1727 (to conclude within 1 hour and any division claimed to be taken immediately) </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_241">- Supplementary Estimate for Public Services [Vote 21] (back from Committee) (without debate and any division claimed to be taken immediately) </p>
          <p eId="para_242"> Wednesday's private members' business shall be the Motion re Health Budget and Recruitment Restrictions, selected by Labour Party.</p>
          <p eId="para_243"> Thursday's business shall be:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_244">- Statements on International Men's Day (not to exceed 2 hours and 25 minutes) </p>
          <p eId="para_245"> Thursday evening business shall be the Second Stage of the School Meals Nutritional Standards Bill 2026, sponsored by Deputy Jen Cummins.</p>
          <p eId="para_246"> Proposed Arrangements for this week's business:</p>
          <p eId="para_247"> In relation to Tuesday's business, it is proposed that:</p>
          <p eId="para_248"> 1. notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_249">(a) the time allocated to Government business shall be extended in accordance with the arrangements for that business and the Dáil may sit later than 10.48 p.m.; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_250">(b) private members' business shall be taken following Government Business with consequential effect on the commencement times for the items following in the ordinary routine of business</p>
          <p eId="para_251"> 2. the proceedings on the Motion re Report of the Committee on Standing Orders and Dáil Reform entitled "Post-enactment Reports" shall be taken without debate and any division claimed thereon shall be taken immediately;</p>
          <p eId="para_252"> 3. the proceedings on the Motion re Leave to Introduce Supplementary Estimates [Votes 6, 9, 12, 14, 18, 20, 21, 24, 26 to 28, 30 to 34, 36 to 38, 42 and 44] shall be taken without debate and any division claimed thereon shall be taken immediately; and</p>
          <p eId="para_253"> 4. the proceedings on the Second Stage of the Finance (International Financial Institutions) Bill 2026 shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion at the end of the first speaking round, which shall not exceed 3 hours and 34 minutes, and the following arrangements shall apply:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_254">(a) the first-round speeches shall be in accordance with the table below (to be read across);</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_255">(b) on conclusion of the first speaking round or where speeches conclude before the 3 hours and 24 minutes have elapsed and no other member is offering, a Minister or Minister of State shall be called upon to make a speech in reply which shall not exceed 10 minutes; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_256">(c) members may share time.</p>
          <table>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_257"> -</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_258">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_259">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_260">SD</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_261">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_262">SF</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_263">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_264">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_265">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_266">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_267">12</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_268">4</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_269">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_270">Lab</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_271">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_272">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_273">IPTG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_274">Gov</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_275">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_276">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_277">12</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_278">4</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_279">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_280">12</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_281">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_282">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_283">ITG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_284">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_285">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_286">OM</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_287">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_288">4</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_289">20</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_290">12</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_291">4</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_292">20</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_293">Total: 3 hours 24 mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_294">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_295">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_296">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_297">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_298">
									</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </table>
          <p eId="para_299"> In relation to Wednesday's business, it is proposed that:</p>
          <p eId="para_300"> 1. notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_301">(a) the time allotted for Government Business shall be extended in accordance with the arrangements for that business and the Dáil may sit later than 9.30 p.m.; </p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_302">(b) any motions to be taken without debate shall be taken on the conclusion of the Motion re Proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of a Regulation on the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation (Eurojust) and repealing Regulation (EU) 2018/1727; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_303">(c) the weekly division time shall be taken on conclusion of proceedings of any motions without debate with consequential effect on the time for the adjournment of the Dáil;</p>
          <p eId="para_304"> 2. the Statements on Childcare shall not exceed 3 hours and 32 minutes and the following arrangements shall apply:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_305">(a) the statements, not including the Ministerial response, shall be in accordance with the sequence contained in the table immediately below (to be read across);</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_306">(b) following the statements, a Minister or Minister of State shall be called upon to make a statement in reply which shall not exceed 10 minutes; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_307">(c) members may share time;</p>
          <table>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_308"> -</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_309">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_310">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_311">SD</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_312">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_313">SF</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_314">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_315">35</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_316">25</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_317">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_318">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_319">5</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_320">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_321">Lab</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_322">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_323">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_324">IPTG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_325">Gov</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_326">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_327">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_328">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_329">5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_330">12</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_331">15</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_332">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_333">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_334">ITG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_335">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_336">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_337">OM</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_338">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_339">5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_340">12</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_341">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_342">5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_343">8</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_344">Total: 3 hours 22 mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_345">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_346">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_347">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_348">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_349">
									</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </table>
          <p eId="para_350"> 3. the proceedings on the amendments from the Seanad to the Media Regulation Bill 2026 shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion after 1 hour, and any amendments from the Seanad not disposed of shall be decided by one question which shall be put from the Chair, and which shall, in relation to amendments to the Seanad amendments, include only those set down or accepted by the Minister for Culture, Communications and Sport;</p>
          <p eId="para_351"> 4. the proceedings on the Motion re Proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026 shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion after 60 minutes and the following arrangements shall apply thereto:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_352">(a) the order of speaking and allocation of time shall be in accordance with the table below;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_353">(b) members may share time; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_354">(c) any divisions claimed thereon shall be taken immediately</p>
          <table>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_355"> -</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_356">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_357">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_358">SD</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_359">Lab</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_360">IPTG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_361">ITG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_362">OM</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_363">Min Resp.</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_364">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_365">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_366">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_367">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_368">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_369">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_370">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_371">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_372">5</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_373">Total: 60 minutes</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_374">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_375">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_376">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_377">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_378">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_379">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_380">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_381">
									</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </table>
          <p eId="para_382"> 5. the proceedings on the Motion re Proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of a Regulation on the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation (Eurojust) and repealing Regulation (EU) 2018/1727 shall, if not previously concluded, be brought to a conclusion after 60 minutes and the following arrangements shall apply thereto:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_383">(a) the order of speaking and allocation of time shall be in accordance with the table below;</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_384">(b) members may share time; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_385">(c) any divisions claimed thereon shall be taken immediately; and</p>
          <table>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_386"> -</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_387">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_388">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_389">SD</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_390">Lab</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_391">IPTG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_392">ITG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_393">OM</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_394">Min Resp.</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_395">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_396">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_397">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_398">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_399">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_400">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_401">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_402">7.5</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_403">5</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_404">Total: 60 minutes</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_405">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_406">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_407">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_408">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_409">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_410">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_411">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_412">
									</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </table>
          <p eId="para_413"> 6. the proceedings on the Supplementary Estimate for Public Services [Vote 21] shall be taken without debate and any division claimed thereon shall be taken immediately.</p>
          <p eId="para_414"> In relation to Thursday's business, it is proposed that:</p>
          <p eId="para_415"> 1. notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders, Thursday evening business pursuant to Standing Order 169 may be taken earlier than 8.24 p.m. with consequential effect on the time for the adjournment of the Dáil; and</p>
          <p eId="para_416"> 2. the Statements on International Men's Day shall not exceed 2 hours and 25 minutes and the following arrangements shall apply:</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_417">(a) the statements, not including the Ministerial response, shall be in accordance with the sequence contained in the table immediately below (to be read across);</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_418">(b) following the statements, a Minister or Minister of State shall be called upon to make a statement in reply which shall not exceed 10 minutes; and</p>
          <p class="indent_2" eId="para_419">(c) members may share time.</p>
          <table>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_420"> -</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_421">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_422">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_423">SD</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_424">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_425">SF</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_426">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_427">25</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_428">15</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_429">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_430">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_431">3</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_432">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_433">Lab</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_434">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_435">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_436">IPTG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_437">Gov</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_438">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_439">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_440">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_441">3</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_442">9</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_443">10</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_444">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_445">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_446">ITG</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_447">Gov</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_448">SF</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_449">OM</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_450">Mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_451">3</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_452">9</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_453">10</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_454">3</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_455">5</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_456">Total: 2 hours 15 mins</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_457">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_458">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_459">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_460">
									</p>
              </td>
              <td>
                <p eId="para_461">
									</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </table>
          <p class="indent_1" eId="para_462"/>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_110">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_463">Are the arrangements agreed to? Not agreed.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigMacLochlainn" eId="spk_111">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Mac Lochlainn<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_464">For months I have requested at the Business Committee that we have statements on the preparation for Irish unity. We have a blueprint from Fine Gael and letters going from the Fine Gael leader to political leaders across the island. This is all very welcome. We have the Taoiseach finally seeing the light and accepting that we need to prepare for Irish unity, for God's sake. When are we going to have statements whereby both sides of the House can debate and have a discussion through statements on preparation for Irish unity?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RoryHearne" eId="spk_112">
          <from>Deputy Rory Hearne<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:30:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_465">We need an emergency debate on rents and homelessness. We see today that according to Daft the average rent is €2,200 and €2,700 in Dublin city. The Government tried to bury the homeless figures last Friday evening. There are 18,000 people homeless in this country.</p>
          <p eId="para_466">We need an emergency debate on that because the Government is refusing to take emergency action. Why will the Government not debate homelessness? It is trying to bury the issue, deflect from it and blame other people. We need an emergency debate to see emergency action.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#DuncanSmith" eId="spk_113">
          <from>Deputy Duncan Smith<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_467">Over the weekend, there were leaked reports stating that the future of public sector recruitment is in jeopardy and could be slashed because of the public sector pay deal that is on the table. Notwithstanding how concerning the leaking of such a message is in advance of a ballot, we need a debate on the future of public sector recruitment with particular regard to the use of AI. It is clear that AI is being used by certain Government Departments. We are receiving responses with mad symbols attached to them and template responses with no information and misgendered applicants. We need a debate on the future of public sector recruitment.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardBoydBarrett" eId="spk_114">
          <from>Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_468">We need an urgent debate and an explanation from the Government as to why it appears to be supporting the extrajudicial sanctioning of an Irish journalist, Chay Bowes, without any hearing. Do not get me wrong; RT is a mouthpiece for Putin and Putin is an imperialist. However, we have plenty of mouthpieces for Israel, NATO and EU militarism and they are not being sanctioned but an Irish citizen is being sanctioned. The Government needs to explain itself.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelCollins2016" eId="spk_115">
          <from>Deputy Michael Collins<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_469">Last week, most of the country was stunned to see the Taoiseach handing over €25 million to Volodymyr Zelenskyy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_116">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_470">I am sorry. I cannot hear the Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelCollins2016" eId="spk_117">
          <from>Deputy Michael Collins<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_471">Last week, you handed over €25 million of Irish taxpayers' money to Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Just to be fair, Independent Ireland held a poll. Over 15,000 people responded and 91.7% said the Taoiseach was wrong and that there should be proper debate in this House in relation to any funding given. That has not happened. I am calling for a proper debate in the House.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_118">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_472">You want Ukraine to surrender to Russia. That is what you want. It is low politics.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_119" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_the_Taoiseach">
          <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_473">I have listened to what the five Whips have said.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RichardBoydBarrett" eId="spk_120">
          <from>Deputy Richard Boyd Barrett<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_474">The Taoiseach can respond if he wants.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryButler" eId="spk_121" as="#Minister_of_State_at_the_Department_of_the_Taoiseach">
          <from>Deputy Mary Butler<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:40:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_475">There were quite a lot of new suggestions on top of the suggestions made at the Business Committee's meeting last Thursday. We have a very busy schedule to get through this week, so the Order of Business stands.</p>
        </speech>
        <debateSection name="division" eId="dbsect_11">
          <summary eId="sum_7">Question put: "That the proposed arrangements for this week's business be agreed to."</summary>
          <summary title="division" eId="sum_8">The Dáil divided: Tá, <quantity refersTo="#ta" normalized="79" eId="qty_1">79</quantity>; Níl, <quantity refersTo="#nil" normalized="62" eId="qty_2">62</quantity>; Staon, <quantity refersTo="#staon" normalized="0" eId="qty_3">0</quantity>.</summary>
          <debateSection name="ta" eId="dbsect_12">
            <p eId="para_476">Tá</p>
            <p eId="para_477">
              <person refersTo="#WilliamAird">Aird, William.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_478">
              <person refersTo="#CatherineArdagh">Ardagh, Catherine.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_479">
              <person refersTo="#GraceBoland">Boland, Grace.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_480">
              <person refersTo="#TomBrabazon">Brabazon, Tom.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_481">
              <person refersTo="#BrianBrennan">Brennan, Brian.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_482">
              <person refersTo="#ShayBrennan">Brennan, Shay.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_483">
              <person refersTo="#ColmBrophy">Brophy, Colm.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_484">
              <person refersTo="#JamesBrowne">Browne, James.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_485">
              <person refersTo="#ColmBurke">Burke, Colm.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_486">
              <person refersTo="#PeterBurke">Burke, Peter.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_487">
              <person refersTo="#MaryButler">Butler, Mary.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_488">
              <person refersTo="#JerryButtimer">Buttimer, Jerry.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_489">
              <person refersTo="#MalcolmByrne">Byrne, Malcolm.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_490">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelCahill">Cahill, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_491">
              <person refersTo="#CatherineCallaghan">Callaghan, Catherine.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_492">
              <person refersTo="#DaraCalleary">Calleary, Dara.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_493">
              <person refersTo="#SeanCanney">Canney, Seán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_494">
              <person refersTo="#MichealCarrigy">Carrigy, Micheál.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_495">
              <person refersTo="#JenniferCarrollMacNeill">Carroll MacNeill, Jennifer.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_496">
              <person refersTo="#JackChambers">Chambers, Jack.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_497">
              <person refersTo="#PeterChapCleere">Cleere, Peter 'Chap'.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_498">
              <person refersTo="#JohnClendennen">Clendennen, John.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_499">
              <person refersTo="#NiallCollins">Collins, Niall.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_500">
              <person refersTo="#JohnConnolly">Connolly, John.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_501">
              <person refersTo="#JoeCooney">Cooney, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_502">
              <person refersTo="#CathalCrowe">Crowe, Cathal.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_503">
              <person refersTo="#EmerCurrie">Currie, Emer.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_504">
              <person refersTo="#MartinDaly">Daly, Martin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_505">
              <person refersTo="#AislingDempsey">Dempsey, Aisling.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_506">
              <person refersTo="#CormacDevlin">Devlin, Cormac.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_507">
              <person refersTo="#AlanDillon">Dillon, Alan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_508">
              <person refersTo="#AlbertDolan">Dolan, Albert.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_509">
              <person refersTo="#SeanFleming">Fleming, Sean.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_510">
              <person refersTo="#NormaFoley">Foley, Norma.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_511">
              <person refersTo="#PatTheCopeGallagher">Gallagher, Pat the Cope.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_512">
              <person refersTo="#JamesGeogheganFG">Geoghegan, James.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_513">
              <person refersTo="#NoelGrealishPD">Grealish, Noel.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_514">
              <person refersTo="#MarianHarkinIND">Harkin, Marian.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_515">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelHealyRae">Healy-Rae, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_516">
              <person refersTo="#MartinHeydon">Heydon, Martin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_517">
              <person refersTo="#KeiraKeogh">Keogh, Keira.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_518">
              <person refersTo="#SeanKyne">Kyne, Seán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_519">
              <person refersTo="#JohnLahart">Lahart, John.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_520">
              <person refersTo="#JamesLawless">Lawless, James.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_521">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelLowry">Lowry, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_522">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelMartin">Martin, Micheál.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_523">
              <person refersTo="#PaulMcAuliffe">McAuliffe, Paul.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_524">
              <person refersTo="#NoelMcCarthy">McCarthy, Noel.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_525">
              <person refersTo="#CharlieMcConalogue">McConalogue, Charlie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_526">
              <person refersTo="#TonyMcCormack">McCormack, Tony.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_527">
              <person refersTo="#SeamusMcGrath">McGrath, Séamus.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_528">
              <person refersTo="#ErinMcGreehan">McGreehan, Erin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_529">
              <person refersTo="#JohnMcGuinness">McGuinness, John.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_530">
              <person refersTo="#KevinBoxerMoran">Moran, Kevin Boxer.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_531">
              <person refersTo="#AindriasMoynihan">Moynihan, Aindrias.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_532">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelMoynihan">Moynihan, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_533">
              <person refersTo="#ShaneMoynihan">Moynihan, Shane.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_534">
              <person refersTo="#JenniferMurnaneOConnor">Murnane O'Connor, Jennifer.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_535">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelMurphy">Murphy, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_536">
              <person refersTo="#JoeNeville">Neville, Joe.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_537">
              <person refersTo="#JimOCallaghan">O'Callaghan, Jim.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_538">
              <person refersTo="#MaeveOConnell">O'Connell, Maeve.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_539">
              <person refersTo="#JamesOConnor">O'Connor, James.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_540">
              <person refersTo="#WillieODea">O'Dea, Willie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_541">
              <person refersTo="#KieranODonnell">O'Donnell, Kieran.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_542">
              <person refersTo="#RyanOMeara">O'Meara, Ryan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_543">
              <person refersTo="#JohnPaulOShea">O'Shea, John Paul.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_544">
              <person refersTo="#ChristopherOsullivan">O'Sullivan, Christopher.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_545">
              <person refersTo="#PadraigOSullivan">O'Sullivan, Pádraig.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_546">
              <person refersTo="#NaoiseOCearuil">Ó Cearúil, Naoise.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_547">
              <person refersTo="#SeanOFearghaillFF">Ó Fearghaíl, Seán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_548">
              <person refersTo="#NaoiseOMuiri">Ó Muirí, Naoise.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_549">
              <person refersTo="#NealeRichmond">Richmond, Neale.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_550">
              <person refersTo="#PeterRoche">Roche, Peter.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_551">
              <person refersTo="#EamonScanlon">Scanlon, Eamon.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_552">
              <person refersTo="#BrendanSmith">Smith, Brendan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_553">
              <person refersTo="#EdwardTimmins">Timmins, Edward.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_554">
              <person refersTo="#GillianToole">Toole, Gillian.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_555">
              <person refersTo="#RobertTroy">Troy, Robert.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <debateSection name="nil" eId="dbsect_13">
            <p eId="para_556">Níl</p>
            <p eId="para_557">
              <person refersTo="#CiaranAhern">Ahern, Ciarán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_558">
              <person refersTo="#IvanaBacik">Bacik, Ivana.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_559">
              <person refersTo="#RichardBoydBarrett">Boyd Barrett, Richard.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_560">
              <person refersTo="#JohnBrady">Brady, John.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_561">
              <person refersTo="#JoannaByrne">Byrne, Joanna.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_562">
              <person refersTo="#MattCarthy">Carthy, Matt.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_563">
              <person refersTo="#SorcaClarke">Clarke, Sorca.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_564">
              <person refersTo="#MichaelCollins2016">Collins, Michael.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_565">
              <person refersTo="#RoseConwayWalsh">Conway-Walsh, Rose.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_566">
              <person refersTo="#RuthCoppinger">Coppinger, Ruth.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_567">
              <person refersTo="#SeanCroweSF">Crowe, Seán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_568">
              <person refersTo="#DavidCullinane">Cullinane, David.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_569">
              <person refersTo="#JenCummins">Cummins, Jen.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_570">
              <person refersTo="#MaireDevine">Devine, Máire.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_571">
              <person refersTo="#PearseDoherty">Doherty, Pearse.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_572">
              <person refersTo="#PaulDonnelly">Donnelly, Paul.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_573">
              <person refersTo="#DessieEllis">Ellis, Dessie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_574">
              <person refersTo="#DanielEnnis">Ennis, Daniel.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_575">
              <person refersTo="#AidanFarrelly">Farrelly, Aidan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_576">
              <person refersTo="#GaryGannon">Gannon, Gary.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_577">
              <person refersTo="#SineadGibney">Gibney, Sinéad.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_578">
              <person refersTo="#PaulNicholasGogartyGP">Gogarty, Paul Nicholas.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_579">
              <person refersTo="#AnnGraves">Graves, Ann.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_580">
              <person refersTo="#JohnnyGuirke">Guirke, Johnny.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_581">
              <person refersTo="#EoinHayes">Hayes, Eoin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_582">
              <person refersTo="#DannyHealyRae">Healy-Rae, Danny.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_583">
              <person refersTo="#SeamusHealy">Healy, Seamus.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_584">
              <person refersTo="#RoryHearne">Hearne, Rory.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_585">
              <person refersTo="#AlanKelly">Kelly, Alan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_586">
              <person refersTo="#EoghanKenny">Kenny, Eoghan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_587">
              <person refersTo="#MartinKenny">Kenny, Martin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_588">
              <person refersTo="#ClaireKerrane">Kerrane, Claire.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_589">
              <person refersTo="#GeorgeLawlor">Lawlor, George.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_590">
              <person refersTo="#PadraigMacLochlainn">Mac Lochlainn, Pádraig.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_591">
              <person refersTo="#MaryLouMcDonald">McDonald, Mary Lou.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_592">
              <person refersTo="#DonnaMcGettigan">McGettigan, Donna.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_593">
              <person refersTo="#ConorDMcGuinness">McGuinness, Conor D.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_594">
              <person refersTo="#PaulMurphy">Murphy, Paul.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_595">
              <person refersTo="#JohnnyMythen">Mythen, Johnny.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_596">
              <person refersTo="#GeraldNash">Nash, Ged.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_597">
              <person refersTo="#NatashaNewsomeDrennan">Newsome Drennan, Natasha.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_598">
              <person refersTo="#CianOCallaghan">O'Callaghan, Cian.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_599">
              <person refersTo="#RobertODonoghue">O'Donoghue, Robert.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_600">
              <person refersTo="#KenOFlynn">O'Flynn, Ken.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_601">
              <person refersTo="#RodericOGorman">O'Gorman, Roderic.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_602">
              <person refersTo="#LouisOHara">O'Hara, Louis.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_603">
              <person refersTo="#LouiseOReilly">O'Reilly, Louise.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_604">
              <person refersTo="#DarrenORourke">O'Rourke, Darren.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_605">
              <person refersTo="#EoinOBroin">Ó Broin, Eoin.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_606">
              <person refersTo="#DonnchadhOLaoghaire">Ó Laoghaire, Donnchadh.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_607">
              <person refersTo="#RuairiOmurchu">Ó Murchú, Ruairí.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_608">
              <person refersTo="#AengusOSnodaighSF">Ó Snodaigh, Aengus.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_609">
              <person refersTo="#FionntanOSuilleabhain">Ó Súilleabháin, Fionntán.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_610">
              <person refersTo="#LiamQuaide">Quaide, Liam.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_611">
              <person refersTo="#MauriceQuinlivan">Quinlivan, Maurice.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_612">
              <person refersTo="#PadraigRice">Rice, Pádraig.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_613">
              <person refersTo="#MarieSherlock">Sherlock, Marie.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_614">
              <person refersTo="#DuncanSmith">Smith, Duncan.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_615">
              <person refersTo="#BrianStanley">Stanley, Brian.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_616">
              <person refersTo="#PeadarToibin">Tóibín, Peadar.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_617">
              <person refersTo="#MarkWall">Wall, Mark.</person>
            </p>
            <p eId="para_618">
              <person refersTo="#MarkWard">Ward, Mark.</person>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <debateSection name="staon" eId="dbsect_14">
            <p eId="para_619">Staon</p>
            <p eId="para_620">
              <person refersTo="#"/>
            </p>
          </debateSection>
          <summary title="tellers" eId="sum_9">Tellers: Tá, Deputies Mary Butler and Emer Currie; Níl, Deputies Pádraig Mac Lochlainn and Rory Hearne.</summary>
          <summary title="decision" refersTo="#carried" eId="sum_10">Question declared carried.</summary>
        </debateSection>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_122">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_621">I welcome Deputy Butler's family who are also in the Gallery today. They are most welcome.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_123">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_622">Renters are being hammered by a crisis that the Government created. We see today that rents have risen by 7.3% in the year to September. The average rent now is €2,239 a month and €2,700 a month in Dublin. The Taoiseach was warned last March when the Government's rent hike Bill was introduced and it removed the protections that renters enjoyed that this would happen, rents would increase, and here we see it happening. We need affordable rents. We need a three-year ban on rent increases. We need an end to the sweetheart deals with the vulture funds which get hundreds of millions of euro from the Government when they gouge tenants. What has Taoiseach got against renters? Why does he refuse to intervene to assist them rather than put more punishment and expense on their backs?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_124">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_623">We do intervene to help renters. We did it in the budget when we substantially increased the tax credit for renters. National rental inflation has slowed to its smallest increase for the third quarter since 2020. Rents are still too high, but the rate of increase is slowing significantly. It was 0.9% between June and September, which is below the average quarterly increase of 1.6% seen over the last decade, but rents do remain over 7% higher compared to the same time last year; not because of the changes or anything like that. Supply is the key. Almost 2,800 properties were available to rent on 1 November, representing a 47% increase on the same date last year and the highest November figure since 2021. The bottom line is this: we need to build more houses. We are building them. If we implemented Sinn Féin's policies like the three-year rent ban----- </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_125">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_624">We would not have homeless kids nor one-in-seven<b>
						</b>young<b>-----</b></p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_126">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_625">-----that would depress supply and make things even worse for the future.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_127">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_626">Seven out of ten of our young people are leaving because they cannot get a home.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_128">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_627">All of Sinn Féin's propositions so far would have made things worse.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MaryLouMcDonald" eId="spk_129">
          <from>Deputy Mary Lou McDonald<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_628">Come on; that is pathetic.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_130">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_629">The stand-off in relation to Cork University Hospital, CUH, continues. At the core of this is the dispute over the number of staff that are needed to run that hospital safely. There is a huge disconnect between what the Taoiseach and the Minister are saying, and what the hospital is saying locally. The Taoiseach and Minister are saying that they are 200 staff over, they say locally that there are 1,000 vacancies. We need to get a solution to the impasse, and that is an independent assessment. We need to see how many staff are out on sick leave and maternity leave, how the counting is done and how the ceiling calculation was made. Why will the Taoiseach not allow that independent assessment to take place? What is he afraid of?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_131">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T14:50:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_630">There should be no need for a stand-off. This is one organisation: CUH, HSE south-west and HSE national. It is surely within the remit of all concerned to resolve these issues. There should not be a stand-off.</p>
          <p eId="para_631">There should be engagement, dialogue and working things out. That is the solution. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_132">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_632">There is a solution on the table.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_133">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_633">Do not interrupt, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_134">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_634">Having spoken to the Minister about this, my understanding is the HSE has gone in and is supporting Cork University Hospital now with the issues raised; it is working to try to get underneath the bonnet of these issues. However, what one cannot deny is that there has been a significant increase in the staffing in CUH in recent years.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_135">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_635">Historic under investment. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_136">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_636">Please, Deputy. There are standing orders. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_137">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_637">We can go on about historic all we like all over the country if that is what the Deputy wants to do but I went through the figures earlier on what has been going on in the health service since 2020. There has been exponential growth in numbers and funding. That said, I have also acknowledged that workers are doing great work in the health service, and people are working hard on behalf of people.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PadraigRice" eId="spk_138">
          <from>Deputy Pádraig Rice<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_638">Answer the question.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_139">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_639">However, the point is there is no need for a stand-off. This is one organisation.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_140">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_640">The Taoiseach's time is up. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_141">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_641">I condemn the continued use of ploys by the Christian Brothers to seek to evade its responsibility to survivors of sexual abuse. I welcome the Taoiseach's comments today when he called on the Christian Brothers to face its responsibility and deal properly with survivors. I also welcome the comments of the Tánaiste who said the Christian Brothers, in refusing to put forward a nominated individual in court actions being taken against it by survivors, is hiding behind a bizarre legal structure. They are both right. This is appalling behaviour by the Christian Brothers, an organisation which last year had net assets in Ireland of €51.7 million. However, the Taoiseach's Government should be doing something about this. The Labour Party brought forward a Bill that was debated in the Dáil in July of this year to ensure complicit religious orders cannot dodge accountability. The Government secured a stay of our Bill until Christmas Eve, promising it would do six months of work in the meantime. I have submitted parliamentary questions seeking updates on this. Can we see Labour's Bill supported or a legal mechanism brought forward-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_142">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_642">Thank you, Deputy. The Taoiseach to respond.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_143">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_643">-----to ensure religious orders can be sued as entities by survivors-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_144">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_644">Have respect please, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#IvanaBacik" eId="spk_145">
          <from>Deputy Ivana Bacik<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_645">-----so that we no longer have to see the naming of hundreds of individuals by survivors in this way?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_146">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_646">I fully agree, and I said this morning and on several occasions that what is going on is unacceptable and shocking, and that survivors would be treated in this manner. In essence, as an organisation, the Christian Brothers is refusing to deal with its responsibilities to acknowledge some among them carried out the most appalling abuse against young students and young pupils when they were in their schools. Those young people, who are now no longer young but have been through a journey in life which has been very traumatic, are entitled to recompense, compensation and acknowledgement of what happened, and the Christian Brothers has a duty to do that.</p>
          <p eId="para_647"> In respect of the Deputy's legislation, time is moving very fast and Christmas Eve is mere weeks away now. This Bill will then come back into play for the new term. I will certainly speak to the Minister in respect of working with the Deputy on that.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#RodericOGorman" eId="spk_147">
          <from>Deputy Roderic O'Gorman<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_648">COP31 in Türkiye is entering its final week, and the key issue of the lack of funding for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC, has now arisen. This is the very organisation that compiles and reviews data on climate change around the globe, and the IPCC could run out of money by the end of the year. If this happens, the science that underpins the entire Paris Agreement will not be progressed. </p>
          <p eId="para_649"> The running costs of the organisation are tiny. It is only €9 million per year but much of that was funded by the US and Trump has pulled that funding. Our former president, Mary Robinson, highlighted the funding gap at COP this week. Ireland holds the EU Presidency and the Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, leads the EU delegation. Will the Taoiseach ask the Minister to use his role to get EU member states and allied countries to guarantee the IPCC budget? He cannot allow climate science to be defunded on Ireland's watch.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_148">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_650">I will talk to the Minister, Deputy O'Brien, about this. It should be within the remit of the international community to do this, notwithstanding the US position. The intergovernmental conference is essential for maintaining the global issue and the research and science behind it. I will engage with the Minister on this as well as with other like-minded countries to see how we can take up the slack on this.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_149">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_651">The Society of St. Vincent de Paul is bracing itself for a record number of calls this Christmas. Louise Bayliss of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul said people will suffer more this Christmas against the rising tide of inflation and a lack of central Government support. The organisation is expecting 270,000 people to reach out for help this winter. Putting that into context, that is the equivalent to the population of all of Leitrim, Longford, Carlow, Monaghan and Sligo. These are people who need help to survive in Ireland in 2026. It is not 1886; it is 2026.</p>
          <p eId="para_652"> Some 500,000 domestic gas and electricity accounts are currently in arrears, and hundreds of thousands of families simply cannot afford to pay their electricity bills. Ireland has the highest cost of electricity in the world at present, with €550 from each family's bill going towards network charges. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#VeronaMurphy" eId="spk_150">
          <from> An Ceann Comhairle<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_653">A question, Deputy.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_151">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_654">The ESB is making a profit of €650 million per year. Will the Taoiseach ask the ESB to reduce the dividends to the Government so that it can reduce the network charges to the families who cannot afford to pay for electricity? </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_152">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_655">The Government is responding to the cost-of-living crisis and pressures on families through our budget and social protection-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_153">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_656">Not according to them. </p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_154">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_657">-----and pension increases. Today, we provided funding in a supplementary for the Christmas bonus and more than €625 million alone is being provided for that. There is also the €10 increase in the core payments on social protection. The cost-of-disability payment and the fuel allowance are significant increased payments that will go to people who are under pressure due to the war in the Middle East and the Ukraine and Russia situation.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_155">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_658">Behind Government taxes on fuel.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_156">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_659">They are the fundamental drivers of high energy prices. ESB is a State company which reinvests everything-----</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_157">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_660">No, it does not. </p>
        </speech>
        <summary eId="sum_11">(Interruptions).</summary>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_158">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_661">But it does not.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_159">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_662">-----to ensure we can expand the grid and have enough for new homes and houses that young people need.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#PeadarToibin" eId="spk_160">
          <from>Deputy Peadar Tóibín<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_663">It pays €150 million dividends to the Government.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CathalCrowe" eId="spk_161">
          <from>Deputy Cathal Crowe<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_664">In these volatile times, food security has never been more important in Europe. However, food security depends on the well functioning, viable farming sector and some stability in commodity prices. The Common Agricultural Policy, CAP, is central to providing that stability, yet the current proposal amounts to a 24% reduction in CAP funding nationally. The IFA estimates this will break down as an annual reduction of €2,178 per annum for Clare families, or if you want a countywide figure, a €12 million reduction per annum.</p>
          <p eId="para_665"> Agriculture can be a very unpredictable business, and I saw this first hand on Saturday at the Sixmilebridge mart. I also met with the IFA in Cooraclare last night and in Dublin a couple of weeks ago. It has a pan-European position with other farming bodies. Given this level of unanimity among farmers across Europe, what is the Government's position in these final crucial weeks, and will it stand up for a properly funded CAP?</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#MichaelMartin" eId="spk_162">
          <from> The Taoiseach<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_666">The Government has stood up for a properly funded CAP, and will continue to do so. There are approximately 17 countries out of the 27 that are in the CAP cohesion side of the argument. The Commission had reduced it, although it is not quite as presented either. There are a number of variables yet in how this ultimately lands. We produced a negotiating box that protected the CAP and provided cuts elsewhere from the Commission's levies in terms of the competitiveness funds and other areas. This was largely well-received by the CAP countries as protecting CAP. </p>
          <p eId="para_667"> There are variables there, and by that I mean how you calculate inflation, where you front-load and other measures and flexibilities within the national envelopes that touch a different structure this time. Our objective is to do everything we possibly can to close the gap. There are a key three months ahead, and it is essential we have a deal by the end of the year. That would be most advantageous for farmers, as opposed to not having agreement on the EU budget because this will not happen in the early part of 2027.</p>
        </speech>
        <speech by="#CatherineCallaghan" eId="spk_163">
          <from>Deputy Catherine Callaghan<recordedTime time="2026-11-17T15:00:00+00:00"/></from>
          <p eId="para_668">Since September, I have been trying to help an 18-year-old student from Kilkenny who is at university in Belfast. She cannot get a student Leap card because the system does not recognise that her university is in Belfast, and Leap card customer care has told her she is not entitled to one. However, the Minister for Transport confirmed to me in a parliamentary question last month that students normally resident in the South who attend a university in the North are absolutely entitled to a 50% reduction in the southern leg of their travel.</p>
          <p eId="para_669"> Yesterday, I heard the same thing from a 36-year-old mature student who is living in the South and studying in Belfast. He is also being refused a student leap card. I have repeatedly contacted Leap card about this but I have not received a response from it in a month. Will the Taoiseach please ask the Minister to work with the NTA and Leap card to ensure the policy is being implemented as intended so that students are not paying more for their public transport than they need to?</p>
        </speech>
      </debateSection>
    </debateBody>
  </debate>
</akomaNtoso>
